The Irish Times view on Keir Starmer's anniversary: little to cheer about
This one not only gutted his proposed reform of disability payments and blew up his government's cherished fiscal rules. It also undermined his political authority.
From now on, a hobbled Starmer will rule, despite his colossal majority, in a new coalition with backbenchers who have tasted power they are unlikely to relinquish and who have shown they have very different ambitions from those of their leadership.
There had always been a paradox at the heart of Labour's landslide. Due to the UK's capricious first-past-the-post voting system, it had been achieved on the back of a popular vote of only 34 per cent, a much lower share than the party received in 2017, when it lost to the Conservatives. Now, however, according to a recent YouGov poll, Labour has the support of only 23 per cent of voters. Nigel Farage's Reform UK, new standard bearer of the right, leads at 26 per cent,with the Conservatives drifting and rudderless at 18 per cent.
READ MORE
Starmer has been in apology mode. Only hours after becoming prime minister, having outlined ambitious plans for the 'change' agenda Labour was elected on, he had warned that 'things will get worse before they get better.' And they did. Now, he admits, he had 'squeezed the hope out,' adding: 'We were so determined to show how bad it was that we forgot people wanted something to look forward to as well.' The vision thing was, and is, missing.
He also apologised for his Enoch Powell-like comments about the dangers of the country becoming an 'island of strangers', blaming a scriptwriter for the overreaction to Farage.
Will humility and mea culpas mollify angry voters? Probably not. The party needs an ideological reset, with many backbench MPs pressing for a turn to the left.
Now the welfare cuts retreat will inevitably mean uncomfortable tax choices for the centrist party leaders, like a wealth tax, to bridge the £5 billion hole left in the budget. Backbenchers point to polling that suggests voters would react favourably to a tack to the left, with one poll finding that nearly 15 per cent of Liberal Democrat supporters and 10 per cent of Greens say they would consider voting for Labour. In contrast, the same poll shows only 1 per cent of Reform voters and 3 per cent of Conservative Party voters said they might do so.
One thing is clear, though: more of the same is a recipe for disaster.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Public finances boosted by another spike in corporate tax receipts
The Government's financial position has been boosted by what Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe described as 'a sharp increase' in corporate tax in June. Exchequer returns for the first six months of the year show the business tax generated €7.4 billion last month, which was €1.5 billion or 25 per cent up on the same month last year. June is the second most important month of the year for corporate tax - behind November - as it reflects payments from companies with financial years ending in December, which include Google, Meta, Microsoft and Intel, all of which have big operations here. After a fall-off in receipts in May, there had been concern that US trade policy uncertainty might be affecting the profitability of these firms. READ MORE But the latest figures, published by the Department of Finance, appeared to dispel those concerns with corporate tax receipts - on a cumulative six-month basis - up 7.4 per cent on last year at €13.1 billion and ahead of the department's own forecasts. Nonetheless Mr Donohoe warned the month-to-month changes highlighted the volatility of corporate tax. 'Corporation tax receipts in June have seen a sharp increase, which follows a sharp decline last month,' he said. 'This serves as a reminder of the extreme volatility in this revenue stream, and of its inherent unsuitability as a basis for permanent spending commitments,' Mr Donohoe said. 'That is why we have established the Future Ireland Fund (FIF) and the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund (ICNF) to set aside some of this potentially temporary revenue to help further protect us in the future,' he said. 'Last month, Government transferred some €3 billion into the two funds, and when the remaining transfers are made towards the end of this year, there will be around €16 billion in the FIF and ICNF," Mr Donohoe said. The latest exchequer figures showed overall tax receipts were €49.5 billion in the first six months of the year, up by 4.5 per cent on the first half of last year. When once-off tax revenues of €1.7 billion arising from the European court ruling against Apple are excluded, the department said 'underlying' tax revenues stood at €47.7 billion, which was a 6.7 per cent up on last year. On a cumulative six-month basis, income tax receipts of €17.4 billion were 4.3 per cent ahead of last year, reflecting the ongoing strength of the labour market with headline unemployment remaining at a low of 4 per cent. June was a non-VAT-due month and therefore monthly receipts 'relatively modest,' the department said. Cumulative receipts from the transactions tax for the six-month period came to €11.6 billion, up by almost 6 per cent on last year's total at this stage. Total expenditure for the first half of the year amounted to €50.9 billion, up by 8.2 per cent on 2024 and ahead of the department's profile by 0.7 per cent. The Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, the Government budgetary watchdog, is warning that overruns in day-to-day public spending are likely to top €2 billion this year. The department noted that year-on-year capital spending levels have increased substantially, with capital spending up 22.5 per cent overall. Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers said: 'Today's figures show a significant increase in capital expenditure which underscores Government commitment to investing in the infrastructure our community needs and which is critical to enhancing our economic competitiveness,' he said. At a headline level, an exchequer surplus of €4.5 billion was recorded in the first half of the year.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Any EU trade deal with US would be limited in scope initially to avoid July 9th tariffs, von der Leyen says
Any trade deal between the European Union and the United States to avoid steep trade tariffs would be limited to an 'agreement in principle', with further details to be worked out later, the European Commission president Ursula von der Leye n has said. US president Donald Trump has threatened to put tariffs of 50 per cent on imports sold into the US from the EU, if the two sides have not agreed a trade deal by July 9th. Near-blanket tariffs on 10 per cent have been charged on EU goods since early April, with cars and steel subject to higher duties. Speaking in Aarhus, Denmark, Ms von der Leyen said EU negotiators were 'ready for a deal' and wanted a negotiated solution to the transatlantic trade tensions. 'At the same time we are all preparing for the possibility that no satisfactory agreement is reached,' the head of the EU executive said. READ MORE 'As always in negotiations you never know when they are successfully concluded, we are aiming at the 9th of July,' she said. [ EU-US trade deal: Cabinet expects 10% baseline tariffs to remain even if agreement is reached Opens in new window ] It would be 'impossible' for any agreement next week to have trashed out the 'very complex' detail required for a full trade EU-US deal, given the two sides had only been in talks for three months, the German politician said. The EU was finalising a 'rebalancing' package of counter tariffs it would hike on a range of US products and industries, in the event Mr Trump's higher import duties on European businesses came into effect, she added. Earlier today, the Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe said he believes an agreement on tariffs was 'possible, but not certain.' Speaking to Ivan Yates on Newstalk's Pat Kenny Show, Mr Donohoe said that the EU would be looking for the minimum level of tariff possible 'And then for sectors that are really important to us we will be making the case that they're very important to America for special recognition of them. I think an agreement is possible, but I don't believe it's certain. 'At the moment, an assessment, a report, is being conducted by the United States government into the life science and medicine sector. And basically, the argument that Ireland is making, along with the European Union, is that if you value affordability in medicines that can make an increasingly big difference to your life, that global supply chains have a big role to play in that. 'And if you want to ship those medicines to other parts of the world, having some of your supply chain outside of America is in your long-term interest for doing that. And that briefly is the case that we are making.' Mr Donohoe said it would be 'very grim for both sides if the situation were to descend to 'tit-for-tat territory'. Trade between the EU and the US was worth €4 billion every day, if a deal did not happen and there were 'escalatory measures' that would mean the price of goods would go up on both sides of the Atlantic, which would have an impact on inflation. The second thing that would happen, he said, would be a real risk that this would be damaging for growth and for jobs, he said. 'We published figures a few weeks ago here in Ireland. A forecast of the impact on the GDP? So we did two things. We said if there's no tariffs, what will our economy look like? And if tariffs are applied, and what we modelled it as on, 10 per cent on everything going into the US and 60 per cent between the US and China. 'And what that would mean for the Irish economy very broadly is that we would still grow, but we would grow at a lower pace. We would still have a record number of people at work, but probably up to 75,000 fewer jobs created across the next two to four years and then we would see our public finances still being surplused but a smaller surplus.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Discrimination against sexual and gender minorities in Ireland has increased, UCD study finds
A new report by researchers at University College Dublin (UCD) has found the frequency of discrimination against, and unfair treatment of, sexual and gender minorities in Ireland has increased over the past year. The report published findings from two surveys undertaken in August 2024 and May 2025. Researchers noted an 'escalation in frequency' of discrimination and unfair treatment of LGBTQ+ people in Ireland, as well as an increase in the targeting of LGBTQ+ people. The findings also show support for the rights of transgender people in Ireland. It is part of the Resist project, addressing 'anti-gender' politics and mobilisations across Europe. It says these manifest differently from country to country but broadly encompass movements opposed to gendered freedoms, trans rights, feminism, abortion rights and LGBTQ+ rights. READ MORE The LGBTQ+ acronym stands for lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans and queer, with the plus symbol signalling an expansive definition that includes other identities not listed. 'Having been working in this area since 2012, the increase in targeting in the last three years has been phenomenal,' said one of the authors, Prof Kath Browne. 'You can really see the increase in media stories, how people talk and what they'll say.' In August 2024, 7 per cent of lesbian, gay, bisexual or queer survey respondents said discrimination or unfair treatment happened 'often or very often'. When the survey was undertaken again in May 2025, this figure rose to 20 per cent. 'There is an indication of a trend from 7 per cent and 20 per cent, but because of the number of LGBTQ+ people in the survey are quite small, we would need more research to truly understand the effects and implications,' Prof Browne said. The survey dealt separately with the experiences of trans and non-binary respondents, 85 per cent of whom reported facing discrimination sometimes, often or very often in the past year. Seventy-one per cent of lesbian, gay, bisexual and queer respondents reported experiencing hostility because of their political views on feminism or LGBTQ+ rights, compared with 30 per cent of heterosexual respondents. Ninety per cent of trans or non-binary respondents reported experiencing hostility. 'LGBTQ people are more likely to be targeted on their political views, even if they hold the same views as their straight peers,' Prof Browne said. The survey report shows robust support for women's and LGBTQ+ rights in Ireland – 83 per cent of all respondents agreed that gender-based violence is a critical issue that needs more attention and resources. The majority of respondents (69 per cent) expressed support for trans people, agreeing that trans rights are human rights. Support for trans rights was higher among lesbian, gay, bisexual and queer respondents (88 per cent) compared with heterosexual respondents (67 per cent). 'The presumption is there's more of a divide within LGBTQ+ communities in other countries,' Prof Browne said, 'whereas here [in Ireland] we don't see that divide.' On women's rights, 82 per cent of respondents agreed that accessing safe and legal abortion services is an essential component of healthcare. One thousand people were surveyed in August 2024 and in May 2025. Of those surveyed in August, 50 per cent were women, 49 per cent were men, and 1 per cent were trans or non-binary. Of those surveyed, 9 per cent identified as lesbian, gay, bisexual or queer. In May 2025, the percentage of LGBTQ+ people was the same, with women making up 56 per cent of those surveyed, and men 43 per cent. The reported concluded: 'This research demonstrates that there is broad support for LGBTIQ+ people, women's rights and abortion. This exists alongside a rise in the targeting of these groups and of those who support them.'
