Irish Government accused of ‘false ignorance' on shipments of Israeli arms
He said that a 'robust' investigation was being carried out by the Department of Transport and added that any breach of Irish law 'cannot be consequence free'.
News website The Ditch has reported that several flights carrying munitions to weapons manufacturers and contractors in Israel have travelled over Ireland.
Permission is needed from Ireland's transport minister to carry munitions through Irish airspace.
Mr Harris, who is also the Foreign Affairs Minister, said last week that he did not believe weapons being used in Gaza were being flown through Irish skies based on the information available to him.
He admitted that it was 'a real challenge' to know what is being carried in planes flying above Ireland.
On Thursday, People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy accused the Government of 'false ignorance' and of 'pretending you don't know what's going on'.
He produced a green folder of what he said were waybills that show 'thousands of tons of weaponry have gone through Irish airspace on the way to be used in a genocide in Gaza'.
'This is not a mystery. The airlines admit it.'
He added: 'You want to know my practical solution? My practical solution is that the Minister for Transport should prosecute the companies. It's the law. They're currently breaking the law.'
Mr Harris said that the Department of Transport is examining the reports and agreed that any breach of Irish law 'cannot be consequence free'.
'Irish law matters, I'm very clear in relation to that, as is the Taoiseach, as is the Minister for Transport,' he told TDs.
'If there have been breaches of Irish sovereign law, decisions will need to be taken on the next steps, based on clear and robust evidence.
'I think we also need to be clear here, and I this is the point I was trying to make, that if you know existing legislation doesn't provide for the implementation of a system of routine and random inspections, and rather, it requires that there first be an appearance of intention or likelihood for a civil aircraft to depart from a point in the state in a manner that will contravene the legislation, for example, carry munitions, I think it is a legitimate question for government to now consider whether we need to amend our own domestic legislation and whether more needs to happen internationally.
'So I'm very clear any breaches of Irish law, it cannot be consequence free, I agree with you. The Department of Transport is carrying out a robust examination of all of these matters and then will advise Government on what next steps are required.'
In response to questions from Social Democrats deputy leader Cian O'Callaghan, Mr Harris said that 'no one is dragging their feet' and Ireland 'is not standing idly by' on Palestine.
He said that he intends to call his EU counterparts in the hours ahead and see if they will 'echo' Ireland's call for the EU to review Israel's obligation to adhere to human rights clauses in its trade association agreement, which the Netherlands had called for on Wednesday.
Mr Harris also said he had met senator Frances Black about her bill that would ban trade with illegal Israeli settlements on Palestinian lands.
Mr Harris and Irish premier Micheal Martin had initially committed to passing the Ms Black's Occupied Territories Bill after it was amended to make it legally 'robust', but since then have suggested new legislation may be required.
Mr Harris said that there is 'a narrow pathway' based on an advisory opinion from the International Courts of Justice, to legislate on banning trade, but Mr Harris said 'we have not yet been able to identify the narrow pathway on services, that's the truth'.
Campaigners have criticised the move to ban the trading of goods but not services, which is estimated to represent around 70% of trade activity.
'It's not a policy position. It's a legal position,' he said.
'There is a need to make sure any bill can withstand the inevitable challenge that this will face.'
He said his hope was that if Ireland brought forward such legislation that it may encourage other countries to do the same.
