'Unimaginable grief' as army chopper crash inquiry ends
The heartbreaking impact of a fatal army helicopter crash has been revealed as a mammoth inquiry into the tragedy finally finished.
Family members of four air crew killed in the 2023 incident broke down before consoling each other in Brisbane on Friday after describing their "unimaginable grief".
One family spoke of losing faith in the Australian Defence Force over the incident while tears flowed as a victim's wife described her husband's death as "preventable".
The emotional scenes capped the inquiry, launched after Captain Danniel Lyon, Lieutenant Maxwell Nugent, Warrant Officer Class 2 Joseph "Phillip" Laycock and Corporal Alexander Naggs died when their MRH-90 Taipan crashed off Queensland's coast in July 2023.
The curtain was drawn on the probe before former judge Margaret McMurdo on Friday after nine hearings and dozens of witnesses spanning more than a year.
The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Inquiry was formed in October 2023, tasked with examining the cause of the crash and whether the action or inaction of army personnel or others contributed.
Over the hearings concerns were raised by army personnel about the helicopter, severe fatigue and high workload for pilots and night-vision technology.
Statements from the air crew's families were heard on Friday, with Capt Lyon's wife Caitland breaking down over the "unbearable" evidence and describing her husband's death as "preventable".
But she said her husband would have wanted the truth behind the helicopter crash to be known.
"He would have fought for it, not just for himself, but for anyone in his position," she sobbed.
She recalled her husband warning "someone would die" after being unhappy with the response to an incident in March 2023 when an MRH-90 Taipan suffered an engine failure, causing it to ditch into the sea.
Months later Capt Lyon was killed with the three other colleagues when their Taipan crashed during the Exercise Talisman Sabre training exercise.
Ms Lyon said her husband trusted the defence force to keep him safe and equipment had been properly tested and selected.
"He gave everything. Even his life," she said.
Capt Lyon's mother Sue said she had lost faith in the defence force.
"Daniel's life cannot be returned to us, but we owe it to his memory and to others who served on July 28, 2023, (that this) never happens again," she said.
Lt Nugent's family said he was exactly where he wanted to be before it ended in tragedy.
"He was 24 with the world ahead of him ... he was doing what he loved," a family statement read.
"We will never get to see where life would have taken him or share in his joys."
Corp Naggs' partner Sarah Loft's voice cracked as she addressed the inquiry.
"It's been 652 days and I'm still unable to watch Friends or Modern Family, to move Alex's toothbrush from where he left it, or to accept that he's not coming home," she said.
"Dan, Max, Phil and Alex deserved better."
Parents Wayne and Dianne Laycock said they could still remember the day two people in khaki uniforms and shiny boots knocked on their door.
"We knew we had lost Phillip on that day," their statement read.
"Hardly a day goes by when we don't wake up in the morning (or) we go to bed at night without memories of Phillip and tears in our eyes."
The air crew's families urged the defence force to implement the inquiry's recommendations to prevent another tragedy occurring.
Ms McMurdo will hand down her findings at an undetermined date.
Lifeline 13 11 14
Open Arms 1800 011 046
The heartbreaking impact of a fatal army helicopter crash has been revealed as a mammoth inquiry into the tragedy finally finished.
Family members of four air crew killed in the 2023 incident broke down before consoling each other in Brisbane on Friday after describing their "unimaginable grief".
One family spoke of losing faith in the Australian Defence Force over the incident while tears flowed as a victim's wife described her husband's death as "preventable".
The emotional scenes capped the inquiry, launched after Captain Danniel Lyon, Lieutenant Maxwell Nugent, Warrant Officer Class 2 Joseph "Phillip" Laycock and Corporal Alexander Naggs died when their MRH-90 Taipan crashed off Queensland's coast in July 2023.
The curtain was drawn on the probe before former judge Margaret McMurdo on Friday after nine hearings and dozens of witnesses spanning more than a year.
The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Inquiry was formed in October 2023, tasked with examining the cause of the crash and whether the action or inaction of army personnel or others contributed.
Over the hearings concerns were raised by army personnel about the helicopter, severe fatigue and high workload for pilots and night-vision technology.
