US blunts Pakistan's Gaza probe proposal
Two months after President Donald Trump announced a halt to US engagement with the United Nations Human Rights Council, Washington is influencing its work by applying pressure publicly and behind the scenes, seven diplomats and rights workers said.
The United States left its seat empty during a six-week session of the 47-member council ending on Friday, but its lobbying and pressure had some success, the sources told Reuters.
They said the US, which has accused the council of an anti-Israel bias, had focused on blunting a proposal by Pakistan on the creation of an International, Impartial and Independent Mechanism (IIIM), the most rigorous type of UN investigation, on Israel's actions in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
The version of Pakistan's proposal that was passed on Wednesday by the council, whose mission is to promote and protect human rights worldwide, did not include the creation of the IIIM. The council already has a commission of inquiry on the Palestinian Territories, but Pakistan's proposal would have created an additional probe with extra powers to gather evidence for possible use in international courts.
A March 31 letter sent by Brian Mast, Chairman of the US House Foreign Affairs Committee, and James R Risch, Chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, cautioned against voting the proposal through. "Any HRC member state or UN entity that supports an Israel-specific IIM ... will face the same consequences as the ICC faced," the letter said.
It appeared to be referring to sanctions approved by the House of Representatives on the International Criminal Court in protest at its arrest warrants for Israel's prime minister and former defence minister over Israel's campaign in Gaza.
The final version of Pakistan's proposal referred only to an invitation to the UN General Assembly to consider an IIIM in the future. Two Geneva-based diplomats said they had received messages from US diplomats before the change of wording asking them to oppose the new investigation. "They were saying: 'back off on this issue'," said one, who spoke on condition of anonymity. Reuters could not establish whether the revision was a direct result of US actions.
A US State Department spokesperson said it was complying with the executive order signed by Trump on Feb 4 withdrawing the US from the council and would not participate in it, adding: "As a matter of policy, we do not comment on private diplomatic conversations."
Pakistan's diplomatic mission in Geneva did not respond to a request for comment.
"The US seems to be trying to have it both ways. It doesn't want to pay for or participate in the UN but it still wants to boss it around," said Lucy McKernan, Deputy Director for United Nations at Human Rights Watch's Geneva office.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
24 minutes ago
- Express Tribune
Bilawal warns of water war risk
The head of the Pakistan parliamentary delegation and former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari called on the international community Friday to engage with India and emphasise that military confrontation was not a solution to the Kashmir dispute or terrorism, stressing that dialogue was the only way forward. Speaking to the European think tanks and international media representatives in Brussels, Bilawal warned that India's aggressive posture, including threats to revoke the Indus Water Treaty (IWT), could escalate tensions to dangerous levels. "We are here to present Pakistan's stance on recent tensions with India and expose New Delhi's anti-Pakistan agenda," he said. He emphasised that the Jammu and Kashmir dispute must be resolved in line with United Nations Security Council resolutions. Bilawal criticised India's "new abnormal" policy of blaming Pakistan for any terrorist attack in India or Indian illegally occupied Jammu and Kashmir without evidence, leading to immediate threats of war. He recalled that Pakistan had proposed an impartial international investigation into the recent Pahalgam incident, but India rejected the offer. He condemned India's suspension of the Indus Water Treaty, calling it a violation of international law and a "war crime" that threatens water access for 240 million Pakistanis. "If India weaponises water, we may have no choice but to retaliate, risking a full-blown water war," he warned. Bilawal reiterated that Pakistan had shown restraint, offered dialogue, and adhered to international law, urging the same standards be applied in South Asia as in Europe. "If the world ignores this crisis, it could become a nuclear flashpoint," he cautioned. On the Pahalgam attack, Bilawal stated that India had failed to provide evidence linking Pakistan to the incident. "To this day, India hasn't revealed the identities of the attackers or how they crossed the heavily militarised border," he said.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
US says monitoring Israel-Iran attacks' impact on global energy supply
WASHINGTON: U.S. Energy Secretary Chris Wright said on Friday he and his team are working with the White House's National Security Council to monitor the situation in the Middle East and any potential impacts to global energy supply. Wright said on X, after Israel's strikes on Iran's nuclear sites and Iran's response of missiles on Israel, that President Donald Trump's policy of maximizing U.S. oil and gas output, which also involves slashing pollution regulations, has boosted U.S. energy security. Oil and gas sites in Iran, an OPEC member, have not been targeted, analysts have said. Global crude oil prices spiked on Friday, settling 7% higher at more than $74 per barrel on investor worries about conflict spreading to the wider Middle East. Iran strikes back at Israel with missiles over Jerusalem, Tel Aviv And U.S. gasoline prices could rise about 20 cents a gallon in coming days during peak U.S. summer driving season 'creating economic pressures and political headwinds for President Donald Trump, who campaigned on lowering energy costs,' analysts at ClearView Energy Partners said in a note to clients. ClearView said higher prices could push Trump to focus on tapping strategic petroleum reserves, seeking supply additions from the OPEC+ production group, and could complicate efforts to tighten sanctions on Russia, one of the world's top three oil producers. The U.S. Energy Department did not immediately respond to a question about the potential to tap the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR), the world's largest, which currently holds 402.1 million barrels of crude. Fatih Birol, the head of the Paris-based International Energy Agency, said on X that the IEA oil security system, which includes the U.S. SPR, has more than 1.2 billion barrels of emergency stocks. The Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries slammed Birol's post, saying on X it raises false alarms and 'projects a sense of market fear.'