'If the EU refuses to act as a collective in relation to this, why don't a number of member states do what we're proposing to do here in Ireland,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Well done Keir! 50k migrants & counting. Everything you touch is a disaster so here's MY 10 point plan to fix the crisis
CONGRATULATIONS, Sir Keir! The number of people arriving here in small boats from France has reached 50,000 since your magnificent government took office. That's something to be proud of, isn't it? The way things are going, you might make it 100,000 by the end of the year. 4 Smashing the gangs was the plan you announced upon taking office. It was about as much use as howling at the moon. And although you deny it, the policy seems to have been quietly shelved. Nor will the one-in, one-out deal work. A pilot scheme which was only ever going to deal with one in 20 of the illegal migrants. You scrapped the Rwanda plan. That at least provided SOME deterrent. And so, like almost every other thing you turn your hand to, you've made things worse and worse. So here's my ten-point plan to stop what seems to be an unstoppable tide. It's not really unstoppable, if you really want to do it. 1: Let it be known that anyone arriving here illegally automatically loses their right to live in the UK, in perpetuity. Cost of this? Nil. Deterrence effect? Very high. No place to live, no permit to work, no schooling, no health care. 2: No more hotels. As Tory leader Kemi Badenoch has suggested, house the migrants who arrive in tents. Empty every hotel which has migrants in them, immediately. Cost of this? Rather less than the hotels, I would reckon. 3: No grants for swimming lessons, gym workouts and hair extensions. No grants for anything except a ticket home. 4: Withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights and all other supranational jurisdiction which stops us from solving our own problems in our own ways. They are well past their sell-by dates, anyway. 5: Abolish the immigration tribunals, immediately. They are all presided over by judges who spend most of their lives advocating the causes of asylum seekers. The legal issue is clear: Arriving illegally means no entry. 6: In complex cases, where it is either not clear where the migrant comes from, or the country of origin refuses to have them back, send them for processing at a place under British jurisdiction. Such as St Helena — a windswept island in the middle of the Atlantic. Or South Georgia. Or, for the really devious ones, Rockall. 7. For those who have already arrived and are currently going through the appeals process, let it be made clear that by arriving illegally they have automatically lost their right to stay here. Also, abolish all legal aid for those who have arrived. 4 8: Offer those who have been here for some time £1,000 to leave the country, never to return. You could throw in some free bags of Monster Munch, and one of those neck cushions, for the flight. 9: Strike a deal with the French to allow British policemen or soldiers to puncture the boats before they leave France. Or otherwise hole them below the waterline. It is obvious we can't trust the French to do this. 10: Start taking things seriously, Starmer. Begin with the conviction that all who arrive illegally must go. Including those who have already arrived. And if the Left moans, so be it. I SPOKE to Rob Davies a few days ago. He's the shopkeeper from Wrexham who was visited by the police for having put up a sign describing shoplifters as 'scumbags'. He was ticked off and warned he might have offended people. Who, shoplifters? We mustn't offend THEM now? Totally bizarre. And you can see where this policy is getting us. There is now one case of shoplifting every minute in the UK. Businesses are closing down because their losses are unsustainable. And when a hard-working shop owner complains about it, he then gets a visit from the Old Bill. Before the last election Sir Keir Starmer warned he was going to get tough on shoplifters. What happened, Keir? Meanwhile the Thames Valley Police and Crime Commissioner, Matthew Barber, has said the public must help in fighting shoplifting. Really? And risk being charged by the Old Bill for being nasty to a vulnerable person? Boring tunes Taylor-made for kids GOT your pre-order in for the new Taylor Swift album? Nope, me neither. But I suppose million upon million will. Her music is bloodless and boring, written by a committee. The lyrics are naff. But she is a consummate saleswoman. She's already been giving teasing hints as to what's on the new album. It includes a cover of a George Michael song, for example. Which is, for me, another reason to stay well away from it. Ah well, she's what a certain section of the kids want now and I suppose I am not necessarily her target audience. But couldn't the kids fall in love with something a little more exciting, and dangerous, and full of adventure? NAKED TRUTH THE Metropolitan Police is considering prosecuting the vigilantes who stopped a bloke waving his b*****s around after he dropped his trousers and pants on the Tube in front of women and children. A few blokes on board remonstrated with him and then, when he got aggressive, wrestled him to the ground and handed him over to an off-duty copper. In other words, they did the right thing. And the response of the idiots at the Met is why the public is reluctant to get itself involved when a crime takes place. UK IN A RIGHTS MESS WHEN friends make constructive criticisms, we should listen. The US State Department has just investigated human rights in the UK – something the Vice President JD Vance has been banging on about. It says our human rights worsened last year. And it claimed there were 'credible reports of serious restrictions on freedom of expression', as well as 'crimes, violence, or threats of violence motivated by antisemitism'. That seems to me pretty much bang on. Over the last 15 years our freedom to express ourselves has diminished and diminished. And that trend hastened last year with the advent of a Labour government which really hates the idea that people should express themselves freely. GOOD luck to all our readers who are about to open their A-level results today. It's always a fun time of year, isn't it? But it doesn't really matter in the end, believe me. And here's a bit of advice to anyone who got lower than As and Bs. Don't go to university. It's not worth the bother. Instead, get yourself an apprenticeship and learn something useful which will keep you in work. Soon you will be earning a decent income while the debt-laden students slum it on awful courses. High flyer? What do you take me for? NOW I really have heard it all. A trolley dolly has just won a discrimination case against British Airways. Jennifer Clifford said she was too scared to fly. Being up in the air in one of those planes made her kind of stressy, you see. So she shouldn't have been given the boot. Do you ever get the impression that, much as the Fun Boy Three suggested all those years ago, the lunatics really have taken over the asylum?