Statements from the air crew's families were heard on Friday, with Capt Lyon's wife Caitland breaking down over the "unbearable" evidence and describing her husband's death as "preventable".
But she said her husband would have wanted the truth behind the helicopter crash to be known.
"He would have fought for it, not just for himself, but for anyone in his position," she sobbed.
She recalled her husband warning "someone would die" after being unhappy with the response to an incident in March 2023 when an MRH-90 Taipan suffered an engine failure, causing it to ditch into the sea.
Months later Capt Lyon was killed with the three other colleagues when their Taipan crashed during the Exercise Talisman Sabre training exercise.
Ms Lyon said her husband trusted the defence force to keep him safe and equipment had been properly tested and selected.
"He gave everything. Even his life," she said.
Capt Lyon's mother Sue said she had lost faith in the defence force.
"Daniel's life cannot be returned to us, but we owe it to his memory and to others who served on July 28, 2023, (that this) never happens again," she said.
Lt Nugent's family said he was exactly where he wanted to be before it ended in tragedy.
"He was 24 with the world ahead of him ... he was doing what he loved," a family statement read.
"We will never get to see where life would have taken him or share in his joys."
Corp Naggs' partner Sarah Loft's voice cracked as she addressed the inquiry.
"It's been 652 days and I'm still unable to watch Friends or Modern Family, to move Alex's toothbrush from where he left it, or to accept that he's not coming home," she said.
"Dan, Max, Phil and Alex deserved better."
Parents Wayne and Dianne Laycock said they could still remember the day two people in khaki uniforms and shiny boots knocked on their door.
"We knew we had lost Phillip on that day," their statement read.
"Hardly a day goes by when we don't wake up in the morning (or) we go to bed at night without memories of Phillip and tears in our eyes."
The air crew's families urged the defence force to implement the inquiry's recommendations to prevent another tragedy occurring.
Ms McMurdo will hand down her findings at an undetermined date.
Lifeline 13 11 14
Open Arms 1800 011 046
The heartbreaking impact of a fatal army helicopter crash has been revealed as a mammoth inquiry into the tragedy finally finished.
Family members of four air crew killed in the 2023 incident broke down before consoling each other in Brisbane on Friday after describing their "unimaginable grief".
One family spoke of losing faith in the Australian Defence Force over the incident while tears flowed as a victim's wife described her husband's death as "preventable".
The emotional scenes capped the inquiry, launched after Captain Danniel Lyon, Lieutenant Maxwell Nugent, Warrant Officer Class 2 Joseph "Phillip" Laycock and Corporal Alexander Naggs died when their MRH-90 Taipan crashed off Queensland's coast in July 2023.
The curtain was drawn on the probe before former judge Margaret McMurdo on Friday after nine hearings and dozens of witnesses spanning more than a year.
The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Inquiry was formed in October 2023, tasked with examining the cause of the crash and whether the action or inaction of army personnel or others contributed.
Over the hearings concerns were raised by army personnel about the helicopter, severe fatigue and high workload for pilots and night-vision technology.
Statements from the air crew's families were heard on Friday, with Capt Lyon's wife Caitland breaking down over the "unbearable" evidence and describing her husband's death as "preventable".
But she said her husband would have wanted the truth behind the helicopter crash to be known.
"He would have fought for it, not just for himself, but for anyone in his position," she sobbed.
She recalled her husband warning "someone would die" after being unhappy with the response to an incident in March 2023 when an MRH-90 Taipan suffered an engine failure, causing it to ditch into the sea.
Months later Capt Lyon was killed with the three other colleagues when their Taipan crashed during the Exercise Talisman Sabre training exercise.
Ms Lyon said her husband trusted the defence force to keep him safe and equipment had been properly tested and selected.
"He gave everything. Even his life," she said.
Capt Lyon's mother Sue said she had lost faith in the defence force.
"Daniel's life cannot be returned to us, but we owe it to his memory and to others who served on July 28, 2023, (that this) never happens again," she said.
Lt Nugent's family said he was exactly where he wanted to be before it ended in tragedy.
"He was 24 with the world ahead of him ... he was doing what he loved," a family statement read.
