
‘Without rules, countries just game the system': Climate report finds major economies overstating forest carbon absorption, risking emission goals
PARIS, April 25 — Major economies are overstating how much carbon their forests can absorb in a climate accounting fudge that could allow them to use even more fossil fuels, new research said yesterday.
The assessment singled out Brazil and Australia, and warned a lack of rules around accounting for forests and other land-based carbon sinks meant countries could 'game the system' when reporting their national greenhouse gas emissions.
Scientists are still unclear about how carbon sinks might behave as the planet warms in future, and exactly how much heat-trapping carbon dioxide they might soak up from the atmosphere.
But that has not stopped countries from making their own assumptions and using those numbers in their national climate plans, which are due to be finalised to 2035 before the next UN climate talks in Brazil in November.
Climate Analytics, a policy institute that independently assesses these plans, said overly optimistic assumptions about how much CO2 forests might draw down was 'masking the scale and pace of the fossil fuel emissions cuts needed'.
This concealed the true effort needed to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels, the ambition set out in the 2015 Paris climate agreement.
In the latest versions of its climate plan, Australia had leaned so heavily on forests to reduce its carbon footprint that it would amount to scaling back real cuts to emissions by 10 per cent, Climate Analytics said.
Brazil, meanwhile, has announced its own pledge to cut emissions by 59 to 67 per cent below 2005 levels by 2035, but has not defined the extent to which forests will help meet this goal.
Climate Analytics said structuring the target in this manner meant Brazil could still allow its energy emissions to double.
'If you don't use forests, then everything has to be done by the energy sector,' said Claudio Forner, who co-authored the new research by Climate Analytics.
'But if you use all forests, then the emissions actually can continue growing.'
He said the problem had arisen because the Paris climate deal allowed for countries to come up with their own assumptions about how much CO2 would be absorbed by their land.
'Without rules, countries just game the system,' Forner told AFP.
Assuming growth
While forests will be crucial to global efforts to reduce planet-heating emissions, these estimates should be listed separately and not used to 'offset' energy and industry emissions, he said.
That is because the complex processes by which forests and other land sinks absorb carbon are not as well understood as the role of fossil fuels in driving climate change.
Carbon stored in trees can also be released back into the atmosphere in the event of forest fires and other natural mechanisms.
There are also concerns that climate change and other human-driven factors are weakening the ability of forests and soils to soak up carbon.
'Science doesn't understand how the carbon sink is going to be behaving into the future,' said Forner.
'And if scientists don't, I'm sure that most governments don't either, but they still just use assumptions of continuing growth to their numbers. If those assumptions are wrong, then you have this deficit.'
Climate Analytics has previously estimated this uncertainty could amount to up to three billion tonnes of carbon dioxide—roughly equivalent to Europe's emissions for a year.
UN climate experts have also raised broad concerns about a 'significant discrepancy' between the way countries account for land in their climate plans and the methods used by scientists, which they said could be equal to around 15 per cent of global emissions.
In a report last year, they said efforts to realign different accounting systems for land use CO2 emissions and removal would mean the world has less time than previously thought to reach net-zero emissions. — ETX Studio

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
China extends hand to Korea
Chinese leader Xi Jinping urged South Korea's President Lee Jae-myung to work with Beijing to uphold free trade and defend 'multilateralism'. In a phone call with Lee, Xi urged Beijing and Seoul to 'inject more certainty into regional and international situations', Xinhua news agency said, as well as to 'promote strategic cooperative partnership to a higher level'. 'A healthy, stable, and continuously deepening China-South Korea relationship aligns with the trend of the times,' Xi said. 'Close bilateral cooperation and multilateral coordination should be maintained to jointly uphold multilateralism and free trade, ensuring the stability and smooth functioning of global and regional industrial and supply chains,' the Chinese leader added. South Korea's new centre-left leader was elected in a landslide last week after winning a snap election triggered by his predecessor's disastrous martial law declaration. Lee's office said the new leader had told Xi he hoped the two countries 'would actively promote exchanges and cooperation in a wide range of fields – including the economy, security, culture and people-to-people exchanges'. Lee also invited Xi to attend the upcoming Apec summit in November, which is being held in Korea's southern city of Gyeongju. Lee said he hoped there would be a chance for 'in-depth discussions on bilateral ties and regional issues.' Lee also asked that China play a 'constructive role in promoting peace and stability on the Korean Peninsula,' in a reference to Beijing's ties with North Korea. Seoul has long trod a fine line between top trading partner China and defence guarantor the United States. Relations suffered under Lee's predecessor Yoon Suk Yeol, who cleaved close to the United States and sought to improve ties with former colonial master Japan. But both countries' export-driven economies have now found themselves in the crosshairs of the US tariff blitz. And Lee hinted on the campaign trail that he would seek to improve ties with Beijing. He has also raised alarm by saying that a future conflict between China and Taiwan would not be South Korea's concern. — AFP


