Idaho doctor and patients sue over new law halting public benefits to immigrants in US unlawfully
The ACLU of Idaho and the National Immigration Law Center filed the federal lawsuit Thursday night on behalf of Dr. Abby Davids and four people with HIV who are not named because they are immigrants without lawful permanent residency. They want a judge to bar the state from requiring immigration status verification from people who receive the federal HIV treatment benefits while the lawsuit moves forward in court.
The complaint says the new law is vague, contradicts federal law and makes it impossible for health care providers to determine exactly what kind of immigration status is excluded and how to verify that status for patients. They want a judge to grant them class-action status, expanding any ruling to other impacted people.
'We are still reviewing the lawsuit and will respond in court after we have had a chance to fully review the complaint and other documents filed,' Damon Sidur, the communications director for Idaho Attorney General Raul Labrador, said Friday in an email to The Associated Press. The lawsuit names Labrador as well as several officials in the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare.
Dozens of patients treated by one Boise-area clinic stand to lose access to HIV and AIDS medication under the law, according to the complaint, including several cared for by Davids.
'Withdrawing HIV treatment from her patients will not only have devastating consequences on their health, it raises the public health risk of increased HIV transmission,' the ACLU wrote in the lawsuit. 'When her patients are undetectable, they cannot transmit the virus. Without HIV treatment, however, they cannot maintain an undetectable viral level and therefore are able to transmit the virus to others.'
The new Idaho law takes effect July 1, and appears to be the first limiting public health benefits since President Donald Trump ordered federal agencies to enhance eligibility verification and ensure that public benefits aren't going to ineligible immigrants.
The law requires people to verify that they are legal U.S. residents to receive public benefits like communicable disease testing, vaccinations, prenatal and postnatal care for women, crisis counseling, some food assistance for children and even access to food banks or soup kitchens that rely on public funding.
Federal law generally prohibits immigrants in the U.S. illegally from receiving taxpayer-funded benefits like Medicare, Medicaid, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families and Social Security. But there are some exceptions for things like emergency medical care and other emergency or public health services.
Idaho's law still allows for emergency medical services. But in a June 18 letter to health care providers, Idaho Division of Public Health administrator Elke Shaw-Tulloch said HIV is a long-term condition and not an emergency — so people must verify their lawful presence in order to get benefits through the federal Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program.
The HIV patients challenging the new law include a married couple from Columbia with pending asylum applications, a man who was brought to the U.S. when he was just 4 years old and has Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals status until next year, and a man from Mexico who has been living and working in Idaho since 2020.
One of the patients said she and her husband were diagnosed with HIV in 2019 and immediately started antiretroviral therapy, receiving the medications at no cost through the Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program. The medication has lowered the viral load in her body enough that it is now undetectable, she wrote in a court filing, ensuring that she won't transmit the virus to others.
'My medication protected my daughter while I was pregnant because it prevented me from transmitting HIV to her during pregnancy,' she wrote.
The treatment allows her to be with her child, watching her grow, she said.
Davids has been trying for weeks to get clarity from the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare about exactly what kind of verification her patients will have to show, and exactly which kinds of immigration status are considered 'lawful.' But the state has yet to provide clear direction, according to the complaint.
'I am really scared about what this means for many of our patients. Their lives will now be in jeopardy,' Davids wrote in a May 30 email to the Department of Health and Welfare.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Journals
20 minutes ago
- Business Journals
The medicaid question
Pennsylvania hospitals are bracing for significant changes as Medicaid cuts loom on the horizon, with potential consequences for patient access and facility operations.
