Health board not clear on design for hospital ventilation system, inquiry finds
One of Scotland's biggest health boards was not clear enough on the design of the ventilation system which delayed the opening of a children's hospital, an inquiry has found.
The Royal Hospital for Children and Young People (RHCYP) and Department of Clinical Neurosciences in Edinburgh were due to open in July 2019 but a delay was announced just hours before.
Eventually opening in March 2021 with the delay believed to have cost almost £17 million, the hospital became a subject of the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry – alongside parts of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital campus in Glasgow.
Lord Brodie, chairman of the inquiry, published 11 recommendations on Monday as part of his interim report, where he criticised NHS Lothian's handling of the design of the RHCYP and accused it of leaving patients and families 'in the dark' on the delay.
Ahead of the opening of the site, issues with the pressure differentials and air change rates – which can help to protect from airborne diseases – in the ventilation of the paediatric critical care department were found, the inquiry reported.
Lord Brodie said: 'On the basis of the evidence that I have heard, I have concluded that in a project for the construction or refurbishment of a healthcare facility, it is the health board, as the prospective provider of that healthcare, in consultation with relevant stakeholders and clinical and technical advisers, that is best-placed to identify what it requires from the ventilation system.
'This includes the precise output parameters that the ventilation system must meet.
'Accordingly, determining the output parameters of a ventilation system should not be left to the judgment of the project company and its subcontractors during the design phase.
'The design should address how previously determined parameters are to be achieved, not what should be achieved.
'In relation to this project, it is my conclusion that NHS Lothian did not present its requirements for the output specifications of the ventilation system with sufficient clarity and precision.'
Instead, the board relied on the contractor's interpretation of NHS guidance for ventilation systems, the inquiry found, and provided a document described as an 'environmental matrix' which set specifications for the ventilation system.
The matrix contained an 'undetected error' in relation to critical care rooms, the inquiry said.
As well as the design of the buildings, the inquiry also criticised NHS Lothian's handling of communications with patients and their families around the delay.
'The decision not to open the hospital as planned had a significant impact on patients and their families, who were shocked, scared and deeply disappointed that long-promised new facilities were not to be available for the treatment, in some cases, of children suffering from very serious conditions,' Lord Brodie said.
'Patients and their families were left in the dark as to the reasons why the hospital did not open as planned.
'Communication with patients and families was unsatisfactory in this regard. I have seen this to have been important.
'There is a group of young patients who are very seriously ill and spend a significant portion of their time, sometimes much of their lives, in hospital.
'They are supported by family members or guardians. The hospital becomes, for them, their second home.
'The impact of unclear or poor communication on the wellbeing of patients and their families during what may already be a very difficult, emotional and uncertain period in their lives is significant.'
The final report of the inquiry is expected next year.
NHS Lothian has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
29-04-2025
- Yahoo
Four guilty over £6m NHS contracts corruption
Four men have been convicted after a £6m corruption and bribery probe involving health boards across Scotland. Contracts awarded to Oricom Ltd, founded by Adam Sharoudi and Gavin Brown, for telecoms and video conferencing equipment between 2010 and 2017 breached rules on financial wrongdoing during the tendering process. An investigation found the company was given "commercially sensitive information" by former NHS employees Alan Hush and Gavin Cox, who received a combined £88,000 in cash and gifts in return. They were found guilty of a string of charges including bribery, corruption, fraud, theft as well as others under the Proceeds of Crime Act at the High Court in Glasgow. The court heard Sahroudi, 41, and Brown, 48, did "acquire, use and possess" a