Swinney 'not fit to lead' after dangerous defence jobs snub, blasts Sarwar
is 'not fit to lead our country', Anas Sarwar said yesterday, as he savaged the First Minister's 'stupid and dangerous' defence jobs snub.
The Scottish Labour leader laid into Mr Swinney over his refusal to support Scottish firms involved in 'munitions' despite growing global instability.
Keir Starmer also said it was 'staggering' the SNP had denied £2.5million towards an £11million Rolls-Royce welding centre on the Clyde as it was linked to an 'attack submarine'.
The Conservatives said the Nationalist ideology 'endangers national security'.
But Mr Swinney insisted the policy, which predates Russia's invasion of Ukraine and a surge in NATO defence spending, was still justified.
He also defended rejecting a high-level security briefing this week to pose with toddlers at a soft play centre for the SNP campaign in the Hamilton byelection.
The row followed jobs quango Scottish Enterprise refusing to put public money into creating a specialist welding centre for Royal Navy submarines because of a policy barring public funding for 'munitions'.
However the state-owned Ferguson Marine shipyard on the Clyde is currently helping build the Navy's new T26 frigates, which will be armed to the teeth.
Speaking in Hamilton yesterday, Mr Sarwar said Mr Swinney had to decide whether to 'live in the real world or in a university student debating chamber'.
He said: 'If he says there's no public money going towards munitions, are we going to Uber the missiles in? 'Are we going to Deliveroo the equipment If someone tries to attack us?
'It's completely and utterly incoherent, frankly stupid and dangerous, and it demonstrates why he's not fit to lead our country.'
Tory MSP Stephen Kerr added: 'John Swinney is more interested in virtue signalling than the security of Scotland and the United Kingdom.
'He needs to call a halt to his usual brand of petty politics and accept reality.
'The Nationalists need to ditch their ideological position which endangers national security.'
Launching the Strategic Defence Review in Glasgow on Monday, Sir Keir said the UK had to be 'battle-ready' because of rising global threats and said thousands of new jobs would come from a 'defence dividend' as the UK ramped up security spending.
Asked by Dunfermline Labour MP Graeme Downie about the Rolls-Royce row at Prime Minister's Questions, Sir Keir said: 'At a time of global conflict, it is staggering that the SNP policy is to block an £11million investment for a new national welding centre on the Clyde. I was there earlier this week and saw the huge potential for apprenticeships, for job opportunities, and for young people. I support it - the SNP blocks it.'
Scotland Office Minister Kirsty McNeill also told MPs she was 'appalled' that Mr Swinney 'snubbed a confidential briefing' on the Review to campaign.
But Mr Swinney stood by the munitions policy and the decision to let SNP veterans minister Graeme Dey take the security briefing from UK veterans minister Alistair Carns.
'The Scottish Government has a long-standing policy that we don't use public expenditure to support the manufacture of munitions. It's been applied in this case in the proper fashion.
Asked if that was an 'ivory tower' position given rising global security threats, he said: 'No. It feels like a long-standing policy position that's been applied consistently.'
