Hot-and-cold Manly in slump as Sharks hold strong
Second on the ladder after the opening four rounds, Manly now have a losing record after again showing themselves to be among the NRL's least consistent sides.
The Sea Eagles threw away a chance to add to the list of NRL comebacks on Sunday, going from 14-0 down to level at 14-14 before the 16-point defeat.
The result kept Cronulla fifth, with Nicho Hynes and Briton Nikora impressing down the right edge, and Blayke Brailey having some nice moments.
But while Manly finished the round in eighth spot, they look a long away from the team that set the competition alight over the opening month.
They have now lost three games in a row at home for the first time since 2022, and hold a 4-5 record despite playing six of their opening nine games at Brookvale.
Sunday's match in some ways summed up their season so far, with the Sea Eagles' slump having coincided with Daly Cherry-Evans' announcement he is leaving at year's end
When Manly's attack is on like it was early in the second half when Tolu Koula produced a double, they are among the most dangerous teams in the NRL.
But when it is off like when they completed at just 61 per cent, they can be beaten by anyone.
"I'm a really firm believer your defence and attack are very much linked," Cherry-Evans said.
"When you're putting yourself under pressure through defence, it can lead to some really poor attack because you start to chase the game.
"That was the story of the first half. Our attack was a bit clunky and we had nine errors compounding it with ill-discipline.
"You don't want to be falling into a trap of hoping your attack saves your defence.
"But that 20 minutes after halftime was exactly the sort of football team I believe we can be, and have shown at times."
After Cronulla burst out of the blocks to claim a 14-0 halftime lead, the hosts were back in the game when Koula's double made it 14-12 with 26 minutes left.
Luke Brooks then broke into open space from the kick-off and had a chance to send Koula over for his third, only for the centre to spill the pass back inside to him.
And while the Sea Eagles got the score back to 14-14 via a penalty goal, more errors proved costly.
Haumole Olakau'atu attempted to push an offload in their first set in tight space, prompting an error from Reuben Garrick.
Garrick then cleaned up a Sharks grubber-kick at the end of their next set, but spilled the ball at the last second and handed an easy try to Braydon Trindall.
From there, the floodgates opened.
Ronaldo Mulitalo and KL Iro both scored late, with Mulitalo's try coming from some nice lead-up play from a kicking Billy Burns.
Earlier, Hynes had shown his return to form when he spotted Tom Trbojevic at marker and kicked for Mulitalo to score after a Nikora break.
The half was again involved in the Sharks' next, when Brailey skirted out of dummy-half and found the halfback, who put Addin Fonua-Blake over untouched.
"He's had a number of good performances now," coach Craig Fitzgibbon said of Hynes.
"He is running the ball, kicking well. I feel like he is organising the team well. He's in a good head space and not letting it get to him."
Manly's hot-and-cold NRL season has left them at risk of a freefall, slumping to their forth loss in five games after a lacklustre 30-14 defeat to Cronulla.
Second on the ladder after the opening four rounds, Manly now have a losing record after again showing themselves to be among the NRL's least consistent sides.
The Sea Eagles threw away a chance to add to the list of NRL comebacks on Sunday, going from 14-0 down to level at 14-14 before the 16-point defeat.
The result kept Cronulla fifth, with Nicho Hynes and Briton Nikora impressing down the right edge, and Blayke Brailey having some nice moments.
But while Manly finished the round in eighth spot, they look a long away from the team that set the competition alight over the opening month.
They have now lost three games in a row at home for the first time since 2022, and hold a 4-5 record despite playing six of their opening nine games at Brookvale.
Sunday's match in some ways summed up their season so far, with the Sea Eagles' slump having coincided with Daly Cherry-Evans' announcement he is leaving at year's end
When Manly's attack is on like it was early in the second half when Tolu Koula produced a double, they are among the most dangerous teams in the NRL.
But when it is off like when they completed at just 61 per cent, they can be beaten by anyone.
"I'm a really firm believer your defence and attack are very much linked," Cherry-Evans said.
"When you're putting yourself under pressure through defence, it can lead to some really poor attack because you start to chase the game.
"That was the story of the first half. Our attack was a bit clunky and we had nine errors compounding it with ill-discipline.
"You don't want to be falling into a trap of hoping your attack saves your defence.
"But that 20 minutes after halftime was exactly the sort of football team I believe we can be, and have shown at times."
After Cronulla burst out of the blocks to claim a 14-0 halftime lead, the hosts were back in the game when Koula's double made it 14-12 with 26 minutes left.
