A new book reveals Macron's exploitation of memory in the relationship with Algeria
The book, published by 'Robert Laffont' publishing house, is an 'investigation into the real President Emmanuel Macron,' authored by Étienne Campion. In it, the author introduces the early beginnings of the Élysée Palace master's thinking on dealing with the Algerian file, and at the forefront of its dimensions is the memory dimension, which is considered the most sensitive among all other files.
The author says: 'Macron's story with Algeria began in 2016. Where did it come from? What motivated him to focus his efforts on the memory file with Algeria?' The author answers this question by attributing the reason to the turbulent political relationship between Paris and Algeria, which has extended for decades. 'Because the Algerian issue is not considered by the French due to the wounds left by memory and repressed memories.'
Étienne Campion believes that the file of France's colonial past in Algeria posed a challenge that all of Macron's predecessors faced, such as Nicolas Sarkozy (2007 / 2012), and François Hollande (2012 / 2017) also did not deal with the file for various reasons. Therefore, Macron tried to embody the desire for reconciliation between Algeria and Paris, crediting the historian Benjamin Stora, Algerian-born (born in Constantine in 1950), for this.
According to the book, Benjamin Stora was the first to confirm that 'the issue of France's colonial past in Algeria directly or indirectly affects everyone on both sides: descendants of immigrants, Pieds-Noirs, Harkis, Jews, conscripts… an unimaginable collective memory.'
Here, Étienne Campion pointed out that the historian Benjamin Stora met Emmanuel Macron in 2014, and according to the same source, the credit for this goes to Paul Jean-Ortiz, the diplomatic advisor to the former French President, François Hollande, knowing that Jean-Ortiz was an old friend of historian Stora.
Despite Jean-Ortiz's death in the same year, the relationship between the historian and the future president of France at the time remained. They met in 2016, and Macron was a prospective presidential candidate. During the meeting, the French president showed an overwhelming desire to tackle this sensitive file, unlike his predecessor François Hollande, who was cautious about taking it too far.
Benjamin Stora was not aware of what Macron, the presidential candidate, was thinking, says Étienne Campion, when he visited Algeria in February 2017, where he issued a statement that turned many expectations upside down when he described colonialism as a 'crime against humanity' and acknowledged that 'we must face it and apologize to those against whom we committed these acts.'
The author asks: 'Why did he do that? Was it to position himself among progressives? And was it to make a sharp turn to the left?' He answers: 'Benjamin Stora has nothing to do with it, but he believes that his excessive will to act is shown through this initiative. Can this statement lead to anything? Stora, optimistic despite everything, believes that this young president, who, if he addresses him informally, may have the same vision and boldness that previous generations did not have.'
The author also spoke about a meeting between Macron and former Algerian President Abdelaziz Bouteflika in December 2017, during an official visit to Algeria, at his therapeutic residence. The French president tried to get an approach from his Algerian counterpart on the 'Harkis' issue, telling him: 'Mr. President, I am a young president, and I am well aware that I did not live through that period. Isn't this the right time for forgiveness?' However, the former president responded firmly. 'These are traitors… Never.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
El Chorouk
2 days ago
- El Chorouk
French Hold Macron Responsible for Losing in Algeria
President Abdelmadjid Tebboune's visit to Italy last weekend received particular attention from political and media circles in France, given its proximity to an unprecedented political and diplomatic crisis between Algeria and Paris. Leading specialists and political analysts considered it a resounding failure of French diplomacy. The French discussed President Tebboune's visit to Rome from the perspective of Rome being Paris's main competitor in the struggle for influence in the former French colony. They focused on the economic and geopolitical gains the Italians have achieved from their rapprochement with Algeria, as well as the losses incurred by France due to the mismanagement of the crisis with it, which began, as is well known, last summer following France's biased position toward the Moroccan regime on the Western Sahara issue. The launch was based on the outcomes of President Tebboune's visit to Rome, the second of its kind in about three years. This visit, as is well known, culminated in the signing of numerous partnership agreements in various sectors, including industry, energy, agriculture, energy transition, and security. The distinguished reception President Tebboune received from officials in the capital of Roman civilisation was, in itself was a powerful message to the French side. Images and videos of President Tebboune walking alongside Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni were broadcast on the far-right CNews channel on Thursday, July 24, 2025. A journalist commented with regret on these scenes and protocols, saying, 'It's extremely humiliating to be French. It's unbearable,' according to Louis de Raguenel. The same political analyst added, 'It's a state visit, with all the usual protocols, not a secret visit.' He continued, 'If Giorgia Meloni is doing this, she's doing so because she feels empowered by the Italian people. She's not afraid of us at all.' He pointed out that Meloni is defending her country's supreme interests, as demonstrated by the outcomes of this visit, which generate economic benefits for the Italians at a time when the French should be defending their strategic interests, rather than continuing to display moral fanaticism and defend interests that do not belong to France. This was a reference to Macron's decision to side with the Moroccan regime in the Western Sahara issue. The visit also had a significant impact on the French, as it came just days after the European Union announced its intention to resort to arbitration in the case of the partnership agreement between Algeria and Brussels. This measure was intended to demonstrate European solidarity against Algeria, even though France was behind this sudden move, which came at a time when the two parties had begun negotiations to resolve differences and review the agreement under its provisions. The shock was also present for Bernard Cohen-Hadad, head of the Marcel Etienne think tank, who, on the same channel, discussed the excellent level of relations between Algeria and Rome, as well as the return of warmth to ties with Spain, which, he said, runs counter to French interests. He held the French side responsible for what was happening, due to the decision taken by Macron last summer regarding the Western Sahara issue. The spokesman described what happened to France after President Tebboune visited Rome as a 'slap in the face' delivered by Giorgia Meloni. Bernard Cohen-Haddad said, 'It doesn't make you happy to be French when you see this slap. It's a slap in the face for French diplomacy.' The French fear that Italy will become a pivotal player in relations between Algeria and the European Union, due to its diplomatic acumen in not siding with the Moroccan regime in the Western Sahara issue. This issue has cost some European countries, such as France and Spain, many of their interests and privileges in a country the size of Algeria, due to inaccurate calculations, as Bernard Cohen-Hadad has stated.
