Uproar in PA over provincial budget 2025-26
The discussion on the provincial budget for 2025-26 commenced in the Sindh Assembly on Monday with several members from government as well as opposition benches voicing contrasting views.
The session, with Deputy Speaker Naveed Anthony in the chair, saw mixed reaction as government members hailed the budget as a people-centric, while opposition members termed it as anti-poor and away from ground realities.
Opening the debate, MQM-P's Jamal Ahmed Khan highlighted the problems in his constituency, saying that people in North Nazimabad were struggling for water. He said, the solid waste management system was dysfunctional, and trash remained uncollected for three days, negates city mayor's commitment of cleaning all areas and roads. Jamal questioned, which roads and areas he is talking about?
PPP's Shazia Karim accused the federal government of discriminatory treatment towards Sindh. She criticised the exclusion of key projects including the Karachi-Hyderabad Motorway and the K-IV water project. She questioned, "Is Sindh a slave to the federation?"
PPP's Ijaz Shah Bukhari said the people had not forgotten the days of bodies found in gunny bags in Karachi, asserting that the PPP had always stood by the public. He criticised the federal government's neglectful attitude toward Sindh, pointing out the ongoing 16-hour power outages in the province.
He called for upgrading the Tando Muhammad Khan Hospital to the district level, increasing its budget, and providing a fire brigade for the local municipal committee.
MQM-P's Abdullah Sheikh warned against maligning the Mohajir community through 'baseless allegations', while raising pointed questions about Zulfiqar Mirza from the gang war era.
He mentioned an incident in Surjani Town where one person lost his life after receiving an extortion note.
PPP's Maliha Manzoor defended saying, the budget was people-friendly. "Women flood victims will receive property rights. Pink buses are already operating in Karachi, and we plan to introduce EV taxis and scooters," she said.
MQM-P's Farah Sohail slammed the budget as anti-people, saying the Sindh government continued the 17-year trend of ignoring public needs.
She question, where the PPP's 'Roti, Kapra aur Makaan' has gone. She claimed that development funds were slashed and projects left uninitiated.
She also criticised the government's health sector performance, pointing out that an assembly member was set to receive Rs70 million in public funds for medical treatment abroad. Ijaz Haq of MQM-P criticised the lack of budget allocations for Orangi Town and the continued neglect of the Qatar Hospital trauma centre.
PPP's Nuzhat Pathan said, despite the federal government's neglect, Sindh has managed to present a better budget.
PPP's MPA Farzana Baloch raised the issue of K-Electric's overbilling and its impact on Karachi's residents. "Those who pay are punished, while defaulters go unchecked," she remarked. PTI's Muhammad Owais condemned the recent arrests of party workers and MPAs, including former opposition leaders, during a youth wing rally. He criticised the PPP for ignoring opposition recommendations in the budget and failing to manage K-Electric's performance.
MQM-P's Adil Askari accused Sindh Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah of nepotism and objected to the appointment of his brother-in-law as chief secretary which is against the principles of good governance. His comments drew strong backlash from PPP members. His remarks angered PPP members, leading to an uproar in the House.
PPP MPA, Mukesh Chawla strongly objected to the speech and demanded that the chief minister's name be removed from the record, calling the statement 'unnecessary and inflammatory'. Following the objections, members from both parties stood up and exchanged harsh words, further escalating the tension. The session descended into chaos, prompting the acting speaker to intervene.
The acting speaker urged the lawmakers, saying, "Please refrain from directly addressing each other. Maintain the dignity of the House." The situation intensified further when another MQM-P member addressed PPP's Farooq Awan, saying, "If, as you say, the MQM founder was a devil, you were probably an inspector in the Sindh Police back then. If you had the courage, you should have spoken up at the time. Now that his politics are over, there's no point in cursing him."