New Straits Times
5 hours ago
- New Straits Times
US-China trade talks continue despite early departure of US Treasury chief
LONDON: US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent on Tuesday described closely watched trade talks with Chinese officials as productive, as scheduling conflicts prompted his departure from London with negotiations ongoing. Top officials from the world's two biggest economies held a second day of trade talks Tuesday at the UK's historic Lancaster House, with meetings stretching into the night. All eyes are on the outcomes as both sides try to overcome an impasse over export restrictions, with US officials earlier accusing Beijing of slow-walking approvals for shipments of rare earths. Bessent left the meetings early to return to Washington for testimony before Congress, a US official told AFP. But US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and trade envoy Jamieson Greer, who were also part of the delegation, would further talks as needed with Chinese counterparts, the offical said. Earlier Tuesday, Lutnick told Bloomberg Television that the negotiations were "going well." Global stock markets were on edge, although Wall Street's major indexes climbed on hopes for progress. With meetings dragging on, "the lack of positive headlines weighed on stocks," said Kathleen Brooks, research director at XTB trading platform. US President Donald Trump told reporters Monday: "We are doing well with China. China's not easy." The London negotiations follow talks in Geneva last month, which saw a temporary agreement to lower tariffs. This time, China's exports of rare earth minerals – used in a range of things including smartphones, electric vehicle batteries and green technology – are expected to dominate the agenda. "In Geneva, we had agreed to lower tariffs on them, and they had agreed to release the magnets and rare earths that we need throughout the economy," Trump's top economic adviser, Kevin Hassett, told CNBC on Monday. Even though Beijing was releasing some supplies, "it was going a lot slower than some companies believed was optimal", he added. "Our expectation is that after the handshake, any export controls from the US will be eased, and the rare earths will be released in volume," Hassett said. Both countries "have developed almost a mirror arsenal of trade and investment weapons that they can aim at each other," said Emily Benson, head of strategy at Minerva Technology Futures. As they tap economic tools to try and shift global power structures, she told AFP, it may not be reasonable to expect a typical trade and investment deal from talks. But both sides could find ways to level off a downward spiral. Tensions between Washington and Beijing have heightened since Trump took office in January, with the countries engaging in a tariffs war. The Geneva pact temporarily brought new US tariffs on Chinese goods down from 145 per cent to 30 per cent, and Chinese countermeasures from 125 per cent to 10 per cent. But Trump later said China had "totally violated" the deal. A dialing-down of temperatures could involve Chinese efforts to shore up some export control licenses caught in their system, Benson said. She noted Beijing appeared understaffed given the volume of requests. On the US side, this could look like a relaxation of certain export curbs in the high-tech domain, she added. But observers remain cautious. "We doubt that the US will back off completely. That's likely to restrain any relief rally," said Thomas Mathews, head analyst of Asia Pacific markets for Capital Economics. Since returning to office, Trump has slapped a 10 per cent levy on friend and foe, threatening steeper rates on dozens of economies. His tariffs have dented trade, with Beijing data showing Chinese exports to the United States plunged in May. The World Bank on Tuesday joined other international organizations to slash its 2025 global growth forecast amid trade uncertainty. Meanwhile, China is in talks with partners including Japan and South Korea to try to build a united front countering Trump's tariffs. Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng is heading the team in London, which includes Commerce Minister Wang Wentao and China International Trade Representative Li Chenggang.


The Star
14 hours ago
- The Star
Beijing woos US influencers with free trip to show ‘real China'
China seeks to enlist young social media influencers from the United States to collaborate with its local content creators. - Photo: AFP BEIJING: China is inviting American influencers to join a 10-day, all-expense paid trip through the country in July, as part of Beijing's efforts to boost people-to-people exchanges and showcase the 'real China'. The initiative, titled 'China-Global Youth Influencer Exchange Programme', seeks to enlist young social media influencers with at least 300,000 followers to collaborate with Chinese content creators, according to recruitment posts by Chinese state-affiliated media outlets, including the China Youth Daily. While relations between China and the US have deteriorated in recent months over issues including geopolitics, technology and trade, the programme marks an effort to boost cultural exchanges. In 2024, President Xi Jinping had called for more exchanges between Chinese and American universities, after previously announcing a plan to welcome 50,000 American students to China. Another post in College Daily, a publication particularly targeting Chinese students in North America, specified that applicants for the exchange programme based in the US should be active on platforms such as Instagram, YouTube, TikTok and X, and should 'love Chinese culture' and 'have no history of bad behaviours'. It called on Chinese students overseas to encourage influencers in their circle to apply, and said the successful candidates will get China's official invite as well as special assistance from the state to process their visas. The trip intends to take the participants across five Chinese cities – Suzhou, Shanghai, Shenzhen, Handan and Beijing, and will cover China's e-commerce hubs, the headquarter of companies such as Xiaohongshu Technology Co and BYD Co. The influencers will also partake in cultural activities such as Taichi and be able to live-stream their trip to the Great Wall, according to the posts. Working with Chinese social media influencers on ideas, and getting their content promoted by China's state media will be part of the deal. Social media content from Western influencers travelling through China post-Covid-19 have won praise from the state media for their authentic portrayal of everyday life in the country. In April, American streamer IShowSpeed's visit to China sparked widespread curiosity among fans about advancements in Chinese technology. The authorities have tapped social media influencers to check negative information and promote positive contents. In 2023, think-tank Australian Strategic Policy Institute analysed over 120 foreign influencers, mostly active on Chinese social media, received the state's help to grow their influence in return for content that praises and spreads Beijing's narrative. - Bloomberg