"We will never get to see where life would have taken him or share in his joys."
Corp Naggs' partner Sarah Loft's voice cracked as she addressed the inquiry.
"It's been 652 days and I'm still unable to watch Friends or Modern Family, to move Alex's toothbrush from where he left it, or to accept that he's not coming home," she said.
"Dan, Max, Phil and Alex deserved better."
Parents Wayne and Dianne Laycock said they could still remember the day two people in khaki uniforms and shiny boots knocked on their door.
"We knew we had lost Phillip on that day," their statement read.
"Hardly a day goes by when we don't wake up in the morning (or) we go to bed at night without memories of Phillip and tears in our eyes."
The air crew's families urged the defence force to implement the inquiry's recommendations to prevent another tragedy occurring.
Ms McMurdo will hand down her findings at an undetermined date.
Lifeline 13 11 14
Open Arms 1800 011 046
The heartbreaking impact of a fatal army helicopter crash has been revealed as a mammoth inquiry into the tragedy finally finished.
Family members of four air crew killed in the 2023 incident broke down before consoling each other in Brisbane on Friday after describing their "unimaginable grief".
One family spoke of losing faith in the Australian Defence Force over the incident while tears flowed as a victim's wife described her husband's death as "preventable".
The emotional scenes capped the inquiry, launched after Captain Danniel Lyon, Lieutenant Maxwell Nugent, Warrant Officer Class 2 Joseph "Phillip" Laycock and Corporal Alexander Naggs died when their MRH-90 Taipan crashed off Queensland's coast in July 2023.
The curtain was drawn on the probe before former judge Margaret McMurdo on Friday after nine hearings and dozens of witnesses spanning more than a year.
The Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force Inquiry was formed in October 2023, tasked with examining the cause of the crash and whether the action or inaction of army personnel or others contributed.
Over the hearings concerns were raised by army personnel about the helicopter, severe fatigue and high workload for pilots and night-vision technology.
Statements from the air crew's families were heard on Friday, with Capt Lyon's wife Caitland breaking down over the "unbearable" evidence and describing her husband's death as "preventable".
But she said her husband would have wanted the truth behind the helicopter crash to be known.
"He would have fought for it, not just for himself, but for anyone in his position," she sobbed.
She recalled her husband warning "someone would die" after being unhappy with the response to an incident in March 2023 when an MRH-90 Taipan suffered an engine failure, causing it to ditch into the sea.
Months later Capt Lyon was killed with the three other colleagues when their Taipan crashed during the Exercise Talisman Sabre training exercise.
Ms Lyon said her husband trusted the defence force to keep him safe and equipment had been properly tested and selected.
"He gave everything. Even his life," she said.
Capt Lyon's mother Sue said she had lost faith in the defence force.
"Daniel's life cannot be returned to us, but we owe it to his memory and to others who served on July 28, 2023, (that this) never happens again," she said.
Lt Nugent's family said he was exactly where he wanted to be before it ended in tragedy.
"He was 24 with the world ahead of him ... he was doing what he loved," a family statement read.
"We will never get to see where life would have taken him or share in his joys."
Corp Naggs' partner Sarah Loft's voice cracked as she addressed the inquiry.
"It's been 652 days and I'm still unable to watch Friends or Modern Family, to move Alex's toothbrush from where he left it, or to accept that he's not coming home," she said.
"Dan, Max, Phil and Alex deserved better."
Parents Wayne and Dianne Laycock said they could still remember the day two people in khaki uniforms and shiny boots knocked on their door.
"We knew we had lost Phillip on that day," their statement read.
"Hardly a day goes by when we don't wake up in the morning (or) we go to bed at night without memories of Phillip and tears in our eyes."
The air crew's families urged the defence force to implement the inquiry's recommendations to prevent another tragedy occurring.
Ms McMurdo will hand down her findings at an undetermined date.
