Judge says detained Turkish national Rumeysa Ozturk must be moved to Vermont
Tufts University PhD candidate Rumeysa Ozturk must be transferred from Louisiana to Vermont, a federal appeals court ruled on Wednesday in a blow to the Trump administration.
Ozturk was detained by plainclothes immigration and customs enforcement (ICE) agents wearing masks on a street close to her home in Somerville, Massachusetts, on 25 March, as she was on her way to break her fast for Ramadan.
She is one of several foreign students in the US on legal visas who have been arrested by the Trump administration in its crackdown on pro-Palestinian voices.
Ozturk's lawyers said she was arrested for co-authoring an opinion article in a student newspaper. She has not been charged with any crime.
Ozturk was driven to multiple places in three states - including New Hampshire and Vermont - before being flown thousands of miles to an ICE detention centre in Basile, Louisiana, making it difficult for her to gain access to legal help and community.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Activists and legal experts have said moving her to Louisiana put her in a court system that could be more favourable to Trump's deportation push.
Last month, a judge in Massachusetts ordered that Ozturk's case be moved to Vermont, where she was previously being held. Judge William Sessions III, who is overseeing the Vermont case, gave the federal government a 1 May deadline to transfer Ozturk.
The federal government appealed that decision.
Wednesday's ruling is a strike against the federal government's push to keep Ozturk in Louisiana, a Republican-leaning state. It likely marks the first time that a federal appeals court has determined in which state the Trump administration can detain students.
Shezza Abboushi Dallal, a lawyer from Clear, one of the organisations representing Ozturk and other detained pro-Palestinian students, told Middle East Eye on Wednesday that the Trump administration faced a defeat in its bid to delay and detain Ozturk.
Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil barred from attending birth of his son Read More »
'We are hoping for her return to Vermont. Another deployed delay strategy that the government waged over the course of the past few weeks is to try to appeal the district of Vermont's order that she be returned from Louisiana…the court earlier today, 7 May, rejected that effort.'
Ozturk is a former Fulbright scholar who was pursuing her PhD at Tufts University in child study and human development when she was detained.
Since then, Tufts University and the local community have rallied around her. More than 20 friends, colleagues, and professors, including the president of Tufts University, have sent letters of support to the court detailing Ozturk's dedication to her work and community and asking for her release.
On 10 April, for the first time in years, Tufts Democrats and Republicans drafted and signed a joint statement condemning the Trump administration's arrest and detention of Ozturk, as well as the government's broader attack on international students and the right to free speech.
On 11 April, a coalition of 27 Jewish organisations, including J Street, Bend the Arc, Jalsa, and Temple Emanu-El, has also come to Ozturk's defence, submitting a proposed amicus brief to the court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
7 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Ex-CIA officer running Gaza aid security advised Boston Consulting Group
Former CIA paramilitary officer Phil Reilly, who heads a private military company that is guarding Israel's newly set up food distribution sites in Gaza, was a senior advisor at the US consultancy that is the latest partner to withdraw from the controversial aid project. The Boston Consulting Group admitted last week that it was involved in developing the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), but has since halted its involvement and distanced itself as 110 Palestinians have been killed and 583 wounded trying to access aid during GHF's 10 days of operations, according to government sources. But Reilly's role with BCG, which ended only six months ago, raises questions about whether the consultancy was also involved in developing the security side of the aid operation. Questions about the firm's role come as BCG announced on Thursday that it had fired two partners for 'unauthorised work' in relation to GHF. BCG said the partners 'failed to disclose the full nature of the work during the client acceptance process' and carried out subsequent unauthorised work in violation of company policies and protocols. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters The firm said the subsequent work had "lacked visible multi-lateral support" and that it has engaged outside counsel to investigate its involvement in the project. 