On the security briefing, he said: 'There was an offer of a phone call from the UK Government Minister, and it was taken by the relevant minister in the Scottish Government. That's how we operate normally.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
39 minutes ago
- The Independent
Why Nato has raised the voices of doom to a scream
Nato chief Mark Rutte has called for a 400 per cent boost to air and missile capabilities – and his demand to raise defence spending across the alliance to 5 per cent has raised the voices of doom to a scream. A return to Cold War levels of defence spending is not, however, a hysterical plea from a lackey of the military-industrial complex. It is a sad acknowledgement that the peace dividend that came with the collapse of the Soviet Union has been squandered by the West in a pointless war in Afghanistan and a criminal conflict in Iraq which expanded the list of peoples with a good reason to hate democracy. But there were plenty around already. Vladimir Putin is one of them, Xi Jinping is another – Donald Trump is rushing to their ranks. Autocracy is on the rise around the world while democracies have been consumed by complacency. 'Wishful thinking will not keep us safe,' said Rutte, who called for Nato to become a 'stronger, fairer and more lethal alliance'. 'The fact is, we need a quantum leap in our collective defence. The fact is, we must have more forces and capabilities to implement our defence plans in full. 'The fact is, danger will not disappear even when the war in Ukraine ends.' He's right, of course. But he is the secretary general of a military alliance. He is banging the drum for more money because he wants to see the return to the days when MAD – mutually assured destruction – was the sword that hung over every head on the planet. In the bad old days, nuclear war was the horror that kept the peace between the superpowers. They pursued their rivalries through proxies – often in Africa. Marxist Mozambique, Angola, and Ethiopia endured civil wars for decades while Western-backed rebels battled the Moscow-backed governments from the 1960s to the 1980s. Sometimes, as in Vietnam and Korea, the West sent its forces into war – but overwhelmingly the suffering for the ideological schism that split the world was in what was then known as the Third World. In South America, CIA-backed coups removed leaders who were deemed too 'commie-inclined' by Washington where Republicans and Democrats were terrified of reds getting under beds in their back yards. Kennedy's clash with Khrushchev came close to WW3 during the Cuban Missile Crisis. But it was the ability of the West to outspend the Soviet Union that brought the Iron Curtain down on the Soviet empire. The Soviets spent between 10 and 20 per cent of GDP on the military while Nato was spending half that. Moscow depended on high oil prices for its economic wellbeing while its collectivisation of farming and industrial policies stifled innovation. When oil crashed from $120/barrel to the mid $20s/barrel in the 1980s, the social and political necessity for reform became overwhelming. According to the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, Russia is estimated to spend at least 7.2 per cent of its GDP on the military, but this does not account for social welfare payments or the costs of administering the occupied territories in Ukraine. A cheap option for Putin in splitting the attention of the West has been to encourage semi-autonomous private military companies to operate in north Africa – like the proxies of the Cold War. Groups like Wagner have expanded their operations in Mali, Niger, from the Sahel to Khartoum, drawing resources and focus away from Ukraine. But in Europe, Rutte said, Nato seems to be no match for Russia. 'Our militaries also need thousands more armoured vehicles and tanks, millions more artillery shells, and we must double our enabling capabilities, such as logistics, supply, transportation and medical support,' he said. Cuts in military spending after the Cold War ended were based on the assumption that a Western-style way of life would be adopted in Russia. But the country largely fell into gangsterism and is seen by many there to have been rescued by Putin's more organised oligarchic kleptocracy underpinned by vigorous Soviet-style fear and denunciation of 'the West'. It may be a Moscow myth that Nato covets the Russian Federation but it is one that is believed widely in Putin's realm. That the West is somehow always going to be safe for democracy is an equally dangerous delusion, Rutte suggested. 'Wishful thinking will not keep us safe. We cannot dream away the danger… Hope is not a strategy. So Nato has to become a stronger, fairer and more lethal alliance.' In the UK, Keir Starmer has committed to spend 2.5 per cent of gross domestic product on defence from April 2027, with a goal of increasing that to 3 per cent over the next parliament – a timetable which could stretch to 2034. But this is well short of what is needed, according to the Nato chief. Rutte's visit to the UK comes after he proposed members of the bloc spend 5 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) on defence as part of a strengthened investment plan for the alliance. The target would require nations to raise core defence spending to 3.5 per cent of GDP, with the remaining 1.5 per cent to be made up of 'defence-related expenditure'. Nato leaders will meet in the Hague later this month, when the 5 per cent spending target by 2035 will be discussed. The leaders gathered will all agree that more must be spent. Few, if any, will know how to sell that idea to their voters.
BBC News
41 minutes ago
- BBC News
M&S restarts online orders after cyber attack
Marks and Spencer is beginning to take online orders again after it halted purchases through its website in April following a major cyber High Street chain said shoppers were now able to buy a selection of its clothes and products for home delivery in England, Scotland and said more fashion, beauty and homeware products would be available in the coming days, with click and collect and delivery services to Northern Ireland resuming "in the coming weeks".The return of online shopping marks a key milestone for the retailer, which has bene struggling to get services back to normal since the attack by hackers, which left some shelves empty and deliveries in limbo. M&S was hit by a cyber attack took place over the Easter weekend in April, which initially affected its click-and-collect and contactless payments. A few days later M&S put a banner on its website apologising that online ordering was not available.
