Are St Johnstone doomed as trap door edges closer?
In the most surreal of surroundings for such a momentous occasion, Callum Davidson punched the air with his right fist.Just yards away, five of his players crashed to their knees in exhaustion and disbelief, the undreamable playing out in front of nobody at a barren Hampden Park.Saturday, 22 May 2021 was the day St Johnstone Football Club probably peaked in its then 137-year history. Their first ever League Cup secured earlier that season, now the Scottish Cup was in the bag. Heroes.For all that was the highest of highs for the Perth club, a troublesome four years since has led them to the brink of relegation, a fate which could be sealed tomorrow if defeated by Ross County.Is it an inevitability? Or do this season's long-term strugglers still have a hope?
The present - alarm bells deafening
The facts facing St Johnstone and manager Simo Valakari make for grim reading. Currently bottom of the Scottish Premiership by six points with nine left to play for, really only a win on Saturday at home to 11th-placed County is going to do.Valakari's team have lost their past four on the spin. They've also only won twice in the league in the past three months, bizarrely most recently against champions Celtic in a rare rally.However, a stall in form is nothing new. St Johnstone have been in the bottom two in the league this season for 160 days, first entering that drop zone seven games in.And glancing further afield, if Dundee avoid defeat at Kilmarnock, realistically 11th is the best St Johnstone can hope for even if they win the relegation rumble against County.
The history - cause for hope or panic?
So St Johnstone have toiled for large swathes of this season. That much isn't really in question. But they're not the first and they certainly won't be the last side to stumble their way into trouble at the wrong end of the table.Since 1999, the team who were bottom of the table with three games to go have only escaped relegation five times, and two of those seasons were because there were no relegated teams at all.In 2005, Dunfermline Athletic overturned a three-point deficit as Dundee went down. Four years later, Falkirk clawed back a four-point gap to actually finish two places above the drop with Inverness Caledonian Thistle dropping out.And in 2014, Kilmarnock finished ninth after being bottom with three games to play, albeit they were just a point adrift of a hat-trick of sides.And while St Johnstone's points tally of 29 with three to play is relatively high for a bottom-placed team, those in and around them are also above average.You can probably put this down to bigger teams dropping more points. Rangers have spilled points in 15 games, Hibernian and Aberdeen doing the same in 20 of them.The main glimmer of hope lies in St Johnstone's nearest rivals. Already this season, they've taken seven points from nine against County, and also four against Dundee, who they face in the final game. There's also a swingable goal difference at play.There's been three narrow 2-1 defeats to Wednesday's opponents Hearts, but timing may be on their side with the Tynecastle club hunting for a new manager.
The reality - 'No one is safe'
Brian McLauchlin, BBC Sport ScotlandSt Johnstone boss Simo Valakari says his job is on the line at the club should they be relegated from the Premiership into the Championship for next season.Valkari says he is in the same situation as everyone else at the club, and insists it would be a huge financial blow should their 16-year stay in the top flight comes to an end."Yes, everyone's job, of course, yes, of course [including my own]," he said."We know how football works and there is no hiding. We can talk about this and this and this, but everyone is on the same boat. No one, no one is safe."Of course we chat [with the owners] every week. We chat many times during the week. They are not happy with the results, who would be?"They understand the circumstances, they see behind the results as well, which is very, very important when you talk about the process."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
‘Under strain' English football must improve value for fans, report says
The English football system is "under strain," a new report has found, urging regulation to address factors like fan engagement and competitive balance. However, Deloitte's latest Annual Review of Football Finance has found a lack of clarity around future regulations is proving "unhelpful" to potential investors. According to the group's report, Europe's 'Big Five' leagues generated over 20 billion euros (£16.9 billion) in 2023-24, with Premier League clubs reporting aggregate revenue of £6.3 billion. The Football Governance Bill is set to create an independent regulator for England's top five leagues after making its way through Parliament. However, concerns remain, particularly at the top-flight level, regarding the impact of regulation on the league's growth potential and ability to attract new investment. Tim Bridge, the lead partner in the Deloitte Sports Business Group, believes that issues surrounding the competitiveness of the Premier League must also be addressed. 'There can be no doubt that the system in English football is under strain,' he wrote in the foreword to the report published on Thursday. 