'We deeply regret that in this situation we did not live up to our standards. We are committed to taking all necessary steps to address the issues identified in the ongoing investigation,' the company said. MEE asked BCG on Friday whether the firm was involved in the security operations to support GHF, what role it had played with the foundation and who had asked the firm to get involved initially. BCG directed MEE to its statement from Thursday which did not answer the questions. Consulting on Gaza A 29-year veteran of the CIA, Reilly served as a senior advisor at BCG for eight years starting in January 2017, just as US President Donald Trump's first term started, according to his LinkedIn account. It was early last year, while still holding his advisory role, that Reilly reportedly first began discussing Gaza aid with Israeli civilians in early 2024. Later in 2024, he worked on a study for Orbis, another US consultancy, which reportedly outlined a plan to outsource food aid delivery to private companies and foundations, the NYT reported. Reilly's advisory role with BCG ended in December, a month after Safe Reach Solutions (SRS), the private military company now operating in Gaza, was registered in Wyoming, a known US tax haven. Mercenary firm set to oversee Gaza aid for Israel goes on LinkedIn hiring spree Read More » Public records show that SRS's registered agent, as first reported by All-Source Intelligence, is the Wyoming-based wealth management fund, Two Oceans Trust LLC. But the public records fail to reveal many more details about SRS, including its funders. It was reported this week that McNally Capital, a Chicago-based private equity firm, has an "economic interest" in SRS, although the scale of the interest remains unclear. The lack of clarity about funding is also true of GHF which is registered with scant few other details in Delaware, another notorious US tax haven. SRS is understood to be the main company currently securing the food distribution sites that are part of Israeli and American moves to take control of aid distribution in the enclave, which have been beset by controversy. The UN and international aid agencies have sounded the alarm for weeks over concerns that the plans which have unfolded at pace failed to meet humanitarian principles and would encourage forced displacement of Palestinians. Hours before GHF was to start distributing aid in Gaza late last month, executive director Jake Wood resigned over concerns that it was impossible for the organisation to operate independently or adhere to strict humanitarian principles. Wood was replaced this week by Johnnie Moore, an evangelical leader who has advised Trump on interfaith issues. Moore has denied reports that Palestinians were killed and injured while seeking aid at GHF's sites in Gaza and said he was demanding results "with Silicon Valley precision".
Middle East Eye
20 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Israeli strikes kill dozens of Palestinians on Eid day
As millions of Muslims celebrated Eid al-Adha on Friday, Israeli air strikes killed at least 34 Palestinians across the Gaza Strip, according to media reports. Among the dead were children and at least eight people shot by Israeli soldiers while attempting to collect aid at a US-run distribution centre in Rafah, the Gaza-based government media office said. The strikes came while severe hunger continues to threaten Gaza's 2.2 million residents, with aid distribution centres established by the US and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) remaining closed for a third consecutive day. Despite the closures, the GHF told Reuters via email that it delivered essential supplies on Friday, contradicting an earlier Facebook post stating that distribution points were not operating. The suspension of the GHF's aid distribution system comes after more than 100 Palestinians were gunned down near its sites over eight days. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Earlier this week, eyewitnesses and local officials told Middle East Eye that Israeli troops opened fire directly on civilians, with many of the fatalities receiving gunshot wounds to their head or chest. Meanwhile, Israeli army's Arabic-speaking spokesperson Avichay Adraee said in a post on X that the area near distribution centers was a "closed military zone" and movement there was not permitted outside the period between 6am and 6pm. Rising journalist death toll Meanwhile, the number of journalists who have been killed in Gaza since 7 October has risen to 226 following the death of journalist Ahmed Qaljah, the media office reported. Israel has already lost the Gaza war. It just doesn't know it yet Read More » Qaljah, who worked for Al-Arabiya TV, succumbed to wounds sustained during Israeli attacks targeting a group of media workers in Gaza City's al-Ahli Arab hospital's courtyard on Thursday. The Israeli attack killed three other reporters, including correspondent Suleiman Hajjaj and photographer Ismail Badah, who both worked for Palestine Today TV, alongside photographer Samir al-Rifai, who worked for the Shams News Agency. Reporters told MEE that Israeli warplanes targeted the hospital's courtyards as journalists were covering the events on the ground. The media office condemned the Israeli "targeting, killing, and assassination of Palestinian journalists" in the "strongest terms". In a statement, the office called on international journalism bodies and organisations to condemn the Israeli assault and take action to protect media personnel amid the ongoing war in Gaza. Israeli soldiers ambushed Meanwhile, Hamas reportedly killed and wounded Israeli soldiers in a number of ambushes in Khan Younis and northern Gaza on Friday. The Israeli military admitted to the death of four soldiers and wounding of five others in a Khan Younis explosion that caused a building to collapse on Israei troops. The killed soldiers were members of elite units. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said it was a 'sad and difficult day'. There was no immediate comment from Hamas. The Friday ambushes are the latest in a series of Hamas attacks targeting Israeli troops in Gaza in recent days. At least eight soldiers have been killed in less than a week. Amid the fighting, Adraee announced more expulsion orders for civilians in north Gaza to head west, threatening to attack the areas and describing it as a "dangerous combat zones".
