logo
The shuttering of Voice of America hurts our ability to explain ourselves

The shuttering of Voice of America hurts our ability to explain ourselves

The Hill05-05-2025
The Voice of America is off the air for the first time in 83 years. The Department of Government Efficiency or DOGE did it.
I understand the impetus behind DOGE. The U.S. is in peril of financial collapse due to decades of deficit spending. Something radical needed to be done. Some indiscriminate damage was unavoidable.
However, the Declaration of Independence, the first public diplomacy document of the U.S., was addressed out of ' a decent respect to the opinions of mankind ' to the entire world. That decent respect is what VOA was designed to show.
VOA is a creature born of war. It began in 1942 broadcasting in German, to explain to the German people what we were fighting for and against. It also gave Germans an accurate version of what was really happening in their totalitarian country.
Having lived and worked overseas, I am familiar with the distorted views of the U.S. that many people have formed, not only from foreign propaganda and disinformation, but from some American popular entertainment and the almost constant self-criticism in which the American people are engaged.
The latter is a sign of a healthy democracy and a source of our strength, but foreign audiences need to understand the broader framework within which this takes place. That is why the VOA Charter requires VOA to represent America in a balanced and comprehensive way. It is vitally important that VOA fosters an understanding of American institutions and the principles behind them. No less important is its essential charter obligation to ' present the policies of the United States clearly and effectively.'
I firmly believe that VOA should not be an echo chamber for American domestic media, which is already largely available overseas on the internet. This is the fault into which the newsroom fell. It has a different job. It should have been offering to audiences what was otherwise unavailable to them. Not operating under the constraints of commercial media, VOA can afford to tell the truth. That is its advantage.
The heart of VOA is not the newsroom, which has deserved the scathing criticism it has received from President Trump, but its 40 language services — the largest part of VOA that most people know nothing about.
Let me provide a small example of its hidden treasures. Harun Maruf is a member of VOA's Somali service. He has more than 170,000 followers on Twitter in Somalia. He co-authored the popular and powerful book, 'Inside Al Shabaab, the Secret History of Al-Qaeda's Most Powerful Ally.' This is the kind of expertise the VOA language services employ — or rather employed. Harun was sent home. The Farsi service to Iran has also been shut, just as the nuclear crisis heats up and as media censorship in that country increases. Isn't now exactly when we most need to reach the Iranian people?
My earliest stint as VOA director was in 2001-2002, a time when the agency was alive with a sense of purpose after the attacks of 9/11. Just as in 1942, we all knew how to support our country in a time of peril. It was an exciting place to work. It hummed.
Does anyone suppose that that was the last war for the United States? How will we reach our Chinese adversaries and our Asian allies when conflict breaks out there, as it is almost certain to do?
VOA's mission is to give voice to America, explain our purposes in the world and the justifications for our actions. 'VOA's job should be to advance the justice of the American cause, while simultaneously undermining our opponents',' I wrote in a 2017 Wall Street Journal essay.
The difference now, I'm sorry to say, is a loss of a sense of mission by certain elements of the agency, who have been led to believe that VOA is solely a news organization. It's not, though news is an integral and essential part of it. It also has the obligation to disclose the character of the American people and their institutions in such a way as the underlying principles guiding American life are revealed. News is a means but not an end.
Reliable news was always a part of U.S. broadcasting, but the mission has never been reduced to just that until recently. When the Dalai Lama called the VOA Tibet service 'the bread of the Tibetan people,' and when Aun San Suu Kyi called the Burmese service 'the hope of the Burmese people,' they were not just talking about the 'news.' Hope is a theological virtue; it is not engendered by news alone. The Declaration of Independence was not a news bulletin.
VOA's foreign audiences must be puzzled as to why the VOA is no longer broadcasting to them. Some African listeners take national radio shutdowns as a telltale sign there has been a coup. Or perhaps, they might think, the U.S. no longer considers them worth reaching, or that it no longer has anything to say. Either answer is a self-inflicted public diplomacy disaster. What has happened to our 'decent respect to the opinions of mankind'?
The U.S. has enduring interests in the world. We need to explain ourselves in the most persuasive way we can, and by the most effective means, particularly to those peoples and countries whose future is going to most affect ours. Destroying the Voice of America is not the way to do this.
Robert R. Reilly served as Voice of America director from (2001 to 2002) and from (2020-2021).
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

China releases AI action plan days after the U.S. as global tech race heats up
China releases AI action plan days after the U.S. as global tech race heats up