'Repeated reports of fan unrest at ticket price and accessibility demonstrate the challenge in the modern era of balancing commercial growth with the historic essence of a football club's role and position in society: as a community asset. 'We still await the output of the Independent Football Regulator to fully understand how this may impact the game in England, but it is clear that the way in which the game is governed and the regulation that underpins it needs to seek to drive value, fan engagement (both physical and digital) and competitive balance. 'The two most recent seasons (2023-24 and 2024-25) underscore the challenge, as in each season, all three clubs promoted from the Championship were subsequently relegated after just one season in the Premier League. 'The financial implications of the 'yo-yo effect' on clubs, their spending, and overall competitiveness are major factors to address in order to continue attracting high levels of investment across the system. 'This should though be viewed by all those running the game as an opportunity. The level of interest and the demand to engage with English football remains high and investors still see the opportunity, particularly when there is a strong community link or adjacent investment opportunities, but the lack of clarity over the future regulatory regime is now unhelpful.' Bridge noted that other top leagues are closely observing how the English regulator takes shape, highlighting an economic report by Spain's LaLiga in 2022-23 which welcomed the introduction of a regulator in England to help contain inflationary pressure on wages and other football spending. The Deloitte report again illustrated how far ahead the Premier League is of its 'Big Five' rivals currently, with its aggregate revenue almost double that of the next highest earners LaLiga – whose clubs generated a combined 3.8bn euros (£3.2bn) in 2023-24.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
English football faces strain between money and fans' needs, says report
England's football system is 'under strain' in a climate of tension between commercial imperatives and the needs of supporters, according to a new report from Deloitte. The analysis also warns that uncertainty over the role and scope of an independent regulator is 'unhelpful' to those wishing to join the rush of investors entering the sport. The Annual Review of Football Finance painted an overall picture of a booming industry, pointing out that the European football market was worth a record £32.2bn in 2023-24. More than £16.9bn of that was generated by the 'big five' leagues, with the Premier League alone recording revenues of £6.3bn. Deloitte cautioned, though, that those numbers do not tell the full tale of a game caught between its community roots and the requirement for continued growth. 'There can be no doubt that the system in English football is under strain,' said Tim Bridge, lead partner at Deloitte sports business group, in the report's foreword. 'Repeated reports of fan unrest at ticket price and accessibility demonstrate the challenge in the modern era of balancing commercial growth with the historic essence of a football club's role and position in society: as a community asset.' A bill to create the independent football regulator went through its second reading in parliament last month. It could transform the game's governance but Bridge cited the gap between Premier League and Championship finances as a problem that must be addressed. 'It is clear that the way in which the game is governed and the regulation that underpins it needs to seek to drive value, fan engagement [both physical and digital] and competitive balance,' he said. 'The two most recent seasons underscore the challenge, as in each season, all three clubs promoted from the Championship were subsequently relegated after just one season in the Premier League. The financial implications of the 'yo-yo effect' on clubs, their spending, and overall competitiveness are major factors to address in order to continue attracting high levels of investment across the system.' The hope is that the regulator can begin its work this autumn, although roadblocks include a likely inquiry into the government's choice for its chair, David Kogan. Bridge pointed out that the uncertainty about its form rings alarm bells for investors. 'The level of interest and the demand to engage with English football remains high and investors still see the opportunity, particularly when there is a strong community link or adjacent investment opportunities, but the lack of clarity over the future regulatory regime is now unhelpful,' he said. He noted that other 'big five' leagues – those of France, Germany, Italy and Spain – are monitoring the regulator's possible effects, seeing it as a potential opportunity to close the financial chasm that has opened between England's top flight and the rest. The Premier League's aggregate revenue was almost double the £3.2bn recorded by La Liga, its nearest competitor. Sign up to Football Daily Kick off your evenings with the Guardian's take on the world of football after newsletter promotion Premier League clubs' aggregate operating profit grew to more than £500m in 2023-24, the report showed, but net debt was up 12% to £3.5bn. Revenues in the Championship soared by a notable 28% to £958m, but all of the division's clubs recorded operating losses. 'Long-term strategies must be established to ensure financial stability across the league,' Bridge said.