Luke Brooks then broke into open space from the kick-off and had a chance to send Koula over for his third, only for the centre to spill the pass back inside to him.
And while the Sea Eagles got the score back to 14-14 via a penalty goal, more errors proved costly.
Haumole Olakau'atu attempted to push an offload in their first set in tight space, prompting an error from Reuben Garrick.
Garrick then cleaned up a Sharks grubber-kick at the end of their next set, but spilled the ball at the last second and handed an easy try to Braydon Trindall.
From there, the floodgates opened.
Ronaldo Mulitalo and KL Iro both scored late, with Mulitalo's try coming from some nice lead-up play from a kicking Billy Burns.
Earlier, Hynes had shown his return to form when he spotted Tom Trbojevic at marker and kicked for Mulitalo to score after a Nikora break.
The half was again involved in the Sharks' next, when Brailey skirted out of dummy-half and found the halfback, who put Addin Fonua-Blake over untouched.
"He's had a number of good performances now," coach Craig Fitzgibbon said of Hynes.
"He is running the ball, kicking well. I feel like he is organising the team well. He's in a good head space and not letting it get to him."
Manly's hot-and-cold NRL season has left them at risk of a freefall, slumping to their forth loss in five games after a lacklustre 30-14 defeat to Cronulla.
Second on the ladder after the opening four rounds, Manly now have a losing record after again showing themselves to be among the NRL's least consistent sides.
The Sea Eagles threw away a chance to add to the list of NRL comebacks on Sunday, going from 14-0 down to level at 14-14 before the 16-point defeat.
The result kept Cronulla fifth, with Nicho Hynes and Briton Nikora impressing down the right edge, and Blayke Brailey having some nice moments.
But while Manly finished the round in eighth spot, they look a long away from the team that set the competition alight over the opening month.
They have now lost three games in a row at home for the first time since 2022, and hold a 4-5 record despite playing six of their opening nine games at Brookvale.
Sunday's match in some ways summed up their season so far, with the Sea Eagles' slump having coincided with Daly Cherry-Evans' announcement he is leaving at year's end
When Manly's attack is on like it was early in the second half when Tolu Koula produced a double, they are among the most dangerous teams in the NRL.
But when it is off like when they completed at just 61 per cent, they can be beaten by anyone.
"I'm a really firm believer your defence and attack are very much linked," Cherry-Evans said.
"When you're putting yourself under pressure through defence, it can lead to some really poor attack because you start to chase the game.
"That was the story of the first half. Our attack was a bit clunky and we had nine errors compounding it with ill-discipline.
"You don't want to be falling into a trap of hoping your attack saves your defence.
"But that 20 minutes after halftime was exactly the sort of football team I believe we can be, and have shown at times."
After Cronulla burst out of the blocks to claim a 14-0 halftime lead, the hosts were back in the game when Koula's double made it 14-12 with 26 minutes left.
Luke Brooks then broke into open space from the kick-off and had a chance to send Koula over for his third, only for the centre to spill the pass back inside to him.
And while the Sea Eagles got the score back to 14-14 via a penalty goal, more errors proved costly.
Haumole Olakau'atu attempted to push an offload in their first set in tight space, prompting an error from Reuben Garrick.
Garrick then cleaned up a Sharks grubber-kick at the end of their next set, but spilled the ball at the last second and handed an easy try to Braydon Trindall.
From there, the floodgates opened.
Ronaldo Mulitalo and KL Iro both scored late, with Mulitalo's try coming from some nice lead-up play from a kicking Billy Burns.
Earlier, Hynes had shown his return to form when he spotted Tom Trbojevic at marker and kicked for Mulitalo to score after a Nikora break.
The half was again involved in the Sharks' next, when Brailey skirted out of dummy-half and found the halfback, who put Addin Fonua-Blake over untouched.
"He's had a number of good performances now," coach Craig Fitzgibbon said of Hynes.
