AIFF refutes Mohun Bagan Super Giant's accusation of mishandling Subhashish Bose's injury
In a letter written to the Kolkata club, the AIFF quoted the opinion of the medical department of the national men's team to support its point.
'Subhasish Bose was not injured during the AFC Asian Cup – 2027 qualifier match vs Bangladesh on March 25th, 2025 in Shillong, where he played 85 minutes and was substituted on a tactical decision and not due to any injury,' the letter written by AIFF deputy general secretary M Satyanarayan said.
'After that, he played full time in both the legs of the ISL semifinals on April 3rd and 7th respectively and 90 minutes in the ISL final on April 12th, where he was substituted. He attended the National Team camp on 18th May 2025 and after 1-2 training sessions, he complained of right groin discomfort.
'On eliciting the history, he informed the medical team that he had sustained an injury to his right groin during the final of ISL on 12th April 2025.' Mohun Bagan Super Giant beat Bengaluru FC 2-1 in the ISL final in Kolkata on April 12.
The AIFF said Mohun Bagan Super Giant did not inform the national federation about Bose's injury.
'After the injury, what he did was taking rest only and attended the camp with a lay-off of more than a month. No investigations or rehab was done during that period. This was not informed to the national team medical department or the support staff by the club.
'When he started to have mild discomfort, his load was reduced, given rest from training for five days along with treatments and separate sessions for rehab were given.' According to the letter, Bose was released from the camp on June 5 on the national team medical department's advice.
'Though he was symptomatically better and the coach wanted him for the AFC Asian Cup Qualifier match on the 9th of June, given his persistence of vague discomfort and the risk of aggravating his injury, he was released from the camp upon the medical team's advise on 5th June 2025.
'The medical team was keeping in touch with Subhasish regarding his progress, while he was rehabilitating with the club medical team.' On Monday, Mohun Bagan Super Giant refused to release players for the national camp ahead of the CAFA Nations Cup 'as the tournament is not being held during FIFA international window', and also accused the AIFF of 'negligence' over player welfare.
There were seven players from Mohun Bagan Super Giant in the 35 probables announced by newly-appointed India head coach Khalid Jamil.
'Every time they take our players, three-four of them return injured, and the AIFF is least bothered to communicate, compensate, or even check on them,' an official had told PTI.
'Look at Bose… He is under rehab, has missed the entire season so far, we are paying his salary, and yet the federation hasn't even called once to inquire about him.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
an hour ago
- First Post
11 ISL clubs urge senior lawyers assisting Supreme Court to bring attention to their crisis ahead of AIFF-FSDL hearing
The letter from the ISL clubs came a day before an Supreme Court hearing of the case on Friday. Amici curiae Gopal Sankaranarayanan and Samar Bansal had earlier mentioned the matter on Monday before the SC which posted the matter for Friday. Mumbai City FC and Bengaluru FC are among the 11 clubs that have written to the two senior lawyers assisting the Supreme Court in the ongoing AIFF-FSDL hearing. PTI Eleven Indian Super League clubs on Thursday urged the two senior lawyers assisting the Supreme Court in a pending case to bring to its notice the existential crisis they are facing due to uncertainty over the ISL's future and the 'urgency of pronouncing judgment at the earliest'. The letter from the ISL clubs came a day before an SC hearing of the case on Friday. Amici curiae Gopal Sankaranarayanan and Samar Bansal had earlier mentioned the matter on Monday before the SC which posted the matter for Friday. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'Given that football clubs (across entire pyramid), their players, employees, and stakeholders are the most directly and immediately affected by the current standstill in Indian football, we have no option but to approach your good selves, as officers of the Hon'ble Court, to humbly request that our concerns be placed before the Ld. Bench,' the letter stated. More from Football 'The urgency of pronouncing judgment at the earliest, given football calendar is at a standstill across pyramid; any consequential directions flowing from the judgment be directed to be completed in a time-bound (15–30 days), to restore certainty at the earliest,' the clubs wrote. 