Following the debate, the Assembly was adjourned until 10am on Tuesday. The debate is expected to continue over the next several days.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Digital sales tax stays with provinces, solar GST cut to 10%: Dar
Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, Senator Muhammad Ishaq Dar on Wednesday said that the digital sales tax on services would remain within the jurisdiction of provinces, while the proposed 18% GST tax on solar panels had been reviewed and revised down to 10% following consultations. Speaking in the National Assembly, Senator Dar stated that after detailed discussions with coalition partners and relevant stakeholders, consensus had been reached on resolving several contentious budgetary issues. As part of the revisions, it was agreed that the imposition of digital sales tax on services falls under the constitutional domain of provincial governments. 'The concerns regarding digital taxation were valid. We held in-depth consultations with all stakeholders, including the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), and it has been decided that the matter will be clearly addressed in the Finance Minister's budget winding-up speech,' he said. Mian Zahid concerned over proposed 18pc tax on solar panels Dar further clarified that the earlier proposal of imposing 18% General Sales Tax (GST) on solar panels had sparked considerable debate. Upon review, it was revealed that 54% of components used in solarization were already taxed under the existing regime, and the 18% tax applied only to the remaining 46%. However, after mutual consultations, we have now proposed reducing the solar GST from 18% to 10%, he announced. He emphasized that tax proposals are essential for revenue generation, and any relief in one area necessitates compensation elsewhere. He pointed out that when the cabinet found the initial proposal of a 6% salary increase for government employees insufficient and raised it to 10%, corresponding budgetary adjustments also had to be made. 'We must move forward collectively. Our approach is rooted in consensus and cooperation,' he said. enter link description here Highlighting another key issue, Dar said it was decided to maintain funding for a proposed university in Sindh under the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) at Rs 4.7 billion through the Higher Education Commission (HEC). He also acknowledged valid concerns raised by MNAs regarding the closure of the Public Works Department (PWD) and confirmed that the Pakistan Infrastructure Development Company Limited (PIDCL) would now oversee all federal development projects across provinces. He said, while PIDCL was initially formed for Sindh, its mandate has now been expanded to oversee development projects across all provinces. Senator Dar concluded by reaffirming the government's willingness to address genuine concerns through mutual dialogue and constructive engagement. Meanwhile, Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) MNA Syed Naveed Qamar thanked Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar for accommodating key PPP and Sindh government budget proposals. Speaking in the National Assembly, Qamar said the government accepted major demands raised by PPP lawmakers during the budget debate. He welcomed the reduction of proposed sales tax on solar equipment from 18% to 10%, aligning with the party's stance. He also acknowledged the government's decision to expand the mandate of the Pakistan Infrastructure Development Company Limited (PIDCL) to all provinces, instead of limiting it to Sindh, effectively addressing another PPP concern.
Express Tribune
17 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Field Marshal Asim Munir to meet President Trump in White House for lunch
Listen to article US President Donald Trump is set to host Chief of Army Staff (COAS), Field Marshal Syed Asim Munir, for lunch at the White House today. The meeting, listed on the president's official schedule, will take place in the Cabinet Room at 10pm Pakistan Standard Time (PST) and is closed to the press, according to the US president's public schedule. The visit also follows last month's aerial skirmish between India and Pakistan, which raised regional tensions. Field Marshall Munir is on a five-day official trip to the United States. Recently promoted to five-star rank — Pakistan's first such elevation since 1959 — COAS has made headlines during his tour. In a speech to the Pakistani American community in Washington, he urged India to abandon regional dominance and called for engagement 'as a civilised nation.' He rejected Indian allegations linking Pakistan to the Pahalgam attack, calling them a pretext for cross-border strikes. 'We would rather embrace martyrdom than accept this dishonour,' he said. The event, held at the Four Seasons Hotel in Georgetown, drew strong support from the diaspora. Attendees greeted Field Marshal with rose petals and slogans, while Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI)-aligned protesters outside called for democratic reforms and the release of jailed leaders. Field Marshal also expressed Pakistan's support for Iran in its war with Israel, while endorsing US efforts to de-escalate the conflict. 'We want this war to end immediately,' he said. Meanwhile Gen Michael Kurilla, head of US Central Command, had earlier called Pakistan a 'phenomenal partner' in the fight against Daesh-Khorasan (Daesh-K). Kurilla told lawmakers that Pakistani forces, aided by US intelligence, had killed dozens of Daesh-K terrorists and captured several top operatives, including Mohammad Sharifullah, a planner of the 2021 Kabul airport bombing that killed 13 US troops. Kurilla said Munir called him personally after the arrest, stating, 'I've caught him — ready to extradite him back to the US.' Sharifullah was subsequently handed over to US authorities. In remarks to Congress, Kurilla praised Pakistan's ongoing operations along the Afghan border and said the country continues to play a central role in regional counterterrorism. Despite facing over 1,000 terror incidents last year, Kurilla said Pakistan 'has been a phenomenal partner in the counterterrorism world.' COAS, during his speech to the diaspora, also praised overseas Pakistanis for their economic contributions and dismissed concerns over brain drain.