total of £5,719,244 of "criminal property" paid by NHS Lothian, NHS Grampian, NHS Lanarkshire, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde as well as NHS Ayrshire and Arran. One single contract was worth £3.1m, the trial was told. Five men face £6.5m NHS Scotland bribery trial Brown founded Oricom in Irvine in 2008 with colleague David Bailey, who had charges against him dropped earlier in the trial. Sharoudi joined as a director and later became friends with Hush, 68, who was telecommunications manager at NHS Lothian and then NHS Scotland video conferencing manager. Hush said he first became aware of Oricom in about 2010. Brown told jurors he believed they "could provide a better service" than some of the well-known companies, leading to Oricom getting a number of big health board contracts. However, in 2015, its offices were raided – including by investigators from NHS Scotland Counter Fraud Services – following concerns into how the deals were secured. It resulted in the Oricom directors as well as Hush and Cox being arrested and charged. Hush, of Leith, Edinburgh, was said to have "failed to instigate a proper tendering process" for work Oricom secured. He also "ferreted about" in a "deception" to obtain false "dodgy" quotes to help the firm get the lucrative business. He was described as "the big cheese" in the NHS telecoms department. Investigators found a text exchange between Sharoudi and Hush in which Hush said that he wanted to "get some commission". He claimed during the trial that had been a "joke" and any money received had been money from his now late father – who "kept a box of £20 notes in his wardrobe". However, it was claimed Hush had used the firm as the "Bank of Oricom" for his help in getting them business including a £750,000 contract with NHS Lothian. He was handed Eurostar train tickets, stays at the Troy and Re Hotels in London, a laptop, an iPad, meals, and concert tickets to see Paul Simon, Rufus Wainwright and Patti Smith for his part in helping Oricom secure the contracts. Sharoudi, of Motherwell, Lanarkshire, told his KC Brian McConnachie that Hush repaid for anything Oricom had purchased for him. Cox, of Cathcart, Glasgow was head of IT and infrastructure at NHS Lanarkshire. He denied being "bribed" by Oricom and that any contract with NHS Lanarkshire was won "fair and square". He was accused of giving Oricom the "heads up" with information to give them a "commercial advantage" to secure business. It was suggested it was "not a level playing field" for other bidders. Brown had been a guest at Cox's surprise 50th birthday party. His "rewards" had been said to include hospitality at the Scottish Grand National at Ayr, a night at the Loch Green Hotel in Troon and a meal at Elliots in Prestwick. Jurors heard he also got thousands of pounds worth of Barrhead Travel holiday vouchers which allowed him to go on trips to New York and Lanzarote. Cox said he believed they were gifts to his wife – a newspaper advertising manager – from Brown's partner who she had become friends with. Prosecutors stated this was "a remarkable coincidence". Cox also denied ever getting a series of cash handouts from Oricom. He also used some of the money he was given to pay for an "extension and landscaping" at a property in Newton Mearns, East Renfrewshire, which he claimed had been paid for from an inheritance from his father. In total, Hush was given £18,231 of cash bungs and gifts, while Cox was handed more than £70,000. Brown also knew another NHS Lanarkshire telecoms official who has since died. Among the charges was one that Oricom in effect bribed him to secure work including a near £700,000 deal. Prosecutors further said smaller "inducements" were given to an IT official who worked at both NHS Lanarkshire and Greater Glasgow and Clyde health boards as well as a woman with NHS Ayrshire and Arran. Hush was found guilty of nine charges, Cox two, Sharoudi seven and Brown a total of six. The jury spent eight days in deliberation after a three month trial. Lawyers for all four had asked for them to remain on bail, however Lord Arthurson remanded them in custody. He described corruption as a "cancer in public life". He added: "The jury has determined that you collectively engaged, to varying degrees, in a deeply cynical, highly corrupt, coldly calculated and criminal betrayal of the welfare state and, ultimately, the taxpayer. "You should expect nothing less than the imposition of significant custodial sentences." Sentencing is due to take place on 5 June in Edinburgh. They also face separate hearings under the Proceeds of Crime Act.