CNBC

time15 minutes ago

  • CNBC

China releases AI action plan days after the U.S. as global tech race heats up

SHANGHAI — The tech race between the world's two largest economies just intensified. China on Saturday released a global action plan for artificial intelligence, calling for international cooperation on tech development and regulation. The news came as the annual state-organized World Artificial Intelligence Conference kicked off in Shanghai with an opening speech by Premier Li Qiang, who announced that the Chinese government has proposed the establishment of a global AI cooperation organization, according to an official readout. Days earlier, U.S. President Donald Trump announced an American action plan for AI that included calls to reduce alleged "woke" bias in AI models and support the deployment of U.S. tech overseas. "The two camps are now being formed," said George Chen, partner at the Asia Group and co-chair of the digital practice. "China clearly wants to stick to the multilateral approach while the U.S. wants to build its own camp, very much targeting the rise of China in the field of AI," Chen said. He noted how China may attract participants from its Belt and Road Initiative, while the U.S. will likely have the support of its allies, such as Japan and Australia. In his speech, Premier Li emphasized China's "AI plus" plan for integrating the tech across industries and said the country was willing to help other nations with the technology, especially in the Global South. The category loosely refers to less developed economies, especially countries outside the U.S. and European orbits. Since 2022, the U.S. has sought to restrict China's access to advanced semiconductors for training AI models. Earlier this month, U.S. chipmaker Nvidia said the U.S. was allowing it to resume shipments of a less advanced H20 chip to China after a roughly three-month pause. However, China has been developing homegrown alternatives, which Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang both praised and described as "formidable" during his third trip to China this month. Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt met with Shanghai Party Secretary Chen Jining on Thursday in the city ahead of the AI conference, according to a city announcement. Schmidt did not immediately respond to a CNBC request for comment.

Trump arrives in Scotland for golf and bilateral talks as EU trade deal nears
Trump arrives in Scotland for golf and bilateral talks as EU trade deal nears

CNBC

time16 minutes ago

  • CNBC

Trump arrives in Scotland for golf and bilateral talks as EU trade deal nears

U.S. President Donald Trump, dogged by questions about his ties to disgraced financier and sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, arrived in Scotland on Friday for some golf and bilateral talks that could yield a trade deal with the European Union. Trump told reporters upon his arrival that he will visit his two golf properties in Scotland and meet with British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, whom he called a "highly respected woman." As hundreds of onlookers cheered his arrival, Trump reiterated his earlier comment about a 50-50 chance of securing a deal with the EU, adding that it would be his administration's largest trade agreement thus far, if it came together. However, he said there were still "sticking points" with Brussels on "maybe 20 different things." Trump said his meeting with Starmer would be more of a celebration of the trade deal already reached than continued work on it, adding, "It's a great deal for both." Before he left Washington, Trump stated that his administration was working diligently on a potential trade deal with the EU, and Brussels was eager to finalize a deal. Von der Leyen said later she would meet Trump in Scotland on Sunday. EU diplomats say a deal could result in a 15% tariff on EU goods, mirroring a framework accord with Japan reached this week and half of the 30% Trump is threatening to impose by Aug. 1. Trump has sought to reorder the global economy after imposing a 10% tariff on nearly all trading partners in April and threatening sharply higher rates for many countries to kick in a week from now. Trump says the moves will reduce the U.S. trade deficit and generate additional revenue, but economists warn that the new trade policies could drive up inflation. Trump, facing the biggest domestic political crisis of his second term, expressed frustration about ongoing questions about his administration's handling of investigative files related to Epstein's criminal charges and his 2019 death in prison. "You make it a very big thing over something that's not a big thing," Trump told reporters in Scotland, urging them to focus on other prominent Americans with ties to Epstein, including former President Bill Clinton. "Talk about Clinton. Talk about the former president of Harvard. Talk about all of his friends. Talk about the hedge fund guys that were with him all the time. Don't talk about Trump," he said. "What you should be talking about is the fact that we have the greatest six months in the history of a presidency." The Epstein issue has caused a rare breach with some of Trump's most loyal Make America Great Again supporters, and majorities of Americans and Trump's Republicans say they believe the government is hiding details on the case, according to Reuters/Ipsos polling. White House officials are hoping the controversy dies down while Trump is abroad, two people familiar with the matter said. Trump will stay at his Turnberry property on Scotland's west coast this weekend, before traveling on Monday to a golf property in Aberdeen, where he will open a second 18-hole course named in honor of his mother, Mary Anne MacLeod. MacLeod was born and raised on a Scottish island before emigrating to the U.S. As he left the White House, Trump said he looked forward to meeting both Starmer and Scottish leader John Swinney, who had publicly backed Democratic candidate Kamala Harris in the 2024 U.S. presidential election. The trip provides Trump and Starmer with an opportunity to strengthen their already warm ties, with key issues on the agenda, including ending Russia's war in Ukraine, according to British and U.S. sources. The deteriorating situation in Gaza is also likely to come up. Starmer on Thursday said he would hold an emergency call with France and Germany over what he called the "unspeakable and indefensible" suffering and starvation being reported there, and called on Israel to allow aid to enter the Palestinian enclave. Gaza health authorities say more than 100 people have died from starvation, most in recent weeks. Human rights groups have said mass starvation is spreading even as tons of food and other supplies sit untouched just outside the territory. Since being elected last year, Starmer has prioritized good relations with Trump, stressing the importance of Britain's defense and security alliance with the U.S., while working to clinch the first tariff-reduction deal with the U.S. in May. The framework agreement reaffirmed quotas and tariff rates on British automobiles and eliminated tariffs on the UK's aerospace sector, but left steel tariffs in place. Starmer is expected to press for lower steel tariffs, but sources close to the matter said it was unclear if any breakthrough was possible during Trump's visit. Trump has described Scotland as a "very special place" and made a similar trip there in 2016 during his earlier presidential run, but he will not necessarily receive a warm welcome. About 70% of Scots hold an unfavorable opinion of Trump, while 18% have a favorable opinion, according to an Ipsos poll conducted in March. Scottish police are gearing up for protests on Saturday in both Aberdeen and Edinburgh, the country's capital. Trump will return to Britain from Sept. 17-19 for a state visit hosted by King Charles. It will make Trump the first world leader in modern times to undertake two state visits to the United Kingdom. The late Queen Elizabeth hosted him at Buckingham Palace for a three-day state visit in June 2019.

