‘Lecture-bashing' ban among new rules for Sydney University students
It comes after the university spent $441,789 on an external review to combat antisemitism in the 18 months following Hamas' October 7 attacks and complaints from Jewish students that they did not feel safe at the institution.
Vice Chancellor Mark Scott said the move was one of five new revised policies that articulated what was and was not acceptable, designed so everyone 'feels safe to be themselves no matter their religion, gender, sexuality, race or ability'.
'In a world of increased conflict and polarisation, that can be challenging. But over the past year, we've done some significant work across the university to ensure our campus is a place where everyone can thrive,' he said in an email on Monday afternoon.
'These policies balance our commitments to campus safety with those to academic freedom and freedom of speech and set clear standards for what is and isn't acceptable.'
For decades, students at Sydney University have engaged in the practice of 'lecture bashing', whereby lecturers permit students to make political statements about non-course-related material.
Student representative council president Angus Fisher said the new rules are an extremely disappointing step because they impinge on the university's long history of political debate.
'In a context where external alt-right anti-abortion representatives come to campus weekly to harass students, it is unclear to me how a ban on lecture announcements results in anything less than stifling free speech and debate,' he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
‘Inflammatory, divisive, disrespectful': Bendigo Writers Festival founder speaks out
As such, it had given author Randa Abdel-Fattah, an Australian woman of Palestinian and Egyptian heritage, little choice, said Sorensen. 'She could do nothing other than withdraw,' she said. 'She has been subject to relentless, ruthless, unscrupulous attacks for years … other writers withdrawing in protest was absolutely the right thing to do.' Sorensen left the festival – which was always a council-funded event under her direction – in 2023, having intended to bow out earlier before the COVID-19 pandemic intervened. She was instrumental in seeking the involvement of La Trobe University academic Clare Wright as co-curator of the La Trobe Presents stream of the program, a move, she says, 'of which I'm proud'. Wright also withdrew from this year's event over the code of conduct issued to participants the day before the event began. The wording of the directive is taken from the Universities Australia statement on racism, to which La Trobe is a signatory. That definition has come in for criticism over its close alignment with the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's 'working definition of antisemitism ', which some critics allege conflates criticism of Israel with antisemitism. The Universities Australia statement states: 'Criticism of the policies and practices of the Israeli government or state is not in and of itself antisemitic. However, criticism of Israel can be antisemitic … when it calls for the elimination of the State of Israel or all Jews or when it holds Jewish individuals or communities responsible for Israel's actions.' Loading The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's position is that 'manifestations [of antisemitism] might include the targeting of the state of Israel, conceived as a Jewish collectivity. However, criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic'. 'Of course, it was about Gaza,' Sorensen said of the code of conduct. 'And I'd have thought such a directive is antithetical not just to a writers festival or a university but to a government and the society it is there to protect.' Though this year's event had turned into a disaster, it need not be the end for the Bendigo Writers Festival, its founder insisted. 'If there's an honest appraisal, an owning of this calamity, then I think writers will support it, too,' she said. Moves in Bendigo and elsewhere to curtail speech in the name of 'respectful debate', as festival organisers put it, were unnecessary and counter-productive, argued Sorensen. 'We have guard rails already,' she said. 'Governments at all levels, and cultural organisations at all levels, responding before the fact is not a guard rail. It's an authoritarian abuse of power and very dangerous for a healthy functioning democracy.' La Trobe University has defended its stance, stating that it was committed to fostering a culture that valued all forms of diversity. Loading 'La Trobe University does not tolerate racism of any kind, including antisemitism and Islamophobia. La Trobe's commitment to academic freedom and freedom of speech is consistent with our approach to creating safe environments for the free exchange of ideas,' a spokesperson said. 'Our Anti-Racism Action Plan, which includes a working definition of Islamophobia, was developed through extensive staff, student and community consultation.'
