logo
Why bonus points may not be all that useful in deciding rugby competitions

Why bonus points may not be all that useful in deciding rugby competitions

Irish Times13-05-2025

The business end of the rugby season has arrived and the English Premiership and
United Rugby Championship
tables, as ever, are being carefully scrutinised. Two from Bristol, Sale and Saracens are now vying to make the Premiership playoffs with two games left while the race for the URC top eight will boil down to the final weekend.
At which point some know-all will intone the well-worn mantra: bonus points will be crucial. And we'll all nod solemnly and start contemplating how Team X or Team Y can best set about scoring either four tries or losing by seven points or fewer. Without necessarily stopping to think whether the cold, hard mathematics support that supposition – or indeed ever have done.
If you go and consult Dr Ellie Nesbitt, a senior lecturer in sports management at Nottingham Trent University, a very different picture emerges. Having crunched the Premiership numbers for the past 25 years, she found bonus points made a major difference to – wait for it – just 2.28 per cent of team positions in the 24 seasons in which they have previously featured. 'Bonus points are not quite irrelevant but they're definitely not making the impact they were probably designed to do,' she says.
Hang on. That hard-earned losing away point in the rain at Sale? That valiant fourth try in the dying seconds against Bath? It turns out they barely count in the wider scheme of things. Nesbitt discovered that a whopping 92 per cent of Premiership league placings were totally unaffected by their inclusion.
READ MORE
No fewer than 10 of those aforementioned 24 Premiership seasons would have ended up with precisely the same league table had bonus points not been included. And in the 8 per cent of occasions where teams would have finished in another position, it still made little material difference in terms of playoff or
Champions Cup
qualification.
Which, for the curious-minded Nesbitt, prompts wider questions. Hailing from a football background, she only became interested in rugby union because her partner was playing at Burton RFC. Watching his team constantly looking for bonus points set her analytical brain whirring.
'Even in their league they chase them. But then I looked at the data and told them: 'It didn't make any difference.' I take the caveat that it potentially creates more of a spectacle but at the end of a season the difference is so marginal. So then you start to question it. 'What is the point of all of this? Is it time for a refresh?' For me it warrants a look at the effectiveness of bonus points. But no one in rugby union seems to be bothered that they're not making an impact.'
It is a fair cop. Take Sale who have claimed only nine bonus points – the second-lowest in the league – and still sit in the top four. What will almost certainly determine their final placing in relation to the Bears, as ever, will be their respective number of wins. It is more than possible the Sharks will finish ahead of Bristol with seven fewer bonus points. So much for attacking rugby paying extra dividends.
But let's open our minds up beyond decimal points. Nesbitt's research around competitive balance, incorporated last year into the Leonard Curtis financial report on English club rugby, invites us to contemplate a landscape totally free of such added complications. What if even the slightly tweaked French system – a bonus point for scoring at least three more tries than the opposition – is a hareng rouge?
Because what if the extra layer of complexity, rather than enticing more people to enjoy the sport, is actively diluting rugby union's popularity? 'It's weird to me that bonus points only really exist in rugby,' says Nesbitt, suggesting football's relative simplicity is not an insignificant part of its appeal. 'Rugby has so many layers that it's difficult to get into. And when something is difficult to get into – whether that's sport, music or history – people switch off. I don't think rugby has helped itself over the years.'
She also wonders aloud if playoff semi-finals represent another well-intentioned idea that might have had its day. The team finishing either first or second in the regular season has gone on to win the Premiership 20 times out of the past 22 editions. Nesbitt's logical academic brain tells her it would be much simpler to save everyone a ton of hassle and just stage a final between the top two sides.
Looking further ahead, she argues, the league also needs to work out who, exactly, it is trying to please. At present, amid plans to launch a franchise Premiership model in autumn 2026, she suggests it is being hampered by blurred vision. 'The reason why a franchise system works in America is because they also have the draft and a salary cap. Rugby union seems to have this half European, half American approach but it doesn't seem to work for them either way.'
Rather than using bonus points as a comfort blanket, accordingly, her analysis points to a more equitable spread of talent and spending power across the league as being more important. 'The issue with rugby union is that the same patterns occur each year because no changes are made. What are your motivations? What do you want from the league?
'If they want to make it a spectacle and make people excited about rugby, I have no doubt the franchise approach could do that. But it is not necessarily going to fix all their problems.' Plenty for us all to ponder, whether you love bonus points or not, before this season's final push. – Guardian

