&w=3840&q=100)
Germany warns Indian students: Avoid agents offering 'complete package'
Surbhi Gloria Singh New Delhi
Germany has warned Indian students against relying on agents offering 'complete packages' for studying abroad. The advice was give by German Ambassador to India Philipp Ackermann on Tuesday, even as he invited Indian students to consider Germany as their first choice for higher education.
Look for universities on your own, he said.
'We want to encourage every student to individually search for universities, avoiding agents who will offer you a complete package, which sometimes is not a satisfaction,' said Ackermann.
These packages often include admission, visa paperwork, accommodation and job placements—but not always reliably.
Divya Singh, advocate at Jotwani Associates, said the warning is rooted in rising cases of fraud, document misrepresentation and legal problems faced by students who went through agents.
Ajay Khatalawala, managing partner at Little & Co, added, 'This guidance is meant to assist students in taking educated decisions and avoiding any pitfalls associated with relying solely on third-party intermediaries. While such services may look handy, they frequently lack transparency and dependability essential for successful admission and settlement in a foreign academic setting.'
What could go wrong?
Khatalawala said some agents do not provide accurate details about visa rules, university accreditation or part-time work regulations. In some cases, students arrive in Germany to discover their chosen institutions are not recognised for long-term study or visa renewal.
'For instance, a student enrols through such a package, realises upon arriving in Germany that the institution was not eligible for visa renewal, resulting in an early termination of his stay,' he said. 'While the student might not be prosecuted, he experiences significant inconvenience and financial loss.'
Fake documents and visa delays
In 2022, Ackermann had pointed out that nearly 15% of Indian student visa applicants submitted fake documents. 'We have to ensure that only the deserving students go to Germany,' he said.
At present, thousands of Indian students are awaiting visas to start academic courses in Germany. 'We are very unhappy about the current situation. It is a big concern for us, because we want Indians to get visas smoothly and quickly,' Ackermann said, calling the delays 'heart-breaking'.
Divya Singh listed the legal and immigration-related risks of working with such agents:
1. Lack of accreditation or regulation
Most agents are not authorised by any academic or immigration body.
There is no legal oversight on the services they offer.
2. Misrepresentation and forged documents
Some agents submit fake admission letters or altered academic records.
Forgery is a criminal offence under Section 267 of the German Criminal Code, with penalties including fines and jail.
3. Visa rejection and deportation
Students presenting false papers risk visa refusal or deportation at the border.
German immigration officers can detain and return individuals upon arrival.
5. No legal recourse
Most such agents do not offer contracts or refunds.
Victims of fraud often have no legal remedy.
For instance, in mid-2023, Indian students using a consultancy in Punjab were detained at Frankfurt airport. Their admission letters were either fake or from unrecognised institutions.
Families had paid between ₹4 and ₹8 lakh each for the process. Students were deported, blacklisted in the Schengen system, and left in debt.
What Indian students should do instead
Legal experts recommend the following steps:
Apply only through official university websites or DAAD (German Academic Exchange Service)
Check that the institution is recognised in official accreditation databases
Consult the German Embassy or certified education counsellors
Avoid agents who offer job guarantees or 'package deals'
'Unless there is deliberate misbehaviour, most students are unlikely to face criminal charges,' said Khatalawala. 'However, immigration consequences such as non-renewal of residence permits or restrictions on future applications remain serious.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Wire
an hour ago
- The Wire
‘India's Richest Families' Guilty of ‘Profiteering' From Russian Oil: US Treasury Secretary
New Delhi: 'Some of India's richest families' are involved in the country's 'unacceptable' 'profiteering' from buying and reselling Russian crude, a Trump cabinet official said on Tuesday (August 19), indicating no let up in the US's stance against New Delhi's continued purchases of oil from Moscow. US treasury secretary Scott Bessent's remarks also came a day after senior White House trade adviser and economist Peter Navarro wrote in a newspaper column that the proceeds from India's purchases of Russian oil – which he said are unbecoming of an American strategic partner – 'flow to India's politically connected energy titans, and in turn, into Vladimir Putin's war chest'. Recalling in an interview to CNBC that Russian crude went from constituting less than 1% of Indian oil imports just before Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine to around 40% today, Bessent said that India 'is just profiteering'. 