Lord of the Rings says burger chain name shall not pass
The rights holder of the Lord of the Rings novels and films, Middle-earth Enterprises, has launched another attack to take its precious title.
It follows an unsuccessful bid in March, where the franchise attempted to block an Australian vegan hamburger chain from trademarking the words "Lord of the" in its name.
Lord of the Fries has been selling items under its name since 2004 and sought to offer plant-based macaroni and cheese under the trademark in 2022.
The case came before a registrar of trademarks in the federal government agency, IP Australia.
Middle-earth argued it had been successful in other similar trademark applications made globally, and used the mark to sell various items including boardgames, clothing and toys.
But Lord of the Fries said there were many examples of similar marks including Lord of the Pies and the business operated as a niche in an entirely different reputation to the Middle-earth franchise.
The registrar delegate, Nicholas Smith, found the names were not deceptively similar and that Middle-earth had cherry-picked evidence in suggesting the connection.
The matter has since been escalated to Sydney's Federal Court, after Middle-earth's lawyers filed an appeal against the IP Australia decision on March 25.
The grounds for appeal were many and varied, the franchise's lawyer Shauna Ross told Justice Michael Lee.
"My client's case is that Your Honour find the mark should be refused," she said on Thursday.
The grounds for appeal included that Lord of the Fries does not own the trademark and that the IP Australia decision was adverse to Middle-earth, who is the true owner of the mark, Ms Ross said.
Justice Lee ordered both parties attend a mediation before June 20.
If the case is not resolved through mediation, Justice Lee said he would assign the matter to a referee, who would then prepare a report for the decision.
"The reality is I don't have time to look at this matter this year," he said.
Lord of the Fries and Middle-earth Enterprises have been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
What's the government doing about autistic children? We explain the changes
The National Disability Insurance Scheme has been an important piece of Australian social policy since it launched in 2013. It was designed to give people with significant permanent disabilities greater choice and control over their lives, and that's what it has done. But it's also evolved in ways that governments didn't see coming. The NDIS was to be jointly funded by states and the federal government but was not meant to entirely replace disability services. Nonetheless, those services soon dried up, and the federal government was left on the hook for cost blowouts. Before long, the NDIS was the only option for thousands of people with a disability – including children. It started growing at more than 20 per cent a year, putting significant pressure on the budget. Now the Albanese government wants to restore the scheme to its original purpose so that it retains support and remains in place for future generations. But this will involve tightening eligibility rules for who can access NDIS support – something that worries many families who have come to rely on it. What are the NDIS changes? Health and Disability Minister Mark Butler gave a significant speech to the National Press Club on Wednesday, outlining the challenges facing the $46 billion scheme. He pointed out that it was set to cost $105 billion each year within the decade, and risked losing its social licence. Loading Butler outlined two major reforms. First, slowing its growth trajectory. At a national cabinet meeting in 2023, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and state leaders agreed to bring down NDIS growth to 8 per cent a year by the middle of 2026. On Wednesday, Butler said he wanted to limit growth further – to 5 or 6 per cent a year within four years. The second major change builds on a second outcome of that 2023 meeting, when the state and federal governments agreed to set up a system, called 'foundational supports'. This would cater to disabled people who need help but not at the intense level the NDIS was designed for.
The Age
an hour ago
- The Age
What's the government doing about autistic children? We explain the changes
The National Disability Insurance Scheme has been an important piece of Australian social policy since it launched in 2013. It was designed to give people with significant permanent disabilities greater choice and control over their lives, and that's what it has done. But it's also evolved in ways that governments didn't see coming. The NDIS was to be jointly funded by states and the federal government but was not meant to entirely replace disability services. Nonetheless, those services soon dried up, and the federal government was left on the hook for cost blowouts. Before long, the NDIS was the only option for thousands of people with a disability – including children. It started growing at more than 20 per cent a year, putting significant pressure on the budget. Now the Albanese government wants to restore the scheme to its original purpose so that it retains support and remains in place for future generations. But this will involve tightening eligibility rules for who can access NDIS support – something that worries many families who have come to rely on it. What are the NDIS changes? Health and Disability Minister Mark Butler gave a significant speech to the National Press Club on Wednesday, outlining the challenges facing the $46 billion scheme. He pointed out that it was set to cost $105 billion each year within the decade, and risked losing its social licence. Loading Butler outlined two major reforms. First, slowing its growth trajectory. At a national cabinet meeting in 2023, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and state leaders agreed to bring down NDIS growth to 8 per cent a year by the middle of 2026. On Wednesday, Butler said he wanted to limit growth further – to 5 or 6 per cent a year within four years. The second major change builds on a second outcome of that 2023 meeting, when the state and federal governments agreed to set up a system, called 'foundational supports'. This would cater to disabled people who need help but not at the intense level the NDIS was designed for.