Lifeline 13 11 14
Open Arms 1800 011 046
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
31-05-2025
- News.com.au
Man missing after jumping off Channel Island Bridge with mates on Friday night
A frantic search is underway for a 55-year-old man who went missing after jumping into the water near Channel Island. Brendon Doherty voluntarily jumped off Channel Island Bridge with work friends on Friday night, and was laughing and active in the water before drifting away. Police received a report at 9.42pm that Mr Doherty was unable to swim back to shore, despite his friends' attempts to encourage him. He was last seen in the middle of the channel, drifting toward Darwin City in strong tidal currents. Witnesses observed him for close to two minutes before losing sight of him. Mr Doherty was last seen wearing shorts, a dark shirt, and steel cap boots. NT Police Search and Rescue deployed and did an extensive search of the Middle Arm area overnight. Police are urging anyone who may witness a man floating or along the shore in the harbour to provide aid and call triple-0 immediately.
The Advertiser
30-05-2025
- The Advertiser
Aniston 'stalker' found mentally incompetent for trial
A man accused of stalking Jennifer Aniston and crashing his car through her front gate is mentally incompetent to stand trial, a judge has ruled. The move in a Los Angeles County mental health court came after a second psychiatrist examined the defendant, Jimmy Wayne Carwyle, and reached the same conclusion as the first: that his mental health would not allow him to answer to felony charges of vandalism and stalking of the Friends star. "The court finds the defendant is not currently competent to stand trial," Judge Maria Cavalluzzi said. "Criminal proceedings will remain suspended." Carwyle, 48, of Mississippi, has pleaded not guilty. He appeared behind glass in a custody area of the courtroom and did not speak. He looked vastly different than his previous two court hearings. His scraggly grey hair and beard had been shorn, and he was wearing bright yellow county jail clothing after previously appearing with bare shoulders, wrapped in a blanket-like smock meant for suicide prevention. Carwyle had argued that he is competent, and exercised his right to a second opinion after an initial incompetence finding last week. "It's not the outcome my client would have preferred," Deputy Public Defender Robert Krauss told the judge. A conviction on the charges, along with an aggravating circumstance of the threat of great bodily harm, could bring up to three years in prison for Carwyle. The incompetence finding has no set end date but it is temporary, and the standard criminal process could resume later. Cavalluzzi ordered more comprehensive mental evaluations to help determine where and how he'll be held, and what his treatment will be. The judge also said a lawyer representing Aniston would be allowed to speak at the next hearing. Carwyle's next court date is June 26. Aniston's lawyer, Blair Berk, was in the courtroom observing on Thursday, but did not speak. He declined comment outside court. Prosecutors allege Carwyle had been harassing Aniston with a flood of voicemail, email and social media messages for two years before driving his Chrysler PT Cruiser through the gate of her home in the wealthy Bel Air neighbourhood of Los Angeles on May 5, causing major damage. A security guard stopped him in her driveway until police arrived. Authorities said Aniston was home at the time, but did not come into contact, and no one was injured. Aniston became one of television's biggest stars in her 10 years on Friends from 1994 until 2004. She won an Emmy Award for best lead actress in a comedy for the role, and she has been nominated for nine more. She currently stars in The Morning Show on Apple TV+. Lifeline 13 11 14 beyondblue 1300 22 4636 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) A man accused of stalking Jennifer Aniston and crashing his car through her front gate is mentally incompetent to stand trial, a judge has ruled. The move in a Los Angeles County mental health court came after a second psychiatrist examined the defendant, Jimmy Wayne Carwyle, and reached the same conclusion as the first: that his mental health would not allow him to answer to felony charges of vandalism and stalking of the Friends star. "The court finds the defendant is not currently competent to stand trial," Judge Maria Cavalluzzi said. "Criminal proceedings will remain suspended." Carwyle, 48, of Mississippi, has pleaded not guilty. He appeared behind glass in a custody area of the courtroom and did not speak. He looked vastly different than his previous two court hearings. His scraggly grey hair and beard had been shorn, and he was wearing bright yellow county jail clothing after previously appearing with bare shoulders, wrapped in a blanket-like smock meant for suicide prevention. Carwyle had argued that he is competent, and