Primer: Can dissenters aid shareholder democracy?
How do no-votes get bypassed?
According to IiAS's review, most shareholder resolutions of Nifty 500 companies pass because the promoters hold the majority 51% of shares. Their holdings are significant. Public shareholders, including institutional investors, big money managers like mutual funds, insurance firms, pension funds and foreign portfolio investors, make up about 27% of ownership. Then, there are 'others' —a mix of retail investors, HNIs, family offices and private equity players. These groups do not have a majority and have lower voter participation. So even when many of them vote against a proposal, they can be ignored.
Do investors show a voting pattern?
In 2024, institutional investors held over a quarter of shares in Nifty 500 companies and voted on nearly 80% of the proposals. Of 4,840 resolutions put before shareholders during the year, only 24 were rejected, meaning 99.5% were approved, underlining promoter dominance. Resolutions on pay packets were opposed. Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone Ltd saw 46.91% institutions vote against a compensation proposal, yet it passed. Similarly, 45.26% opposed a resolution at Persistent Systems Ltd but it passed. Employee Stock Option Plans faced the most dissent from institutional investors.
What does the report say on types of resolutions?
Those on owner-manager remuneration are classified as 'ordinary' and need a simple majority. Since promoters vote on these, they always get approved. The report suggests reclassifying these to 'majority-of-minority', requiring more votes and stopping promoters from voting on their compensation. This could result in greater accountability and fairness.
Do retail and small investors have a say?
They have very little say in company decisions. In calendar year 2024, retail investors owned 22% of the shares in Nifty 500 companies, but only 19% of them exercised their voting rights. Even when they did vote, fewer than 1% voted against. In contrast, promoters who owned more than 51% of the shares voted on the majority of their holdings, giving them higher influence. Because of this imbalance, even if small investors disagree with a decision, it rarely changes the outcome. Their voices often go unheard.
How can the dissent mechanism improve?
IiAS proposes a dissent review mechanism, where more than 10% of votes against a resolution would trigger a formal response from the company. After engaging with dissenting shareholders, the board would disclose any action taken, such as amendments made to the resolution. This is inspired by the Indian Constitution, which allows the President to return a bill to Parliament for reconsideration. Translated for resolutions with more than 10% dissent it means fewer than one in ten resolutions will need to be revisited.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
7 minutes ago
- Mint
Muthoot Finance share price jumps 10% after posting strong Q1 results. Do you own?
Muthoot Finance share price rallied over 10 per cent upper circuit to ₹ 2,776 apiece in early morning session on Thursday after the company posted strong financial results for the quarter ending on June 30, 2025, beating market estimates. Muthoot Finance shares have largely remained positive in both short-term and long-term. The NBFC stock delivered significant returns by surging over 23 per cent in six months and 53 per cent in one year. The NBFC stock has given multibagger returns to its long-term investors by surging over 128.40 per cent in five years. The company announced its Q1FY26 results, reporting a 65 per cent year-on-year (YoY) surge in profit after tax (PAT) to ₹ 1,974 crore, compared to ₹ 1,196 crore in the same quarter last year. On a sequential basis, PAT rose 37 per cent from ₹ 1,444 crore in Q4FY25. Muthoot Finance achieved its highest-ever consolidated loan assets under management (AUM) of ₹ 1,33,938 crore as of June 30, 2025, reflecting a 37 per cent YoY increase of ₹ 35,891 crore over the ₹ 98,048 crore recorded in the corresponding period last year. Quarter-on-quarter, consolidated loan AUM grew by 10 per cent, adding ₹ 11,757 crore. On a standalone basis, loan AUM reached ₹ 1,20,031 crore, up 42 per cent YoY, or ₹ 35,707 crore, while standalone PAT hit a record ₹ 2,046 crore, marking a 90 per cent jump from the previous year. 'As the Indian economy advances, demand for quick, reliable, and affordable credit is rising – and gold loans remain a critical enabler in this space. We are also accelerating our digital transformation journey to ensure faster, more seamless credit access for millions of customers across the country. Strategic investments in technology and innovation are enhancing operational efficiency and customer experience. With this momentum, we are confident of sustaining strong growth in the quarters ahead,' said George Jacob Muthoot, Chairman of Muthoot Finance, while commenting on the company's Q1 performance. Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, not Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Economic Times
3 hours ago
- Economic Times
Brokerages get a Q1 bounce, but the YoY gap's still wide
