Sheku judge accused of 'torpedoing' his own independence amid private meetings with the victim's family
An inquiry judge has 'torpedoed' his own independence with the 'spectacularly ill-advised' decision to meet with the family of a man who died in police custody, it has been claimed.
The Sheku Bayoh Inquiry has been plunged into crisis amid an extraordinary bias row involving chairman Lord Bracadale, who held five private meetings with the family of the 31-year-old after he died being restrained by officers in Kirkcaldy, Fife, nearly a decade ago.
The Scottish Police Federation and the officers at the centre of the probe have now demanded Lord Bracadale step down as inquiry chairman.
But the retired High Court judge, who chaired a hearing into his own conduct, claimed that Mr Bayoh's family would have 'walked out' had he not met them.
The landmark statutory inquiry - which began in November 2020 and is nearing its closing stages - aims to find out whether racism played a part in the death of the father-of-two in 2015.
But the future of the chairman is now in doubt with a special two-day hearing which is said to cost around £2million being held in Edinburgh.
Roddy Dunlop KC, representing the Scottish Police Federation, told the hearing Lord Bracadale had to go and the meetings he held were 'in almost their entirety completely inappropriate'.
The KC added: 'They were doubtless well-meaning, they were doubtless arranged out of the best of intentions, but and with the greatest of respect, they were spectacularly ill-advised and they have torpedoed the independence of the chair.'
Lord Bracadale told the inquiry, in a written statement, that the meetings were needed.
He said: 'Given the fragility of the confidence of the families in the Inquiry at various stages, I consider that meeting them on an annual basis did contribute to obtaining and retaining their confidence in the Inquiry and securing their evidence.
'I consider that, if I had not had meetings with them, there is a high probability that they would have stopped participating and would have walked out of the Inquiry.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Scottish couple lose legal challenge of winter fuel payment cuts
A couple have lost a bid to sue the UK and Scottish governments over the decision to cut winter fuel Peter and Flo Fanning, from Coatbridge in North Lanarkshire, took their case to the Court of Session in Edinburgh in March, alleging that both governments failed to adequately consult with those of pension age and did not release an equality impact assessment on the Court of Session ruled to refuse the petition on couple's lawyers have said they have no doubt the Fanning's litigation had been influential in securing U-turns by both governments. A spokesperson from the Govan Law Centre told BBC Scotland News: "While our clients have lost their case at first instance, we have no doubt that this litigation has been influential in securing the partial U-turn made by the Scottish government last November and the major policy U-turn confirmed by the UK government earlier this week."We hope that the Scottish government will now follow suit and restore the winter fuel payment in full for people such as our clients."Earlier this week, the UK government abandoned plans to withdraw the payments from all but the poorest pensioners after the scheme drew widespread Scottish government had already launched its own winter fuel benefit in response to the original cuts which included extra support for those less well-off, but also a universal payment which is unaffected by Govan Law Centre added the legal challenge "was always one of process" and the fact the UK government has already reconsidered the cuts "vindicates" their said that an appeal would have "reasonable prospects of success" but added it is unlikely that legal aid would be provided for this. What's happening with winter fuel payments? About 10 million pensioners in England and Wales lost their allowance under new measures announced by chancellor Rachel Reeves in July last on pension credit or certain other means-tested benefits retained the annual payments, worth between £100 and £ Scotland, the payment was devolved to Holyrood in April 2024, but the Scottish government followed the actions of their counterparts in Westminster in terminating it in August 2024, arguing £160m had been taken from its budget.A new alternative, called the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment (PAWHP), was due to be introduced the following month, but that has since been pushed back to winter will also be means-tested, despite ministers claiming it would not Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville recently said the universal approach of the devolved Scottish scheme was important - but that wealthier pensioners would be made aware that they could opt current plan is for all pensioner households to receive at least £100 regardless of income, while those on pension credit will receive up to £305 depending on the devolved government in Northern Ireland also followed suit, but affected pensioners were given a one-off £100 payment from Stormont in November.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Council workers to be balloted on new pay offer amid threat of strikes