exercised his right to a second opinion after an initial incompetence finding last week. "It's not the outcome my client would have preferred," Deputy Public Defender Robert Krauss told the judge. A conviction on the charges, along with an aggravating circumstance of the threat of great bodily harm, could bring up to three years in prison for Carwyle. The incompetence finding has no set end date but it is temporary, and the standard criminal process could resume later. Cavalluzzi ordered more comprehensive mental evaluations to help determine where and how he'll be held, and what his treatment will be. The judge also said a lawyer representing Aniston would be allowed to speak at the next hearing. Carwyle's next court date is June 26. Aniston's lawyer, Blair Berk, was in the courtroom observing on Thursday, but did not speak. He declined comment outside court. Prosecutors allege Carwyle had been harassing Aniston with a flood of voicemail, email and social media messages for two years before driving his Chrysler PT Cruiser through the gate of her home in the wealthy Bel Air neighbourhood of Los Angeles on May 5, causing major damage. A security guard stopped him in her driveway until police arrived. Authorities said Aniston was home at the time, but did not come into contact, and no one was injured. Aniston became one of television's biggest stars in her 10 years on Friends from 1994 until 2004. She won an Emmy Award for best lead actress in a comedy for the role, and she has been nominated for nine more. She currently stars in The Morning Show on Apple TV+. Lifeline 13 11 14 beyondblue 1300 22 4636 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) A man accused of stalking Jennifer Aniston and crashing his car through her front gate is mentally incompetent to stand trial, a judge has ruled. The move in a Los Angeles County mental health court came after a second psychiatrist examined the defendant, Jimmy Wayne Carwyle, and reached the same conclusion as the first: that his mental health would not allow him to answer to felony charges of vandalism and stalking of the Friends star. "The court finds the defendant is not currently competent to stand trial," Judge Maria Cavalluzzi said. "Criminal proceedings will remain suspended." Carwyle, 48, of Mississippi, has pleaded not guilty. He appeared behind glass in a custody area of the courtroom and did not speak. He looked vastly different than his previous two court hearings. His scraggly grey hair and beard had been shorn, and he was wearing bright yellow county jail clothing after previously appearing with bare shoulders, wrapped in a blanket-like smock meant for suicide prevention. Carwyle had argued that he is competent, and exercised his right to a second opinion after an initial incompetence finding last week. "It's not the outcome my client would have preferred," Deputy Public Defender Robert Krauss told the judge. A conviction on the charges, along with an aggravating circumstance of the threat of great bodily harm, could bring up to three years in prison for Carwyle. The incompetence finding has no set end date but it is temporary, and the standard criminal process could resume later. Cavalluzzi ordered more comprehensive mental evaluations to help determine where and how he'll be held, and what his treatment will be. The judge also said a lawyer representing Aniston would be allowed to speak at the next hearing. Carwyle's next court date is June 26. Aniston's lawyer, Blair Berk, was in the courtroom observing on Thursday, but did not speak. He declined comment outside court. Prosecutors allege Carwyle had been harassing Aniston with a flood of voicemail, email and social media messages for two years before driving his Chrysler PT Cruiser through the gate of her home in the wealthy Bel Air neighbourhood of Los Angeles on May 5, causing major damage. A security guard stopped him in her driveway until police arrived. Authorities said Aniston was home at the time, but did not come into contact, and no one was injured. Aniston became one of television's biggest stars in her 10 years on Friends from 1994 until 2004. She won an Emmy Award for best lead actress in a comedy for the role, and she has been nominated for nine more. She currently stars in The Morning Show on Apple TV+. Lifeline 13 11 14 beyondblue 1300 22 4636 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732) A man accused of stalking Jennifer Aniston and crashing his car through her front gate is mentally incompetent to stand trial, a judge has ruled. The move in a Los Angeles County mental health court came after a second psychiatrist examined the defendant, Jimmy Wayne Carwyle, and reached the same conclusion as the first: that his mental health would not allow him to answer to felony charges of vandalism and stalking of the Friends star. "The court finds the defendant is not currently competent to stand trial," Judge Maria Cavalluzzi