Reality check for Liverpool after summer transfers and tragedy
Alexander Isak may soon become a Liverpool player. That will be decided soon enough by the transfer market; a game of charades is being played before money eventually dictates its conclusion.
Modern football's eternal melodramas fade into significance when considering the player Isak could replace as a Liverpool centre-forward.
The club plays under the shadow of the loss of Diogo Jota, his death alongside his brother André Silva on a Spanish highway, its shattering of family and friends a reminder that football is played by real people with real lives.
Liverpool's pre-match lineup did not feature a No 20, Jota's number retired.
The season ahead will be played in the memory of a popular, skilled yet understated professional, 12 months ago at Ipswich the scorer of the first Premier League goal of Arne Slot's reign. Jota died a champion, a beloved teammate. Before kick-off, Wembley was supposed to drop to a minute's silence, only for an idiot fringe of Crystal Palace's fans to shame themselves by chanting.
A tiny minority though enough for a booed response from Liverpool fans, referee Chris Kavanagh blowing his whistle quickly. What should have been a moment of perspective was sullied. Football's ability to crack on blithely in the face of tragedy is one of its worst qualities.
The Palace contingent, 99% of whom had been observant, wanted to get their own message across. 'Uefa mafia' declared a banner, highlighted by burning pyro. Palace's summer of FA Cup celebration is still overshadowed by the legal wrangle over their European participation – the outcome of the club's appeal due to be announced on Monday – while Uefa and Nottingham Forest principal Evangelos Marinakis had names taken in vain in a lengthy chorus of disdain.
The show rolled inexorably on, Wembley offering a snapshot of a new Liverpool. Whether Jota would have been part of the sporting director Richard Hughes' plans to overhaul the squad Jürgen Klopp left last year for Slot is for the birds but it was Hugo Ekitiké, part of the overhaul, who scored first.
As a central striker, Ekitiké looked much like the real deal should Isak not arrive. A player denied a chance to shine as Paris Saint-Germain turned to galacticos laid his marker, though rued a couple of misses. Florian Wirtz added grace and magic, all drops of the shoulder and accelerations, sometimes strolling, sometimes darting, carrying the haughty, aristocratic air of the very best German footballers.
Liverpool became champions last season by their consistency, patiently taking the steam from opponents. Pre-season and Wembley suggest a more open-house approach, with attendant vulnerabilities. Amid the sound and fury of an occasion played at near-full pelt by both teams, the problems of Liverpool turning the dial up to 11 on attack were soon apparent.
Jeremie Frimpong is not Trent Alexander-Arnold as an attacking full-back breaking behind the lines rather than passing beyond them. His goal was almost certainly inadvertent, but showed the dimensions he might add. That he scored on the 20 minutes and 20 seconds mark, as Liverpool fans remembered Jota, showed off perfect timing, too.
That Eberechi Eze, drifting inside left, had Frimpong's defensive measure was just one problem. Liverpool's other Dutch defender, Virgil van Dijk, was unusually clumsy in bringing down Ismaïla Sarr for a penalty, flat-footed on other occasions.
The return of another Dutchman, Ryan Gravenberch, on paternity leave, or Alexis Mac Allister, short of fitness to start, may solve such issues but there was top-heaviness, imbalance. Opposing scouts will have noticed the lack of cover Mohamed Salah provided to Frimpong, as often the case for Alexander-Arnold.
The Egyptian king's creative partnership with Wirtz needs working on, too. There was a fault on the line between them, Salah reduced to one effort on goal, sometimes enough but not here, and dragged into Dean Henderson's hands. The less said about his shootout penalty the better.
If Milos Kerkez was ever keen to overlap, Sarr's running showed he can be exposed defensively, and the out-of-position Hungarian was at fault as his tormentor scored Palace's second equaliser. Perhaps a £150m forward is not the answer Slot is looking for.
Marc Guéhi, a central defender Liverpool are linked with but maybe beyond their spending limits should Isak actually arrive, showed typical cool as Palace assumed control in the second half. Adam Wharton, a midfielder the elite should covet, found his forwards with his passing range. Oliver Glasner has barely been able to add to his squad during the summer's limbo but the Austrian's golden touch continued as Palace edged a nerve-filled shootout to celebrate another trophy win.
For Liverpool, losing the Community Shield cannot come remotely close to the genuine, human loss of the friend and teammate their squad must play on without.
Wembley suggested reclaiming the glory enjoyed when Jota was among them may not be as easy as a summer of transfer fantasy had made it seem.
Guardian
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
42 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Roy Keane issues gloomy prediction over where Manchester United will finish this season
United have spent big money to sign the attacking trio Benjamin Sesko, Bryan Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha this summer, with Amorim suggesting he has seen encouraging signs in his squad ahead of the big kick-off this weekend. Yet former United captain Keane is less optimistic, as he gave a gloomy verdict to The Overlap when asked where he expects United to finish this season. 'At best United for me, eighth or ninth,' he stated. 'The summer has not been too bad for United, but the proof starts at the weekend. 'They have brought a few attacking players in who know the Premier League. To me, over the last few years, they were bringing in players who were getting used to the pace of the Premier League and they weren't robust enough. The next challenge is can they do it week-in, week-out for United. 'There is positives, but I will judge it over the next few weeks. Are these players up to it, will they score enough goals. 'They still have a lot of problems, of course. Huge questions marks… we will be here all day. They still have to sort out the goalkeeper situation and defensively. 'Don't be putting United in the bracket of Arsenal, Liverpool and Chelsea. They are not in that conversation.' Keane's former United team-mate Wayne Rooney offered up a more optimistic vision of United's ambitions this season, as he told the BBC that Amorim's side could challenge for a top five finish that could be good enough to secure Champions League qualification. 'I still think they need one or two more signings, but I think you can see what Amorim is doing,' said Rooney. 'I think it's looking better for Manchester United, and I think they will sneak into the top five. I hope they do, you never know.' Rooney went on to back Liverpool to retain their title, as they continue to push to sign Newcastle striker Alexander Isak. 'I already had Liverpool as favourites to win the title this year, but if Isak comes in, then I think they're gonna be unstoppable,' he added. 'The quality they've got, as Danny's just alluded [to], and I think a big thing was replacing Trent [Alexander-Arnold]. There's a lot of chances created, a lot of goals came from that side. 'I think [Jeremie] Frimpong has got the attributes to fill that, so I think Liverpool look strong.'