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
The end of a magical voyage: Disney Cruise Line pulls out of Australian waters
Mickey and Minnie Mouse on a Disney cruise ship. Picture: File By Sarah Falson Updated August 21 2025 - 2:18pm, first published 1:13pm Disney Cruise Line will cease operations in Australia and New Zealand after one final season as industry experts decry high operating costs for cruise ships in local waters. Subscribe now for unlimited access. or signup to continue reading All articles from our website The digital version of Today's Paper All other in your area Disney took to social media to announce the news, calling it a "farewell for now" for its Disney Wonder ship. Explore understands Disney has not ruled out bringing ships back to the region in the future. But for now, it's the end of an era when the 2025/2026 season concludes, only three years after setting sail for the first time in 2023 in Australia. Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA) managing director Australia, Joel Katz, indicated local cruising was facing an uncertain future without policy changes. "CLIA has consistently warned that the complex regulatory environment and high operating costs in Australia and New Zealand are putting the region at risk of losing cruise capacity to other markets," Mr Katz told Explore. "Demand for cruising remains strong internationally, however without action we risk losing valuable tourism revenue, jobs, and investment to countries with more competitive conditions." What customers need to know Cruiseabout general manager, Brad Kennedy, said no itineraries had been cancelled so all customers who had booked on the Disney Wonder for the 2025/2026 season would still be sailing as planned. He said the cruise line had been popular with multi-generational groups and families and though it was "disappointing" to see Disney relocate their ships, there were still many cruise lines that continue to service the Australian market like Royal Caribbean's Wiggles cruises. "Australia is one of the biggest source markets for cruise in the world and continues to grow. Aussies are used to having to fly somewhere for a holiday and we are seeing more and more choosing fly-cruise options," he said. The Disney Wonder. Picture: Supplied "Royal Caribbean have also recently announced the development of their own private island in the South Pacific, LeLepa. This investment and the development of such infrastructure shows the commitment from the world's largest cruise line to the region." Disney will be bringing its Disney Adventure - with the longest rollercoaster at sea - to Singapore for the first time from December 2025. Flight Centre Travel Group leisure CEO, James Kavanagh, said this would give cruisers another choice in the region, particularly with Asian airfares "pricing well". Cruising's future in Australia Mr Kavanagh said port operating costs were "certainly a key consideration" for cruise lines sailing in Australia, as was "ensuring ports can accommodate these bigger vessels that are being built". "With more support from the government for our cruise industry, we'll have a more accessible and open region for cruising, and a financially competitive environment for more cruise lines to invest in," he said. Helloworld Travel group general manager - cruise, Steve Brady, said Disney helped bring new-to-cruise customers into the market which was "a great thing for the cruise industry overall". The travel agency is working to help fill the final cabins in Australia. "Disney Cruise Line had a place in the market before Disney Wonder came to Australia, and they will have a place in the market going forward," he said. Words by Sarah Falson Sarah is ACM's travel producer. She believes regional travel is just as fun (if not better) than staying in the big cities and loves any travel experience to do with nature, animals and food!.My all-time favourite destination is ... Cornwall. From the giant seagulls to the blustery beaches, Cornish pasties and fishing villages, it stirs something romantic and seafaring in me. Next on my bucket list is … Mongolia. I want to go somewhere really unique that feels totally foreign and challenges my way of life. My top travel tip is … Don't plan too much. Walk the streets and let it happen. And make sure you check out what's within a few blocks of your hotel - sometimes the best local food is found that way.