said. "Criminal proceedings will remain suspended." Carwyle, 48, of Mississippi, has pleaded not guilty. He appeared behind glass in a custody area of the courtroom and did not speak. He looked vastly different than his previous two court hearings. His scraggly grey hair and beard had been shorn, and he was wearing bright yellow county jail clothing after previously appearing with bare shoulders, wrapped in a blanket-like smock meant for suicide prevention. Carwyle had argued that he is competent, and exercised his right to a second opinion after an initial incompetence finding last week. "It's not the outcome my client would have preferred," Deputy Public Defender Robert Krauss told the judge. A conviction on the charges, along with an aggravating circumstance of the threat of great bodily harm, could bring up to three years in prison for Carwyle. The incompetence finding has no set end date but it is temporary, and the standard criminal process could resume later. Cavalluzzi ordered more comprehensive mental evaluations to help determine where and how he'll be held, and what his treatment will be. The judge also said a lawyer representing Aniston would be allowed to speak at the next hearing. Carwyle's next court date is June 26. Aniston's lawyer, Blair Berk, was in the courtroom observing on Thursday, but did not speak. He declined comment outside court. Prosecutors allege Carwyle had been harassing Aniston with a flood of voicemail, email and social media messages for two years before driving his Chrysler PT Cruiser through the gate of her home in the wealthy Bel Air neighbourhood of Los Angeles on May 5, causing major damage. A security guard stopped him in her driveway until police arrived. Authorities said Aniston was home at the time, but did not come into contact, and no one was injured. Aniston became one of television's biggest stars in her 10 years on Friends from 1994 until 2004. She won an Emmy Award for best lead actress in a comedy for the role, and she has been nominated for nine more. She currently stars in The Morning Show on Apple TV+. Lifeline 13 11 14 beyondblue 1300 22 4636 1800 RESPECT (1800 737 732)
Perth Now
29-05-2025
- Perth Now
Cassie Ventura ‘has welcomed her third child'
Cassie Ventura has reportedly welcomed her third child. The 38-year-old singer was heavily pregnant as she gave harrowing testimony in Sean 'Diddy' Combs' ongoing federal trial after she accused him of a series of abuses, and it has now emerged she gave birth days after finishing her disturbing appearance in court. According to an ABC News report on Wednesday (28.05.25) she has now given birth, with her and her husband Alex Fine, 32, expected to share further details in the coming days. News broke on Tuesday (27.05.25) she had gone into labour. Cassie and Alex have already shared their pregnancy journey on social media with snaps of Cassie showing off her growing baby bump in recent weeks. The singer, whose full name is Casandra Ventura, confirmed in March her third the baby would be a boy. In a birthday message to Alex on Instagram, she wrote: 'You've taken care of me and my heart like no other, you're hands down the best girl dad and I'm SO excited to see you now become a father to OUR SON!' The couple already share two daughters – Frankie, born in late 2019, and Sunny, born in 2021. Cassie and Alex married in 2019 shortly after the singer's relationship with Combs ended. Alex was present in New York City earlier this month as Cassie gave testimony against her former partner, who is facing federal charges including racketeering conspiracy, sex trafficking and transportation to engage in prostitution. Combs, 55, has pleaded not guilty to all charges and denies all allegations. Cassie spent four days on the witness stand, offering detailed accounts of what she described as an abusive relationship with Combs. According to her testimony, she endured years of physical and sexual abuse, as well as episodes of forced drug use. Her testimony followed a civil lawsuit filed in November 2023, in which Cassie accused Combs of rape, battery and human trafficking. The case was settled out of court, with Cassie later revealing during proceedings that she received a $20 million settlement. Cassie has spoken publicly about the balancing act of being a mother and maintaining her own career. In a 2020 interview with Hatch, she said about bringing up her daughter: 'I don't want to lose myself in becoming a mom. Of course, I will do anything for her, but I also want to remain true to myself. 'I want her to grow up watching me do my thing. I want her to see me making music, building my business, being a mom, a wife, a force, and be inspired by it all.' Sunny, the second child of Alex and Cassie, was born on 22 March 2021. Announcing her birth, Cassie posted on Instagram: 'On Monday March 22nd, 2021 @ 10:22am our hearts got bigger. Welcome to the world baby girl! We love you so much Sunny Cinco Fine!'
