Mashatile bodyguards: Do we really have a rule of law?
The internal exoneration of Deputy President Paul Mashatile's bodyguards raises disturbing questions about power, impunity and the rule of law in South Africa.
In the 1960s, the corrupt and tyrannical president of Haiti, François 'Papa Doc' Duvalier, was so paranoid about any opposition that he created a force of thugs, known as the Tonton Macoute, as his bodyguards and they embarked on a reign of terror on the island which was to last decades.
Anybody suspected of challenging 'Papa Doc' was liable to be assaulted, kidnapped – or just murdered.
Closer to home, the various thugs running the ZanuPF government in Zimbabwe have been doing similar things for years.
But we, here in South Africa, we are civilised, we have a constitution and the rule of law – and that wouldn't happen here.
ALSO READ: Mashatile's VIP protection officers acquitted of assault by police
Or would it? That's the question we have to be asking ourselves in the wake of reports that eight South African Police Service (Saps) members of Deputy President Paul Mashatile's VIP presidential protection unit have been cleared by an internal police disciplinary process, following their brutal assault on the driver and passengers in a car on a Joburg highway in 2023.
The attack was captured on video, showing the VIP officers – brandishing rifles and pistols – jumping out of a BMW X5 and attacking the occupants of a VW Polo.
The men are still out on bail waiting for the finalisation of a criminal case against them, but DA MP and chair of the portfolio committee on police Ian Cameron is right to ask: 'If police officers can beat civilians on camera and walk free, if unions can obstruct justice with no consequence, and if Saps can sign off on it all – what is left of public accountability?'
Cameron claimed police unions had helped protect the VIP cops and delay and frustrate the disciplinary process.
Our politicians must learn they are not gods and they are accountable to us. We are not a banana republic… yet.
NOW READ: 'Not clearly defined' — What ANC leaders are saying about Mashatile's 'assassination' attempt
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
an hour ago
- The South African
Bloem teenager allegedly taken by unknown men in SAPS uniform
Police in Bloemfontein are searching for 19-year-old Kamogelo Baukudi, who was allegedly kidnapped by two men impersonating officers on Thursday afternoon. He was immediately reported missing. 'The complainant, Daniel Malebatso, arrived at Marti Du Plessis School in Fitchardpark as usual, to fetch Baukudi who is a Grade 11 learner at the school,' said SAPS national spokesperson, Brigadier Athlenda Mathe. According to Mathe, Malebatso left the school with the teenager and they were driving in a Suzuki Ertiga. Malebatso said while driving on Vereeniging Drive near Erlichpark Extension, they suddenly heard a siren going off behind them. He said they were pulled over by a White Toyota Hilux GD-6 Double Cab. He alleges that he saw two male persons inside the vehicle and insists that their identities are unknown to him. However he said that one of the men was wearing a police uniform while the other wore blue tracksuits. 'According to the complainant, the suspects bakkie was fitted with blue lights on the grill and what looked like a police radio inside,' said Mathe. According to Malebatso, the suspect who was wearing a police uniform confronted him and informed him that the vehicle they were driving in was suspected of drug trafficking. He alleges the two 'officers' then separated him from Baukudi. Malebatso claims he was instructed to drive in front of the 'police vehicle', while they followed behind him en route to Park Road Police Station. 'Both vehicles turned back and drove in westerly direction in Vereeniging Drive. Malebatso alleges that a truck went in-between the Suzuki he was driving and the Toyota Hilux and he never saw it again,' said Mathe. 'Malebatso recalls that one of the suspects was speaking Sesotho fluently and even mentioned the name 'Thipe',' said Mathe She said the cellphones belonging to both Malebatso and Baukudi were found under the bridge on Ferrera Road. A case of kidnapping and impersonating the police has since been opened at Parkweg Police Station. Police are pleading with anyone who might have information that can help locate Kamogelo Baukudi, to come forward. If you have any information, contact Captain Sabata Jafta Moseme at 082 5262 713. Alternatively the information can be submitted on MySAPS App or call the SAPS Crime Stop number 08600 10111. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
The South African
2 hours ago
- The South African
Taxpayers cough up R1 million for Paul Mashatile's Japan hotel