'So India is just profiteering … they're reselling, they've made $16 billion in excess profits, some of the richest families in India,' said Bessent, whose role is roughly equivalent to that of finance minister. India's 'arbitrage' in 'buying cheap Russian oil' and 'reselling it as [a] product has just sprung up during the war, which is unacceptable', he continued. Earlier this month, US President Donald Trump announced a 25% 'penalty' tariff on India – on top of an existing 25% 'reciprocal' levy – in response to its sustained purchases of Russian oil despite Moscow's continued aggression against Ukraine. New Delhi termed the penalty, which is scheduled to take effect on August 27, 'extremely unfortunate', saying it was being singled out 'for actions that several other countries are also taking in their own national interest'. When asked in the CNBC interview if China – which is the biggest importer of Russian oil ahead of India but does not face a penalty for its purchases – was not also in the wrong, Bessent said that what Beijing is doing is a 'completely different thing'. 'Well, let's go back and look at the history though … China importing is suboptimal. If you go back and look pre-'22, pre-invasion, 13% of China's oil was already coming from Russia. Now it's 16%. So China has diversified input of their oil,' he said. The treasury secretary's remarks lambasting the 'richest families in India' – Mukesh Ambani's Reliance along with the Russian-owned Nayara are the the largest buyers of Russian oil in India – come a day after Navarro wrote that the surge in India's imports of Moscow's crude 'has not been driven by domestic oil consumption needs' but by 'profiteering by India's Big Oil lobby'. Ambani had also met Trump ahead of his inauguration in January as well as at a state dinner organised for the president in Qatar by its Emir Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani. 'The refiners buy oil at a steep discount, process it and then export refined fuels to Europe, Africa and Asia – all the while shielding India from sanctions scrutiny under the pretence of neutrality … The proceeds flow to India's politically connected energy titans, and in turn, into Vladimir Putin's war chest,' he wrote in an op-ed in the Financial Times. Going on to call India's reliance on Russian oil 'opportunistic and deeply corrosive of the world's efforts to isolate Putin's war economy', Navarro declared that if India 'wants to be treated as a strategic partner of the US, it needs to start acting like one'. New Delhi, which maintains that its purchases of oil are guided by market considerations, said upon Trump's announcing his intention to ratchet up tariffs against India for its purchases of Russian crude that after the Ukraine war began, the US 'actively encouraged such imports by India for strengthening global energy markets' stability'. When Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin met in Alaska to discuss an end to the conflict, the Ministry of External Affairs said it 'appreciates the progress made' in the two leaders' summit.
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
Meet Krishangi Meshram – The 21-Year-Old Indian-Origin Youngest Solicitor In UK
New Delhi: Indian-origin law graduate Krishangi Meshram has become one of the youngest solicitors in England and Wales at just 21. Born in West Bengal and raised in the ISKCON Mayapur community, she presently resides in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). She started her legal studies at The Open University in Milton Keynes at the age of 15 and completed her degree with First Class Honours in Law by 18, becoming the youngest law graduate in the university's history. Talking about her journey, she said, 'I am incredibly thankful that The Open University gave me the opportunity to begin my LLB studies at the age of 15. It was during my studies that I not only laid the academic foundation for my legal career but also discovered a deep and lasting passion for the law.' The Open University highlighted her achievement in a feature this week titled 'Law grad Krishangi makes history once again'. Meshram completed her secondary education at an international school in Mayapur before enrolling in her law degree. She earned LLB in just three years, paving the way for her early entry into the legal profession. In 2022, she joined an international law firm and has since expanded her legal knowledge through global programmes at Harvard Online and professional experience in Singapore. Her interests span fintech, blockchain, artificial intelligence and private client services, including wills and probate. She aims to provide specialised legal services to both businesses and individual clients. Looking ahead, Meshram intends to work with top law firms in the United Kingdom or the UAE, focusing on emerging digital technologies and client-focused legal solutions.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Visa Chaos, Harvard Shock & Canada Cap: What's Next for Indian Students Abroad?
Visa clampdowns, fake documents, and even Harvard's shock move—global education is shifting fast. Where does that leave Indian students? From CBSE vs IB competitiveness to whether Canada is still worth it, and if Asia is the new frontier, Namita Mehta, President and Partner, The Red Pen, breaks it all down. We dive into ROI across US, UK, Europe, and Canada, the misinformation crisis in visas, and the real opportunities in Ireland, Netherlands, and beyond. This is your essential guide to navigating the new study abroad landscape.
