Why bonus points may not be all that useful in deciding rugby competitions
The business end of the rugby season has arrived and the English Premiership and
United Rugby Championship
tables, as ever, are being carefully scrutinised. Two from Bristol, Sale and Saracens are now vying to make the Premiership playoffs with two games left while the race for the URC top eight will boil down to the final weekend.
At which point some know-all will intone the well-worn mantra: bonus points will be crucial. And we'll all nod solemnly and start contemplating how Team X or Team Y can best set about scoring either four tries or losing by seven points or fewer. Without necessarily stopping to think whether the cold, hard mathematics support that supposition – or indeed ever have done.
If you go and consult Dr Ellie Nesbitt, a senior lecturer in sports management at Nottingham Trent University, a very different picture emerges. Having crunched the Premiership numbers for the past 25 years, she found bonus points made a major difference to – wait for it – just 2.28 per cent of team positions in the 24 seasons in which they have previously featured. 'Bonus points are not quite irrelevant but they're definitely not making the impact they were probably designed to do,' she says.
Hang on. That hard-earned losing away point in the rain at Sale? That valiant fourth try in the dying seconds against Bath? It turns out they barely count in the wider scheme of things. Nesbitt discovered that a whopping 92 per cent of Premiership league placings were totally unaffected by their inclusion.
READ MORE
No fewer than 10 of those aforementioned 24 Premiership seasons would have ended up with precisely the same league table had bonus points not been included. And in the 8 per cent of occasions where teams would have finished in another position, it still made little material difference in terms of playoff or
Champions Cup
qualification.
Which, for the curious-minded Nesbitt, prompts wider questions. Hailing from a football background, she only became interested in rugby union because her partner was playing at Burton RFC. Watching his team constantly looking for bonus points set her analytical brain whirring.
'Even in their league they chase them. But then I looked at the data and told them: 'It didn't make any difference.' I take the caveat that it potentially creates more of a spectacle but at the end of a season the difference is so marginal. So then you start to question it. 'What is the point of all of this? Is it time for a refresh?' For me it warrants a look at the effectiveness of bonus points. But no one in rugby union seems to be bothered that they're not making an impact.'
It is a fair cop. Take Sale who have claimed only nine bonus points – the second-lowest in the league – and still sit in the top four. What will almost certainly determine their final placing in relation to the Bears, as ever, will be their respective number of wins. It is more than possible the Sharks will finish ahead of Bristol with seven fewer bonus points. So much for attacking rugby paying extra dividends.
But let's open our minds up beyond decimal points. Nesbitt's research around competitive balance, incorporated last year into the Leonard Curtis financial report on English club rugby, invites us to contemplate a landscape totally free of such added complications. What if even the slightly tweaked French system – a bonus point for scoring at least three more tries than the opposition – is a hareng rouge?
Because what if the extra layer of complexity, rather than enticing more people to enjoy the sport, is actively diluting rugby union's popularity? 'It's weird to me that bonus points only really exist in rugby,' says Nesbitt, suggesting football's relative simplicity is not an insignificant part of its appeal. 'Rugby has so many layers that it's difficult to get into. And when something is difficult to get into – whether that's sport, music or history – people switch off. I don't think rugby has helped itself over the years.'
She also wonders aloud if playoff semi-finals represent another well-intentioned idea that might have had its day. The team finishing either first or second in the regular season has gone on to win the Premiership 20 times out of the past 22 editions. Nesbitt's logical academic brain tells her it would be much simpler to save everyone a ton of hassle and just stage a final between the top two sides.
Looking further ahead, she argues, the league also needs to work out who, exactly, it is trying to please. At present, amid plans to launch a franchise Premiership model in autumn 2026, she suggests it is being hampered by blurred vision. 'The reason why a franchise system works in America is because they also have the draft and a salary cap. Rugby union seems to have this half European, half American approach but it doesn't seem to work for them either way.'
Rather than using bonus points as a comfort blanket, accordingly, her analysis points to a more equitable spread of talent and spending power across the league as being more important. 'The issue with rugby union is that the same patterns occur each year because no changes are made. What are your motivations? What do you want from the league?