"He is running the ball, kicking well. I feel like he is organising the team well. He's in a good head space and not letting it get to him."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
NRL world divided as Nathan Cleary goes nuclear over controversial ruling in Storm's epic win
Nathan Cleary has accused Storm rival Harry Grant of 'playing for' a game-changing penalty in Thursday night's golden-point epic, in a decision that has left the NRL world divided. A depleted Storm side outlasted the defending premiers thanks to an individual piece of brilliance from Harry Grant in golden point. But the Panthers felt they had been hard done by, after Cleary slotted a field goal with three minutes remaining in regulation time, only for it to be waved away. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. It would have given them a 19-18 lead, but referee Ashley Klein immediately penalised forward Moses Leota for running interference, stepping into Grant's path, which blocked him from putting pressure on Cleary, who later had two attempts charged down. 'Harry Grant has played for this, but you can't stand there,' Andrew Voss said in Fox commentary. 'I don't like it; he hasn't done a whole lot, and Grant has played for it.' To which Queensland great Cooper Cronk hit back: 'You might not like it, but the rule is you can't stand in front of anyone taking a field goal shot.' Voss then noticed Leota had slightly changed his line and therefore changed his tune in commentary. 'He does take a baby step. You know what, I applaud Ashley Klein for making such a big call, and it's been supported by the bunker,' Voss said. 'But the crazy thing is, Leota doesn't have to do it; he has the best field goal kicker in the comp!' Post-match Panthers coach Ivan Cleary was diplomatic, stating, 'Harry was too smart at both ends. That's pretty much it.' While his son Nathan couldn't help but make his feelings known. 'If that was in the field of play and you run a block shape, it wouldn't have been an obstruction because they ruled that out if you're typically defending at that three-man and you play for an obstruction, they don't want that in the game,' he said. 'But for some reason, it's different for a field goal. 'I thought the blocking rule was brought in so that people wouldn't stand next to the play the ball, but Moses wasn't in that position. 'I don't believe that everyone can get behind me on that field goal, and then essentially Harry played for it because he knew he was going to get the penalty. 'I don't believe that Moses moved, so it was pretty frustrating.' Cleary also said he believes it wasn't fair to penalise Moses for simply being there. 'I'm not sure what he was meant to do. I know it's a common cliche, but is he meant to then run through? But if he runs through, then he's a chance to take people out,' he continued. 'Do we expect him to get all the way behind the ball, but then we've got no one to run it. I feel like it's a split-second thing where I'm calling like I want the ball to take the field goal, and Moses is there to take the run, and he didn't move.' However, Grant unsurprisingly sang a different tune. When told of Cleary's frustrations, the Melbourne hooker said the rule is black and white and that Leota should have just got out of the way. 'I think anyone in the game has seen that's been policed numerous times, and that's the rule within the game,' he said. 'Even the Penrith boys were aware of it in the game, and when it happened, so I'm happy if that's the rule, then we stick to it, but if we want to change it, then come out during the week and change it. 'I think anyone would agree that's been policed numerous times throughout the year. Hats off to the officials for policing it the same way because it would have been easy to change it. 'A lot of attention will go to that, but it doesn't need to. 'The attention should go to what a quality contest it was and how well they played. We were underdogs and had a fair few players out, but we turned up, so I really think that (people should focus on the result).' While fans were equally divided over the call. 'The front on angle clearly shows that Grant milked it, should have been given (as a field goal),' one wrote. 'Harry Grant doesn't even have eyes for the ball. Runs straight at Leota,' another added. While a third said the right call was made. 'Yes, Grant has played for it, but by the letter of the law, that's a penalty. The right call was made.' The controversial penalty took a bit of the shine off Grant's heroics at the death. The crafty hooker fooled the markers who raced out to pressure a potential shot at goal, with the Storm hooker was able to dart over under the black dot for the winner, as he did at the same venue in golden point against the Eels two years ago.
