Govt expects audit of hip surgeries in coming days, Taoiseach says
The Taoiseach said the Government hopes to receive the clinical audit of hip surgeries on children at two Dublin hospitals by the end of next week.
Micheál Martin was responding to the Social Democrats deputy leader Cian O'Callaghan who claimed the Government was entirely ignorant about how many children may be affected.
The Taoiseach has been asked in recent days to clarify if all families and parents potentially affected by the Children's Health Ireland (CHI) hip surgery controversy have been contacted about the concerns.
Mr O'Callaghan accused the Coalition of "trying to maintain plausible deniability about the crisis" by refusing to answer questions.
Mr Martin described the issue as very serious and he said the Government has no objective in hiding anything.
"The least we owe to the parents and the families are the facts," he said.
Mr Martin said that letters already issued to families are general in nature and they were sent in response to an "alleged draft report" of the clinical audit which was published earlier this year.
He repeatedly said that the number of letters issued is not the key point, but he added that the Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has asked CHI to publish the number today.
"It is horrendous if anything wrong was done but we need to find out the full facts," he said.
The CHI-commissioned independent review into hip surgeries in children, announced in July last year, is looking at a random, anonymised sample of dysplasia of the hip surgeries, between 2021 and 2023, at Children's Health Ireland hospital sites, as well as Cappagh Orthopaedic Hospital.
This type of surgery is where the ball and socket joint of a child's hip has not properly formed.
Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín said there is a "excruciating lack of information for parents" over dysplasia of the hip surgeries in children, and that the Government is "adding to the confusion".
Speaking on RTÉ's Today with Claire Byrne that it was "incredible" that the Taoiseach stated during Leaders Questions in the Dáil yesterday that the audit will not go back 15 years.
"The letter that parents are receiving I understand is saying that children are being called back for routine appointments.
"However the Taoiseach has stated that the Department is identifying patients who may be affected but are not included in the audit.
"Then we see reports in the media saying the appointment letters are because of an early recommendation in the unpublished review."
"Clearly those three sentences cannot be true at the same time so the Government is giving out confusing messages in terms of what parents are being contacted."
He added that if there is wrongdoing from previous years, it needed to be investigated.
"Are the Government looking to do an audit for two years and then draw a veil over the practice previously?
"Parents have a right to know what happened to their children a number of years ago, and citizens have a right to know why there is dysfunction in our health service," he said.
The review has been examining whether the criteria used for surgical intervention varied between three hospitals and if surgery was required in all cases.
Children who have had developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) surgeries at the hospitals are to be offered "routine follow-up care" in the coming months if a child is not already in a long-term follow-up process with one of the hospitals, according to letters sent to parents recently by CHI.
It follows an early recommendation from the independent review, that is yet to be completed, into dysplasia of the hip operations at Crumlin, Temple Street and the National Orthopaedic Hospital Cappagh.
The letters sent by CHI say that the follow-up appointment is part of the "normal post-operative review process and is not urgent".
The letter states that the DDH review is not complete, and the hospital cannot provide any detail of its findings, nor can it comment on any media reports as to what it might ultimately say.
"However, an early recommendation.. is that all children who have had DDH surgery should receive routine follow-up care until the child's bones have fully grown and developed (skeletal maturity) in line with current best practice," the letter from CHI states.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
5 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Parents of boy with muscular dystrophy to hold rally at Dáil to campaign for vital drug
The mother of a child with a muscle-wasting disease is to hold a rally at the Dáil on Wednesday, urging the Government to support the introduction of a vital drug here that will help slow progression of the disease. Archie Ennis, aged 8, from Dublin, was diagnosed with muscular dystrophy before Christmas — a condition that affects about 120 boys in Ireland. There is no cure for it. The schoolboy's parents, Una and Kenneth, launched a GoFundMe campaign to help pay for specialist gene therapy in the US, which costs at least €3.2m. Meanwhile, the couple had also been campaigning for the Government to sanction pay for a new drug called givinostat, which has just been approved by the European Medicines Agency. Ms Ennis told the Irish Examiner: 'This drug will slow down Archie's muscle-wasting disease, but it also means it will help other children here. Archie Ennis: The rally outside the Dáil will take place at 1pm and Ms Ennis will be joined by family, friends and the other parents of boys with muscular dystrophy who are all supporting the call for the rollout of givinostat here. 'The drug was approved by the EMA recently, now the pharmaceutical companies can apply to the Government to see if they will refund the drug. 'But that will take time as they have to wait for the Government to decide if they will pay for this in order to make it free here. 'It makes sense for it to be made available free here, if the Government doesn't pay for the drug, they will be paying for other things such as more equipment for a child with the disease, they'll be paying for the care of that child, and carer's allowances — it all balances out,' Ms Ennis said. The rally outside the Dáil will take place at 1pm and Ms Ennis will be joined by family, friends and the other parents of boys with muscular dystrophy who are all supporting the call for the rollout of givinostat here. 'Time is muscle' she said. 'Archie's muscles are weak; he needs help going up the stairs and he gets tired when we are out on walks. This drug will slow down the progression of the disease, keep him on his feet for longer, keep his heart and lungs healthier longer and he will do better. She said the drug givinostat was something 'that the country needs,' but Archie will also need gene therapy — for which they are fundraising. The GoFundMe has so far raised €600,000 for Archie's treatment abroad, but it not even half of what he needs. 'We have been to Miami to get tests done but we really need the drug introduced here to start the process. 'We are hoping to follow Scotland, which is pushing to have the drug in pharmacies within five months. 'We have booked the AV room in Leinster House for 2:30pm on Wednesday and have invited all of the TDs, including the health minister to come along and hear our stories.'