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
‘It's humbling' – Andy Murray admits embarrassment at being beaten by 5-year-old son in different sport
SIR ANDY MURRAY has revealed that he is regularly "humbled" by his five-year-old son as the youngster has started to beat him at a new sport. Murray, 38, may have been hoping to raise tennis ' next big star, but it would appear he is developing a chess prodigy instead. 2 The Scot, who retired from tennis last year, has been spending his time away from the court taking on son Teddy at chess. Murray revealed that the little one is already learning the strategic sport and is doing so well that is often getting the better of his dad. Speaking to the BBC, Murray revealed why losing to your own son can be pretty hard to take as a parent. He said: "My five-year-old boy has got really into chess, which I'm really enjoying playing with him. "I'm not a particularly good chess player, but I've got quite an analytical mind and I enjoy the game and watching him learn and playing with him. "It's difficult losing to a five-year-old when in the middle of the game he's asking you to come and wipe his bum, essentially. "He's going to the toilet in the middle of the game, and then he comes back and is beating me at chess. It's humbling that, for my intelligence". Murray has had more time to spend polishing his chess game since he left his role as Novak Djokovic's coach last month, splitting on amicable terms after spending most of the year on the Serbian's team. 2 But he has found himself a new career in the time since, entering the world of venture capitalism. The two-time Wimbledon champion has taken up a role as an associate partner at London-based investment firm Redrice Ventures. Rafael Nadal reveals Andy Murray's 18-word text message ONE second after Arsenal beat Real Madrid He told the Sunday Times: "It's difficult to step away from a sport like tennis, which has been so all-consuming for me for so long, and then not have anything to fill that void. 'I've seen it before with other athletes — when they haven't had other interests straight after sport, it becomes hard for them to know who they are. 'I'm also only 38 years old, so that's a long time to be retired. 'My plan was always to spend more time on my other business interests once I'd finished playing tennis, and I'm enjoying starting to work on some of those projects now. 'I think for me it's the work ethic and single-minded determination to succeed.' Murray previously worked with Redrice in 2018 as part of a co-investment involving sportswear company Castore. He already has several business interests including a five-star country house hotel in Scotland, a padel tennis firm and a crowdfunding platform called Seedrs. Andy Murray's career timeline SIR Andy Murray is Great Britain's most successful tennis player of the Open era. After breaking through in 2005 to reach the Wimbledon third round at 18, the Scot was British No1 by the following year. In 2008 he reached his first Grand Slam final at the US Open, only to fall to Roger Federer in straight sets. Two more final defeats at the Australian Open to Federer and Novak Djokovic followed in 2010 and 2011 before heartbreak at Wimbledon in 2012. Despite taking the first set against Federer, he fell 4-6 7-5 6-3 6-4 in front of a home crowd before breaking into tears on Centre Court. But a month later on the same court he beat the Swiss legend to earn Team GB a gold medal at the London 2012 Olympics. And weeks after that he broke his Grand Slam duck at the fifth attempt, beating Djokovic in five sets in the US Open final. In 2013, following another Australian Open final loss, Murray beat Djokovic in straight sets to become the first British man in 77 years to win the Wimbledon title. Three more losing Grand Slam finals followed, at the 2015 and 2016 Australian Opens and the 2016 French Open. But in his third Grand Slam final of 2016, Murray won Wimbledon again with a straight sets victory over Canadian Milos Raonic. He followed it up with his second Olympic gold medal, beating Juan Martin del Potro in a four-hour epic in the final in Rio de Janeiro. Later in 2016 Murray became world No1 - the first British man to do so in history. Over his career Murray reached 11 Grand Slam finals, winning three. He won two Olympic golds and a silver (in the mixed doubles alongside Laura Robson). He finishes his career with 46 titles and over £50million in earnings, making him the fourth all-time leader in earnings. His final match was at the Paris 2024 Olympics, where he lost in the quarter-final of the men's doubles at Roland Garros to USA pair Tommy Paul and Taylor Fritz.
