Widow of murder victim ordered to pay €11,000 for care of seized XL Bully dogs
Veronica Maher (54) pleaded that her four beloved restricted breed pets were all she had to remember her late husband, who was shot dead in a Blanchardstown steakhouse on Christmas Eve, 2023.
Advertisement
Ms Maher, of Sheephill Avenue, Blanchardstown, came before Dublin District Court on May 28th to challenge a Garda application under the Control of Dogs Act for an order to destroy Oddie, Reggie, their mother Medusa, and the fourth dog, Joe.
They have been in a dog pound and given veterinary attention since being taken from Ms Maher on April 4th.
Granting a destruction order for all four, Judge Anthony Halpin had noted evidence of six gardaí at the scene on March 28th when four officers fled from Oddie, who escaped from Ms Maher's garden.
He accepted they had to take 'evasive action to save themselves from being savaged by an XL Bully dog.' He said they were terrified, and 'I can only imagine the utmost horror which they experienced.'
Advertisement
However, Ms Maher is to appeal, attempting to overturn the ruling in the Circuit Court about Oddie and possibly bringing a judicial review of the destruction order being extended to the other three dogs.
This has led to a temporary halt on the animals being put down pending the outcome of the appeals.
On Wednesday, the case resumed, and she appeared again before Judge Halpin to consider costs.
Garda Sergeant Michael Harkin said the upkeep of the dogs for the past nine weeks was €10,716, and there was a €500 vet's bill.
Advertisement
Judge Halpin granted the costs order for Ms Maher to pay €11,216 but also acceded to Ms Maher's lawyer's application for a transcript of the original hearing for the appeal.
During the earlier hearing, Judge Halpin said Oddie 'left the premises and pursued the gardaí was dangerous and could easily have fatally wounded one or all those gardaí,' he remarked.
Visibly upset, Ms Maher denied opening a gate to unleash the unmuzzled dog on gardai patrolling in her cul-de-sac.
She said the dogs were part of her family, like their children, and Oddie slept in her king-sized bed.
Advertisement
The judge also noted evidence that she had these dogs to protect the property.
She testified that three-year-old Oddie jumped the front garden wall, and she denied the accusation that she set the dog on the garda. She also claimed Medusa had also been in the yard at the time.
The court heard the other two were in cages in the back garden, and Oddie had already damaged a rear garden exit.
Garda Sean McLoughlin alleged that when he got near her house, she told him, 'Get the f**k away from my house yous murderers'.
Advertisement
He was in absolute fear for his life that he would be viciously attacked by the dog, which chased and tried to bite him. He alleged she let the dog out her front garden gate.
He and three colleagues fled to different gardens, with one standing on a wall until backup arrived a few minutes later.
He believed that Oddie was a credible threat and he would be set on them again.
Ms Maher brought the dog back into the house, and she denied telling gardaí, 'If yous don't fuck off now, I'll get him back out here.'
Witness Kayleigh McEntee (26), of Waterville Row, Blanchardstown, was at the house and contradicted the evidence that Ms Maher opened the gate. She also said the dogs were safe and often around children.
Ireland
Judge orders 'destruction' of XL Bully dogs owned...
Read More
Three more gardaí said they also had had to flee to gardens in the cul de sac, with one telling Judge Halpin that he feared he would be killed.
Photographs were handed in showing some of the dogs with family and children.
In his ruling, Judge Halpin described one image of an infant surrounded by two enormous XL Bully dogs as upsetting 'given the potential ferocity of these animals'.
He found that the dogs were dangerous and not under proper control.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
10 hours ago
- Times
Asylum seekers denied housing may be able to sue
The Department of Justice is examining a ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) amid fears the state could face compensation claims from hundreds of asylum seekers left homeless after being denied accommodation. The judgment, delivered last Friday, stems from two test cases brought before the High Court by men seeking international protection who alleged the government had breached their rights under the EU Reception Conditions Directive and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. Both men applied for asylum in 2023 but the state denied them accommodation. Each was issued with a €25 voucher and deemed ineligible for the standard daily allowance, which led to them sleeping rough in Dublin. The government had argued the breaches were due to exceptional circumstances, namely an influx of asylum seekers, which amounted to force majeure. The CJEU rejected this argument, however. Jim O'Callaghan, the justice minister, is said to be deeply concerned about the judgment given its potential to expose the state to scores of compensation claims from asylum seekers who were denied accommodation. Immigration officials also fear the ruling could inspire fraudulent claims, with new applicants lodging cases when no accommodation is available in the hope of securing compensation. On Saturday the Department of Justice confirmed the judgment was being examined. A spokesman said there had been sustained pressure on the international protection system since 2022, when a significant increase in applications began. The department added that while demand was still high, the rate of new applications had slowed since last October and the number without housing fell from more than 3,500 in March to 942 in July.