Express Tribune
3 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Pakistan warns Israel's strikes on Iran pose grave threat to regional, global security
Pakistan's Permanent Representative to the UN, Ambassador Asim Iftikhar Ahmad, speaks at the UN Security Council meeting on Israel-Iran conflict on June 13, 2025. Courtesy: X@PakistanUN_NY Listen to article Israel's strikes on Iranian nuclear and military facilities have been described as a 'grave danger and a serious threat' to the peace, security, and stability of the entire region and beyond, Pakistan told the UN Security Council during an emergency session convened on Friday. The 15-member Council adjusted its original schedule to address the rapidly evolving crisis, hearing from the head of the UN nuclear watchdog, who warned of the grave risks to both regional stability and nuclear safety. In his remarks, Ambassador Asim Iftikhar Ahmad, Pakistan's permanent representative to the UN, strongly condemned Israel's 'unjustified and illegitimate' aggression against Iran. He reaffirmed that Pakistan stood in resolute solidarity with the Iranian government and people. Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi had requested the Security Council meeting, stating that Israel had 'now crossed every red line,' urging the international community to ensure that these crimes were not left unpunished. Among those supporting the request for the meeting were Pakistan, China, and Russia. In the face of escalating tensions, Ambassador Ahmad urged the Security Council to uphold its responsibility to enforce international law and immediately halt the aggression. He strongly called for the resolution of the crisis through dialogue and diplomacy. During the meeting, Rosemary DiCarlo, the UN Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs, briefed the Council on the repercussions of the attacks, which were already being felt across the region. 'I reaffirm the Secretary-General's condemnation of any military escalation in the Middle East,' she said, urging both Israel and Iran to exercise maximum restraint and avoid, 'at all costs, a descent into a deeper and wider regional conflict.' She also highlighted that the military escalation had occurred just as 'some significant diplomatic developments' were unfolding, including the planned resumption of US-Iranian talks in Oman, which Iran has now indicated it will no longer attend. DiCarlo urged all parties to stay committed to diplomacy, stating, 'A peaceful resolution through negotiations remains the best means to ensure the peaceful nature of Iran's nuclear programme.' She added, 'We must avoid, at all costs, a growing conflagration that could have enormous global consequences.' Rafael Grossi, Director-General of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), also briefed the Council, saying his agency was in constant contact with Iran's Nuclear Regulatory Authority to assess the status of affected facilities and determine the broader impacts on nuclear safety and security. He stressed that nuclear sites should never be targeted under any circumstances. 'Such attacks have serious implications for nuclear security, safety, and safeguards, as well as for regional and international peace and security,' Grossi said. He added that he was ready to travel to the region as soon as possible to assess the situation and support safety, security, and non-proliferation efforts in Iran. 'It is clear that the only sustainable path forward for Iran, Israel, the entire region, and the international community is one grounded in dialogue and diplomacy to ensure peace, stability, and cooperation,' Grossi concluded. He also offered the IAEA as a neutral platform, where 'facts prevail over rhetoric' and where technical engagement can replace escalation. 'I reaffirm both my personal commitment and the agency's readiness to facilitate dialogue and support efforts that promote transparency, security, and the peaceful resolution of nuclear issues in Iran.'
