Credit Rating Agency Warns About Ottawa's Fiscal Plan
Shortly after Liberals secured another minority government, a credit rating agency says the spending plans outlined during the campaign will put pressure on Canada's credit profile.
The spending promises made by Prime Minister Mark Carney point to 'considerable fiscal loosening that would exacerbate already expanding fiscal deficits,' Fitch Ratings said in an April 29
Credit ratings are used by investors to help assess the ability of an entity, in this case a country, to repay a debt or meet a financial obligation, such a repaying holders of sovereign bonds.
The Liberals' costed platform promises $129 billion in new spending over the next four years and consecutive deficits which would add nearly $225 billion to the federal debt.
The previous Liberal government under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau had forecasted a $42.2 billion deficit in fiscal 2025-26 in its last Fall Economic Statement. The Carney Liberals have projected a $62.3 billion deficit next year. This exceeds the Trudeau government's fiscal anchor of maintaining the deficit below 1 percent of GDP.
'Canada's credit strengths offer significant headroom to weather a fiscal or economic shock, but increased structural deficits would pressure its credit profile,' said Fitch.
Related Stories
4/30/2025
4/30/2025
The agency said the minority status of the government could lead to actual spending differing from the platform, while adding that 'further fiscal loosening seems inevitable' given the scale of new planned expenditures.
'Canada has experienced rapid and steep fiscal deterioration, driven by a sharply weaker economic outlook and increased government spending during this electoral cycle,' said Fitch.
Carney has
'It's an entirely new government, it's a fundamentally different approach,' he said on April 21. He added that Canada is in the 'worst crisis of our lifetimes,' alluding to U.S. tariff threats, and that his fiscal plan 'meets the moment.'
Several
On the flip side, Fitch had also noted a 'weakened fiscal position' reflecting 'rapid expenditure growth amid a stagnant economy.'
'Top AAA-rated'
Canada's strong credit rating had often been touted by the Trudeau government to defend against Conservative Opposition charges that it's taking on too much debt and that the country's economy is faltering.
'We have been there to invest for Canadians responsibly. We still have one of the top AAA-rated economies in the world. Our fiscal plan is sustainable and responsible,' Trudeau
Before the mini-budget was tabled later that fall, then-Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland was asked by reporters whether exceeding her own fiscal guardrails could risk Canada being downgraded by credit rating agencies.
'We do take Canada's fiscal position seriously. Fiscal sustainability is really important to our government,' she said in December 2024.
A few days later, as she was scheduled to table the Fall Economic Statement (FES), Freeland resigned from cabinet. In her letter of resignation to Trudeau made public, Freeland said the prime minister had informed her he was removing her from finance and that she was still expected to deliver the FES.
In her letter, Freeland also criticized Trudeau for using 'costly political gimmicks' at a time when Canada should be bracing for U.S. tariffs, referring to a two-month sales tax holiday and $250 cheques to Canadians announced at the time.
Freeland's position as finance minister appeared to be under threat shortly after Liberals lost the Toronto-St. Paul's riding in a June 2024 byelection, with anonymous sources from the Prime Minister's Office telling media Freeland was to blame for not effectively communicating the government's economic agenda.
Asked by reporters at the time if she had received assurances from Trudeau that she would stay on as finance minister, she responded, 'I do have the confidence that I need to do my job effectively.'
Freeland also said that as finance minister, 'you have to say 'no' a lot of the time' to proposed spending plans. 'That's how we keep our AAA credit rating,' she said in July 2024.
Freeland lost the Liberal leadership race to her longtime friend Carney. She was appointed as transport minister in Carney's first cabinet in March. The prime minister will be announcing his new cabinet in the coming days.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
What are Canada's governing Liberals going to do about AI?