'If they want to make it a spectacle and make people excited about rugby, I have no doubt the franchise approach could do that. But it is not necessarily going to fix all their problems.' Plenty for us all to ponder, whether you love bonus points or not, before this season's final push. – Guardian
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
British & Irish Lions calm fears over Tadhg Furlong's fitness for Australia tour
The British & Irish Lions have insisted they have no fitness concerns over the veteran tighthead prop Tadhg Furlong and have revealed he and other Premiership and URC finalists will be considered for their opening match against Argentina in Dublin next Friday. Furlong, who has started the last nine Lions Tests, has not played for his province since early May due to a calf injury, prompting fears over his availability for the Australia tour. Zander Fagerson withdrew from the squad on Monday, leaving options at tighthead severely limited. Ireland's Finlay Bealham has been called up to replace Fagerson and with Bath's Will Stuart preparing for the Premiership final against Leicester on Saturday, Sale's 20-year-old Asher Opoku-Fordjour has been called up to the Lions' Portugal training camp. He and Jamie George – another called up for the week in the Algarve – are among 24 players at Andy Farrell's disposal with Bath, Leicester, Leinster and Toulouse players focused on club commitments. The Lions forwards coach, John Dalziel, delivered positive news on Duhan van der Merwe, Huw Jones and Mack Hansen, who have been injured recently, and was quick to allay fears over Furlong. Farrell was expected to select the team to face Argentina from the 24 in Portugal, but Dalziel was adamant that club finalists will be considered. 'Tadhg has the availability to be able to train and play this week with Leinster,' he said. 'There are no real concerns in terms of his ability to come back to full training. Tadhg had returned to play and was playing. He's now being modified in terms of [being] off-feet in the last few weeks. We've got no real concerns [around] when he comes back to full training and playing. 'We will put our best team and our best foot forward for Argentina, with everybody available the squad will be together on Sunday, everybody in after the finals, then we will select and prepare that team that week. We will get some structures in place here, some language and some learning with the wider group, then we will arrive back in Dublin on Sunday with everyone and prepare for Argentina.' Dalziel also revealed that Fagerson, who toured South Africa with the Lions in 2021, may return to the squad when fit. 'He'll become available at the right time and when he's ready should we need him again. His injury isn't long term. I think it's three or four weeks. It's a setback. He's looking to try and get through that. As soon as he gets the tick off, he'll be available to come back into the squad should needs must.' The Lions arrived in Portugal on Tuesday after convening in Dublin the day before and after a high-octane gym session at the Campus resort on Wednesday, Farrell will run the rule over his players with two training sessions on Thursday and Friday. During their free time, players have been kept entertained by the golf courses and padel courts while Henry Pollock is now in official possession of BiL, the Lions' mascot, traditionally the responsibility of the youngest member of the squad. He was presented with the toy lion by Maro Itoje, this year's captain, who had the honour in 2017. 'The connection piece in modern sport is so important,' said Dalziel. 'Just the way the lads have integrated with the coaches, it's been so pleasing. Everyone has their own personality, but it's excellent to see guys you've previewed, and have been a thorn in your side, you can use them now.' Meanwhile, Australia's star turn Joseph Suaalii has declared himself fit for the series after recovering from a broken jaw. The 21-year-old signing from rugby league – who starred on his debut against England at Twickenham last November – was injured last month. 'My face was really big for a bit, I was wearing a face mask everywhere,' he said. 'It's such an important time for myself and Australian rugby and I want to be playing, so obviously I was a little bit of nerves but … I had surgery maybe three weeks ago now and looking good going into the Lions.' England have called Henry Arundell into camp this week as they prepare for a clash with a France XV at Twickenham on Saturday week before a tour of Argentina and the US. Arundell, who joins Bath next season, has endured a torrid season with Racing 92 but, given his impending move back to the Premiership, Borthwick has called up the 22-year-old speedster for the first time in 20 months. Guardian
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Bulls stalwart Willie le Roux urges teammates to seize moment in Croke Park showdown with Leinster
There is a temptation to describe Willie le Roux's thoughts on Saturday's URC final at Croke Park as bullish, but a fairer expression is forthright. The Bulls have come to play and to win. The 35-year-old fullback has never shirked a confrontation on the pitch. He is occasionally spiky, but with that temperament comes a player of sublime attacking instincts. When the Bulls beat Leinster in last year's URC semi-final at Loftus Versfeld Stadium in Pretoria, Le Roux helped pick the Irish province apart with his cross-field punting. It is his running game, though, for which the double World Cup-winning Springbok is acclaimed. He has never shied away from a counterattack, irrespective of field position. It is a course of action that carries its own tariff when things go awry. He preaches this gospel, especially to younger players. 'The bit of advice I can give younger guys is that it (a final) is the same as playing the first game of the season,' he said. 