Council staff are to be balloted on whether to accept a new two-year pay offer. Unison Scotland said Cosla has offered local government workers 4% this year and 3.5% next year. The union said it will recommend staff accept the offer. Unison, which represents 80,000 workers across Scotland's 32 councils, began balloting members on strike action last month after local authority staff were offered a 3% pay rise. The union said the ballot amounted to the biggest vote of its kind in years and was held after 92% of members indicated they would support industrial action. [xdelx] Unison Scotland's head of local government, David O'Connor, said: 'The threat of possible strikes by council employees has forced Cosla back to the table. 'But it should not have taken the possibility of staff walkouts closing services to get Cosla and the Scottish Government to listen to the workforce. 'Local authority workers were due a pay rise in April. Despite the delay, this is a sensible offer. 'The union will be putting the new amount to council staff over next few weeks, recommending that they accept.' Cosla has been approached for comment.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Tributes paid to ‘trailblazer' academic Sir Geoff Palmer after death aged 85
Sir Geoff Palmer, one of Scotland's best-known academics who was the country's first black professor, has died at the age of 85. The professor was long associated with Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh, serving as chancellor and professor emeritus for many years. He was also a prominent public figure in other fields, recently reviewing the legacy of slavery and colonialism in the Scottish capital. The university hailed him as a 'trailblazer and inspiration within higher education and in wider society', while Labour MSP Foysol Choudhury described him as a 'courageous voice for justice and equality'. Sir Geoff died on Wednesday. He is survived by his wife Margaret, their three children, and grandchildren. Born in Jamaica in 1940, he moved to London aged 14 as part of the Windrush generation. He came to Edinburgh in the 1960s, where he completed a Phd in grain science and technology. His developments in the field went on to be adopted by some of the largest breweries in the UK. In 1989 he became Scotland's first black professor as he began a teaching role at Heriot-Watt which continued until 2005. Sir Geoff returned to the institution as a professor emeritus and later as chancellor in 2021. He was knighted in 2014 for services to human rights, science and charity, and last year he was appointed to the Order of the Thistle, Scotland's greatest order of chivalry. As well as being a scientist, Sir Geoff was an outspoken advocate of human rights and racial equality. He wrote several articles and books exploring these topics and pushed for education around Scotland's past roles in colonialism and slavery. In response to the Black Lives Matter movement, City of Edinburgh Council commissioned an independent review group to examine its historic links with slavery in the public realm. Sir Geoff led the group and his report made 10 recommendations, including ordering a 'significant' new public artwork and 're-presenting' buildings and places which have historic links to slavery. In 2022 he successfully campaigned for a plaque at the Court of Session commemorating the 1778 judgment of Knight v Wedderburn, which established that Scots law would not support slavery. He told the PA news agency at the time the plaque meant a 'tremendous amount' to him. Despite his years-long efforts to address racism, Sir Geoff did not advocate for the removal of statues and building names associated with historic slave owners and those connected to the trade, such as Viscount Dundas. He said: 'If you remove the evidence, you remove the deed.' Richard A Williams, principal of Heriot-Watt, led tributes to Sir Geoff. He said: 'Today marks a sad day for this university and for everyone who knew Sir Geoff. 'He was an inspiration not just to me but to colleagues past and present, and countless students around the world. His infectious enthusiasm and passion for education was impossible to ignore and this university was all the richer for having such a strong association with him over the years. 'He will be dearly missed, and our thoughts are with his loved ones at this difficult time.' MSP Mr Choudhury said he was 'deeply saddened' at the news. He wrote on social media: 'He was not only a distinguished scientist and academic, but also a courageous voice for justice and equality. 'My sincere condolences to his family and all who knew and admired him. May his soul rest in peace.' Scottish First Minister John Swinney said: 'Sir Geoff Palmer was a pioneer and an outstanding intellectual. 'He had a hugely positive impact on Scotland and will be sorely missed. My sympathy to his family.' Scotland Office minister and Midlothian MP Kirsty McNeill described Sir Geoff as 'an innovator, campaigner and educator', adding: 'We were lucky to have someone of his extraordinary warmth and breadth of interest in Midlothian.'