Fresh off his election victory, Prime Minister Mark Carney has been focused on standing up to Donald Trump's claims on Canada as the 51st state and American tariffs. But while that political drama unfolds, one topic that seems to have quietly slipped under the radar is the rise of artificial intelligence. Despite its transformative impact on everything from jobs to national security, AI received surprisingly little attention during the campaign and in the first weeks following Carney's victory. The consequences of that lack of attention are already starting to show, as emissions and electricity costs continue unabated without a clear vision of where AI fits in. Read more: Although Carney has appointed former journalist Evan Solomon as Canada's first-ever AI minister, it's not yet clear what action the Liberal government plans to take on AI. The Liberals' 'Canada Strong' plan outlining the prime minister's proposals is scarce on details. Still, it provides some clues on how the Liberals see AI and what they believe it offers to the Canadian economy — and also what they seem to have misunderstood. First, the plan includes some robust initiatives for improving Canada's digital infrastructure, which lags behind other leading countries, especially in terms of rural broadband and reliable cell service. To accomplish these goals, the Liberals say they'll incentivize investment by 'introducing flow-through shares to our Canadian startup ecosystem…to raise money faster' for AI and other technologies. In other words, they will reuse the model of mining and oil companies whereby investors can claim a tax deduction for the same amount as their investment. A major question is whether Canada's investment ecosystem has enough big players willing to take these risks. The plan gets less promising as it comes to the implementation of AI within 'the economy of tomorrow.' The Liberals say they plan to build more data centres, improve computing capacity and create digital supply chain solutions 'to improve efficiency and reduce costs for Canadians.' All that that sounds OK — so far. But how will they do this? The Liberals plan to establish the Bureau of Research, Engineering and Advanced Leadership in Science (BOREALIS), linking AI development directly to the Canadian Armed Forces and the Communications Security Establishment Canada, which provides the federal government with information technology security and foreign signals intelligence. This approach to AI is focused on what it offers to Canada's defence, whether by manufacturing semiconductors or improving intelligence gathering, so that it can rely less on the U.S. Similarly, Canadian defence tech firms will access funding to help reduce dependence on American suppliers and networks. The Liberals are pledging sovereignty and autonomy for Canada's defence and security, all enabled by 'the construction and development of AI infrastructure.' What goes unsaid is the intense power needs of data centres, and the consequences for emissions and climate action of 'building the next generation of data centres' in Canada. New data centres cannot be built without also constructing more renewable energy infrastructure, and none of this addresses emissions or climate change. If the centres crop up in big numbers as planned, Canadians could also see their electricity costs go up or become less reliable. That's because finding space within the existing grid is not as easy as it may sound when AI data centres require over 100 megawatts (MW) of electricity demand versus five to 10 MW for a regular centre. With the rapidly evolving market for AI-based data centres, Canadian policymakers need to provide clear guidance to utilities in terms of their current decisions on competing industrial-scale demands. As the Canadian Climate Institute points out: 'Anything less risks higher rates, increased emissions, missed economic opportunities — or all of the above.' So far, the Liberal plan fails to address any of these concerns. What else does the 'economy of tomorrow' hold? Apparently, it means more efficient government. According to the Liberal plan, AI 'is how government improves service delivery, it is how government keeps up with the speed of business, and it is how government maximizes efficiency and reduces cost.' Despite otherwise clashing with the Trump administration, this language is reminiscent of Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), which has also centred its use of AI. Read more: The Liberals will open an Office of Digital Transformation, which aims to get rid of red tape and 'reduce barriers for businesses to operate in Canada.' They don't seem to really know what this would actually look like, however. They say: 'This could mean using AI to address government service backlogs and improve service delivery times, so that Canadians get better services, faster.' Their fiscal plan points out that this frame of thinking applies to every single expenditure: 'We will look at every new dollar being spent through the lens of how AI and technology can improve service and reduce costs.' The economy will also benefit, the government argues, from AI commercialization, with $46 million pegged over the next four years to connect AI researchers with businesses. This would work alongside a tax credit for small and medium-sized businesses to 'leverage AI to boost their bottom lines, create jobs, and support existing employees.' But a new report by Orgvue, the organizational design and planning software platform, shows that over half of businesses that rushed to impose AI just ended up making their employees redundant without clear gains in productivity. Creating a tax credit for smaller companies to introduce AI seems like a recipe for repeating the same mistake. Much of the Liberal plan seems to involve taking risks. There's a shortsightedness on this rapidly advancing technology that requires significant guardrails. The government seem to view AI as a solutions machine, buying into the hype around it without taking the time to understand it. As policy is properly hashed out in the weeks and months to come, the Liberals' feet will have to be held to the fire on the issue of AI. Canadians must benefit from its limited uses and be protected from its abuses. This article is republished from The Conversation, a nonprofit, independent news organisation bringing you facts and trustworthy analysis to help you make sense of our complex world. It was written by: Jake Pitre, Concordia University Read more: Canada has a chance to lead on AI policy and data governance at the 2025 G7 Leaders' Summit Artificial intelligence should not be allowed to adjudicate cases in Canada's Federal Court AI and criminal justice: How AI can support — not undermine — justice Jake Pitre does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Ottawa sending support from armed forces amid northern Ontario wildfire evacuations