Irish Independent
14 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Number of children living in consistent poverty rises to over 100,000, figures reveal
A Children's Rights Alliance report has acknowledged the number of children in consistent poverty has risen to more than 100,000 – nearly twice the previous mark – while the figure for homeless children has also increased, to nearly 5,000. The group has called on the Government to invest in solutions that address inter-generational poverty following the release of these figures from the Central Statistics Office and the Department of Housing. The Alliance is asking for measures such as resourcing early years support, cost-of-living relief, increasing budget allocation to Tusla and tackling overcrowding as a result of the housing crisis. 'What is deeply concerning is the number of children in consistent poverty – who are living in these conditions perpetually – which rose by a staggering 45,107 in 2024 to 102,977,' Tanya Ward, chief executive of the Children's Rights Alliance, said. 'Policy decisions and budget investments determine the fate of these children and young people.' The report analysed Government progress and action to address child poverty. The research report spans figures on homelessness, family support and alternative care, adequate income and early years and education. Last month's figures from the Department of Housing showed that an additional 100 children were living in emergency accommodation, an increase to 4,775. Ms Ward said: 'The rise in homeless figures is nothing new. 'We have seen a year-on-a-year increase every time we publish the Child Poverty Monitor. 'The combination of rising rents – the latest average reaching over €2,000 a month nationally – and a scarcity of supply has resulted in thousands of families being made homeless but also, countless more living on top of each other or in seriously cramped and inappropriate conditions.' Ms Ward said she acknowledged positive developments with the introduction of free school books, hot school meals and free GP care for children under eight. However, she called on the Government to focus on long-term investments. 'Universal measures have advanced, many quicker than expected such as the historic billion-euro investments in childcare,' she said. 'However, these have come at the expense of the targeted measures and strategic investment that are critical to breaking the cycle of intergenerational poverty our children are inheriting. Budget 2026 has to focus on breaking the cycle.'
Irish Times
15 hours ago
- Irish Times
Letters to the Editor, June 10th: On clinical governance, alcohol tax and gardening leave
Sir, – I write as both a mother and a scientist. In 2023, when my daughter was just four years old, she was recommended for hip surgery to treat developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) under the care of Children's Health Ireland (CHI). We were deeply concerned about whether the procedure was truly necessary and ultimately chose to decline it. We sought a second expert opinion who reviewed her medical records and imaging, confirming what we had feared: our daughter no longer had DDH and had never needed surgery in the first place. We were lucky. Too many families were not. The revelations about unnecessary hip surgeries are just one part of a far wider institutional collapse. From the use of non-medical grade spring devices in spinal surgeries, to the misappropriation of National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) resources, what's becoming clear is that these failures are not isolated – they are systemic. Clinical governance, patient safety, and ethical standards were compromised across CHI. Children with complex needs were not treated with dignity or respect, but as burdens to be managed. READ MORE As a scientist, I am appalled. I cannot comprehend how invasive surgeries were conducted without solid clinical evidence, peer oversight, or proper audit. This betrays the most basic principles of evidence-based medicine. As a parent, I am devastated. The very system meant to care for our children ignored parental concerns, dismissed expert warnings, and placed vulnerable lives at risk. This crisis did not emerge in silence. Since 2017, advocacy groups – many led by parents – have raised alarms about systemic dysfunction within CHI. Their warnings were persistent, informed, and largely ignored. Had they been taken seriously; my daughter would never have faced this decision – and countless other children might have been spared real harm. We cannot accept vague apologies or bureaucratic delay. What is needed is a full public enquiry, criminal investigations where warranted and accountability at every level of CHI and the HSE, and binding reforms to ensure this never happens again. The lives and the futures of children depend on it. Ireland's children deserve care that is safe, ethical, and humane. Nothing less. – Yours, etc, DR THERESE MURPHY, Lecturer in Molecular Diagnostics and Bioinformatics, School of Biological, Health and Sports Science, Technological University Dublin, Dublin. Alcohol consumption and tax Sir, – The recent report showing a 4.5 per cent drop in alcohol consumption in Ireland last year ( 'Alcohol consumption falls 4.5 per cent, putting Irish at European average,' June 9th ), is welcome news, reflecting healthier public attitudes