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Referee is unimpressed' – England vs Senegal DELAYED with Three Lions stars forced to wait in tunnel for visitors
‘Referee is unimpressed' – England vs Senegal DELAYED with Three Lions stars forced to wait in tunnel for visitors

The Irish Sun

time3 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

‘Referee is unimpressed' – England vs Senegal DELAYED with Three Lions stars forced to wait in tunnel for visitors

ENGLAND'S friendly with Senegal kicked off late - because the visitors were late out of the dressing room. The clash at the City Ground in Nottingham was due to get underway at 7.45pm. 2 England vs Senegal kicked off five minutes later than planned Credit: AFP 2 Senegal took an age coming out of the dressing room However, Nicolas Jackson got things underway at 7.50pm. And that was due to Pape Thiaw's team taking too long to come out and line up in the tunnel. ITV commentator Sam Matterface was describing the action live on TV. He said: "Welcome to the City Ground in Nottingham where we await the arrival of the Senegalese players who have eventually been coaxed out of the dressing room by French official Stephanie Frappart. "Three-and-a-half minutes after they were supposed to emerge." THIS IS A DEVELOPING STORY.. The Sun is your go to destination for the best football, boxing and MMA news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video . Like us on Facebook at

World Cup winner's son, 21, following his dad's footsteps as he's fast-tracked into England squad after just 10 games
World Cup winner's son, 21, following his dad's footsteps as he's fast-tracked into England squad after just 10 games

The Irish Sun

time5 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

World Cup winner's son, 21, following his dad's footsteps as he's fast-tracked into England squad after just 10 games

A RUGBY WORLD CUP winner's son is following in his dad's footsteps with an England call-up. Kyran Bracken, 53, played 51 times for the Red Rose between 1993 and 2003. Advertisement 5 Kyran Bracken, right, helped England win the 2003 World Cup Credit: PA 5 The Dublin-born back made four of his 51 England caps at the tournament Credit: Getty 5 His son Charlie Bracken has been named in the England training squad Credit: Getty His final cap was the 2003 World Cup semi-final against France. That was his fourth appearance in Australia during the six-week - which also included featuring against Wales in the quarters. The scrum-half was an unused substitute in the final against Australia - But he did Advertisement READ MORE ON RUGBY And now his son is hoping to have the same impact for his country. Charlie Bracken is one of 16 uncapped players named in England's latest training squad. The 21-year-old - who like his father plays at scrum-half - will hope to get his chance to shine in the summer tour of Argentina and the USA. England also face a France XV at Twickenham on June 21. Advertisement Most read in Rugby Union CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS Bracken Jr has played at junior level for England, including at Under-20s, but has been given a fast-track route into the senior camp. The Saracens rising star - whose brother Jack is an up-and-coming winger - has just ten Premiership appearances under his belt. Shocking moment enormous brawl breaks out in rubgy league after 'horrendous hit' But Steve Borthwick is impressed and feels as though he has seen enough to give the youngster a shot amongst the senior internationals. Advertisement The squad for the upcoming tours will be confirmed on June 23. But the training camp met today and will train together until Friday. However, no Bath or Leicester Tigers players were included due to their Premiership final on June 14. And it also excluded the England men named in the Advertisement 5 Bracken is making a name for himself at Saracens Credit: Getty 5 Both Kyran and Charlie play at scrum-half Credit: Getty

Man Utd stars to make Soccer Aid history as record number of Old Trafford legends sign up for huge celebrity match
Man Utd stars to make Soccer Aid history as record number of Old Trafford legends sign up for huge celebrity match

The Irish Sun

time8 hours ago

  • The Irish Sun

Man Utd stars to make Soccer Aid history as record number of Old Trafford legends sign up for huge celebrity match

