logo
How a can of Coke and day-old cake led to iconic photo that went around the world

How a can of Coke and day-old cake led to iconic photo that went around the world

The Age29-04-2025

By 1975, the AP's bureau had shrunk as well, and as the North Vietnamese Army and its allied Viet Cong guerilla force in the south pushed towards Saigon, most staff members were evacuated.
Arnett, Esper and Franjola volunteered to stay behind, anxious to see through to the end what they had committed so many years of their lives to covering – and conspiring to ignore New York if any of their managers got the jitters and ordered them to leave at the last minute.
'I saw it from the beginning, I wanted to see the end,' Esper said. 'I was a bit apprehensive and frightened, but I knew that if I left, the rest of my life I would have been second-guessing myself.'
On April 30, 1975, the monsoon rains had arrived and Arnett watched in the early morning hours from the slippery roof of the AP's building as helicopters evacuated Americans and selected Vietnamese from the embassy four blocks away.
After catching a few hours of sleep, he awoke at 6.30am to the loud voices of looters on the streets. An hour later, from the rooftop of his hotel, he watched through binoculars as a small group of US marines that had accidentally been left behind clambered aboard a Sea Knight helicopter from the roof of the embassy – the last American evacuees.
He called it in to Esper in the office, and the story was in newsrooms around the world before the helicopter had cleared the coast.
'I was thinking in my own mind these are North Vietnamese, there are South Vietnamese, Americans – we're all the same.'
George Esper, AP journalist
Franjola and Arnett then took to the streets to see what was going on, while Esper manned the desk. When they got to the US Embassy, a mob of people were grinning and laughing as they looted the building – a sharp contrast to the desperation of people the day before hoping to be evacuated.
'On a pile of wet documents and broken furniture on the back lawn, we find the heavy bronze plaque engraved with the names of the five American soldiers who died in the attack on the embassy in the opening hours of the Tet Offensive in 1968,' Arnett recalled in an email detailing the day's events. 'Together we carry it back to the AP office.'
At 10.24am, Arnett was writing the story of the embassy looting when Esper heard on Saigon Radio that South Vietnam had surrendered, and immediately filed an alert.
'Esper rushes to the teleprinter and messages New York, and soon receives the satisfying news that AP is five minutes ahead of UPI with the surrender story,' Arnett said, citing AP's biggest rival at the time, United Press International. 'In war or peace, the wire services place a premium on competition.'
Esper then dashed outside to try and gather some reaction from South Vietnamese soldiers to the news of the capitulation, and came across a police colonel standing by a statue in a main square.
'He was waving his arms, 'fini, fini', you know, 'it's all over, we lost',' Esper remembered. 'And he was also fingering his holstered pistol and I figured, this guy is really crazy, he will kill me, and after 10 years here with barely a scratch, I'm going to die on this final day.'
Suddenly, the colonel did an about-face, saluted the memorial statue, drew his pistol and shot himself in the head.
Shaken, Esper ran back to the bureau, up the four flights of stairs to the office and punched out a quick story on the incident, his hands trembling as he typed.
Stories flow as Saigon falls
Back on the streets, Franjola, who died in 2015, was nearly sideswiped by a Jeep packed with men brandishing Russian rifles and wearing the black Viet Cong garb. Arnett then saw a convoy of Russian trucks loaded with North Vietnamese soldiers driving down the main street and scrambled back into the office.
''George,' I shout, 'Saigon has fallen. Call New York',' Arnett said. 'I check my watch. It's 11.43am.'
Over the next few hours, more soldiers, supported by tanks, pushed into the city, engaging in sporadic fighting while the AP reporters kept filing their copy.
Loading
It was about 2.30pm when they heard the rubber sandals outside the office, and the two NVA soldiers burst in, one with an AK-47 assault rifle swinging from his shoulder, the other with a Russian pistol holstered on his belt. To their shock, the soldiers were accompanied by Ky Nhan, a freelance photographer who worked for the AP, who proudly announced himself as a long-time member of the Viet Cong.
'I have guaranteed the safety of the AP office,' Arnett recalled the normally reserved photographer saying. 'You have no reason to be concerned.'
As Arnett, Esper and Franjola pored over the map with the two NVA soldiers, they chatted through an interpreter about the attack on Saigon, which had been renamed Ho Chi Minh City as soon as it fell.
The interview with the two soldiers turned to the personal, and the young men showed the reporters photos of their families and girlfriends, telling them how much they missed them and wanted to get home.
'I was thinking in my own mind these are North Vietnamese, there are South Vietnamese, Americans – we're all the same,' Esper said.
'People have girlfriends, they miss them, they have the same fears, the same loneliness, and in my head I'm tallying up the casualties, you know nearly 60,000 Americans dead, a million North Vietnamese fighters dead, 224,000 South Vietnamese military killed, and 2 million civilians killed. And that's the way the war ended for me.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Trump deploys National Guard to quell LA protests
Trump deploys National Guard to quell LA protests