Yahoo
13-03-2025
- Yahoo
Inquiry findings show we were right to delay opening of hospital, says Gray
The findings of an inquiry show it was the right decision not to open an Edinburgh children's hospital, Scottish Health Secretary Neil Gray has said. The Scottish Hospitals Inquiry released its interim findings earlier this month, with chairman Lord Brodie saying NHS Lothian was not clear enough on the design of the Royal Hospital for Children and Young People and Department of Clinical Neurosciences in the capital. The opening of the facility was halted just hours before it was due to begin receiving patients at the behest of then health secretary Jeane Freeman due to concerns about the ventilation system in the paediatric critical care department. Ms Freeman later launched the inquiry, which has also looked at issues with the building of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital campus in Glasgow after a number of deaths of patients linked to infections. Speaking in Holyrood on Thursday, Mr Gray said Lord Brodie's report showed Ms Freeman made the right decision. 'The interim report confirms that the decision taken by the then cabinet secretary to postpone the opening of the hospital was the right decision,' he said. 'This decision understood the risks associated with the introduction of patients into a facility that had not met the required safety standards. 'Only through this direct intervention by the then cabinet secretary were we able to act and deliver the necessary changes to the built environment.' The opening of the hospital was delayed by almost two years until March 2021, at a reported cost of almost £17 million. The hospital, Mr Gray said, is now providing 'safe, effective, person-centred care, and has been since the facilities opened in March 2021'. But Scottish Labour deputy leader Dame Jackie Baillie – who is also her party's health spokeswoman – questioned why a similar delay did not take place at the Glasgow hospital. 'In the case of the Edinburgh Sick Kids, unfortunate though the delay was and the uncertainty for families, thankfully, no child lost their life,' she said. 'I believe Jeane Freeman was right to put patient safety first. 'In contrast, the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital, Nicola Sturgeon's flagship, was rushed through when it clearly was not safe and children died as a consequence.' Dame Jackie asked the Health Secretary what lessons had been learned as a result of the issues encountered at the facilities. 'I would caution Jackie Baillie around arriving at conclusions around the Glasgow side of the inquiry – the inquiry is still ongoing,' the Health Secretary said. 'There is much evidence still to be led in that inquiry and I would not, I certainly cannot, prejudge or seem to cut across in any way, the work of a public inquiry.' On lessons that have been learned, the Health Secretary pointed to NHS Assure, an agency set up to assess risk in the NHS estate, which he said was 'about making sure that every single stage of the commissioning of a health infrastructure programme that we have assurance as to the safety and to the practicality of a health project'. He added: 'I believe that is giving us much greater assurance as to the safety that Jackie Baillie is looking for.'
Yahoo
03-03-2025
- Yahoo
Health board not clear on design for hospital ventilation system, inquiry finds
One of Scotland's biggest health boards was not clear enough on the design of the ventilation system which delayed the opening of a children's hospital, an inquiry has found. The Royal Hospital for Children and Young People (RHCYP) and Department of Clinical Neurosciences in Edinburgh were due to open in July 2019 but a delay was announced just hours before. Eventually opening in March 2021 with the delay believed to have cost almost £17 million, the hospital became a subject of the Scottish Hospitals Inquiry – alongside parts of the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital campus in Glasgow. Lord Brodie, chairman of the inquiry, published 11 recommendations on Monday as part of his interim report, where he criticised NHS Lothian's handling of the design of the RHCYP and accused it of leaving patients and families 'in the dark' on the delay. Ahead of the opening of the site, issues with the pressure differentials and air change rates – which can help to protect from airborne diseases – in the ventilation of the paediatric critical care department were found, the inquiry reported. Lord Brodie said: 'On the basis of the evidence that I have heard, I have concluded that in a project for the construction or refurbishment of a healthcare facility, it is the health board, as the prospective provider of that healthcare, in consultation with relevant stakeholders and clinical and technical advisers, that is best-placed to identify what it requires from the ventilation system. 'This includes the precise output parameters that the ventilation system must meet. 'Accordingly, determining the output parameters of a ventilation system should not be left to the judgment of the project company and its subcontractors during the design phase. 'The design should address how previously determined parameters are to be achieved, not what should be achieved. 'In relation to this project, it is my conclusion that NHS Lothian did not present its requirements for the output specifications of the ventilation system with sufficient clarity and precision.' Instead, the board relied on the contractor's interpretation of NHS guidance for ventilation systems, the inquiry found, and provided a document described as an 'environmental matrix' which set specifications for the ventilation system. The matrix contained an 'undetected error' in relation to critical care rooms, the inquiry said. As well as the design of the buildings, the inquiry also criticised NHS Lothian's handling of communications with patients and their families around the delay. 'The decision not to open the hospital as planned had a significant impact on patients and their families, who were shocked, scared and deeply disappointed that long-promised new facilities were not to be available for the treatment, in some cases, of children suffering from very serious conditions,' Lord Brodie said. 'Patients and their families were left in the dark as to the reasons why the hospital did not open as planned. 'Communication with patients and families was unsatisfactory in this regard. I have seen this to have been important. 'There is a group of young patients who are very seriously ill and spend a significant portion of their time, sometimes much of their lives, in hospital. 'They are supported by family members or guardians. The hospital becomes, for them, their second home. 'The impact of unclear or poor communication on the wellbeing of patients and their families during what may already be a very difficult, emotional and uncertain period in their lives is significant.' The final report of the inquiry is expected next year. NHS Lothian has been contacted for comment.