and the success of evidence-based policy, including minimum unit pricing. However, the suggestion from the Drinks Industry Group of Ireland (DIGI) that this progress should now justify a cut in alcohol excise duty is deeply misguided. Alcohol continues to cause enormous harm in Irish society, with thousands of lives lost or devastated every year through liver and heart disease, dementia, breast cancer, domestic abuse and more. Each year, alcohol costs the Irish State billions in healthcare, policing and lost productivity. Alcohol taxation remains one of the few public tools that reduces consumption while raising vital revenue to offset just a small fraction of the costs alcohol imposes on society. If anything, our alcohol excise rates urgently need revision as despite rising costs and inflation, they have remained essentially unchanged since 2014. Most Irish citizens do not know or understand the risks of alcohol consumption. The dangers of alcohol, particularly its links to cancer, cardiovascular disease and cognitive decline, remain hugely under-recognised. The unambiguous position of the World Health Organisation needs to be better known: no level of alcohol consumption is safe for our health. – Yours, etc, DR RALPH HURLEY O'DWYER, Specialist Registrar in Public Health Medicine, Dublin. Gaza and food aid Sir, – I'm delighted by the international impact of the Madleen, due to the presence of Greta Thunberg and other international activists. I wonder have your readers forgotten the 2010 Irish endeavour to respond to the tragedy of an earlier Palestinian Nakba. Together with Malaysian support, we purchased a ship which carried 60 tonnes of cement for rebuilding essential humanitarian infrastructure in Gaza. And significantly, onboard was Mairead Maguire, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize. The ship we named the Rachel Corrie after a young Jewish girl who gave her life in trying to stop the bulldozing of a Palestinian home. As in the case of the Madleen, we were intercepted by Israeli forces in international waters. The Rachel Corrie was boarded from two Israeli gunships and we were taken into Ashdod. There were seven Irish and seven Malaysian activists onboard. Malaysia had assembled the funding for the purchase of the ship, which was fitted out in Dundalk, and where a retired Scottish captain was hired. The then minister for foreign affairs, Micheál Martin, contacted me via satellite phone to express his concern for the safety of Irish nationals, and to inform me that he had been in touch with the Israelis. I explained that, in addition to delivering cement to Gaza, we intended to enter Gaza, just as our friends onboard the Madleen had intended. In both cases, the attempt was to break the stranglehold over Gaza and the people of Gaza by Israel. Micheál Martin understood the situation, and arranged for the Irish ambassador to meet me in Ashdod after our arrival at the detention centre. At his request the ambassador met me, and together with his Thai counterpart, he agreed to get the Filipino crew, the Cuban engineer, and the Malaysian activists out of the Israeli prison as soon as possible. These were all citizens of countries that did not recognise Israel. We Irish had agreed we would not leave detention until the other shipmates including the Scottish captain had been freed and flown home. Our opportunity to prosecute Israel for military action in international waters was not taken up by Ireland or Malaysia, regrettably, and now we see the same violation of international law taking place. – Yours, etc, DENIS J. HALLIDAY, Former UN assistant secretary general (1994-98) Ranelagh, Dublin 6. Sir, – In light of the Gaza genocide can we stop pretending there is such a thing as international law. Countries only talk about it when it is broken by another. It is only enforced when it is opportunistic for wealthy powerful countries. Instant action occurs when container ships are threatened, but none when humanitarian aid is in international waters under a British flag. – Yours, etc, JANE JACKSON , Greystones, Co Wicklow. Sir, – How ironic to see Israeli defence soldiers handing out food and water to protestors who themselves were trying to force Israel to hand out food and water to starving Gazans. – Yours, etc, DAVID CURRAN, Knocknacarra, Galway. Gardening leave and the HSE Sir, – The two HSE employees who have been on gardening leave for 11 years must have very fine specimens by now. ( 'Two staff on gardening leave for 11 years,' June 9th). In this other world 'gardening leave' is a term used to describe a short-term paid absence from work between two employments. But in the public sphere it means being paid indefinitely (eleven years and counting) to do nothing. Why would the gardener even contemplate the possibility of alternative employment in these circumstances? Martin Wall reports the HSE as saying that it endeavours to carry out all investigations 'as expediently as possible'. I think 'expeditiously' may have been intended but 'expediently' fits the bill beautifully. – Yours, etc, PAT O'BRIEN, Rathmines, Dublin 6. Sir, – Two HSE staff on gardening leave for 11 years . Clearly, they are creating something spectacular for Bloom. -– Yours, etc, FRANK J BYRNE, Glasnevin, Dublin 9. Sir , – I see that two HSE employees have been on 'gardening leave ' for 11 years. With such experience perhaps