Sheku judge accused of 'torpedoing' his own independence amid private meetings with the victim's family
The Sheku Bayoh Inquiry has been plunged into crisis amid an extraordinary bias row involving chairman Lord Bracadale, who held five private meetings with the family of the 31-year-old after he died being restrained by officers in Kirkcaldy, Fife, nearly a decade ago.
The Scottish Police Federation and the officers at the centre of the probe have now demanded Lord Bracadale step down as inquiry chairman.
But the retired High Court judge, who chaired a hearing into his own conduct, claimed that Mr Bayoh's family would have 'walked out' had he not met them.
The landmark statutory inquiry - which began in November 2020 and is nearing its closing stages - aims to find out whether racism played a part in the death of the father-of-two in 2015.
But the future of the chairman is now in doubt with a special two-day hearing which is said to cost around £2million being held in Edinburgh.
Roddy Dunlop KC, representing the Scottish Police Federation, told the hearing Lord Bracadale had to go and the meetings he held were 'in almost their entirety completely inappropriate'.
The KC added: 'They were doubtless well-meaning, they were doubtless arranged out of the best of intentions, but and with the greatest of respect, they were spectacularly ill-advised and they have torpedoed the independence of the chair.'
Lord Bracadale told the inquiry, in a written statement, that the meetings were needed.
He said: 'Given the fragility of the confidence of the families in the Inquiry at various stages, I consider that meeting them on an annual basis did contribute to obtaining and retaining their confidence in the Inquiry and securing their evidence.
'I consider that, if I had not had meetings with them, there is a high probability that they would have stopped participating and would have walked out of the Inquiry.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
27 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Transgender teacher buys Scottish souvenir plot in bid to be called Lord instead of Miss
A transgender teacher in Florida has bought a plot of land in Scotland in a bid to be called Lord instead of Miss. Toby Tobin, 30, who teaches maths and science to fifth graders, claims to have been forced to resign after school authorities insisted a female title and pronouns were used. The teacher, who is biologically female, was open about identifying as male when taking the job in 2021 and had previously been referred to as Mr Tobin. But in 2023, a new law was applied in the state which said that when it comes to public schools a person's sex is an 'immutable biological trait and that it is false to ascribe to a person a pronoun that does not correspond to such person's sex'. It meant school staff were banned from asking students to refer to them by pronouns which do not reflect their sex at birth and students were not required to use them. In an effort to get around the law, the teacher bought a 4 sq ft 'souvenir plot' on an estate in Fife through a website offering customers the chance to become a 'Lord, Lady or Laird'. Toby purchased a 4 sq ft 'souvenir plot' on an estate in Fife through a website offering people a chance to become a 'Lord, Lady or Laird'. However, the school refused to let the teacher use the title or ask the 10 and 11-year-old children in the class to use it. In response, Toby filed a lawsuit against the Pinellas County School District claiming gender discrimination. The teacher said: 'After a conversation with the district they said I would have to use only female-specific pronouns and a title. 'In response to this I thought "OK, I can't be Mr Tobin, why don't I go purchase some land in Scotland and I could become a Lord?". 'So I did make some attempts to combat this in the most gentle way that I could at the time.' Toby also became an ordained minister and a Count of the Principality of Sealand - an offshore platform in the North Sea - in other attempts to dodge using a female title and pronouns. 'After proposing that I be Lord Tobin my administration said "no", but I did not give up,' the teacher said. 'I became a minister through the Universal Life Church so I now am Minister Toby Tobin as well as Lord Toby Tobin. 'I then found the Principality of Sealand and I became a Count with them which I thought would be hysterical because I taught math. 'Count Tobin was also not deemed appropriate for the classroom so I started to realise that if it wasn't Mrs it wasn't going to be it so I was essentially constructively discharged.' Toby's lawsuit, filed in the US District Court in Florida, states: 'Plaintiff attempted to work with the school district by voluntarily obtaining honorifics such as "lord" by purchasing a tract of land in Scotland. 'Defendant did not allow plaintiff to use any titles or pronouns other [than] ones that corresponded to the incorrect gender. 'Defendants' directives undermined plaintiff's identity, dignity, and ability to perform his job in a manner consistent with his personal and professional integrity.' Lawyers for the school authorities filed a motion to dismiss the case, arguing Toby's pronoun preference is not protected speech and the state's interest in upholding the law outweighs his request. There are a handful of websites selling souvenir plots in remote parts of Scotland to give owners a chance to become a lord or lady. However, the companies warn that you 'cannot buy a noble title' and use of it is for enjoyment purposes only.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Trans teacher buys Scottish land in bid to be called Lord, not Miss
An American transgender teacher embroiled in a gender naming row bought a piece of land in Scotland in an attempt to be called Lord rather than Miss. Toby Tobin, a fifth-grade maths and science teacher in Florida who was born female, claims to have been forced to resign from teaching after school authorities insisted upon the use of a female title and pronouns. When Tobin originally took a job with the school in 2021, the teacher was open about identifying as male and had previously been referred to as Mr Tobin. However, in 2023 new laws implemented in Florida stated that when it comes to public schools a person's sex is an 'immutable biological trait and that it is false to ascribe to a person a pronoun that does not correspond to such person's sex'. • Trans ruling set to be key issue for SNP at next election School employees were prohibited from asking students to call them by pronouns not based on their sex at birth and students were not required to use them. In an attempt to get around the ban on calling himself Mr Tobin, the teacher bought a small plot of Scottish land to secure the title of Lord Toby Tobin. Tobin purchased a 4 sq ft 'souvenir plot' on an estate in Fife through a website offering buyers the chance to become a 'Lord, Lady or Laird'. After the attempt to use the title was rejected, the 30-year-old launched a lawsuit against the Pinellas County School District claiming gender discrimination. 'After a conversation with the district they said I would have to use only female-specific pronouns and a title,' Tobin said. 