El Chorouk
4 days ago
- El Chorouk
Algeria And Rwanda Sign Military Cooperation Protocol
On Wednesday, the Deputy Minister of National Defense, Chief of Staff of the People's National Army, Army General Saïd Chanegriha, received in Algiers Rwandan Minister of Defense Juvenal Marizamunda, where a military cooperation protocol was signed. According to a statement from the Ministry of Defense, the two sides reviewed opportunities for bilateral military cooperation, as well as ways to develop and enhance coordination on issues of common interest. The two sides also discussed the security challenges facing the world in general, and the African continent in particular, and exchanged views on various current issues. In a speech delivered on the occasion, the Army General Said Chanegriha began by welcoming the Rwandan Minister of Defense, noting the new dynamic witnessed in bilateral relations, marked by the exchange of visits between officials of the two countries. The Army General also affirmed that the signing of the Algerian-Rwandan joint governmental agreement protocol for cooperation in the military field on the occasion of this visit reflects the determination of the leaders of the two countries to promote bilateral relations to be exemplary.
El Chorouk
5 days ago
- El Chorouk
French Right Demands EU Halt Negotiations With Algeria!
European MP and second-in-command of France's right-wing 'Les Républicains' party, François-Xavier Bellamy, revealed that the silence surrounding Interior Minister Bruno Retailleau for weeks, as he stopped attacking Algeria, was a result of a request from French authorities, hoping for Sansal's release. He also revealed that Retailleau would meet with French President Emmanuel Macron on Thursday to clarify matters regarding the management of the crisis with Algeria. François-Xavier Bellamy stated: 'The Interior Minister, and generally in the European Parliament (…), were asked to remain silent (regarding Algeria), otherwise the fate of Boualem Sansal's release would be risked, which we were informed was imminent.' This is the second such statement in less than a week from 'Les Républicains,' following the tense statements made by party leader Bruno Retailleau last weekend. The French Interior Minister had announced the end of the undeclared truce with Algeria last Friday, when he said in press statements: 'The diplomacy of good intentions has failed… We must change our tone and rely on the balance of power chosen by the Algerian government itself,' he claimed. As symbols of the French right freed themselves from the political constraints imposed on them in dealing with Algeria, the threads of the conspiracy against Algeria from within the European Parliament began to unravel. On Monday evening, the vice-president of 'Les Républicains' demanded, in a statement to Agence France-Presse (AFP), that the European Union make the release of French-Algerian writer Boualem Sansal a 'fundamental condition' for the negotiations expected to begin soon between Algeria and Brussels. Like his party leader, the European MP strongly criticized his country's stance in dealing with the escalating crisis with Algeria, considering it 'negative,' noting that: 'What we are witnessing are the consequences of a form of submission (of France to Algeria),' while commenting on the positions of the Élysée Palace and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, saying that they preferred to return to 'a position of surrender and negativity, which will contribute to tarnishing France's reputation, not only before Algeria, but on the international stage in general.' It is known that Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot did not delay much in responding to Bruno Retailleau's demands. He expressed his complete rejection of what his government colleague said in a tweet on the 'X' platform, which read: 'There is no diplomacy of good feelings, nor diplomacy of resentment. There is only diplomacy.' Although he did not target Retailleau by name, the response was clear to the phrase 'the diplomacy of good intentions has failed.' Based on the statement by the European MP from 'Les Républicains,' Retailleau will meet with French President Emmanuel Macron on Thursday to discuss the position the French government should adopt, given the Algerian side's adherence to the sovereignty of judicial decisions in Sansal's case, and thus its rejection of repeated French demands in this regard. The leader of 'Les Républicains,' who also holds the portfolio of the Ministry of Interior, demands the use of a balance of power logic with Algeria, due to the issue of migrants and the cancellation or revision of the 1968 agreement. These demands are rejected by the French President and the Foreign Minister, who consider them outside the Interior Minister's powers, which puts Retailleau's future in François Bayrou's government at a real test.