Broking firms witnessed a profit rebound in the June quarter, recovering from a weak January-March. Motilal Oswal Financial Services reported significant profit. IIFL Capital Services and 5Paisa Capital also saw gains. Angel One's profits declined. Market regulator SEBI's regulations impacted broker revenues. BSE's profits surged, gaining market share. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Exchanges Road Ahead Most listed broking firms posted a rebound in profits and revenues in the June quarter from January-March, boosted by improved trading activity in the wake of the stock market recovery. But their earnings performances still paled in comparison to last year as volumes, especially derivatives, remained below their peak levels in the June quarter, Motilal Oswal Financial Services ' standalone profit after tax stood at ₹532 crore in the first quarter, against a loss of ₹8 crore in January-March. The standalone profits of IIFL Capital Services and 5Paisa Capital went up by 140% and 15% respectively, from the March One's standalone net profits declined 26% to ₹134 crore in the June quarter. The benchmark Nifty 50 advanced 8.5% in the April-June period, compared to January-March, when it declined 0.6%."Brokerage firms' earnings remained muted in the first quarter, weighed down by a nearly 15% year-on-year drop in cash market volumes and a 25-30% decline in derivatives premiums," said Suresh Shukla, chief business officer at SBI Securities. "Firms more reliant on derivatives income, like discount brokers, faced steeper revenue pressure than those with higher cash market exposure."Since 2024, revenues and profits of brokers have remained under pressure due to some of the steps taken by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), like allowing only one weekly index expiry per exchange, as well as uniform fee and 'true-to-label' norms introduced last July, which ended volume-based discounts and required brokers to pass on full exchange charges to MIIs ( market infrastructure institutions ), hurting their of the broking companies have declined between 1% and 37% this year, whereas the Nifty 50 is up 3.7% and Nifty 500 has gained 1%.Analysts are in no hurry to recommend broking shares to clients despite the recent declines."Although valuations of listed broking firms have moderated amid a decline in share prices, we remain cautious on the sector," said Apurva Sheth, head of research at Samco Securities. Sheth said the performance of broking firms will continue to track overall market the exchanges, profits of both BSE and NSE advanced from the March quarter. While NSE's profits went up 14% from the previous year, BSE gained 103%. "BSE has shown stronger performance on the back of gaining market share from its peer," said Shukla. The stock is up 40% this year. Sheth said BSE appears fairly valued following strong Q1 results and sees limited upside from current second-quarter activity still subdued, a meaningful recovery in broker incomes will depend on indices regaining momentum in the second half of the year, said also said while benchmarks are expected to remain stable due to steady SIP inflows, they are unlikely to surpass previous lifetime highs in the near term.
Mint
3 hours ago
- Mint
Five cash-rich large-cap stocks to watch
In a market obsessed with growth, cash often gets overlooked. But it's often what separates the strong from the weak. At last count, over two dozen Nifty 500 companies had more cash on their books than debt, with some sitting on liquidity buffers upwards of ₹20,000 crore. That's not just idle capital. For the right companies, it gives them an opportunity to invest, to innovate, to stay relevant without chasing debt-fuelled growth. FY25 threw plenty of curveballs, such as rising input costs, uneven demand recovery, and geopolitics. Yet, a few large-cap companies not only held their ground but also came out stronger, with cleaner books and tighter execution. In this editorial, we highlight five such cash-rich stocks. Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd HAL is India's largest defence aerospace manufacturer. It is among the few companies globally with end-to-end capabilities in the design, development, manufacturing, repair, and overhaul of aircraft, helicopters, and engines. HAL's order book has nearly doubled in just a year. From ₹94,100 crore at the start of FY25, it has ballooned to ₹1,89,300 crore by year-end, despite booking revenues of over ₹30,100 crore in the year. Manufacturing contracts totalled ₹1,02,300 crore and include big orders like the 240 AL-31FP engines worth ₹25,500 crore, 156 LCH Prachand helicopters worth ₹62,700 crore, and 12 new Sukhoi-30 aircraft. It also bagged ₹19,200 crore in repair and overhaul contracts and ₹493 crore in export orders. HAL has over ₹38,000 crore plus in cash and investments on its books, giving it immense financial strength to self-fund R&D and capex. A large portion of its capex, ₹14,000-15,000 crore over five years, will go towards expanding capacity for new engine programs (GE-414, IMRH), setting up overhaul and testing facilities and backward integration into forgings and carbon fibre. FY25 revenue rose 2% year-on-year. Ebitda (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) margin remained strong at 31%. Operating leverage is expected to improve as more of the order book starts translating into revenues. HAL expects LCA Mark-1A deliveries to hit full stride in FY26, with support from a newly commissioned third line in Nashik. Other platforms, including HTT-40 and LUH, are also scaling up production. Despite near-term growth capped at 8-10%, the visibility is high. Over the medium term, double-digit revenue growth is likely, supported by large-scale manufacturing orders and exports. Operating margins are expected to stay healthy at around 27-31%. Coal India Ltd Coal India is the world's largest coal miner and India's most critical energy backbone. It powers nearly 40% of the country's commercial energy needs. In FY25, coal production hit an all-time high of 781 million tonnes (mt), up 1% year-on-year, while offtake touched 763mt. Even with modest volume growth, Coal India managed to post strong financials as operating margin remained robust at 33%, aided by stable realizations and cost controls. But revenue growth was flat. The company's real strength is in its balance sheet. With zero long-term debt and ₹10,000 crore in net