'In response to this I thought 'OK, I can't be Mr Tobin, why don't I go purchase some land in Scotland and I could become a Lord?'. So I did make some attempts to combat this in the most gentle way that I could at the time.' Tobin also became an ordained minister and a Count of the Principality of Sealand, an offshore platform in the North Sea, in an attempt to avoid using a female title. 'After proposing that I be Lord Tobin my administration said 'no', but I did not give up,' the teacher said. 'I became a minister through the Universal Life Church so I now am Minister Toby Tobin as well as Lord Toby Tobin. I then found the Principality of Sealand and I became a Count with them which I thought would be hysterical because I taught math. 'Count Tobin was also not deemed appropriate for the classroom so I started to realise that if it wasn't Mrs it wasn't going to be it so I was essentially constructively discharged.' Tobin's lawsuit, filed in the US District Court in Florida, states: 'Plaintiff attempted to work with the school district by voluntarily obtaining honorifics such as 'lord' by purchasing a tract of land in Scotland. 'Defendant did not allow plaintiff to use any titles or pronouns other [than] ones that corresponded to the incorrect gender. Defendants' directives undermined plaintiff's identity, dignity, and ability to perform his job in a manner consistent with his personal and professional integrity.' Lawyers representing school authorities have filed a motion to dismiss the case, arguing Tobin's pronoun preference is not protected speech and the state's interest in upholding the law outweighs his request. A number of companies sell souvenir plots in remote parts of Scotland giving owners the chance to become a lord or lady. However, purchasers are warned that you 'cannot buy a noble title' and use of it is for enjoyment purposes only. A spokesman for the Pinellas County School District said it does not comment on continuing legal cases.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
Wheesht team cries hypocrisy as library unveils ‘democracy' grants
SNP ministers have been accused of hypocrisy as a fund to support 'democracy' in public libraries was announced less than a week after it emerged that Scotland's national library had refused to exhibit a feminist book. The Scottish Library and Information Council (Slic) is seeking grant applications from libraries for £450,000 of Scottish government money. It says projects will be prioritised if they tackle misinformation or support democratic choice, among other topics. However, documents show that Amina Shah, Scotland's national librarian and the chief executive of the National Library of Scotland, who sits on the Slic board, was persuaded to block the inclusion of The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht in a special display despite it receiving more than enough public votes. The book charts the rise of the grassroots movement that opposed Nicola Sturgeon's gender self-identification law. Angus Robertson, Scotland's culture secretary, hailed the launch of the fund saying it 'exemplifies the transformative power of libraries, from introducing digital inclusiveness to teaching about economic wellbeing'. Alison Nolan, chief executive of Slic, said the themes of this year's awards would 'ensure libraries continue to lead as trusted, inclusive spaces at the heart of every community'. Susan Smith, a director of the campaign group For Women Scotland which clarified the legal definition of the term 'woman' in a landmark victory at the UK Supreme Court, said: 'It is quite extraordinary that this announcement has come only a week after the national library was exposed for cowardice and censorship after they pulled The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht from an exhibition at the behest of bullies. 'In doing so, they maligned the writers and misrepresented the book — not something that sits well with campaigns against misinformation.' Smith asked if Shah only applied the principles referred to in the scheme 'selectively or when convenient' . She said: 'Will the culture secretary, Angus Robertson, relocate his spine and speak out against the decision of the chief librarian? Her position was already untenable: unless action is taken, both Shah and Robertson look like the most pathetic of hypocrites.' The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht was due to be included in the national library's centenary exhibition but was pulled after a backlash by the library's LGBT staff network, which claimed it contained 'hate speech' and that displaying it would cause 'severe harm' to workers. They threatened to 'notify LGBT+ partners of the library's endorsement of the book' if management did not remove the publication. Shah pointed to the potential impact on 'key stakeholders' and the library's reputation if the essay collection was featured. She has faced opposition since her decision was made public, with Alex Graham, a library donor, saying he was 'shocked and angry' about the exclusion. Robertson has not directly addressed the row. Susan Dalgety, a co-editor of The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht, said: 'Libraries play a central function in nurturing democracy and promoting rational debate. 'Yet our book, one written by more than 30 women from across Scotland, has been excluded from its rightful place in the exhibition. 'This anti-democratic decision goes against everything libraries stand for. It is somewhat ironic that Slic has announced funding to support democracy this very week. The council should remind the national librarian and Sir Drummond Bone, the library chair, of their central role in promoting democracy through freedom of expression.' Murdo Fraser, the Scottish Conservative Party spokesman for culture, said: 'Many will be sceptical at the timing of the SNP's support for this fund given the recent furore over the national library's censorship of Women Won't Wheesht. 'If ministers like Angus Robertson are serious about tackling misinformation then perhaps they will finally apologise for years of denying the reality of there only being two biological sexes. 'He should also apologise for all the local libraries across Scotland that have closed, or been threatened with closure, as a result of SNP cuts.' The national library reissued its statement about the exclusion of the book from the display. It said: 'Anyone can visit our reading rooms and access this book as well as the 200 other titles that were not selected for display. A full list of those publications is available as part of the exhibition. 'Libraries are vital places where people can access all kinds of publications for free and form their own opinions.' Slic said: 'Stock selection in libraries is a complex issue shaped by a wide variety of external factors. Slic has always advocated for open access to diverse voices in Scotland's public libraries and continues to do so.' The Scottish government said: 'Ministers have no role in curation decisions taken by individual institutions. The Scottish government supports the right to freedom of expression and we are clear that there is no place for any form of discrimination in Scotland.'