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Albanese praises RBA's rate cut despite housing concerns
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has embraced the RBA's recent rate cut despite experts raising fears the decision will price more Aussies out of the property market. On Tuesday, the Reserve Bank of Australia decided to cut the cash rate for the third time this year, bringing it down 25 basis points to 3.60 per cent. Within an hour, Mr Albanese praised the decision as the result of his government's efforts to tackle the cost-of-living crisis. 'Interest rates have just been cut again. It will mean Australians paying less on their mortgages,' he said. 'We're working hard to help families with the cost of living . There's more to do and that's what we're focused on every day.' The announcement fell on deaf ears, with a number of Australians pointing out the decision will drive up demand for housing, ultimately pushing up prices. 'Historically, every time interest rates have been cut, home prices tend to increase,' Mr van Onselen told the Daily Mail. 'Cutting interest rates is a band-aid. It can increase your borrowing capacity and it can reduce your monthly mortgage payments - so if you already have a mortgage, it's great if you're looking to buy again. 'It can lower your payments on a new home loan because you've got to pay less monthly. 'But as that lower interest rate gets capitalized into higher prices, it then reduces affordability going ahead. So, it makes affordability structurally worse down the road.' Mr Van Onselen says the root cause of the housing crisis was rising immigration. 'We've grown by 8.7million people in less than 25 years - 46 per cent population growth - and you wonder why we don't have enough housing, we don't have enough infrastructure. 'We've run one of the biggest immigration programs in the world, and we haven't built enough houses, enough infrastructure, enough anything, to cope with it.' According to his analysis, if Australia's population growth slowed by 15 per cent over the next five years, the country would end up with a surplus of 40,000 homes. 'That was buried at the back of the NHSAC's report and what that tells you is that the solution to this mess is to cut immigration,' Mr van Onselen said. The Albanese government has committed to shoring up Australia's housing supply, with a target of 1.2 million new homes in the next five years. Meanwhile, the National Housing Supply and Affordability Council predicted in May the government will fall short of its goal by at least 250,000. Even if it were to reach its goal, Mr van Onselen said rising demand fueled by government policy would keep accessibility out of reach. 'It's a government policy failure - we've got the supply issues but it won't get better until the government stops pumping demand with things like its five per cent deposit scheme and mass immigration,' he said. Despite the government's efforts to address the supply issue, NSHAC predicted Australia's housing shortage will worsen over the next five years. According to Loan Market, home loan pre-approvals spiked across the country last month as homebuyers scrambled to secure financing ahead of an expected rate cut. Loan pre-approvals were 53 per cent higher in July compared to the same time last year, with an 80 per cent spike in the Northern Territory and South Australia. Pre-approvals were up 79 per cent in Western Australia while the eastern states all recorded upticks of nearly 50 per cent. Loan Market chief executive David McQueen said a tight housing stock was forcing homebuyers to test their borrowing capacity ahead of the Spring rush.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: plan to charge EVs for road use, which jobs are least vulnerable to AI, Paul Kelly's Gravy sequel revealed
Morning everyone. Momentum is growing to start charging EV drivers a tax to drive their cars, as the federal government seeks a new revenue source to replace the fuel excise as EV takeup accelerates. Plus: a study shows the jobs least (and most) at risk from AI, Donald Trump warns Russia of 'severe consequences' if it doesn't agree to a truce in Ukraine, and Paul Kelly says farewell to Joe. 