The Advertiser

time2 hours ago

  • The Advertiser

Trump deploys National Guard to quell LA protests

President Donald Trump's administration says it will deploy 2000 National Guard troops as federal agents in Los Angeles face off against a few hundred demonstrators during a second day of protests following immigration raids. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth warned on Saturday the Pentagon was prepared to mobilise active-duty troops "if violence continues" in Los Angeles, saying the Marines at nearby Camp Pendleton were "on high alert". Federal security agents on Saturday confronted protesters in the Paramount area in southeast Los Angeles, where some demonstrators displayed Mexican flags. A second protest in downtown Los Angeles on Saturday night attracted some 60 people, who chanted slogans including "ICE out of L.A.!" Trump signed a presidential memorandum to deploy the National Guard troops to "address the lawlessness that has been allowed to fester"the White House said in a statement. Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, told Fox News the National Guard would be deployed in Los Angeles on Saturday. California Governor Gavin Newsom called the decision "purposefully inflammatory". He posted on X that Trump was deploying the National Guard "not because there is a shortage of law enforcement, but because they want a spectacle", adding: "Don't give them one. Never use violence. Speak out peacefully." Newsom said it was "deranged behavior" for Hegseth to be "threatening to deploy active-duty Marines on American soil against its own citizens." Trump posted on his Truth Social platform that if Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass can't do their jobs "then the Federal Government will step in and solve the problem, RIOTS & LOOTERS, the way it should be solved!!!" The protests pit Democratic-run Los Angeles, where a significant portion of the population is Hispanic and foreign-born, against Trump's Republican White House, which has made cracking down on immigration a hallmark of his second term. Senior White House aide Stephen Miller, an immigration hardliner, described the protests as a "violent insurrection." The 1807 law empowers a president to deploy the US military to enforce the law and suppress events such as civil disorder. The last time it was invoked was during the 1992 Los Angeles riots at the request of the California governor. Video footage of the Paramount protest showed dozens of green-uniformed security personnel with gas masks lined up on a road strewn with overturned shopping carts as small canisters exploded into gas clouds. Los Angeles police posted on X that "multiple people have been detained for failing to disperse after multiple warnings were issued." It did not give further details. There was no official information of any arrests. "Now they know that they cannot go to anywhere in this country where our people are, and try to kidnap our workers, our people - they cannot do that without an organised and fierce resistance," said protester Ron Gochez, 44. A first round of protests kicked off on Friday night after Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents conducted enforcement operations in the city and arrested at least 44 people on alleged immigration violations. The Department of Homeland Security said in a statement that there were about "1,000 rioters" at the protests on Friday. Reuters could not verify DHS's account. Angelica Salas, executive director of immigrants' rights organisation Chirla, said lawyers had not had access to those detained on Friday, which she called "very worrying". Trump has pledged to deport record numbers of people in the country illegally and lock down the US-Mexico border, with the White House setting a goal for ICE to arrest at least 3000 migrants per day. But the sweeping immigration crackdown has also caught up people legally residing in the country, including some with permanent residence, and has led to legal challenges. ICE, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Los Angeles Police Department did not respond to requests for comment on the protests or whether there had been any immigration raids on Saturday. President Donald Trump's administration says it will deploy 2000 National Guard troops as federal agents in Los Angeles face off against a few hundred demonstrators during a second day of protests following immigration raids. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth warned on Saturday the Pentagon was prepared to mobilise active-duty troops "if violence continues" in Los Angeles, saying the Marines at nearby Camp Pendleton were "on high alert". Federal security agents on Saturday confronted protesters in the Paramount area in southeast Los Angeles, where some demonstrators displayed Mexican flags. A second protest in downtown Los Angeles on Saturday night attracted some 60 people, who chanted slogans including "ICE out of L.A.!" Trump signed a presidential memorandum to deploy the National Guard troops to "address the lawlessness that has been allowed to fester"the White House said in a statement. Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, told Fox News the National Guard would be deployed in Los Angeles on Saturday. California Governor Gavin Newsom called the decision "purposefully inflammatory". He posted on X that Trump was deploying the National Guard "not because there is a shortage of law enforcement, but because they want a spectacle", adding: "Don't give them one. Never use violence. Speak out peacefully." Newsom said it was "deranged behavior" for Hegseth to be "threatening to deploy active-duty Marines on American soil against its own citizens." Trump posted on his Truth Social platform that if Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass can't do their jobs "then the Federal Government will step in and solve the problem, RIOTS & LOOTERS, the way it should be solved!!!" The protests pit Democratic-run Los Angeles, where a significant portion of the population is Hispanic and foreign-born, against Trump's Republican White House, which has made cracking down on immigration a hallmark of his second term. Senior White House aide Stephen Miller, an immigration hardliner, described the protests as a "violent insurrection." The 1807 law empowers a president to deploy the US military to enforce the law and suppress events such as civil disorder. The last time it was invoked was during the 1992 Los Angeles riots at the request of the California governor. Video footage of the Paramount protest showed dozens of green-uniformed security personnel with gas masks lined up on a road strewn with overturned shopping carts as small canisters exploded into gas clouds. Los Angeles police posted on X that "multiple people have been detained for failing to disperse after multiple warnings were issued." It did not give further details. There was no official information of any arrests. "Now they know that they cannot go to anywhere in this country where our people are, and try to kidnap our workers, our people - they cannot do that without an organised and fierce resistance," said protester Ron Gochez, 44. A first round of protests kicked off on Friday night after Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents conducted enforcement operations in the city and arrested at least 44 people on alleged immigration violations. The Department of Homeland Security said in a statement that there were about "1,000 rioters" at the protests on Friday. Reuters could not verify DHS's account. Angelica Salas, executive director of immigrants' rights organisation Chirla, said lawyers had not had access to those detained on Friday, which she called "very worrying". Trump has pledged to deport record numbers of people in the country illegally and lock down the US-Mexico border, with the White House setting a goal for ICE to arrest at least 3000 migrants per day. But the sweeping immigration crackdown has also caught up people legally residing in the country, including some with permanent residence, and has led to legal challenges. ICE, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Los Angeles Police Department did not respond to requests for comment on the protests or whether there had been any immigration raids on Saturday. President Donald Trump's administration says it will deploy 2000 National Guard troops as federal agents in Los Angeles face off against a few hundred demonstrators during a second day of protests following immigration raids. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth warned on Saturday the Pentagon was prepared to mobilise active-duty troops "if violence continues" in Los Angeles, saying the Marines at nearby Camp Pendleton were "on high alert". Federal security agents on Saturday confronted protesters in the Paramount area in southeast Los Angeles, where some demonstrators displayed Mexican flags. A second protest in downtown Los Angeles on Saturday night attracted some 60 people, who chanted slogans including "ICE out of L.A.!" Trump signed a presidential memorandum to deploy the National Guard troops to "address the lawlessness that has been allowed to fester"the White House said in a statement. Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, told Fox News the National Guard would be deployed in Los Angeles on Saturday. California Governor Gavin Newsom called the decision "purposefully inflammatory". He posted on X that Trump was deploying the National Guard "not because there is a shortage of law enforcement, but because they want a spectacle", adding: "Don't give them one. Never use violence. Speak out peacefully." Newsom said it was "deranged behavior" for Hegseth to be "threatening to deploy active-duty Marines on American soil against its own citizens." Trump posted on his Truth Social platform that if Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass can't do their jobs "then the Federal Government will step in and solve the problem, RIOTS & LOOTERS, the way it should be solved!!!" The protests pit Democratic-run Los Angeles, where a significant portion of the population is Hispanic and foreign-born, against Trump's Republican White House, which has made cracking down on immigration a hallmark of his second term. Senior White House aide Stephen Miller, an immigration hardliner, described the protests as a "violent insurrection." The 1807 law empowers a president to deploy the US military to enforce the law and suppress events such as civil disorder. The last time it was invoked was during the 1992 Los Angeles riots at the request of the California governor. Video footage of the Paramount protest showed dozens of green-uniformed security personnel with gas masks lined up on a road strewn with overturned shopping carts as small canisters exploded into gas clouds. Los Angeles police posted on X that "multiple people have been detained for failing to disperse after multiple warnings were issued." It did not give further details. There