The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 26
The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 26

Chicago Tribune

timean hour ago

  • Chicago Tribune

The Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 26

It was another hot and humid week in Chicago. With dangerous heat engulfing the city, residents again turned to box fans and AC units for relief from the soaring temps — that is despite recent spikes in electric costs. The heat subsided only to welcome thunderstorms that knocked out power for 50,000 ComEd customers. But it wasn't all doom and gloom this week. After years of construction, four North Side Red Line stations reopened Sunday, and in some good news for homeowners, Mayor Brandon Johnson said he won't seek a property tax hike in his upcoming budget proposal. Gov. JB Pritzker, along with 17 other Democratic governors, petitioned the Trump administration to release nearly $7 billion in withheld federal education grants. On Friday, the Department of Education did just that. But local education leaders are still struggling with their own funding problems. At Thursday's Chicago Board of Education meeting, Chief Budget Officer Michael Sitkowski reiterated that Chicago Public Schools has identified $165 million in spending reductions, including cuts to its administrative staff and vendor contracts, but the district is still searching for a solution to its $734 million budget deficit. Two of the four defendants in the 'ComEd Four' case were sentenced this week. Ex-ComEd CEO Anne Pramaggiore and the utility's former lobbyist Michael McClain will spend two years in prison for their part in the elaborate scheme to bribe then-House Speaker Michael Madigan. New Tribune reporting shows arrests by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement are up in Chicago since President Donald Trump took office, and local children recently received deportation letters from the Department of Homeland Security. Meanwhile, on Friday, a federal judge in Chicago blocked the Trump administration's challenge over sanctuary policies in the state of Illinois. In global news, the United States cut short ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas on Thursday, while hunger and malnutrition surges in Gaza. France also announced this week that the country will recognize Palestine as a state. Three big names in the world of celebrity and entertainment passed away this week. Malcolm-Jamal Warner, the 54-year-old actor best known for his role as teenage son Theo Huxtable on 'The Cosby Show,' died in an accidental drowning Sunday in Costa Rica. Ozzy Osbourne, lead singer of Black Sabbath and godfather of heavy metal, died at the age of 76, just weeks after his farewell show. And professional wrestling legend Hulk Hogan died Thursday after suffering cardiac arrest. He was 71. Plus, the Chicago Cubs and White Sox play each other in this weekend's City Series at Rate Field. It's a matchup with stakes for both teams, as the Sox come off their best roadtrip since September 2022 and the Cubs just dropped from first place in their division. That's it for the headlines! Now here's the Tribune's Quotes of the Week quiz for July 20 to 26. Missed last week? You can find it here or check out our past editions of Quotes of the Week.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store