worth, the company has ample cash to fund growth and still reward shareholders. In FY25, Coal India paid out hefty dividends, translating to a massive dividend yield of over 5%. Looking ahead, the company aims to raise production to 1 billion tonnes by FY29 and 1.22 billion tonnes by FY35. Capex will go towards expanding mechanised coal evacuation, digitisation, washeries, and first-mile connectivity. Coal India is also placing strategic bets on diversification. This includes coal gasification projects (worth ₹2,480 crore) in partnership with BHEL and GAIL to convert coal into synthetic gas and chemicals. Thermal power demand continues to rise, and with India's per capita electricity consumption still among the lowest globally, Coal India has high visibility on growth. Siemens Ltd Siemens is one of India's largest industrial automation and electrification players. The company is involved in power transmission, digital industries, mobility, and smart infrastructure. So far, 2025 (the company follows a September year-end) has been a year of strategic shifts. The company completed the long-awaited demerger of its energy business in March, sharpening its focus on high-growth verticals such as electrification, automation, semiconductors, and railway mobility. Revenue rose 2.6% on-year to ₹4,260 crore in Q2 FY25, with smart infrastructure and digital industries offsetting some of the weakness in mobility and low-voltage motors. Order inflow jumped 43.5% on-year to ₹5,310 crore in the quarter, taking the total order book to a record ₹41,460 crore. Profitability was under pressure as Ebitda margin contracted sharply to 11%, hurt by normalising product mix, higher input costs, and some spillover of demerger expenses. Still, the business remains fundamentally sound, with a strong book-to-bill ratio of 1.25 and improving export contribution, now at 11.4% of revenues. The balance sheet continues to be rock solid. Siemens has no debt and sits on over ₹6,000 crore in cash and bank balance. Looking ahead, Siemens is poised to benefit from multi-year megatrends, digitisation of factories, EV infrastructure, clean energy investments, and railway modernization. Capex across sectors such as data centres, pharma, semiconductors, and utilities is creating fresh demand for automation, smart grids, and electrification. The company is also investing in new manufacturing capacity for vacuum interrupters and switchgear at Goa and Aurangabad. Despite near-term margin headwinds, the growth outlook remains strong. BSE Ltd BSE is Asia's oldest stock exchange and a fast-growing exchange in India, with strong traction across equities, mutual funds, derivatives and SME fundraising. Over the last year, it has reinvented itself with a fresh focus on derivative markets and monetizing digital infrastructure. FY25 was a strong year. Consolidated revenue surged 105% on-year to ₹3,200 crore, while net profit more than doubled to ₹1,300 crore. A large part of this was driven by sharp gains in transaction charges and a jump in mutual fund platform revenues. StAR MF handled over 600 million transactions, and single stock derivatives turnover crossed ₹4,760 crore. With rising volumes, profitability is scaling faster. Ebitda rose 63% to ₹1,800 crore with a margin of 58%. Derivatives contributed ₹550 crore to revenue in FY25, up nearly 7X from the year before. The company ended FY25 with over ₹5,100 crore in cash and investments on the books. Looking ahead, BSE sees continued traction in equity and derivatives trading. It plans to launch a new debt platform and a gold spot exchange. Investments in regulatory tech, cyber infra, and SME engagement are expected to sustain momentum. HCL Technologies Ltd HCL Technologies is one of India's leading IT services exporters. The company enjoys a growing global presence in engineering, cloud, and enterprise software. It has also been quick to embed AI across its service offerings and internal operations. In FY25, revenue rose 4.7% in constant currency to ₹1,15,360 crore, with services growing 4.8% and software up 3.5%. Ebit margin held steady at 18.3% despite a tough demand environment. New deal momentum stayed strong. The company booked $9.3 billion worth of net new contracts during the year, the second-highest in its history. Engineering and R&D services were a key driver, supported by wins in telecom, financials, media, and auto. GenAI deployments scaled up rapidly, with over 500 use cases across 400 clients, powered by HCL's AI Force, AI Foundry, and AI Labs platforms. HCLTech remains a highly cash-generative business. Free cash flow touched ₹20,650 crore, and the company ended the year with cash of ₹30,240 crore. For FY26, the management has guided for 2-5% revenue growth and Ebit margin between 18-19%. The company will focus on expanding the public sector vertical in the US, AI-led application services, and ramp-up of large cloud and digital engineering deals. Conclusion As investors chase the next big opportunity, cash-rich large-cap stocks offer resilience. These companies are not just sitting on idle capital. They are deploying it selectively into capacity, innovation, and shareholder returns. In a market that often swings between hope and hype, balance sheet strength can be a powerful differentiator. But cash is only part of the story. What matters more is how it's used to drive earnings visibility, weather cycles and fund future growth without overreach. For long-term investors, these businesses offer stability without losing sight of ambition. The key is to separate those merely hoarding liquidity from those turning it into a strategic advantage. Happy Investing. Disclaimer: This article is for information purposes only. It is not a stock recommendation and should not be treated as such. This article is syndicated from