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
US sanctions four ICC judges over Israel and Afghanistan investigations
The administration of US President Donald Trump on Thursday issued sanctions on four judges of the International Criminal Court (ICC) over investigations into the US and its ally Israel. The sanctions build on the designation of ICC chief prosecutor Karim Khan in February, carried out under an executive order issued shortly after Trump assumed office. "This is an escalation in a series of attacks by the US government against this global judicial institution, which was created to end impunity for the worst crimes," said Meg Satterthwaite, the UN's special rapporteur on the independence of judges, speaking to Middle East Eye. "It is shocking to see a country that has for decades championed the rule of law using a tool usually reserved for corrupt or criminal actors against judges of this global judicial body." The sanctioned judges, all women, are: ICC Second Vice-President Reine Adelaide Sophie Alapini Gansou (Benin), Solomy Balungi Bossa (Uganda), Luz del Carmen Ibanez Carranza (Peru) and Beti Hohler (Slovenia). New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Gansou and Hohler have been sanctioned in connection with their decision as pre-trial judges to issue arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant in November over charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in Gaza. The US and Israel are not state parties to the Rome Statute, the treaty that established the ICC in The Hague in 2002. Both states have opposed the court's investigation into the situation in Palestine, launched by the ICC's previous prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda, in 2021. 'It is shocking to see a country that has for decades championed the rule of law using a tool usually reserved for corrupt or criminal actors against judges of this global judicial body' - Meg Satterthwaite, UN rapporteur The court's jurisdiction was based on the accession of the state of Palestine to the Rome Statute in 2015. Accordingly, the court can investigate Israeli individuals for crimes committed in occupied Palestine, which includes the Gaza Strip, the West Bank and East Jerusalem. However, Israel and the US have challenged the court's jurisdiction, saying they do not recognise Palestine as a state, and that Israel is best placed to investigate itself under the principle of complementarity as set out in Article 17 of the Rome Statute. Trump's order of 6 February reiterated this view and described the arrest warrants as an abuse of power, an allegation refuted by the ICC. The ICC is the only permanent international court tasked with the prosecution of individuals for war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide. 'President Trump's sanctions on ICC judges aim to deter the ICC from seeking accountability amid grave crimes committed in Israel and Palestine and as Israeli atrocities mount in Gaza, including with US complicity,' Liz Evenson, international justice director at Human Rights Watch, told MEE. Under Netanyahu's government, Israel has faced accusations of war crimes, genocide and crimes against humanity. The US is the largest supplier of arms to Israel and has backed its offensive in Gaza since October 2023, triggering accusations of aiding and abetting alleged crimes. Israel's war on Gaza has killed more than 54,000 Palestinians, forcibly displaced most of the 2.1 million population and made the enclave largely uninhabitable. Obstruction of justice Experts who spoke with MEE in the aftermath of Trump's order have suggested that the ICC should bring charges of obstruction of justice against the US president and any individuals behind the sanctions, based on Article 70 of the Rome Statute. The article prohibits offences against the administration of justice, including: "Impeding, intimidating or corruptly influencing an official of the Court for the purpose of forcing or persuading the official not to perform, or to perform improperly, his or her duties; and retaliating against an official of the Court on account of duties performed by that or another official." UN rapporteur urges EU to use legal powers to protect ICC from Trump sanctions Read More » The ICC has jurisdiction over Article 70 offences, irrespective of the nationality or location of the accused individuals. The Slovenian foreign ministry reacted to the sanctioning of Hohler, saying it will support her in carrying out her