was no official information of any arrests. "Now they know that they cannot go to anywhere in this country where our people are, and try to kidnap our workers, our people - they cannot do that without an organised and fierce resistance," said protester Ron Gochez, 44. A first round of protests kicked off on Friday night after Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents conducted enforcement operations in the city and arrested at least 44 people on alleged immigration violations. The Department of Homeland Security said in a statement that there were about "1,000 rioters" at the protests on Friday. Reuters could not verify DHS's account. Angelica Salas, executive director of immigrants' rights organisation Chirla, said lawyers had not had access to those detained on Friday, which she called "very worrying". Trump has pledged to deport record numbers of people in the country illegally and lock down the US-Mexico border, with the White House setting a goal for ICE to arrest at least 3000 migrants per day. But the sweeping immigration crackdown has also caught up people legally residing in the country, including some with permanent residence, and has led to legal challenges. ICE, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Los Angeles Police Department did not respond to requests for comment on the protests or whether there had been any immigration raids on Saturday. President Donald Trump's administration says it will deploy 2000 National Guard troops as federal agents in Los Angeles face off against a few hundred demonstrators during a second day of protests following immigration raids. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth warned on Saturday the Pentagon was prepared to mobilise active-duty troops "if violence continues" in Los Angeles, saying the Marines at nearby Camp Pendleton were "on high alert". Federal security agents on Saturday confronted protesters in the Paramount area in southeast Los Angeles, where some demonstrators displayed Mexican flags. A second protest in downtown Los Angeles on Saturday night attracted some 60 people, who chanted slogans including "ICE out of L.A.!" Trump signed a presidential memorandum to deploy the National Guard troops to "address the lawlessness that has been allowed to fester"the White House said in a statement. Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, told Fox News the National Guard would be deployed in Los Angeles on Saturday. California Governor Gavin Newsom called the decision "purposefully inflammatory". He posted on X that Trump was deploying the National Guard "not because there is a shortage of law enforcement, but because they want a spectacle", adding: "Don't give them one. Never use violence. Speak out peacefully." Newsom said it was "deranged behavior" for Hegseth to be "threatening to deploy active-duty Marines on American soil against its own citizens." Trump posted on his Truth Social platform that if Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass can't do their jobs "then the Federal Government will step in and solve the problem, RIOTS & LOOTERS, the way it should be solved!!!" The protests pit Democratic-run Los Angeles, where a significant portion of the population is Hispanic and foreign-born, against Trump's Republican White House, which has made cracking down on immigration a hallmark of his second term. Senior White House aide Stephen Miller, an immigration hardliner, described the protests as a "violent insurrection." The 1807 law empowers a president to deploy the US military to enforce the law and suppress events such as civil disorder. The last time it was invoked was during the 1992 Los Angeles riots at the request of the California governor. Video footage of the Paramount protest showed dozens of green-uniformed security personnel with gas masks lined up on a road strewn with overturned shopping carts as small canisters exploded into gas clouds. Los Angeles police posted on X that "multiple people have been detained for failing to disperse after multiple warnings were issued." It did not give further details. There was no official information of any arrests. "Now they know that they cannot go to anywhere in this country where our people are, and try to kidnap our workers, our people - they cannot do that without an organised and fierce resistance," said protester Ron Gochez, 44. A first round of protests kicked off on Friday night after Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents conducted enforcement operations in the city and arrested at least 44 people on alleged immigration violations. The Department of Homeland Security said in a statement that there were about "1,000 rioters" at the protests on Friday. Reuters could not verify DHS's account. Angelica Salas, executive director of immigrants' rights organisation Chirla, said lawyers had not had access to those detained on Friday, which she called "very worrying". Trump has pledged to deport record numbers of people in the country illegally and lock down the US-Mexico border, with the White House setting a goal for ICE to arrest at least 3000 migrants per day. But the sweeping immigration crackdown has also caught up people legally residing in the country, including some with permanent residence, and has led to legal challenges. ICE, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Los Angeles Police Department did not respond to requests for comment on the protests or whether there had been any immigration raids on Saturday.