Press and Journal
3 hours ago
- Press and Journal
Aberdeen defender Jack Milne could follow £4.75million star's Pittodrie career path, says legend Brian Irvine
Signing Jack Milne on a long-term contract is a masterstroke by Aberdeen as the defender's career rise could mirror Scott McKenna's, says legend Brian Irvine. Aberdeen boss Jimmy Thelin and the Pittodrie hierarchy recently tied centre-back Milne on an extended deal in April until summer 2029. A month-after committing his long term future to the club Milne played a key role in the Scottish Cup final triumph – in only his third start of the season. The 22-year-old delivered a stellar performance at Hampden as the Dons lifted the Scottish Cup for the first time since 1990. Irvine netted the winning penalty in the 1990 cup win and was at the national stadium to watch Milne shine at the heart of a five-man defence. He reckons youth academy graduate Milne's performance proves he has the potential to emulate the Pittodrie career path of Scotland international McKenna. McKenna emerged through the Aberdeen youth system to become a first team star before securing a £3million move to then-English Championship Nottingham Forest in 2020. The figure Aberdeen banked for McKenna rose to £4.75m due to add-ons being achieved when he helped Forest earn promotion to the Premier League in 2022. Irvine said: 'Signing Jack Milne on a long-term contract until 2029 is a great move by Aberdeen. 'He delivered a fantastic performance in the Scottish Cup final that was extremely mature for a young player. 'Milne can take real confidence from how he played at Hampden and will benefit from that going forward. 'It could ultimately be another Scott McKenna situation where Milne gets a big move from Aberdeen in the future. 'McKenna was superb for Aberdeen for a number of seasons then went on to get the big transfer to England. 'At club and international level McKenna has had a fantastic career since coming through at Aberdeen. 'Milne could potentially mirror that.' Aberdeen's Scottish Cup final triumph has secured guaranteed European league action next season and a Uefa cash bonus of around £5million. The Dons will enter the Europa League play-offs with ties played on August 21 and 28. Should they lose the play-off, Aberdeen will parachute into the Conference League. Manager Jimmy Thelin has already began bolstering his squad in a bid to balance European league action with domestic commitments. Australian international striker Kusini Yengi, 26, has signed a pre-contract. Yengi will arrive on a free following the expiration of his contract with Portsmouth. Versatile left-back Emmanuel Gyamfi, 20, was signed from German Bundesliga 2 club FC Schalke 04 on a four-year-deal for an undisclosed fee. Australian winger Nicolas Milanovic was also secured for around £400,000 from A-League club Western Sydney Wanderers. The 23-year-old was recently named the A-League player of the year. Keeper Nick Suman, 25, was also secured and will join the Reds when his contract with Cove Rangers expires later this month. Aberdeen are in advanced talks with multiple transfer targets ahead of the summer transfer window. Irvine is confident the Reds will build on the Scottish Cup triumph. He said: 'All the Aberdeen players should take huge confidence from the cup win. 'Ultimately they lost out on that third-placed Premiership finish. 'But that was overtaken by qualifying for the Europa League play-off anyway by winning the Scottish Cup. 'It has been a great season for all the players and now they should build on that. 'Thelin signed a lot of players in his first season, with many Scandinavians, and it takes a little time to settle. 'They'll have more confidence and experience to take the next step in their Aberdeen career. 'There will be more new signings in the summer window. 'However, most of the players have been under Thelin for a year and we will see the best of them next season.' Pittodrie great Irvine famously scored the winning penalty as the Dons triumphed 9-8 in a spot-kick shoot-out against Celtic in the 1990 Scottish Cup final. Irvine was back at Hampden for further penalty shoot-out drama. Only this time he was watching as one of the 20,000 Aberdeen supporters who cheered the Reds to a 4-3 triumph on penalties. Aberdeen also won the Scottish Cup on Irvine's 60th birthday. He said: 'I was down on a supporters' bus that was arranged by the club, and left from Pittodrie. 'At Hampden, I sat in amongst the supporters – because I am one myself. 'I was there with my daughter's partner. 'It was a slightly different position from 35 years ago… but just as nervy! 'When we won the Scottish Cup for the first time since 1990, it was a very emotional moment. 'I'm delighted for the players, the club and the fans. 'It was extra special because Aberdeen won the cup on my 60th birthday. 'A lot of supporters took selfies with me at Hampden, which I really enjoyed. 'On the journey home the music was pumping out with lots of songs sung. 'We got back to Pittodrie just ahead of the team bus which arrived just after 11. 'The night was probably still young for the youngsters, but 60-year-old me thought I had better go home. 'The unity between the club and city is strong at the moment which is fantastic to see.'
