New Zealand PM mulls privacy laws after aide ‘secretly recorded sex workers'
Michael Forbes, a senior aide, resigned after the local news outlet Stuff alleged he covertly recorded audio of sessions with sex workers and secretly photographed women at the gym.
The prime minister, Christopher Luxon, said he was 'shocked' by the news – but it was unclear whether Forbes had broken the law.
'If you're a New Zealander you ask quite legitimate questions about how does this behaviour happen, and is it legal or illegal,' he told reporters on Thursday. 'I have that same reaction to it as well.'
The manager of a Wellington brothel where the recordings allegedly took place told the broadcaster RNZ that privacy laws needed overhauling when it came to recording people without their knowledge.
'This is an issue for all women. Women are being recorded, photographed, filmed without their consent or knowledge and heaven only knows where it's ending up. This is the main issue and that's what needs to be focused on.'
Luxon said new privacy laws could be drafted to clear up the legal grey area. 'I'm open to looking at our settings again as we go through this experience. We have a series of laws, whether it's the harmful digital bill, whether it's the privacy laws, or now new stalking laws, but we're open to looking at that further as well,' he said.
The incidents were investigated by police but did not lead to any charges, Luxon said, and occurred after Forbes had been vetted to work for the social development minister, Louise Upston.
Forbes had an obligation to declare those incidents to the prime minister's office 'because it impacts the office and the reputation of the office, for obvious reasons', Luxon said. 'But that didn't happen.'
In a statement to RNZ, DI John Van Den Heuvel, the Wellington district manager of criminal investigations, said police also found 'a number of photos and video of women in public spaces, and what appears to be women in private addresses, taken from a distance away'.
Police considered the available evidence and concluded it did not meet the requirements for criminality, and therefore charges could not be filed, he said.
'The individual concerned voluntarily spoke with police and admitted to taking the images and recordings. He was reminded of the inappropriateness of his behaviour and encouraged to seek help,' he said.
Forbes deleted the images in the presence of police.
Police were unable to progress the matter further, but should any new information arise, it would be 'thoroughly considered', Van Den Heuvel said.
The police commissioner, Richard Chambers, told the media on Thursday the Department of Internal Affairs would conduct a 'deep dive' into what had happened. Chambers said the allegations were 'obviously very concerning' but did not believe police had erred by not charging Forbes.
'I have faith in the decisions that have been made based on the [information] that's been available to the investigation team or district crime manager in Wellington,' he said.
Forbes, a former journalist who became Luxon's deputy chief press secretary in February, apologised in a statement sent to the media.
'I want to offer my sincerest apologies to the women I have harmed,' he said. 'In the past, I was in a downward spiral due to unresolved trauma and stress, and when confronted with the impacts of my behaviour a year ago, I sought professional help, which is something I wish I had done much earlier.
'What I failed to do then was make a genuine attempt to apologise. Instead, I tried to move on without offering those I had harmed the acknowledgment, accountability, or amends they deserved. I recognise how wrong that was.'
'I understand that my past actions may have undermined the trust people place in me. So I have resigned from my job to focus on the work I need to do.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
6 hours ago
- The Independent
Family's desperate plea to father who has been on the run with his children in the wild for nearly four years
The family of a fugitive father have for the first time issued a direct appeal in a desperate attempt to get him to return home with his three children from New Zealand 's wilderness. Tom Phillips has been on the run with his children – Ember, now nine, Maverick, ten, and Jayda, 12 – since December 2021. A warrant was issued for Phillips' arrest in 2023 over his suspected involvement in a bank robbery. The family was last seen walking in a grass field near Marokopa town on the country's North Island, spotted by two young hunters who discreetly recorded them. In the three years and eight months Phillips and his children have spent in the bush, his wider family and parents, Neville and Julia, have never given interviews. Now as they're coming to the end of four winters in the wild, Phillips mother, Julia, has written a heartfelt letter to bring them home, according to New Zealand news outlet Stuff. 'Tom - I feel really sad that you thought you had to do this. Not considering how much we love you and can support you,' the letter started, read by Phillips' sister Rozzi in an interview with Stuff. 'It hurts every time I see photos of the children and of you and see some of your stuff that is still here. Thinking what could have been if you had not gone away. 'Jayda, Maverick, Ember - I love you so much and really miss being part of your lives. Everyday I wake up and hope that today will be the day that you will come home.' Phillips fled with his children after a dispute with their mother, identified only as Catherine. He did not have legal custody of the children and violated a custody order by taking them to an 'unknown location'. It is believed the children have had no outside contact since. Despite numerous police searches, rewards and public appeals, there had been no trace of Phillips until the October sighting. After the encounter, one of the hunters alerted police, who launched a search with two helicopters including a military chopper with night vision. They were unable to find the family. Rozzi Phillips described the letter as 'from a mother's heart, just to her son', believing that the father will see the letter at some point. 'Maybe he's going to see this, and maybe he's going to get to see that he can come home, and that we are here for him, and it might just be okay,' she told Stuff. The sister also joined his mother in issuing an emotional appeal directly to Phillips. 'There's a lot of love and there's a lot of support, and we're ready to help you walk through what you need to walk through,' she said. 'I miss you, and I miss being part of your life, and I really want to see you and the kids and be part of your lives again. You're very special to me. You're my friend, as well as my brother, and I love you, and it's okay.' Rozzi Phillips also echoed a previous witness, who describe the family as seeming 'well prepared for the wilderness', according to Stuff. She said her brother had completed a six-month outdoor survival program and often took the kids hunting. She believes he is a skilled builder and could build the children a shelter. An arrest warrant for Phillips was issued soon after he vanished in late 2021, but the public has been warned not to approach him as he may be armed. The children's mother previously gave an emotional plea in video released last year: 'I am standing here before you today begging you for your help to bring my babies home.' 'They are just innocent children, they don't deserve to be treated this way. They do not deserve the life that is being provided to them right now.'