Condemn Israel's leaders but not its people
Condemn Israel's leaders but not its people

The Age

time6 hours ago

  • The Age

Condemn Israel's leaders but not its people

Education reduces crime From the early 2000s, young refugees were resettled in Melbourne under conditions which would inevitably have repercussions, now turbo-charged by the underworld's intervention. In Sudanese culture, education is said to be 'my mother and my father'; that is, as beloved as family. On arrival, these humanitarian refugees were highly motivated to study, gain qualifications and contribute to Australia. However, they confronted often impossible conditions. By policy, unschooled refugee children were placed in classes by age, with little or no English or curricular preparation, requiring them to somehow 'pick up' literacy, maths, science and so on, starting in, say, year 8. The consequences included feelings of failure and school-avoidance. This was raised at conferences attended by politicians and senior bureaucrats. I had numerous letters published about it. Yet, nothing changed. Education is the bulwark against crime, and it should never have been thus compromised by the Victorian government. Further, particular media outlets ran negative campaigns, often emphasising the refugees' appearance. I was teaching parents distressed at their children being subsequently severely picked on in the streets and playgrounds. Having worked with refugees from the Vietnamese to the Africans, I observed the adversity faced by the latter to be unprecedented, unjustifiable and avoidable. Crime is never excusable but far better policies must ensure it never becomes the default pathway. Barbara Chapman, South Yarra Bad behaviour faulty fix While the new powers invested in school principals to be able to expel students for inappropriate behaviour outside of school sounds like a quick fix, I can only see it adding enormously to their already excessive workload. As a former principal, expulsions are never used lightly. It's the last shot in the locker and only used after every other option is explored. I can also see it backfiring on principals who, upon consideration, may decide not to expel a student who regrettably then may reoffend outside the school. The principal would have the finger of blame pointed at them (and not the offender) from some of the more hard-hearted people in the school community ″⁣who just wanted the student gone″⁣. It's a no-win situation. Better to work with the student than ″⁣cut them off at the knees″⁣ as they say. Nick Toovey, Beaumaris Not a defence strategy There is much discussion regarding Australia's poor defence preparation and recruiting. The elephant in the room of recruiting is that those of fighting age are discouraged by the shocking deployment of Australian personnel to America's wars, and the lack of support for returning soldiers. Why would they want to volunteer or enlist? John Marks, Werribee Selective outrage Oh, the outrage! (″⁣ Welcome to Tim Town ″⁣, 7/6) Tim Wilson is suddenly deeply concerned about people being filmed in public without permission. Strange, because I don't recall him stepping in when his own cheer squad, proudly wearing Liberal Party T-shirts and standing right next to him, kept snapping photos of me in my Team Zoe T-shirt around Goldstein. Not to mention my family and friends, just minding their business in everyday clothes. So filming him is a scandal, but photographing us is just good clean campaigning? Classic case of 'do as I say, not as I do'. Goldstein deserves better than selective outrage. Carolyn Brydon, Brighton East Ambitious seed Thank you for Stephen Brook's interview with Tim Wilson (7/6). One aspect that often fails to get mentioned with Tim is that he was a student politician and was elected twice as a university student council president. It's where that ambitious seed is planted for many future leaders and seeing his relentless pursuit of politics, I'm not surprised we might have our first openly gay prime minister. I wholeheartedly disagree with his politics but admire his tenacity to come back, and representation still matters in our parliament. Mel Smith, Brighton Musk got played Here's a thought: If I'm a people user and need someone, I'm nice to them. If I don't need them any more, I'm not as nice. If I really want to shake them off (that expectation of gratitude can be so annoying), I'm downright nasty. In a nice way, of course. Relationships