'In the event the present proceedings are to go on beyond August 22, 2025, the processes related to conducting the leagues and any ancillary operations may be allowed and expedited so that a long-term constructive solution for all parties may be obtained at the earliest,' the clubs wrote, while mentioning that they are not parties to the case. The eleven ISL clubs which signed the letter are Bengaluru FC, Hyderabad FC, Odisha FC, Chennaiyin FC, Jamshedpur FC, FC Goa, Kerala Blasters FC, Punjab FC, NorthEast United FC, Mumbai City FC and Mohammedan Sporting. The same 11 clubs had earlier warned All India Football Federation (AIFF) that they face the possibility of shutting down entirely due to uncertainty over the ISL's future. The crisis surfaced after FSDL, the ISL organisers as well as AIFF's commercial partner, put the 2025-26 season 'on hold' on July 11 due to uncertainty over the renewal of Master Rights Agreement (MRA), prompting at least three clubs to either pause first-team operations or suspend player and staff salaries. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The current MRA, signed in 2010 between FSDL and AIFF, ends on December 8. The AIFF gets Rs 50 crore annually from FSDL under the MRA. In the letter, the clubs said with no clarity on the ISL, the revenues of the clubs have been severely affected and their survival faced immediate threat, jeopardising the livelihoods of thousands engaged in the football ecosystem – players, staff, vendors, service providers. 'Even one season's disruption would erode the trust of fans, sponsors, investors, and international federations, undoing more than a decade's progress.' The ISL clubs said they have invested hundreds of crores of rupees into youth academies, training facilities, stadium upgrades, and professional squads, creating a robust footballing structure. 'The ISL now sustains the majority of professional football players in India, providing more than 400 full-time player contracts annually, besides developmental pathways for youth and grassroots players. 'It is respectfully submitted that a league of this calibre cannot be assembled at the last minute and requires long-term buy-in to obtain best possible deals. Broadcast agreements, sponsorship deals, player registrations, and logistical arrangements ideally require long-term buy-in and stability, and even thereafter approximately 6–8 weeks of advance certainty to implement every season. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'Therefore, the current delay has already placed us in a situation where any further delays may cause irreparable harm and there is an urgent need for certainty in the greater interest of the entire football ecosystem, including clubs, players, staff, and all other stakeholders.' They said that the loss of even a single ISL season would have catastrophic and irreversible consequences for Indian football as a whole – including the well-being of the players and staff associated with the sport, the professional league structure including the I-League and lower divisions, grassroots academies, and other football competitions – all of which depend on the stability of the top-tier competition. Current deadlock The clubs also submitted that 'this deadlock has indirectly arisen in the present case because there is, as we understand, a verbal stay/injunction on any discussions in relation to the MRA effective April 30, 2025'. 'This has created an anomalous situation where no resolution or forward planning for the 2025–26 season and beyond can take place. As matters stand, there is no certainty beyond 8 December 2025, when the current commercial partner demits its term. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'At that point in the calendar, ordinarily less than a quarter of the season would have been completed, leaving the league and, by extension, the wider pyramid in complete limbo. For the entire footballing system, it is also crucial that a long-term, stable solution is arrived at urgently. 'Clubs have multi-year sponsorships and contractual commitments, and several sponsors have already withdrawn due to the prevailing uncertainty. 'No commercial partner can be expected to invest or commit resources under an interim arrangement or for short term, given sheer scale and complexity of organizing a tournament like ISL and securing long-term broadcast and sponsorship partnerships. Therefore, it is imperative the current proceedings be expedited to provide necessary certainty for the league.'