BreakingNews.ie
12 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Man (50s) charged following seizure of cannabis worth €2.1 million
A man in his 50s has appeared in court in Cork, following the seizure of approximately 107kg of herbal cannabis with an estimated street value of €2.1 million. In a joint operation, Gardai and Revenue seized the drugs that were hidden in a truck that arrived into Cork Port from Belgium last Sunday. They were found in a trailer which had originated in Croatia and had disembarked a vessel arriving from Zeebrugge in Belgium. Investigations are ongoing. Advertisement
Daily Mail
12 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Mother and her two children who were murdered in 'unspeakable way' are finally together again, funeral hears
A murdered mother and her two children are 'together and finally safe' as they were laid to rest at their funeral. Crowds flooded into the County Clare village of Barefield, west Ireland for the funeral of Vanessa Whyte, 45, and her children James Rutledge, 14, and Sara Rutledge, 13, who died in a shooting at their home in Maguiresbridge, County Fermanagh. Many of the mourners wore GAA jerseys and bright colours as requested by the family as they lined the main street to watch the three hearses pass by. Delivering the eulogy, Ms Whyte's sister Regina said they have been robbed of their loved ones but one comfort was knowing they were 'together and finally safe'. Those in attendance at the funeral at the Church of the Immaculate Conception on Saturday included a representative for the Taoiseach Micheal Martin and GAA president Jarlath Burns. The mother and two teenagers died following a shooting on July 23. Three ambulances and an air ambulance were called to the scene at about 8.20am, where Ms Whyte, a government veterinary surgeon, alongside one of the children, were tragically pronounced dead. The other child was airlifted by air ambulance to to the South West Acute Hospital in Enniskillen where they sadly later died as a result of their injuries. Critically injured Ian Rutledge, 43, from the same household was being treated at the Royal Victoria Hospital in Belfast but died on Monday - he was the only suspect in the shooting of his family. Ms Whyte's sister told mourners: 'Vanessa, James and Sara were taken from this world in a cruel and vicious manner - there are no words available to express how this has impacted our family and their friends. 'We as a family have been robbed of both a relationship with our sister and a chance to see James and Sara grow up, and they have been robbed of the remainder of their lives. 'It has taken us 11 days to be in a position to have Vanessa, James and Sara back to Clare. 'This was supposed to be a joyous occasion where Vanessa would see her new nephew, and Sara and James would meet their baby cousin for the first time. Instead we are in the position of choosing coffins, final burial places and funeral hymns. 'For us as a family, the only comfort we have is that Vanessa, James and Sara are together and finally safe. 'Vanessa will have her children at either side of her forever, as they were when they were alive.' She described her sister as 'witty, bright, kind and determined', and said James and Sara were the 'focus of her world'. Mourners queue outside the Church of the Immaculate Conception where Amazing Grace and Somewhere Over The Rainbow were played during the service She recalled James's love of the GAA, playing both hurling and football, and also cricket, adding he has been acknowledged as the 'kind, bright, determined teenager we as a family know so well'. 'James's smile was infectious, and his loyalty was strong,' she said. Sara was remembered as having a deep love for animals, and aspiring to follow in her mother's footsteps to become a vet, as well as loving sport. 'She was an excellent hurler, a footballer and skilled at netball. She was a team player, a quiet leader, and like every sister, never let James away with anything,' she said. Amazing Grace and Somewhere Over The Rainbow were among the music played during the service. Bishop Ger Nash, Bishop of Ferns and a family friend, described heartbreak over the 'tragic and unspeakable loss of three lives with so much to give to the world'. Delivering the homily, he said every story and shared memory since their deaths 'reminds us of the irreplaceable part they played in the lives of their families, their community, their schools, workplaces, teams and clubs'. 'The tragic events of last week, and the ripping away of three people from their family and friends leave us searching for answers and coming back again and again to the only answer that is completely true: 'We don't know',' he said. He noted messages of condolences for the mother and her children including from neighbours, but also many from those who simply described themselves as 'A Waterford Mammy', 'A Cork Granny', and 'A Wicklow Mother'. 'There were some with both dads and mams mentioned, but there were many where a woman spoke from her own heart,' he said. 'They don't know you, nor you them, but they know your story, and if they hug their teenagers more tightly and call a ceasefire in the perpetual war about tidy rooms, then they have learned that life is precious, and we must be grateful for every day given to us and to those we love. 'Over and over, I could see that women and mothers, as individuals, reached out in their shock and sadness at the loss of a mother and children, but also conscious that there were heartbroken mothers left behind. 'The messages highlighted the vulnerability of women to pain inflicted by others and were signs of solidarity in the face of that pain.' Last week crowds also turned out for Ms Whyte, James and Sara for a service of removal in Maguiresbridge on Wednesday. Agricultural contractor Mr Rutledge, who died on Monday, is understood to be the only suspect in the shooting of his family. Police in Northern Ireland have said a triple murder and attempted suicide was a line of inquiry. Ms Whyte, James and Sara are to be buried together in Templemaley Cemetery later.