to Avoid 101: A challenging subject but a bonanza for wily grifters. Musk was simply a mark who got played. We have to hand it to Trump. It takes a lot of skill and understanding of human nature to encourage someone to shoot themselves in the foot. Marina Dobbyn, Glen Waverley Think like Wes Anderson If you want to have a good laugh about what drives our global world today I recommend seeing The Phoenician Scheme, Wes Anderson's latest film. Driving to see the film listening to the latest squabbles between Trump and Musk on radio, and then seeing a magnificent physical fight, full of similar personal fury between two global financiers on screen, also came with the bonus of a beautiful end. It's great to see a film, having laughed nearly all the way through, even though slightly mystified to be left by a feel-good ending. Sara Ginsbourg, East Bentleigh Rain delays Despite the arrival of the weekend's rain, Victorian primary producers are still not out of the woods. Grain producers will be rejoicing at the arrival of the rain, but for livestock producers it doesn't rain grass. There'll be a critical three weeks in the slowest growing season of the year until anything of feed value appears from the ground. Keep up the great support for the rural families whose commitment feeds us daily, it's not quite over yet. Andy Worland, Ballarat AFL's roof logic The AFL has unfairly imposed onerous and politically divisive conditions for the long-overdue inclusion of a Tasmanian team. It has demanded a new 23,000-capacity roofed stadium at Macquarie Point costing a billion dollars, despite the existing 19,500-capacity Bellerive Oval being capable of expansion and upgrade at a fraction of that massive cost. Furthermore, as roughly half of Tasmania's population live in the north, they would be better served if a share of the Devils' home games were played at Launceston's York Park (the venue used for some Hawks games) which could also be upgraded relatively cheaply. Why is the AFL also insisting on the inclusion of a very expensive roof when no such condition is being imposed on Brisbane's proposed Gabba replacement? Inclement weather is unlikely to affect games in Hobart any more than in Brisbane, which recently had a game cancelled due to a cyclone. About 170 AFL games are being played this season at roofless venues, with only 36 at Marvel, the only existing roofed venue. Peter Cole, Clifton Hill Tasmanian bind Tasmania is in an incredible bind. Does it submit to the bullying of the AFL (a point that few are willing to acknowledge) or forgo a team when it should have been a contributing team a decade ago? The AFL is not an elected body. It should have never put the state in such a position, ever. Tasmanian football is rich in tradition, skills and culture. The only thing missing is a governing body that genuinely wants the Devils in. Stephen Maude, Boronia AND ANOTHER THING Federal politics If the Exclusive Brethren want to participate in community, then let's invite them to pay taxes. John Cain, McCrae I recall that Tim Wilson was a strident supporter of the libertarian aspect of freedom of speech. It seems he doesn't like his own medicine when he's confronted by a passionate local constituent when interviewed for ″⁣ Welcome to Tim Town ″⁣, 4/6. Sally Walcock, Toorak No James Massola (Opinion, 7/6), the Labor government doesn't need the coalition to pass the superannuation bill. Drop the 30 per cent rate to $2.5 million and the Greens will get it over the line in the Senate. Job done. Ross Hosking, Blackwood, SA Israel Thank you to Josh Szeps (Opinion, 6/7) for your informed and balanced article on the history and painful complexities of the conflict between Israel and Palestine. April Baragwanath, Geelong From a fellow Aussie Jew; thank you Josh (son of wonderful character actor Henri). You speak for me with great eloquence and logic. Maurie Johns, Mt Eliza USA Donald Trump. There could be no greater definition of 'man child'. Frank Flynn, Cape Paterson I used to think movie villains such as Dr No, Goldfinger, Blofeld and Dr Evil were absurd Hollywood fantasy characters. Observing Elon's behaviour recently, I'm not so sure. Don Phillips, Fitzroy It could be worse. Your celebrity couple name could be Mump. Christian Barrington, St Kilda The joyous photo of two toddlers on the front page of Saturday's Age made my heart sing. Now let's hope the rain falls on those who need it most. Marea O'Brien, Deepdene