a transfer to the Botanic Gardens would be in order. – Yours, etc, HUGH PIERCE, Co Kildare. Some guides to St Stephen's Green Sir, – Your interesting recent supplement on St Stephen's Green (' A guide to who owns St Stephen's Green ', June 7th) reminded me how 21 years ago, when the shiny new Luas first pulled into Stephen's Green West, I suggested by letter to your paper that the four very functionally named thoroughfares surrounding the Green revert to their historical more attractively sounding monikers: ie. Stephens Green East – Monk's Walk, West – French Walk, South – Leesons Walk and North – Beaux Walk (as shown on Rocque's Map 1757). All this time later 'You are now approaching French Walk' would still sound so much more sublime as you glide in on the Luas or stroll on to Beaux Walk towards the Shelbourne. Ah let it be done, a little renaming enhancement to uplift further this famous old marshy Square! – Yours, etc, HELEN KEHOE, Stoneybatter, Dublin 7. Sir, – The headline 'A guide to who owns St Stephen's Green,' caught my attention. I was afraid the ownership of the public park had moved to the private sector and I'd be reading how the bandstand could now be rented for €3,000 per month. So it was delightful to discover it only referred to the property around the rectangular Green. – Yours, etc, DERMOT O'ROURKE, Lucan, Dublin. Some pointers for the GAA Sir, – I could not agree more with Nicky English's analysis of Saturdays Munster final in Limerick at 18.00hrs on a Saturday evening. (' Weary Limerick's errors allowed Cork's confidence to flourish,' June 9th). I was one of the spectators who because I had to walk (my running days are over!) left the stadium at half time in extra time to catch the 21.00hrs train back to Dublin. Let me declare an interest, I am a Corkman who loves the game of hurling and obviously delighted with the result. The performance by both sets of amateur players on Saturday was up there with the best I have been privileged to witness over the years. I'll leave it to your columnists and others to describe the passion, excitement etc. of the game but would add some observations, which are meant to be constructive. The core issue with the scheduling of games in both codes is the contraction of the season. It is an issue needing immediate attention to be sorted for the 2026 season. There are so many reasons why it should, all of which have been well articulated, and I can honestly say I have yet to meet a supporter of either code who agrees with the short season for our inter county championships. I fully agree with Nicky's comments on refereeing. I have been arguing for a long time that the game is too fast and hectic now for one referee and in my opinion we should have two, each in full control of their own half, at least for major championship games. I also agree the new football rules in relation to the clock and hooter should be implemented as should some disciplinary measures on dissent and gamesmanship. Not so sure about revaluing the goal to four points! When I entered the Gaelic grounds at 17.40 hrs on Saturday and Croke Park at 15.30 hrs on Sunday there were no programmes for sale. Why? and please don't tell me they were all sold out!! Another issue which I don't like bringing up is the toilet facilities at our stadiums. The scene under the Mick Mackey stand during the intervals on Saturday can only be described as appalling, disgraceful, third world. Whatever about men jamming the entrances/ exits trying to get in and out , the sight of our women supporters, who are growing in such numbers, lining up in orderly lengthy queues is so so embarrassing and must be so demeaning for them. I don't accept there is no solution to this problem in this age of mobile units which we see deployed in other venues throughout the country. – Yours etc. JOE WALSH, Sutton, Dublin. Gulf stream and climate change Sir, – A recent letter from Richard Herriott (my first cousin as it happens) queried why the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA)latest report did not mention the possible collapse of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation – more popularly known as the Gulf Stream. While the concern is valid, the omission is understandable. The EPA's focus is on Ireland's emissions and our domestic climate action. The destabilisation of the Gulf Stream is indeed one of the most alarming global climate tipping points, but it is also largely beyond our direct influence. In contrast, the report highlights the many areas where we can make a difference – reducing emissions from transport, agriculture, buildings, and energy. These are spheres where policy and behavioural change can yield real and measurable results. The real scandal is not what the report left out, but what we continue to leave undone. We are failing to act even where action is clearly within our grasp. It would be tragic if, in the face of potential planetary upheaval, we chose to focus on the immovable rather than the urgent and fixable. Or we could do a Nero and pull out a fiddle. – Yours, etc, JAMES CANDON, Woluwe St. Pierre, Brussels. Season's Greetings Sir, – At 9.20 am on Monday June 9th, an out-of-service bus passed me on Kevin Street, Dublin 8, bearing the greeting, 'Merry Christmas from Dublin Bus' on its display screen. Is this a record? – Yours, etc, MARK HARKIN, New Bride Street, Dublin 8.