'It's not to put this (final) on a pedestal and make it that much bigger that you go into your shell, you don't want to try stuff, you don't want to run from your own half and you don't want to try something. READ MORE 'That is not what got us here in the first place. We got here through taking chances. We see an opportunity, we take it. That is what you must do in those big games as well, whether you make a mistake or not. It's about putting yourself out there, putting yourself in the battle. You must be able to pull the trigger and take that because you might not get a lot of chances — Willie Le Roux 'You might lose a few battles, but you might also win. That's just the little things that I tell the guys. Try and ask for the ball, get your hands on the ball and do as much as you can. You might lose a few battles but it's about getting back up and putting yourself into as many as you can. And have no doubts.' He pointed to the disparate strengths of players and the importance of not being overwhelmed by the occasion. 'You shouldn't wait,' said Le Roux. 'If you're a winger, you don't wait outside on the wing to get the ball; you come in and you work off your wing and you get your hands on the ball as much as you can, because it doesn't help not putting yourself into battles.' Bongi Mbonambi of the Sharks tackles the Bulls' Willie le Roux during last weekend's URC semi-final in Pretoria. Photograph: Steve Haag Sports/Inpho/Christiaan Kotze In continuing the theme, Le Roux spoke about the fine line in game management when it comes to putting the team in the right areas of the pitch and being swift in the decision-making process. 'I think the balance is knowing when to attack and when to kick,' he said. 'In these types of games, you might only get one or two [opportunities]. That might be a turnover on your try line and that is the time to take your chance. 'It might be in the first minute. You must be able to pull the trigger and take that because you might not get a lot of chances.' Le Roux emphasised the importance of players making decisions on the pitch. 'You've got a senior group making the calls. It's about making the right calls at the right times, the plays: 'Should we go [for the] posts? Should we go for a lineout?' Do you feel you have them under pressure or do you feel they have the pressure on you? 'So, it's a big thing about making the right calls at the right times as well, and taking chances. And I think that it's a good core group of guys making decisions on the field together, knowing the roles, knowing when to do what. 'I think we are very tight as a group and we understand what our plan is. You can't not go out there, put a smile on your face and go enjoy it on the biggest stage. So, yeah, we're looking forward to it.' [ Six of the best games between Leinster and Bulls ahead of URC final Opens in new window ] The Bulls, who have lost two finals in three years, are hoping it's third time lucky at Croke Park. Scratch that. They are not going to be paralysed by the pressure to end that sequence. It is not a hope thing. Le Roux points to a simple focus, to embrace and enjoy the experience and play for your brothers, one of whom is missing but not forgotten. He played alongside Cornal Hendricks in several teams . Hendricks, who died of a heart attack last month aged 37, was a friend as much as a teammate. 'He would light up a room when he walked in,' said Le Roux. The Bulls might have taken a little umbrage with the phrase 'mission impossible', which has been used in some quarters to describe Saturday's assignment. Bolstered by a strong belief in their ability, uncertainty shouldn't be a factor. Leinster know that from past experiences.
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Finlay Bealham will be a great fit for the group – Lions head coach Andy Farrell
British and Irish Lions head coach Andy Farrell believes replacement call-up Finlay Bealham will prove a "great fit" for the squad following the "heartbreaking" withdrawal of injured Scotland prop Zander Fagerson. Glasgow Warriors tight head Fagerson has been ruled out of the summer tour to Australia by a calf problem. The news of Fagerson's withdrawal came a day before the squad – minus those involved in the Premiership and United Rugby Championship finals – headed out to Portugal for a training camp. Farrell, though, accepts such situations are part of the game, with the group now looking to sharpen focus towards a warm-up fixture against Argentina in Dublin on 20 June. "It is heartbreaking, but at the same time, he (Fagerson) is a realist. All rugby players know that's the game," Farrell told Sky Sports. "He will work unbelievably hard to get himself fit and who knows what's going to happen down the track." On Bealham, who moved to Ireland from Australia aged 18, being added to the squad, Farrell said: "Finlay has been called up in his place and he is in good form. He is very good at what he does. "He was certainly right up there in the conversation from the very start as well, and he would have been disappointed not to make the group. "So we just know he will be a great fit for the group going forward. He is the only conversation that I was able to have because of the way we did the squad announcement. "By giving him a phone call and telling him he was selected within the squad, unfortunately for Zander, but it was one of the best phone conversations I have ever had. "The emotion that went through the phone actually welled me up. It was great to be able to do that." With 15 of the selected players still on club duty – including 12 from Leinster – England duo Jamie George and Asher Opoku-Fordjour have also joined the five-day training camp at Quinta do Lago to provide some front-row cover. "It is what it is," said Farrell. "You've just got to be open-minded enough to see what you end up with – what we have ended up with is a squad of 24. "It is a new group that has come together for the first time, so to keep it small and tight gives plenty of time in this five-day camp for people to get in the saddle and get up to speed with new systems, a new way of playing. "We will see what we need to add to the squad in the coming weeks." The fixture against Argentina is set to be a first Lions game played in Ireland. The tour of Australia schedule – which features three Tests against the Wallabies – begins against Western Force in Perth on 28 June.