Xi plots next move in trade war with chips, tariffs at stake
Xi plots next move in trade war with chips, tariffs at stake

Sydney Morning Herald

time8 hours ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

Xi plots next move in trade war with chips, tariffs at stake

'We're in very good shape with China and the trade deal,' Trump told reporters on Thursday after the 90-minute conversation. 'I would say we have a deal, and we're going to just make sure that everybody understands what the deal is,' he added. Loading The big immediate problem for the US was a lack of rare earth magnets essential for American electric vehicles and defence systems. After the Geneva meeting, the US side believed it had secured the flow of these materials, only to be disappointed when China kept its export licensing system in place, saying that exporters to the US still needed to apply just like everyone else. China, in turn, felt betrayed by a fresh wave of US restrictions on AI chips from Huawei Technologies, software for designing chips, plane engines and visas for upwards of 280,000 Chinese students. 'Both sides felt that the agreement in Geneva was being violated,' said Gerard DiPippo, associate director at the RAND China Research Centre. From the White House's perspective, he said, 'China committed to send the magnets.' Although Xi flexed his muscles with the rare earths restrictions, he also has reasons to come to the table. China's economy is expected to slow sharply in the second quarter and come under pressure into the second half of the year, according to Morgan Stanley economists led by Robin Xing. 'Now the China pendulum is swinging back from 'political principle' of standing firm against the US to 'pragmatism' in support of a still-fragile economy,' said Han Lin, China country director at The Asia Group. 'In other words, Beijing wants to de-escalate, and as long as there is a face-saving path for Xi to do so, now is better than never.' Xi can point to several things that indicate more is coming. The addition of Lutnick in upcoming trade talks, led in Geneva by Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and trade representative Jamieson Greer, signals Trump may be willing to consider reversing some of the technology curbs that threaten to hobble China's long-term growth ambitions. Xi's statement after the call also made clear he expects the US to 'remove the negative measures taken against China,' which could include warnings against the use of Huawei's Ascend chips and restriction on the sale of chip design software to China. The two leaders also exchanged invitations to visit each other's country, events that will build momentum toward stabilising the relationship with agreements on thorny issues spanning trade, export controls and people-to-people exchanges. Trump said their wives would also come along, adding to the positive optics. It's significant that Trump agreed to visit China first, according to Bert Hofman, professor at the East Asian Institute at the National University Singapore and former World Bank country director for China. 'Xi probably realised that a call would be in the Chinese interest given the eagerness of Mr Trump to have one,' he said. 'This will accelerate talks and hopefully extend the truce beyond August,' he added, as the tariff reductions agreed in Geneva will expire in early September. But some analysts advised against being overly optimistic, pointing out the lack of details on key trade matters. 'There doesn't seem to be a deeper agreement that would prevent either side from taking additional negative actions, even as talks proceed,' said Kurt Tong, a former US consul general in Hong Kong and a partner at The Asia Group. Loading That fragility is compounded by Trump's transactional approach to foreign policy and ties with China in particular. In January 2020, when Trump signed a Phase One trade deal with Beijing, he said the relationship between the countries was 'the best it's ever been' before it quickly unravelled following the spread of COVID-19 around the globe. 'It would be unwise to bet that Trump has a vision for further negotiations that he won't abandon suddenly later on,' said Graham Webster, who leads the DigiChina project at Stanford University. Another area where Xi could see an early win is on the issue of fentanyl. Any deal to co-operate in blocking the flow of the drug to the US could immediately bring down American tariffs on Chinese imports by 20 percentage points. While the call helped to stem the negative trajectory of the relationship, the next two weeks will be crucial to confirm whether the truce will last, according to Wu Xinbo, a professor at Fudan University in Shanghai. He said China expects to see more progress on tariffs and US tech curbs. 'The call in itself is not a reward,' Wu said. 'What's important is what will come out of the call.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store