The federal government has deployed members of the Canadian Armed Forces to help evacuate a northwestern Ontario First Nation as wildfires rapidly spread in the region, Prime Minister Mark Carney said Sunday. Carney said in a social media post that Ottawa has accepted Ontario's urgent request for assistance in and around Sandy Lake First Nation, and the military will help with emergency airlift evacuations. "We're prepared to mobilize every resource needed to keep Canadians safe," Carney wrote. The military deployment was also discussed at a meeting of the Incident Response Group that Carney convened on Sunday to address the already highly active wildfire season, according to a readout of the meeting provided by the Prime Minister's Office. As of Sunday, the Ontario government said the Red Lake 12 wildfire, near Deer Lake First Nation, is out of control and more than 1,500 square kilometres in size. The fire is about six kilometres from the community of Sandy Lake First Nation, it said. "Overnight growth was minimal, but the fire has been exhibiting high intensity activity this morning," the Ministry of Natural Resources said. Helicopters and fire ranger crews are continuing to suppress the fires and are focusing on structure protection, the ministry said, adding that minimal rain is forecasted in the next 24 hours. The ministry said Sandy Lake First Nation is conducting a phase one evacuation of residents by air, and boats will be available if needed. The province said Deer Lake First Nation remains evacuated and is being protected by fire rangers. It said the province's northwest region had 26 active fires as of Saturday night, seven of which were out of control. Videos and photos on social media showed one fire approaching a construction site near Sandy Lake First Nation on Saturday, with multiple cargo containers catching on fire and crews reportedly escaping the blaze by sheltering in one of them. Manitoba-based construction company Sigfusson Northern confirmed their 14 crew members and four additional staffers were safely evacuated after they were working on a job site near the First Nation. "Our crews showed an extreme level of professionalism and courage in the face of a rapidly changing situation," the company said in a social media post. The crew began work in Sandy Lake on Saturday before an evacuation order was in place, but the company says it initiated an aircraft evacuation early that morning and the crew were evacuated later in the day. Other provinces, including Manitoba and Saskatchewan, are also undergoing evacuation efforts in some areas due to wildfires. The wildfires prompted air quality alerts in Ontario. Environment Canada warned that smoke is causing poor air quality and reduced visibility in areas including Sioux Lookout, Summer Beaver and Ear Falls. The weather agency added that some northeastern areas, including Timmins, Kapuskasing and Attawapiskat, are under a special air quality statement Sunday due to the smoke. Special air quality statements in place across most of the southern part of the province over the weekend had been lifted as of Sunday. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 8, 2025. Rianna Lim, The Canadian Press
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Carney lays out Canada's G7 summit priorities while managing a complicated guest list
With one week to go until G7 leaders gather in Alberta, Prime Minister Mark Carney has announced his priorities for the meeting and is managing a guest list that lays bare fault lines in some of Canada's international relationships. The G7 leaders summit will be held in Kananaskis from June 15 to 17. On Saturday, Carney said Canada will "seek agreements and co-ordinated action" on three core missions. The first is protecting Canadian communities and the world by strengthening peace and security, countering foreign interference as well as transnational crime and improving joint responses to wildfires. The second is "building energy security and accelerating the digital transition" through fortifying critical mineral supply chains and using artificial intelligence to boost economic growth. Finally, Carney said Canada will push to secure new partnerships that will catalyze "enormous private investment to build stronger infrastructure, create higher-paying jobs and open dynamic markets where businesses can compete and succeed." Those international goals tie closely to Carney's domestic agenda. WATCH | Carney and his Liberals table One Canadian Economy bill: Earlier this week, the Liberal government tabled the One Canadian Economy Act — a bill it says will eliminate federal barriers to internal trade and explain how nation-building infrastructure projects will be identified and approved faster. Many provinces are eager to take Carney up on nation-building plans, especially provinces ready to extract more critical minerals for their regions. B.C. Energy Minister Adrian Dix said one project on his mind is the North Coast Transmission Line, which would expand the province's electricity system and could unlock more critical mineral extraction in B.C.'s northwest. "It's a project that exists. We're working with First Nations on [it] right now. That's a significant project," Dix said in an interview on Rosemary Barton Live. Ontario Premier Doug Ford is pushing to use powers in his government's recently passed Bill 5 to designate the mineral-rich Ring of Fire as a special economic zone, where cabinet can exempt companies and projects from having to comply with any provincial law, provincial regulation or municipal bylaw. Ford put the Ring of Fire at the top of his list presented to Prime Minister Mark Carney for consideration as a potential nation-building project. Carney came under fire earlier this week when it was announced he'd invited Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the G7 summit just months after the RCMP accused his government of acts of murder, extortion and coercion. The prime minister defended the move and said on Friday that India and Canada "have now agreed importantly to continued law enforcement dialogue. So there's been some progress on that." Last fall, the RCMP laid out allegations accusing agents of the Indian government of playing a role in "widespread violence" in Canada, including homicides, and warned that it poses "a serious threat to our public safety." That came after Canada accused Indian government agents of being involved in the killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Canadian activist for Sikh separatism. WATCH | B.C. Liberal says constituents 'concerned' over Modi's G7 invitation: The Sikh Federation of Canada called the invitation "a grave insult" and Liberal MP Sukh Dhaliwal, who represents the Surrey riding where Nijjar was shot, said neither he nor many of his constituents support Modi. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum has also been invited to the G7 summit, but it's not confirmed whether she will attend — a hesitation that underscores some diplomatic tensions after some premiers suggested Canada ditch Mexico and pursue a new bilateral trade agreement with the United States. Arturo Sarukhán, former ambassador of Mexico to the United States, said Sheinbaum should attend because it would allow her to "reset relationships with Canada" and leave aside "the pissing match that Canadians and Mexicans have been in since the fall." Sarukhán also said on Rosemary Barton Live that Mexico's attendance "would allow Carney and Sheinbaum to have a first sit-down with Donald Trump on neutral ground" to discuss a looming renegotiation of the North American free trade deal. When asked whether the North American free trade deal will hold up, Sarukhán said "probably the outcome of the process is that we will end up with two separate free trade agreements. One between the U.S. and Canada [and] one between Mexico and the United States." "That's not a good outcome for future North American competitiveness if the U.S. wants to be successful in its recalibration of its relationship with Beijing," Sarukhán said. "It needs Canada and Mexico for that recalibration to be successful."