Deputy President Paul Mashatile is under fire following revelations that nearly R1 million in public funds was spent on luxury hotel accommodation during a five-day diplomatic visit to Japan in March 2025. According to details disclosed in a recent parliamentary Q&A, Mashatile and his wife, Humile Mashatile, racked up R956 057 in hotel expenses alone – part of a total R2.3 million bill for the Tokyo trip, which was billed as a high-level engagement to strengthen trade and cultural ties between South Africa and Japan. The cost of accommodation has sparked particular outrage. Based on a four-night stay, the expenses average out to roughly R239 000 per night – far more than the rates charged by even Japan's most opulent hotels. Parliamentary records did not name the hotel used by the delegation, and this lack of transparency has only fueled criticism from opposition MPs and civil society groups, who say the spending is excessive and unjustifiable, especially during a time of economic hardship for many South Africans. 'This kind of wasteful expenditure is unacceptable,' said DA MP Lerato Ngobeni, who posed the original parliamentary question. 'Taxpayers are struggling to make ends meet, while senior officials are living in five-star luxury.' The March visit came just months after Paul Mashatile was sworn in as deputy president on 3 July 2024. Since then, he has undertaken several international trips, including stops in Ireland, the United Kingdom, Zimbabwe, Botswana, and Japan – trips that have collectively drawn scrutiny over rising travel costs. Mashatile did not travel alone. He was accompanied by a delegation that included ministers and deputy ministers from several portfolios, such as Sport, Agriculture, Higher Education, and International Relations. The government has defended the trip, arguing it held strategic value for bilateral cooperation in trade, education, and science. Yet critics remain unconvinced. Transparency watchdogs and public finance monitors have demanded an audit of the Japan trip and called for stricter guidelines on government travel, citing the lack of itemised breakdowns and vague justifications. 'This isn't just about one trip,' said Sipho Mbele, an analyst with the Public Accountability Forum. 'It's about a pattern of abuse where government elites operate under a different set of rules than ordinary citizens. There's very little transparency or restraint.' As pressure mounts, at the time of publishing, Paul Mashatile's office has remained silent on the matter. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
TimesLIVE
3 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Police launch manhunt after school pupil ‘kidnapped by fake cops'
The police's task team in Bloemfontein, Free State is searching for 19-year-old Kamogelo Baukudi, who was allegedly kidnapped by two men impersonating police on Thursday. According to police, the complainant, Daniel Malebatso, arrived at Marti Du Plessis School in Fitchardpark as usual to fetch Baukudi, who is a grade 11 pupil at the school. "The two left the school premises with Baukudi driving the Suzuki Ertiga," said provincial police spokesperson Lt-Col Thabo Covane. While driving on Vereeniging Drive Erlichpark in Extension, Malebatso alleged they heard a siren sound from behind and were pulled over by occupants in a white Toyota Hilux GD-6 double cab. "Inside the Toyota Hilux, there were two unknown male persons, one wearing a police uniform and the other a blue tracksuit," said Covane. The suspects' bakkie was allegedly fitted with blue lights on the grill and what appeared to be a police radio inside. Covane said the suspect wearing a police uniform told Malebatso the Suzuki Ertiga they were driving was suspected of delivering drugs. He said the suspects then allegedly separated Baukudi and Malebatso and instructed Malebatso to drive at the front while they followed from behind to the Park Road police station. "The two vehicles turned back and drove in a westerly direction on Vereeniging Drive. Malebatso alleged a truck moved in between the two vehicles and he did not see the the Hilux again. "He said one suspect was speaking Sesotho fluently and mentioned the name 'Thipe'. Cellphones belonging to Baukudi and Malebatso were found under a bridge on Ferrera Road." A case of kidnapping and impersonating police was opened at the Parkweg police station. Any member of the public who might have information that can help the police find Baukudi and might have seen the vehicles while on Vereeniging Drive is requested to contact Capt Sabata Jafta Moseme at 082 5262 713. Alternatively, the information can be submitted on the MySAPS App or call the SAPS Crime Stop number 08600 10111.