MANCHESTER UNITED are making history once again, by having a record number of former stars playing in Soccer Aid. This year, Soccer Aid is being hosted at Old Trafford, where reigning champions England will take on the Soccer Aid World XI in the globe's biggest charity match. 7 Wayne Rooney is leading a record-breaking contingent of former Man Utd stars appearing at Soccer Aid this year Credit: Rex 7 He will be joined on team England's side by Gary Neville Credit: PA 7 Paul Scholes will also line up for the Three Lions in the charity match Credit: Reuters 7 Meanwhile, Peter Schmeichel will be barking orders from the touchline as manager of the World XI Credit: Getty But it will feel like a homecoming for many of the top stars on the billing following their careers, which saw them playing at the Red Devils' home for many years. As many as NINE former The ex-pros include many stars who have tried their hand at coaching and management, such as Wayne Rooney and Michael Carrick, and others who are now household names in punditry, like Gary Neville or Paul Scholes. That quartet will be lining up for team READ MORE IN FOOTBALL Meanwhile, the World XI will have their own share of Man Utd greats in their ranks. Edwin van der Sar, Nemanja Vidic, John O'Shea, and Carlos Tevez will all be taking to the pitch, while legendary goalkeeper The ex-stars will also be joined by a sizeable contingent of celebrity Man Utd fans. Among them will be businessman Most read in Football Join SUN CLUB for the Man Utd Files every Thursday plus in-depth coverage and exclusives from Old Trafford Despite this large contingent of Man Utd support, there will be a notable absence of super fan While appearing in Soccer Aid last year, the legendary Olympic sprinter ruptured his Achilles and was stretchered off the field. Sam Thompson reveals Soccer Aid appearance is hanging by a thread - and horrifying after-effects of 260 mile bike ride Soccer Aid 2024 broke records as it raised over £15million for Unicef, while it has raised more than £100m since it was founded by Robbie Williams in 2006. The match will be available to watch for free on ITV1, ITVX and STV on June 15, kicking off at 7.30pm BST. If you wish to buy tickets, starting from £10.50 for concessions and £21 for adults, find out how here. You can donate to Soccer Aid by clicking the 7 Rooney will be joining Man Utd fan and boxer Tyson Fury as a coach Credit: PA 7 A number of Red Devils fans are playing in the event, including content creator AngryGinge Credit: PA 7 There will be a notable absence of Man Utd fan Usain Bolt after he ruptured his Achilles playing last year Credit: Getty England team and coaching staff Here is a look at the full team for England for Soccer Aid 2025... Team: Steven Bartlett (Entrepreneur) Alex Brooker (TV personality) Jermain Defoe (Former footballer) Toni Duggan (Former footballer) Angry Ginge (YouTuber) Tom Grennan (Musician) Bear Grylls (TV personality) Joe Hart (Former footballer) Steph Houghton (Former footballer) Aaron Lennon (Former footballer) Dame Denise Lewis (Olympic gold medallist) Paddy McGuinness (TV personality) Sir Mo Farah (Former Olympian) Gary Neville (Former footballer) Sam Quek (Former hockey player/TV personality) Wayne Rooney (Former footballer and manager) Paul Scholes (Former footballer) Jill Scott (Former footballer) Sam Thompson (King of the Jungle) Louis Tomlinson (Musician) Michael Carrick (Former footballer) Phil Jagielka (Former footballer) Roman Kemp (Radio host) Jack Wilshere (Former footballer) Bella Ramsey (Actor) Coaches: Wayne Rooney (Former footballer and manager) Tyson Fury (Boxer) Harry Redknapp (Former football manager) Vicky McClure (Actor) Goalkeeping coach: David James (Former footballer) World XI team and coaching staff Here is a look at the full team for the World XI for Soccer Aid 2025... Team: Tony Bellew (Former boxer) Leonardo Bonucci (Former footballer) Tobi Brown (YouTube star) Martin Compston (Actor) Richard Gadd (Actor) Bryan Habana (Former rugby star) Dermot Kennedy (Musician) Kaylyn Kyle (Former footballer) Gorka Marquez (Dancer) Nadia Nadim (Footballer) Livi Sheldon (Gladiators star) Edwin van der Sar (Former footballer) Nemanja Vidic (Former footballer) Harry Kewell (Former footballer) Big Zuu (YouTube star) Noah Beck (Actor) Carlos Tevez (Former footballer) Billy Wingrove (Football freestyler) Robbie Keane (Former footballer) John O'Shea (Former footballer) Maisie Adam (Comedian) David Trezeguet (Former footballer) Nicky Byrne (Singer) Kheira Hamraoui (Former footballer) Manager: Peter Schmeichel (Former footballer) Soccer Aid stats SOCCER AID has been played since 2006. It started out as a biennial event but since 2018 it has been played every year. The match is between England and a World XI. Who is the Who has Who is Soccer Aid founder Who is What do the How much What is MAN UTD TRANSFER NEWS LIVE: All the latest deals and rumours from Old Trafford

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store