Indian Express
6 hours ago
- Indian Express
Online gaming bill set to end ‘easy money' source for sports
Over the last decade, the Indian sports ecosystem has become increasingly dependent on the money flowing in from real-money fantasy gaming platforms. Nearly half a dozen mainstream sports and professional leagues relied on their money to run the daily operations, even if partially. Their logos were plastered on the t-shirts of the teams in the Indian Premier League, football's Indian Super League, the kabaddi league and, of course, the Indian cricket team. The players who wore those shirts were named as the brand ambassadors. And broadcasters roped them in as key sponsors. With the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Bill, 2025, now headed to President Droupadi Murmu's desk for her assent — after it was passed in the Lok Sabha on Wednesday followed by the Rajya Sabha on Thursday — the future of online gaming companies, as well as the sports, teams, players, and broadcasters that rely on them for sponsorship, looks shaky. It is learnt that the companies — individually or collectively — are likely to approach the courts. In a letter to the Home Ministry on Tuesday the E-Gaming Federation (EGF), All India Gaming Federation (AIGF) and Federation of Indian Fantasy Sports (FIFS) said that the blanket prohibition will 'strike a death knell for this legitimate, job creating industry, and would cause serious harm to Indian users and citizens'. The government cited risks of psychological distress, financial loss, money laundering and even financing of terrorism as reasons to prohibit the 'harmful' real-money gaming services. It went on to cite the 'threat to national security' as another reason to take the step. 'Unchecked expansion of online money gaming services has been linked to unlawful activities including financial fraud, money-laundering, tax evasion and in some cases, the financing of terrorism, thereby posing threats to national security, public order and the integrity of the State.' Nandan Kamath, a prominent sports lawyer, called the Bill — 'which came more or less out of the left field' — a turning point 'not just for the gaming ecosystem but also for the Indian sports ecosystem that lies downstream, benefitting through direct and indirect and induced revenues from the gaming as well as offshore betting sector'. An ISL club official, requesting anonymity, added: 'For the last few years, this has been easy money for the teams, leagues and players. The offshore sports betting companies were looking for a foothold in the Indian market and, through surrogates, splurged money on marketing campaigns and everyone benefitted from it. Now, we anticipate a short-term impact.' Although they were provided the shelter after being classified as a 'game of skill', the real-money fantasy gaming platforms have for years operated in a legal grey area. For, they promoted a business that, though legal, was similar to sports gambling, which is banned in India, in many ways because contestants can make money by predicting players' performances. Fantasy gaming requires its customers to select a playing XI of professional players and compete against each other using statistics from a live match. The websites charge a fee for entering a team, and the contestants — who have to submit their PAN card, bank details and other personal information — win or lose money based on real-life performances of players. The Bill added: 'Such games often use manipulative design features, addictive algorithms, bots and undisclosed agents, undermining fairness, transparency and user protection, while promoting compulsive behaviour leading to financial ruin.' There has been a sharp rise in the number of real-money fantasy gaming platforms, which now goes well into triple digits. But Dream11 is the biggest, with a valuation of $8 billion, according to Bloomberg. Dream11 is the Board of Control for Cricket in India's lead sponsor, acquiring the three-year rights for Rs 358 crore. Similarly, My11Circle paid Rs 625 crore for a five-year right to be the IPL's official fantasy sports partner. Kamath said the companies can still continue their association with the teams and leagues by changing their business models. However, identifying a similar, successful revenue stream — which was until now driven by entry fees paid by a user for entering a competition — to ensure sustainability remains an issue. The rise of the real-money fantasy gaming platforms has coincided with the proliferation of sports betting companies in the Indian market. And while the real-money fantasy gaming platforms were caught by surprise with the government's decision, the offshore sports betting companies have been on the radar for a while. Earlier this month, the Enforcement Directorate grilled former cricketer Suresh Raina for eight hours in an 'alleged illegal betting app-linked money-laundering case'. Raina was questioned in a case linked to 1xBet, a controversial offshore betting website. In 2019, a Sunday Times investigation revealed that 1xBet's 'brand had been used to promote betting on children's sports, cockfighting and a 'pornhub' casino with topless women dealing the cards.' It led to Britain's Gambling Commission blacklisting the website, and top football clubs that compete in the English Premier League were forced to terminate their sponsorship contracts. Two years later, in October 2021, the online bookmaker was banned in Russia, where it was founded, adding to the growing list of countries that had blacklisted the firm. The other nations included the USA, Cyprus and the Netherlands while, according to Spanish daily AS, the company was also fined in countries like Kenya, Poland, Israel, and the Netherlands for violating laws. In India, betting companies like 1xBet, Dafabet and FairPlay have tried to gain a foothold by operating under the banner of a 'professional sportsblog' to circumvent the rules. Through the surrogate operation, they launched a marketing blitzkrieg and sponsored live broadcasts of matches as well as teams across different leagues.