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘Inflammatory, divisive, disrespectful': Bendigo Writers Festival founder speaks out
As such, it had given author Randa Abdel-Fattah, an Australian woman of Palestinian and Egyptian heritage, little choice, said Sorensen. 'She could do nothing other than withdraw,' she said. 'She has been subject to relentless, ruthless, unscrupulous attacks for years … other writers withdrawing in protest was absolutely the right thing to do.' Sorensen left the festival – which was always a council-funded event under her direction – in 2023, having intended to bow out earlier before the COVID-19 pandemic intervened. She was instrumental in seeking the involvement of La Trobe University academic Clare Wright as co-curator of the La Trobe Presents stream of the program, a move, she says, 'of which I'm proud'. Wright also withdrew from this year's event over the code of conduct issued to participants the day before the event began. The wording of the directive is taken from the Universities Australia statement on racism, to which La Trobe is a signatory. That definition has come in for criticism over its close alignment with the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's 'working definition of antisemitism ', which some critics allege conflates criticism of Israel with antisemitism. The Universities Australia statement states: 'Criticism of the policies and practices of the Israeli government or state is not in and of itself antisemitic. However, criticism of Israel can be antisemitic … when it calls for the elimination of the State of Israel or all Jews or when it holds Jewish individuals or communities responsible for Israel's actions.' Loading The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance's position is that 'manifestations [of antisemitism] might include the targeting of the state of Israel, conceived as a Jewish collectivity. However, criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic'. 'Of course, it was about Gaza,' Sorensen said of the code of conduct. 'And I'd have thought such a directive is antithetical not just to a writers festival or a university but to a government and the society it is there to protect.' Though this year's event had turned into a disaster, it need not be the end for the Bendigo Writers Festival, its founder insisted. 'If there's an honest appraisal, an owning of this calamity, then I think writers will support it, too,' she said. Moves in Bendigo and elsewhere to curtail speech in the name of 'respectful debate', as festival organisers put it, were unnecessary and counter-productive, argued Sorensen. 'We have guard rails already,' she said. 'Governments at all levels, and cultural organisations at all levels, responding before the fact is not a guard rail. It's an authoritarian abuse of power and very dangerous for a healthy functioning democracy.' La Trobe University has defended its stance, stating that it was committed to fostering a culture that valued all forms of diversity. Loading 'La Trobe University does not tolerate racism of any kind, including antisemitism and Islamophobia. La Trobe's commitment to academic freedom and freedom of speech is consistent with our approach to creating safe environments for the free exchange of ideas,' a spokesperson said. 'Our Anti-Racism Action Plan, which includes a working definition of Islamophobia, was developed through extensive staff, student and community consultation.'
Perth Now
7 hours ago
- Perth Now
MP's big issue with Albo's Palestine pledge
Anthony Albanese should have consulted the opposition before pledging to recognise Palestinian statehood next month, a Liberal frontbencher says. The Prime Minister unleashed a firestorm when he declared his intention on Monday. He has been both accused of 'rewarding terrorists' and praised for joining the global push to realise the rights of Palestinians. Sussan Ley has criticised him for, in her view, bungling one of the biggest foreign policy challenges facing governments and vowed to reverse Palestinian recognition. In the same breath, she has also lashed him for being 'fixated' on events abroad. Though, with more than 100,000 marching across the Sydney Harbour Bridge in protest of the war in Gaza, it is a hot-button issue for Australians – especially the many with family ties in the region. Senior opposition MP Tim Wilson on Sunday said it would have been 'sensible' to reach out to the Coalition and form a bipartisan position that could go beyond the government of the day. Opposition frontbencher Tim Wilson says Labor should have consulted the Coalition on Palestinian recognition. Martin Ollman / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia 'We've taken a long-term bipartisan position around a two-state solution based on a series of preconditions that we would expect in that - like the lasting security and respect for the state of Israel, like making sure Israeli hostages are returned, like making sure there isn't going to be Hamas running any government,' Mr Wilson told the ABC. 'Up until last Monday, that was also the position of the government.' He said the Albanese government has 'thrown that into turmoil by making a commitment to recognise a Palestinian state but not being able to then say if those preconditions are going to be met'. 'There wasn't the engagement with the opposition up until this point,' Mr Wilson said. 'I would have thought that actually having an engagement with the opposition for a lasting policy position from the Australian government would be a sensible way forward. 'They've chosen not to take that path.' When announcing his Palestine pledge, Mr Albanese outlined four 'commitments' he secured from Mahmoud Abbas, the president of the Palestinian Authority (PA). The first two were Hamas having 'no role' in a future Palestinian state and the PA recognising 'Israel's right to exist in peace and security'. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese pledged to recognise Palestinian statehood at the UN General Assembly. Martin Ollman / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia While Mr Albanese said Mr Abbas 'reaffirmed' his support for the second point, the PA administers the West Bank and has no presence in Gaza or over Hamas. The PA itself is often criticised for its corruption, ineffectiveness and lack of elections. The last presidential vote was in 2005. It also faces accusations of supporting terrorism by paying families of 'martyrs' – Palestinians wounded or killed in flare-ups with Israel. Mr Albanese said Mr Abbas also committed to scrapping the 'Martyrs Fund' as part of broader transparency reforms, demilitarising, and holding elections. Both independent experts and the opposition have said it is impossible for these commitments to be fulfilled before the UN General Assembly, where Mr Albanese and several other Western leaders have vowed to recognise Palestine.