Boston Globe
an hour ago
- Boston Globe
Joseph Lovett, TV producer who shed an early light on AIDS, dies at 80
In May 1983, when Mr. Lovett produced the first long-form news segment on AIDS for the ABC News program '20/20,' the disease had received slim coverage since being identified by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in 1981. After witnessing friends dying of the disease, he resolved to cover it. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up In the resulting segment, a young Geraldo Rivera sounded the alarm about the crisis in interviews with public officials, patients, researchers, and activists, including Dr. Edward N. Brandt Jr., assistant secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services; Dr. Anthony Fauci, who at the time was an immunology researcher at the National Institutes of Health; and playwright and AIDS activist Larry Kramer. Advertisement The segment criticized the Reagan administration's slow response to the crisis and singled out The New York Times for an absence of AIDS-related articles on its front page. After it aired, letters of support poured in from AIDS patients, health officials, and fellow journalists across the country. Advertisement 'He dragged television audiences kicking and screaming into understanding the epidemic,' Rivera said in an interview. 'He was nonstop. Once he got wound up, he was determined.' As the epidemic became national news -- the Times ran its first front-page article about it within a week of the '20/20' investigation -- Mr. Lovett remained a steadfast chronicler in follow-up segments, including one about Rock Hudson's death from the disease in 1985 and another in which Barbara Walters held a toddler diagnosed with AIDS, to dispel public fears about skin contact. Mr. Lovett's reports were often crowdsourced from a vibrant network of activists and journalists he had cultivated in Lower Manhattan, where he lived. With his partner, Jim Cottrell, an anesthesiologist at SUNY Downstate Medical Center, he would host activists, journalists, and intellectuals at their home, on Fifth Avenue in Greenwich Village. After 10 years at the network, Mr. Lovett left ABC in 1989 and started his own independent production company. In the early 1990s, he created 'In a New Light,' a yearly series of star-studded specials aimed at demystifying the disease and raising prevention awareness. Airing from 1992 to 1996, it was hosted by celebrities including Elizabeth Taylor, Arsenio Hall, Paula Abdul, and Walters. Mr. Lovett drew heavily on personal tragedies in later films and documentaries. He staged a reenactment of his mother being crushed by a runaway car, an incident he witnessed as a 13-year-old, in the film 'The Accident' (1999). The death of his father and three siblings to cancer prompted him to produce and direct 'Cancer: Evolution to Revolution' (2000), a film about coping, treating, and learning to live with the disease; in one scene, he had a colonoscopy on camera. The documentary won a 2001 Peabody Award and was nominated for a Primetime Emmy in 2000. Advertisement Throughout his career, Mr. Lovett developed a frank approach to his productions. 'We don't talk about bodily fluids, we talk about sexual fluids,' he told Etcetera magazine, an LGBTQ+ digest based in Atlanta, before a new installment of 'In a New Light' in 1993. 'We don't deal in euphemisms.' 'Television is a fantastic opportunity for education,' he added. 'And education doesn't have to be dull.' Joseph Fromm Lovett was born in Providence on March 29, 1945. The youngest of five siblings, he moved in with his older sister, Trisha, after the death of his mother, Jeanne (Millman) Lovett, in 1958. His father, Samuel Lovett, a builder who worked on Cape Cod, had died of colon cancer in 1954, when Joseph was a child. He earned a bachelor's degree in English at Columbia University in 1967. That year, he enrolled in the film MFA program at the university, but, swept up by student protests, he dropped out in 1968. His first job after film school was casting actors for Amram Nowak Associates, a production company. He was hired as an editor for CBS in 1975 and later promoted to producer. His first long-form segment, 'Parents of Gays,' was aired in 1977 on 'Magazine,' a daytime program. Mr. Lovett met Cottrell in 1976. They married in Barnstable in 2004, on the first day that same-sex marriage was legal in Massachusetts. Mr. Lovett joined ABC as a producer in 1979. His '20/20' segments covering the AIDS crisis earned him a reputation as a crusading journalist, and he also became known as a gregarious mentor to young reporters. Advertisement He started his own production company, Lovett Stories & Strategies, in 1989. Among the projects he worked on was a one-hour ABC special on adoption, 'Born in My Heart' (2001), which he produced with Walters. He also produced and directed the documentaries 'Gay Sex in the 70s' (2005); 'Going Blind' (2010), which was prompted by his own glaucoma diagnosis; and 'Children of the Inquisition' (2019), which followed descendants of families who had fled the Spanish and Portuguese Inquisitions as they traced their roots. Cottrell is Mr. Lovett's only immediate survivor. One of his final projects, 'Something Terrible Happened to Joey' (2022), a short animated film about confronting childhood trauma narrated by Rosie Perez, follows a boy who experiences an unspecified 'terrible' thing and, as a result, has to navigate the world carrying a giant sack of coal. The boy lugs the coal around for years, but it begins to shrink only when he opens up to his friends about the terrible thing. When the sack finally disappears, he searches for it but instead finds a balloon. It lifts him above magnolia trees, above blossoming flower beds, above his waving friends, and into a white sky. This article originally appeared in
Newsweek
2 hours ago
- Newsweek
With Eyes on 2028, Democratic Governors Rip Page From Trump Playbook