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Barbs fly during Sindh assembly budget session
KARACHI: Opposition slammed the fiscal budget 2025-26 as discriminatory and dubbed it 'the darkest budget in Sindh's history', while the treasury hailed the financial plan as balanced and pro-people, during the Sindh Assembly session on Tuesday. Lawmakers from both the treasury and opposition benches also engaged in fiery exchanges during the budget debate that entered the second day as a tense atmosphere gripped the legislature The session was chaired by Deputy Speaker Anthony Naveed. Opening the floor, PPP MPA Yousuf Baloch praised Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah and his team for crafting a people-centric budget in the face of stringent IMF conditions and limited funds. 'It was no easy task, but we relied on our own resources to ensure that the budget serves the people,' he remarked. He also defended Sindh's education performance, claiming it fared better than other provinces and would further improve through fresh teacher recruitment. PPP lawmaker Hina Dastagir affirmed the Chief Minister's capacity to deliver for the public, while Arooba Rabbani said health and education had received special attention, including Karachi's academic institutions. She noted that Shahrah-e-Bhutto would be completed this fiscal year. 'PPP's work is always visible on the ground,' she said. From the opposition benches, MQM's Faheem Patni lamented that no authority was responding to the severe public issues in his constituency. 'I've told my people that the PPP government will not provide them even drinking water,' he said. 'This budget won't change the lives of ordinary citizens— it will only benefit those who made it.' PPP MPA Sarfraz Shah extended congratulations to the leadership for a 'commendable budget' and requested that a branch of NICVD be established in Naushero Feroze. He also called for reconstruction of flood-damaged schools. MPA Khair-un-Nisa Mughal urged authorities to hand over vacant athlete hostels in Mirpurkhas to local universities and thanked Minister Sharjeel Inam Memon for launching the People's Bus Service there. MQM's Moid Anver highlighted sewage water entering a cemetery in PS-101 Essa Nagri and lamented 'Karachi's marginalization' despite contributing 60% of federal revenues. 'PPP has done nothing for the people in its 17-year rule,' he asserted. PPP MPA Pir Mujeeb ul Haq said all development in Sindh had happened under PPP's tenure, citing the 18th Amendment for increasing provincial budgets. He called for Sindh University's Dadu campus to be granted full university status and urged federal authorities to expedite the long-stalled Gaj Dam project. PPP's Seema Khurram said the Benazir Hari Card continued to benefit thousands of farmers and congratulated the CM and his team on a progressive budget. MPA Noor Muhammad Bhurgari noted incomplete roads in Badin and called for their completion. Opposition MPA Naseer Ahmad criticised the government's neglect of Manghopir, claiming the area was treated 'like a foreign territory,' and accused PPP of enabling land mafias. 'They should rename themselves 'Pet Palan Party',' he quipped. PPP's Agha Siraj Durrani cautioned against personal attacks and reminded members to focus on policy matters, not party names. Panel Chairperson Rehana Leghari expunged objectionable remarks made about PPP. PPP's Jam Shabbir Ali called for unity, emphasiwing that 'Karachi is the capital of Sindh and belongs to all of us.' Faqeer Sher Muhammad criticised low budget allocation for the Sukkur-Hyderabad Motorway and suggested converting diesel-run RO plants in Thar to solar due to fuel shortages. MQM's legislator Nasir Qureshi accused the government of under-funding Hyderabad's healthcare. He questioned why the President had to be flown to Karachi when the Gambat Institute exists and noted the ICU in Civil Hospital Hyderabad lacked beds. In her speech, PPP's Saadia Javed said that a budget was more than just numbers. She lauded the party's health sector achievements but stirred controversy by referencing MQM's past association with Farooq Dada. Her remarks triggered uproar from MQM lawmakers, though the Deputy Speaker maintained she had not used any inappropriate language. Saadia then remarked that MQM had yet to formally distance itself from its founder. She also referred to PTI's founding leader as a 'convicted former prime minister,' prompting protests from PTI members. PPP's Rehana Leghari called for an end to hate-based politics and highlighted her colleague Heer Soho's marriage to an Urdu-speaking man as a symbol of unity. She reminded the House that regions like Thatta and Sujawal had historically contributed taxes to Karachi. MQM lady lawmaker, Bilqees Mukhtar, said the budget crushed the poor and claimed that the 18th Amendment had turned the province into a centralised authority. 'Unless local governments are empowered, the public will see no real change,' she asserted. She demanded more powers for the mayor's office. PPP's Dr Sikandar Shoro recommended initiating a crop insurance scheme and extending the IBA testing time for teachers. MPA Ali Ahmed praised the CM for a 'balanced budget' and shared that funds had been allocated for the Qatar Hospital, including the establishment of a trauma centre and a new 100-bed hospital in Orangi Town. PTI's lawmaker, Sajid Hussain denounced the budget as unrealistic and anti-poor. 'Schools remain closed. People are dying of hunger and disease despite a hefty budget,' he said, citing encroachments on dispensaries in his constituency. MQM's Aneel Kumar questioned the transparency of temple fund allocations and decried the lack of development schemes for non-Muslim communities in Umerkot, Tharparkar, and Mirpurkhas, where he claimed 90% of the population is non-Muslim. PPP's Syed Ameer Ali Shah thanked the leadership for a 'people-centric budget,' citing completed road projects and calling for the full activation of the DHQ Hospital. MPA Shah Hussain Shah Shirazi emphasised the need to ensure resources reach the 'tail-end' areas. Sher Muhammad Mughairi praised Pakistan Army's role in past wars and defended Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's international trips, saying they were aimed at presenting Pakistan's true image. He also requested the construction of storm water drains in his constituency. During PPP MPA Ajaz Khan Swati's speech, PTI lawmakers created a commotion. Some PPP members were heard referring to the PTI founder as 'Prisoner No. 420,' prompting a rebuke from the Deputy Speaker, who asked members to refrain from such labels and address the Chair respectfully. JI's Muhammad Farooq reminded the House of an advisory committee agreement that applied equally to all. He criticized PPP ministers for indirectly mocking the PTI leader. After a rebuttal by Saeed Ghani, Sharjeel Memon rose to say, 'Their prisoner isn't just No. 420.' The debate continued with contributions from multiple MPs, including Heer Soho, who described the budget as a landmark for Sindh's development. The session was adjourned until 10 a.m. Wednesday. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