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Wayne Rooney hits back at Tom Brady: ‘I don't think he really understood football'
Wayne Rooney has bitten back at Tom Brady over comments aired in a recent documentary depicting their short spell working together at Birmingham. Brady, the legendary NFL quarterback and winner of seven Super Bowls, is heard during Built In Birmingham: Brady & The Blues, to question Rooney, when he was manager. 'I'm a little worried about our head coach's work ethic,' Brady tells his business manager Ben Rawitz. 'I mean, I don't have great instincts on that.' That follows a terse encounter between Rooney, the five-time Premier League winner and Manchester United record goalscorer, and Brady before they attend a meeting with the squad. Rooney was sacked after two wins in 15 matches. Brady was at Blues' training complex in his capacity as a minority owner, and as an adviser to the majority owner, Tom Wagner. 'We're trying to make this a world-class team,' Brady says in the introduction to a series that begins with Blues' relegation from the Championship. Rooney, relaunching his own media career with a BBC-affiliated podcast, has had his say. He said: 'I think Tom came in once, which was the day before a game where the days are a little bit lighter anyway, and I don't think he really understood football that well. But what he does understand is … he's a hard worker – we know that.' Rooney defended his short spell in the second city, saying: 'When I went into Birmingham, they were in a mess really. Hence the fact that the players weren't really the players who could take the club forward. You had Tony Mowbray, Gary Rowett after me, who also struggled as well.' Brady is also heard to refer to Birmingham players from the 2023-24 relegation campaign as 'lazy and entitled'. The documentary's brief meeting of the two appears a case of two former sportsmen taking their next career steps and struggling to find the other's wavelength. Rooney said: 'Football is not NFL – NFL works for three months a year. Players do need rest as well, so I think he's very unfair, the way he's come out and portrayed that.' Brady, as a serial winner, would have played seasons spanning from September to February. While last season Rooney was briefly the manager at Plymouth, Blues, after a summer of heavy spending, were promoted under Chris Davies as champions, collecting a record 111 points. Rooney was happy to offer credit for that revival. 'Listen, I respect Tom Brady massively,' he said. 'He's one of the greatest, if not the greatest, athletes of all time and Birmingham do look like they're getting it right now, which is good, and I think what they have done is got the players out that they needed to get out.' Birmingham were bought out by the Wagner-led consortium Knighthead Capital Management in the summer of 2023 and Brady became a shareholder two months later.
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Premier League refs to clamp down on holding in the penalty area
More penalties could be awarded in this season's Premier League with referees instructed to keep a close eye on holding in the box. It is understood that greater emphasis will be placed on holding in the 2025-26 campaign, in particular where officials consider it sustained and impactful. Officials will give consideration to whether there is a clear impact on the opponent's ability to play or challenge for the ball, and where there is a clear, extreme action which impacts an opponent's movement. Referees and VARs will also take note of whether the holding player's focus is on the ball or the opponent. Last season, Nottingham Forest were awarded a penalty against Brighton after Tariq Lamptey was penalised for holding on to Morgan Gibbs-White, and referees will be on the lookout for similar offences in the new campaign. Simulation will be another area of focus, with referees urged to book players who clearly attempt to deceive them. Referees will also immediately signal for doctors or physios to come on when a player appears to have suffered a head injury. The player will leave the field for further assessment and remain on the touchline for a minimum of 30 seconds after the match has restarted. Referee body cameras will be trialled in the Premier League this season, but sources indicated they would not be used until match round three at the earliest. They will provide extra angles for broadcasters to use in their live coverage, but will not be used to replay controversial incidents. As first reported last month, referees will announce the outcome of VAR reviews except for factual offside and onside decisions. The high bar for VAR intervention will be maintained this season, with 83 per cent of game stakeholders surveyed earlier this year – including players, managers, directors and supporters – supporting a continuation of the threshold. There was also strong support for continuing to follow the same interpretation of handball offences, with 78 per cent thinking the level was correct. Referees will not see it as a punishable offence if the arm is in a justifiable position, is supporting the player's body, where a player plays the ball on to their own arm, where there is a clear change of direction when touched by the same player, where the ball is played by a team-mate or where there is close proximity. Handballs will be penalised where there is a deliberate movement of the arm away from the body, there is clear additional arm movement or the arm position makes the body bigger and is unjustifiable. Only nine penalties were awarded for handball in the Premier League last season. This will also be the first Premier League campaign since the introduction of the eight-second rule for goalkeepers holding on to the ball. Referees will start to count down once the goalkeeper is in full control of the ball and is completely unobstructed by any opponent. A corner will be awarded to the other team where goalkeepers exceed the eight-second limit, while any attacking player who pressures or prevents a goalkeeper from releasing the ball during the countdown will be penalised by the awarding of an indirect free-kick.