'Mind blown' | About 5% of common Australian wild birds including kookaburras and lorikeets could have undergone a 'sex reversal' where their genetic sex does not match their reproductive organs, according to a new study. Charging up | Anthony Albanese has signalled that the long-delayed reform of road charging for electric vehicle drivers will be thrashed out at next week's productivity roundtable as the surge in the use of EVs reduces the revenue from petrol. Bookie bust | A man who 'binge gambled' $40,000 in an 11-hour session was awarded VIP status by the bookmaker BlueBet and assigned a dedicated manager who encouraged him to keep betting. At the double | Qantas has cancelled flights at double the rate of Virgin, its main competitor, which had the lowest monthly cancellation rates of any major domestic airline over the past year. Racing chance | The Victorian government could save almost $500m in subsidies if it follows Tasmania in phasing out greyhound racing, according to independent analysis. Wildfire warning | The heatwave-fuelled wildfires that have killed two people in Spain and destroyed thousands of hectares of land are a 'clear warning' of the impact of the climate emergency, the country's environment minister has said. Elsewhere, 400 people have died from extreme heat in Arizona's Maricopa county alone this summer, while Alaska's capital city of Juneau is urging many residents to evacuate because of the risk of flooding caused by glacial melt. Veteran US scientists are planning a response to a government report casting doubt on the consensus on the climate crisis. Trump pledge | Donald Trump said there would be 'severe consequences' if Russia doesn't agree to end the war after he spoke to European leaders before his summit with Vladimir Putin tomorrow. A Pitts take | Los Angeles police have formally linked a break-in at Brad Pitt's home in the city in June to a string of other burglaries at properties belonging to celebrities including Nicole Kidman and Austin Butler. Caught out | David Lammy, the British foreign secretary, has referred himself to the environment watchdog after going fishing with JD Vance without the required licence during the US vice-president's trip to the UK. Rap sheet | Lawyers for Drake allege that the head of Universal Music was 'personally involved' in the notorious Kendrick Lamar diss track aimed at the rival rapper and which is now the subject of a defamation case. Al Jazeera's managing editor on Israel's killing of journalists in Gaza Al Jazeera's managing editor, Mohamed Moawad, talks to Nour Haydar about the death of their correspondent Anas al-Sharif and why he refused to leave Gaza. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ The march of artificial intelligence spells danger for professions such as accounting and research, but you'll be all right if you're in cleaning, construction or hospitality. At least so says a new report by Jobs and Skills Australia whose authors nevertheless conclude that no matter 'which sector you are in, or at what skill level: you will be influenced by AI'. It began with a mysterious death notice published in a newspaper mourning 'Joe'. But it soon became clear that the 'much-loved father' was the protagonist of Paul Kelly's How To Make Gravy and that the veteran singer was promoting Rita Wrote a Letter, a kind of coda to his famous song. Jenny Valentish hears more from the great man. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion AFLW | Officials hope a 'Goldilocks' combination of face-to-face access to players, kick-to-kick after the siren and entertaining football within a community setting will spark an upswing in attendances for the 10th season of the AFLW starting tonight with Collingwood v Carlton. Cricket | The Cricket Australia chief executive, Todd Greenberg, has warned some nations will go 'bankrupt' if they continue to play the longest format of the game, stressing he sees a future with less Test nations. With 100 days to go before the Ashes, Scott Boland says Australia won't be fazed by England's aggressive style. Tennis | Venus Williams will make her return to grand slam singles at the US Open after a two-year absence at the age of 45, making her the oldest entrant for nearly five decades. Flights to and from Bali have been identified as the worst for unruly passengers as alcohol and drug abuse fuels bad behaviour on planes, the Sydney Morning Herald reports. Far north Queensland has seen a surge of bookings from tourists, the Cairns Post says, while the Courier Mail reports the state's south-east has been hit by 'snowlike' hail. The Age celebrates the 'drab' views that are part of the appeal of Melbourne's newly reopened ferris wheel. New South Wales | 'Knitting nannas' Helen Kvelde and Dominique Jacobs face jail when they are sentenced for environmental protests. Northern Territory | Hearing at federal court Sydney in a lawsuit to protect water at Daly Waters from fracking. Business | Origin Energy and Telstra both report full-year results today. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword
