Klemzig early learning centre under investigation over storage of children's images
The state's Education Standards Board (ESB) chief executive Benn Gramola said the investigation began when they received a complaint "of inappropriate discipline" in early May from a parent whose child attended the Little Shining Stars Early Learning Centre.
He said as part of that investigation, ESB officers found "photos taken of children in care to evidence nappy rash and minor scratches and grazes" at the Klemzig centre.
"The concern with that is obviously we don't consider that appropriate," he said.
"There's a small number of images that were identified as part of our investigation and the service is being proactive in helping us and being cooperative with us.
"We believed this is a misguided arrangement or process to evidence injury or nappy rash within the service. We don't believe there is any malicious intent with this."
The ESB seized those devices and referred the matter to SA Police, who Mr Gramola said found no evidence to warrant criminal charges.
The ESB issued an emergency action notice and directed Little Shining Stars services to notify the families of each child enrolled during times when the photos were taken as well as engage a counselling service for the children and their families.
It also directed the centre to reset all service devices and permanently delete the images.
The centre was also ordered to amend their policies and procedures to ensure they were in line with national regulations.
The ESB further issued emergency action notice to four other Little Shining Stars centres at Pooraka, Virginia, Wayville and Evanston regarding the practice of taking and storing images evidencing injuries.
The ESB also said the service provider had terminated the employment of three female workers following the parent's complaint that children were being tapped on the head during nap times.
The ABC has contacted the centre for a formal response.
ESB chief executive Benn Gramola said the Little Shining Stars incident was considered "isolated".
"I want to reassure families that children's safety remains our highest priority," he said.
"I encourage staff, families, and members of the public to report any concerns or complaints about early childhood education and care services to the Education Standards Board."
The ESB said the investigation was continuing and other regulatory action, including prosecution, may be taken when it ends.
More money was invested in the ESB in 2023, which has seen service visits rise by 63 per cent on the previous year, and staffing levels double.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
7 minutes ago
- ABC News
Environmentalist Mark Graham barred from Forestry Corp offices after protest
A prominent ecologist who allegedly breached bail by attending a protest at NSW Forestry Corporation offices and allegedly injuring a police officer has been ordered to stay at least 500 metres away from the state-owned logging service. Mark Stewart Graham was arrested in June after he attended and filmed an environmental protest at the Forestry Corporation offices in Coffs Harbour. Police allege he attempted to avoid arrest and struck a police officer on the foot. He was later released on bail. Mr Graham was arrested again on July 9 after he allegedly sent a message to the mother of Coffs Harbour Mayor Nikki Williams on July 8, saying that the mayor had "earned a place in hell". The 49-year-old was denied bail at Coffs Harbour Local Court earlier this month on charges of intimidation, contravening an AVO, and hindering police. On Wednesday, he appeared before the NSW Supreme Court via video link, where he again sought bail release. Justice Richard Weinstein granted bail on the condition that Mr Graham not travel within half a kilometre of the Forestry Corporation offices. Justice Weinstein remarked that a Forestry Corporation vehicle was akin to "a red flag to a bull" for the defendant. "We want to prevent the volatility." Mr Graham is a prominent local environmentalist and campaigner who has previously featured in ABC documentaries, including Australia's Wild Odyssey. He also served as a one-term councillor on the City of Coffs Harbour Council in 2008. In opposing his bail, the DPP argued the defendant posed an "unacceptable risk to workers and the community". But Justice Weinstein said that by not granting bail, it was possible that Mr Graham could spend nine months in custody, which would likely exceed the non-parole period for the offences he was charged with. Affidavits and letters of support for Mr Graham were tendered to the court, including from the CEO of the Bob Brown Foundation, Steven Chaffer. Justice Weinstein said that these significant community ties and his relatively recent criminal history had to be weighed against his risk in what he described as an "unusual little case". "Mr Graham is a perfectly respectable citizen until about 2022 or thereabouts, perfectly law-abiding, and then on one view, he goes a little bit off the rails after that," Mr Weinstein said. As part of his bail conditions, Mr Graham will have to report daily to Coffs Harbour police station, is subject to a curfew, and must not use or possess any encrypted device or approach any prosecution witnesses. Mr Graham will return to Coffs Harbour Local Court on September 17.
ABC News
7 minutes ago
- ABC News
Names released of 29 failing childcare centres at risk of losing funding, with more expected to follow
The names of 29 childcare businesses that have failed to meet national quality and safety standards have been made public, with 11 of the centres based in Western Australia. Compliance actions were issued to the centres last week by the federal education department. It's the first time the warnings have been handed down, after federal parliament passed legislation which allows the government to strip funding from centres that don't pass basic checks. The National Quality Standards (NQS) relate to the health, safety and education of children at all childcare centres, family day care facilities, outside school hours care, preschool and kindergarten. The centres issued with warnings failed to meet the standards for at least seven years and were required to tell parents about the compliance action by this week. Some 30 centres have been warned and the ABC has been told that more will be added to the list. While all the names will be released eventually, 29 have been made public so far. They include childcare centres, family day care centres and out of school care, which looks after children in primary school. At this stage, no large for-profit childcare companies are on the list that has been made public. Warnings were issued to five centres in Queensland, among them was the Cairns Regional Family Day Care, Babyco Family Day Care and Moonlight Family Day Care Services. In New South Wales, two family daycare centres, Newton Family Day Care and Little Oz Kids Family Day Care Pty Ltd — Oakhurst, were warned. Four childcare centres had a compliance action issued, while Cooinda Early Learning Centre OOSH, a service which provides care to primary school children after school hours, was asked to improve its standards. Western Australia had the highest number of centres warned. Four centres that care for primary school aged children before and after school have been told to improve their standards. Seven other family and centre-based centres have been given six months to lift standards. Provider Lex Education has received a warning for two of its centres. The NQS ranks each centre on how it manages educational programs, children's health and safety, the setup of play areas, staffing, relationships with children, partnerships with families, governance and leadership. Education Minister Jason Clare says the centres have six months to improve. "These centres need to lift their game or they will face further consequences," he said in a statement. The government can either cut funding to a centre, place conditions on a centre's Child Care Subsidy (CCS) approval, have the approval suspended or cancelled. The CCS approval is essential for a centre to operate. Early Childhood Education Minister, Jess Walsh, said that while the vast majority of educators do the right thing, the compliance notices serve as a warning. "Today's action should signal to all early childhood education and care providers that the National Quality Standards are not optional, and that all services must be up to scratch," she said in a statement.
ABC News
7 minutes ago
- ABC News
Alleged murder victim's body not found for 20 days, as man charged granted home detention bail
The body of an alleged murder victim was not found for 20 days and her cause of death remains "unascertained" – but her alleged killer's bloodied fingerprints were found at a crime scene, a court has heard. Lionel Ernest Bernard, 52, previously pleaded not guilty to murdering his 44-year-old partner after her decomposing body was discovered at a home in Felixstow in November 2023. He was granted home detention bail in the Adelaide Magistrates Court today, but will not be freed because his proposed bail address – to live with a family member – was not deemed suitable. Mr Bernard's defence lawyer, Jane Powell, told the court a post-mortem report had listed the victim's cause of death as "unascertained", and noted she had comorbidities which could have played a role in her death, including liver disease and heart disease. "At trial, the primary issue will be causation … my submission is that the prosecution will not be able to exclude other causes of death," she said. Ms Powell said the report noted the victim had multiple facial injuries which occurred around her time of death, but they had not caused her death. She said prosecution evidence included CCTV footage of her client at the home around the time the woman died, while Mr Bernard had attempted to call triple-0 twice "three or four hours apart". Ms Powell said her client – who grew up in the state's APY Lands – had limited English skills and may not have been able to articulate to a call-taker. The court heard the victim was last seen alive on October 25, 2023, and that Mr Bernard had attempted to catch a bus to Port Augusta on October 26 before succeeding the next day, on October 27. It heard he went to his brother's house in Port Augusta, and the victim's phone was later found at that address. Kirby Draper, prosecuting, told the court Mr Bernard's family members had been "lying" when they gave statements to police suggesting they had spoken to the victim the day after Mr Bernard arrived in Port Augusta. "We say, on the prosecution case, that cannot be right," she said. "The phone attributable to the deceased was in the defendant's possession." She said the victim's body was found on November 15, and when police arrived at the scene they found "a very significant pool of blood on a chair" and more blood throughout the house. She said there were "rudimentary" efforts made to clean the area, while an attempt had also been made to conceal boots with the defendant's DNA and the victim's blood on them in a cupboard. "Perhaps most compellingly, there is smeared blood and cleaning cloths stained with that blood … (and) the evidence of fingerprints, or palm impressions of the defendant marked in the deceased's blood," she said. She said while the pathology report had noted the victim had a number of comorbidities, there was not evidence they were "at end of life stage". Ms Kirby also told the court the triple-0 calls were made around the time Mr Bernard was attempting to leave Adelaide. She told the court prosecutors opposed bail on three grounds including the gravity of the offending, risk of re-offending and the risk Mr Bernard could abscond. She said two proposed home detention addresses were not suitable because potential witnesses resided at one, while the alleged victim of an unrelated domestic violence incident lived at another. Magistrate Justin Wickens said he would grant Mr Bernard, who was assisted by an interpreter, release on home detention bail if a suitable address could be found for him to reside. He adjourned the case for a month to allow time to find a suitable residence.