The Sun
9 hours ago
- The Sun
Perv teacher Myah Adams, 27, who tried to keep conviction for sex acts with teen student, 15, a secret is unmasked
A HIGH school teacher who confessed to grooming a teen can now be named. The sick former teacher performed sexual acts on a 15-year-old boy after repeatedly flirting with him on Snapchat. 2 Myah Adams, 27, from Auckland, New Zealand, hoped to remain anonymous - but a judge has ruled to lift the anonymity order and unmask her. He ruled that it was in the public interest to expose her - and that it outweighs her suffering from a bad rep. He said there was a significant breach of trust in this case given Mrs Adams was a teacher. But her other wish was granted. The perv - whose reputation now lies in tatters - sobbed as the judge sentenced her to two years and one month of imprisonment. But Mrs Adams was let off the hook - almost. Her sentence was swapped for 10 months of home detention. It was partly because of the impact imprisonment would have on her young daughter. The teacher gave the underage boy vapes, booze and even her credit card to manipulate him. She showered him in compliments and flirted heavily online. The teacher even took grooming to a new level by taking him out of school to the hairdresser's. Pals of boy bombarded with nudes by teacher 'praised him for being lucky' They went to the cinema, where she performed a sexual act on him. After driving him to a secluded car park for more action, Mrs Adams tried to hush up what she'd done. She asked the unnamed boy to keep it "on the low down" then started sending him nudes on Snapchat. The pervy teacher's lawyer argued that the risk of re-offending was low, and the age gap apparently wasn't very big. But the victim's mental health had already taken a hit. His grades fell behind his peers as he spiralled into psychological turmoil. Despite this, the court agreed to take her off the Child Sex Offenders Register. They decided she poses no future threat to children. The victim and his family opposed her being allowed anonymity. Judge Brooke Gibson said: 'The public interest in knowing the identity of the teacher who committed the offending considerably outweighs the impact of publication on Ms Adams. "That public interest is not diminished by Ms Adams leaving the teaching profession, which is a likely outcome, even if Ms Adams had not taken that decision herself."
The Independent
18 hours ago
- The Independent
A soldier in New Zealand is sentenced to two years in military prison for attempted espionage
A New Zealand soldier, who admitted trying to spy for a foreign power, was sentenced to two years in military prison followed by discharge from the army. The sentencing by a judge and a panel of three senior military officers Wednesday came two days after the man pleaded guilty to three charges, including attempted espionage. It was the first conviction for spying in New Zealand's history. The soldier's name was suppressed, as was the name of the country he sought to pass secrets to. Military court documents said the man believed he was engaged with a foreign agent in 2019 when he tried to communicate military information, including base telephone directories and maps, assessments of security weaknesses, his own identity card and log-in details for a military network. The wording of the charge said his actions were 'likely to prejudice the security or defense of New Zealand.' The soldier wasn't speaking to a foreign agent, but rather an undercover New Zealand police officer collecting intelligence on alleged right-wing extremist groups, documents supplied by the military court showed. Judge Kevin Riordan said the espionage attempts were unsophisticated, unlikely to cause harm and naive, but his actions were still serious. 'There is no such thing as a non-serious act of espionage," Riordan said, according to Radio New Zealand. "There is no trivial act of espionage.' The soldier came to the attention of law enforcement as part of an operation that was established after a March 2019 terrorist attack on two mosques in the city of Christchurch, when an Australian white supremacist opened fire on Muslim worshipers, killing 51. Officers spoke to the man twice about his involvement in a group, court documents showed, and after the government became aware he had expressed a desire to defect he was contacted by the undercover officer. When the soldier's hard drive was searched, investigators found a copy of Christchurch gunman Brenton Tarrant's livestreamed video of his massacre and a manifesto document he published online before the killings. Possession of either without permission is a criminal offense in New Zealand and the soldier, who pleaded guilty to that charge as well, joins several others convicted in New Zealand of having or sharing banned material. In a statement read to the court by his lawyer, the man said the two nationalist groups with which he was involved were 'no more than groups of friends with similar points of view to my own,' according to RNZ. The lawyer, Steve Winter, added that his client denied supporting the Christchurch shooter's ideology. The soldier, who was based at Linton Military Camp near the city of Palmerston North, also pleaded guilty to accessing a military computer system for dishonest purposes. The amended suite of three charges replaced 17 counts levelled against him earlier in the proceedings. New Zealand's Army Chief Maj. Gen. Rose King said there was no place for people like the soldier in the country's military. 'The actions of this individual were deplorable,' she said in a statement. 'They were incredibly poorly judged and brought risk to all of those he served alongside, as well as the wider New Zealand public.' The three charges carried maximum prison terms varying from seven to 10 years in New Zealand. He had been due to stand trial by court-martial before he admitted the offenses. His was the first charge in a New Zealand military court for espionage or attempted spying. The last time such a case reached the civilian courts was in 1975, when a public servant was acquitted on charges alleging he had passed information to Russian agents.