NDTV
7 hours ago
- NDTV
11 ISL Clubs Write To Lawyers Assisting SC To Bring Existential Crisis To Notice Of Top Court
Eleven Indian Super League clubs on Thursday urged the two senior lawyers assisting the Supreme Court in a pending case to bring to its notice the existential crisis they are facing due to uncertainty over the ISL's future and the "urgency of pronouncing judgment at the earliest". The letter from the ISL clubs came a day before a SC hearing of the case on Friday. Amici curiae Gopal Sankaranarayanan and Samar Bansal had earlier mentioned the matter on Monday before the SC which posted the matter for Friday. "Given that football clubs (across entire pyramid), their players, employees, and stakeholders are the most directly and immediately affected by the current standstill in Indian football, we have no option but to approach your good selves, as officers of the Hon'ble Court, to humbly request that our concerns be placed before the Ld. Bench," the letter stated. "The urgency of pronouncing judgment at the earliest, given football calendar is at a standstill across pyramid; any consequential directions flowing from the judgment be directed to be completed in a time-bound (15–30 days), to restore certainty at the earliest," the clubs wrote. "In the event the present proceedings are to go on beyond August 22, 2025, the processes related to conducting the leagues and any ancillary operations may be allowed and expedited so that a long-term constructive solution for all parties may be obtained at the earliest," the clubs wrote, while mentioning that they are not parties to the case. The eleven ISL clubs which signed the letter are Bengaluru FC, Hyderabad FC, Odisha FC, Chennaiyin FC, Jamshedpur FC, FC Goa, Kerala Blasters FC, Punjab FC, NorthEast United FC, Mumbai City FC and Mohammedan Sporting. The same 11 clubs had earlier warned All India Football Federation (AIFF) that they face the possibility of shutting down entirely due to uncertainty over the ISL's future. The crisis surfaced after FSDL, the ISL organisers as well as AIFF's commercial partner, put the 2025-26 season "on hold" on July 11 due to uncertainty over the renewal of Master Rights Agreement (MRA), prompting at least three clubs to either pause first-team operations or suspend player and staff salaries. The current MRA, signed in 2010 between FSDL and AIFF, ends on December 8. The AIFF gets Rs 50 crore annually from FSDL under the MRA. In the letter, the clubs said with no clarity on the ISL, the revenues of the clubs have been severely affected and their survival faced immediate threat, jeopardising the livelihoods of thousands engaged in the football ecosystem -- players, staff, vendors, service providers. "Even one season's disruption would erode the trust of fans, sponsors, investors, and international federations, undoing more than a decade's progress." The ISL clubs said they have invested hundreds of crores of rupees into youth academies, training facilities, stadium upgrades, and professional squads, creating a robust footballing structure. "The ISL now sustains the majority of professional football players in India, providing more than 400 full-time player contracts annually, besides developmental pathways for youth and grassroots players. "It is respectfully submitted that a league of this calibre cannot be assembled at the last minute and requires long-term buy-in to obtain best possible deals. Broadcast agreements, sponsorship deals, player registrations, and logistical arrangements ideally require long-term buy-in and stability, and even thereafter approximately 6–8 weeks of advance certainty to implement every season. "Therefore, the current delay has already placed us in a situation where any further delays may cause irreparable harm and there is an urgent need for certainty in the greater interest of the entire football ecosystem, including clubs, players, staff, and all other stakeholders." They said that the loss of even a single ISL season would have catastrophic and irreversible consequences for Indian football as a whole -- including the well-being of the players and staff associated with the sport, the professional league structure including the I-League and lower divisions, grassroots academies, and other football competitions -- all of which depend on the stability of the top-tier competition. Current deadlock The clubs also submitted that "this deadlock has indirectly arisen in the present case because there is, as we understand, a verbal stay/injunction on any discussions in relation to the MRA effective April 30, 2025". "This has created an anomalous situation where no resolution or forward planning for the 2025–26 season and beyond can take place. As matters stand, there is no certainty beyond 8 December 2025, when the current commercial partner demits its term. "At that point in the calendar, ordinarily less than a quarter of the season would have been completed, leaving the league and, by extension, the wider pyramid in complete limbo. For the entire footballing system, it is also crucial that a long-term, stable solution is arrived at urgently. "Clubs have multi-year sponsorships and contractual commitments, and several sponsors have already withdrawn due to the prevailing uncertainty. "No commercial partner can be expected to invest or commit resources under an interim arrangement or for short term, given sheer scale and complexity of organizing a tournament like ISL and securing long-term broadcast and sponsorship partnerships. Therefore, it is imperative the current proceedings be expedited to provide necessary certainty for the league."