mandate. It also said it would propose the activation of the EU Blocking Statute. The statute primarily focuses on shielding EU operators, such as the Netherlands-based ICC, from certain US sanctions considered to have extraterritorial reach, like those against Cuba and Iran. Belgian Foreign Minister Maxime Prevot has also said his government would ask the EU to activate the statute. "While this would be the first time the blocking statute is applied in defense of the ICC, Belgium believes it is essential to protect the Court's independence and its crucial role in delivering justice for the gravest crimes," he said on Friday. The pre-trial chamber that issued the Netanyahu and Gallant decision included Gansou and Hohler, as well as French national Nicolas Guillou. It remains unclear why Guillou has been excluded from the sanctions. Legal scholar Kevin Jon Heller, who is Khan's war crimes advisor, argued that the US has sanctioned individuals who are perceived to be nationals of weaker states. 'The US seems to have sanctioned only the judges who come from smaller and less powerful states,' Heller said. The two other judges, Bossa and Ibanez Carranza, have been sanctioned for being part of the 2020 appeals chamber that authorised the ICC's investigation into crimes committed in Afghanistan since 2003. This included actions by the Taliban, Afghan National Security Forces, and US military and CIA personnel. Heller pointed out that Canadian judge Kimberly Prost was part of the same panel as the Ugandan judge Bossa and the Peruvian judge Ibanez Carranza, but she has been excluded from sanctions. 'The US seems to have sanctioned only the judges who come from smaller and less powerful states' - Kevin Jon Heller, legal advisor to Karim Khan 'That supports the 'weak state' explanation, because Judge Prost (Canada) was part of the same AC and is still an ICC judge,' he wrote on X. In response to the ICC's decision to investigate crimes in Afghanistan, the previous Trump administration imposed sanctions on ICC officials, including then-prosecutor Fatou Bensouda, and revoked her US visa. But since 2021, the ICC has shifted its strategy under current prosecutor Khan, deprioritising investigations into alleged crimes by US forces - a move widely denounced by human rights groups. Khan stated that the focus would instead be on crimes committed by the Taliban and the Islamic State - Khorasan Province, citing resource constraints and the need to concentrate on those most responsible for the gravest crimes. In January 2025, Khan applied for arrest warrants for two Taliban leaders for the crime against humanity of persecution on the grounds of gender. No applications for arrest warrants for US nationals have been made by the prosecutor. What is the impact of sanctions? The sanctions will have a wide-ranging financial impact on the affected judges, particularly on any property in the US and any transactions involving US citizens. 'As a result of today's sanctions-related actions, all property and interests in property of the sanctioned persons described above that are in the United States or in possession or control of U.S. persons are blocked and must be reported to the Department of the Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC),' the State Department said. The three ICC judges who issued the historic Netanyahu arrest warrant Read More » 'Additionally, all individuals or entities that are owned, either directly or indirectly, individually or in the aggregate, 50 percent or more by one or more blocked persons are also blocked.' The ICC denounced the sanctions, saying they aim at hindering its efforts to bring justice to victims of atrocities worldwide. 'These measures are a clear attempt to undermine the independence of an international judicial institution which operates under the mandate from 125 States Parties from all corners of the globe,' a statement by the ICC read, saying the sanctions will affect all situations being investigated by the court beyond Palestine. 'These sanctions are not only directed at designated individuals, they also target all those who support the Court, including nationals and corporate entities of States Parties.' Dutch Foreign Minister Caspar Veldkamp said the Netherlands 'disapproves' of the sanctions and stands behind the court and its officials. However, he has yet to announce specific measures to protect the sanctioned officials. MEE has reached out to the Dutch and Slovenian foreign ministries for comment.