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. Three of the Democratic Party's highest-profile governors—California's Gavin Newsom, Illinois' JB Pritzker and Minnesota's Tim Walz—are taking a page from President Donald Trump's playbook by rolling back public health care for undocumented immigrants. All three governors have greenlit proposals to freeze, cap or eliminate health benefits for noncitizens without legal status, citing budget shortfalls. The policy reversals, which will impact tens of thousands of people in some of the country's most immigrant-heavy states, come as each leader is widely viewed as a potential contender for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2028. In Illinois, a program that provided publicly funded health coverage to over 30,000 undocumented adults ended July 1. Governor JB Pritzker included the cut in his latest state budget, telling it was a "difficult decision" forced by national economic headwinds. "This year, passing a balanced budget required the difficult decision that reflects the reality of Trump and Republicans tanking our national economy and attempting to strip away healthcare," Pritzker's office told Newsweek, referencing prior comments made by the governor. Illinois Governor JB Pritzker, California Governor Gavin Newsom, and Minnesota Governor Tim Walz have each backed cuts to health care programs for undocumented immigrants, drawing criticism from progressive groups and immigrant advocates. Illinois Governor JB Pritzker, California Governor Gavin Newsom, and Minnesota Governor Tim Walz have each backed cuts to health care programs for undocumented immigrants, drawing criticism from progressive groups and immigrant advocates. Getty Images Eliminating the program for middle-aged adults is projected to save the general revenue fund about $330 million, according to the governor's office. Minnesota followed shortly after. A bipartisan bill passed by the legislature and signed by Governor Tim Walz removed undocumented adults from MinnesotaCare, the state-run insurance program for low-income residents. "No one got everything they wanted," Walz said after the compromise was finalized in a special session. "There were very difficult conversations... but at the end of the day, we were able to come to this agreement". California Governor Gavin Newsom, who has frequently spoken about health equity, unveiled a plan in May to cap new enrollment for undocumented adults in Medi-Cal, the state's Medicaid program. While those currently enrolled will not lose coverage, they will face new costs—including a $100 monthly premium starting in 2027—and cuts to dental services. "We are not cutting or rolling back those that are already enrolled in our Medi-Cal system, we're just capping it," Newsom said on July. "No state has done more than the state of California... That's a point of pride". More than 120 organizations signed an open letter condemning Newsom's Medi-Cal cuts, calling them more harmful than the health care changes included in Trump's "big, beautiful" tax and spending bill. 'Not Just Tone' Newsom, Pritzker, and Walz are widely seen as potential candidates for the 2028 Democratic presidential nomination. A Morning Consult poll from April showed Newsom with 11 percent support among Democratic primary voters, tied with Pete Buttigieg and behind only Kamala Harris. An Echelon Insights poll also showed Newsom at 6 percent, Pritzker at 2 percent, and Walz around 3 percent. All three have increased their national visibility, with Newsom and Pritzker making appearances in early primary states. But critics say the three Democrats are courting political optics at the expense of vulnerable residents. President Donald Trump arrives to speak at Fort Bragg, Tuesday, June 10, 2025, in Fort Bragg, N.C. President Donald Trump arrives to speak at Fort Bragg, Tuesday, June 10, 2025, in Fort Bragg, N.C. Associated Press "These governors may be known for their sharp anti-Trump rhetoric, but their recent policy choices echo the very worst aspects of his administration: using immigrants—particularly those without the right to vote—as economic scapegoats," wrote Jim Mangia, president of St. John's Community Health, in a column for The Hill. Public health experts have long argued that covering undocumented residents reduces costs by avoiding more expensive emergency room visits and stabilizing community health care systems. Mangia cited a University of Chicago study showing state-run immigrant coverage had created cost savings for Illinois hospitals. Immigrant rights organizations have condemned the changes. "Terminating state coverage for immigrants will compromise our collective health, as well as the health care infrastructure that serves all of us," Tanya Broder, senior counsel at the National Immigration Law Center, told NBC News. Progressive groups have warned the cuts risk alienating the Democratic base. "This assumption that by moving more to the middle or to the right that you're going to recruit some people back—I think it's a miscalculation," Jennifer Driver of State Innovation Exchange told NBC. "The frustration that you're seeing in the Democratic base is due to this kind of waffling". Meanwhile, Republicans have seized on the reversals. In Colorado, GOP members of Congress have called on Democratic Governor Jared Polis to roll back health care programs for undocumented residents, citing the actions in California, Minnesota and Illinois. "Every dollar that Colorado hands out for free health care for illegal immigrants is money that can't be spent on seniors and rural hospitals," a spokesperson for Republican Rep. Gabe Evans told Newsweek. For now, Newsom, Pritzker and Walz say they are juggling competing priorities while trying to balance their budgets. But immigrant advocates warn the damage could be lasting—both for vulnerable residents and for Democrats trying to distinguish themselves from Trump on policy, not just tone. "These cuts are not just cruel—they are economically shortsighted," Mangia wrote. "We need leaders who will fight to expand care—not slash it".