The Australian
4 hours ago
- The Australian
Billy Walters reveals Benji Marshall mentorship for Broncos five-eighth mission
Billy Walters has vowed to keep Brisbane's season alive, revealing how mentoring sessions with five-eighth legend Benji Marshall has him primed to fire in the famous Broncos No.6 jumper. In his first interview since being pitchforked into the halves, Walters backed his emergency band-aid pairing with halfback Ben Hunt to keep Brisbane's title assault on track in Saturday's derby blockbuster against the Dolphins. Walters has played 15 of his 20 games off the bench this season but hamstring injuries to star halves Ezra Mam and Adam Reynolds has seen him answer a scrumbase SOS for the must-win Battle of Brisbane at Suncorp Stadium. The makeshift pivot concedes he doesn't have the instinctive brilliance Mam, but the son of Broncos five-eighth legend Kevin Walters is steeled by his lessons from legendary Tigers magician Marshall. The pair spent a season together at the Wests Tigers in 2020. Former whiz-kid Marshall once rated Walters' show-and-go as deceptive as that of Cowboys champion Johnathan Thurston and the Broncos hooker-turned-pivot is confident he can stabilise Brisbane's strife-torn scrumbase. 'I think I can do the job for sure,' Walters said ahead of his scrumbase duel with Dolphins halves Kodi Nikorima and Isaiya Katoa. ''Madge' (coach Michael Maguire) isn't expecting me to be like Ezra Mam, my job is to bring some experience and a bit of a calm head I guess. 'It's my role to kick to the corners and defend well and that's probably my role going forward the next few weeks while we wait for 'Reyno' and hopefully Ezra to return. 'I thought my days at five-eighth were behind me, but Madge suggested I do some reps in the halves because Ezra was serving his suspension and Reyno ended up having neck surgery, so it's ended up working out well for me and 'Hunty'.' Walters says the advice of 346-game legend Marshall, who won a premiership at the Wests Tigers in 2005, will hold him in good stead for the Dolphins clash. 'I was lucky to work with Cameron Smith at Melbourne and it was so cool learning off Benji at the Tigers,' Walters said. 'Benji was really good for me in terms of relaxing and finding a balance between being serious in the NRL, but also enjoying the moment. 'He obviously is a better runner of the football than me, but he said you need to be in a good headspace to be having fun and playing your best football. 'That's the biggest thing I learned from him _ I'm in a good spot at the moment.' Walters' form over the past two months has been sensational. For many years, the 31-year-old lived in the shadow of his famous father, but former Broncos coach Kevin Walters lauded his son's versatility and says he won't let the Broncos down at second receiver. 'He is maturing and proving to everybody what he can do,' said Walters, who will be analysing the Battle of Brisbane exclusively live on Fox League. 'He's played in the halves before, not only at the Broncos, but also for the Tigers and also for the Storm. He is no newcomer to that role. 'The Broncos have the luxury where you lose Adam Reynolds and you drop Ben Hunt into halfback. 'That's a huge advantage for them. 'Billy's got great self-belief and we all believe in him so much, but that belief is coming through in his football now. 'He knows that he belongs at the Broncos and in that jersey. 'I feel he's playing good football. 'Last year I thought Billy was one of our better players and the year before in the grand final run he was up with our best players. 'This year is no different. He's had a different sort of role to play this year which he's taken on and embraced and the Broncos have benefited from that.' Walters' career at the Broncos appeared at the crossroads in pre-season when he lost the No.9 jumper to Cory Paix for the premiership opener against the Roosters. But Walters has thrived on the challenge and is relishing the prospect of combining with Hunt to steer the Broncos to the playoffs. 'It was disappointing losing my starting position,' he said. 'But credit to Cory Paix, he had a pretty good pre-season and it was a challenge for me to bring out my best football, which it did in the end. 'I never take my spot at the Broncos for granted, especially in these Battle of Brisbane games against the Dolphins, so I'll enjoy every second I'm out there.' NRL Popular ABC rugby league broadcaster Andrew Moore is in intensive care at Westmead hospital, after suffering a serious heart attack that required emergency surgery. NRL Penrith's nine-game winning streak has come to an end at the hands of Melbourne, with some Xavier Coates brilliance and a moment of individual magic from Harry Grant sealing a dramatic golden point win.
The Australian
4 hours ago
- The Australian
PNG Prime Minister James Marape goes one better than Donald Trump in golf stakes
Think Donald Trump would be the last politician to create a golfing headline this year? Yeah, James Marape has just asked the commander-in-cheat, as he's dubbed by his harshest golf critics, to hold my beer. Professional golfing tournaments around the world have been laced with dubious and truly bizarre invitations over history, but there's another to be added to the list: Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister playing in the country's national open on Thursday. Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister James Marape competes at the PNG Open. Picture: Supplied To most Australian sports fans, Marape is the man who stood alongside Anthony Albanese and Peter V'landys to announce PNG's dream of its own NRL franchise had been realised. As part of the $600 million in funding from the Albanese government for the 19th licence, Marape promised his security pact would be tied to his neighbours in the Pacific, and not China. Now, it also appears he fancies playing a bit of golf too. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese with Papua New Guinea's Prime Minister James Marape in 2024. Picture: David Gray / AFP If you scrolled down far enough on the leaderboard for the Papua New Guinea Open being played in Port Moresby this week, the first event of the PGA Tour of Australasia's new season, there was a name which stood out: Hn James Marape (a). The 'a' stood for amateur, in case you weren't sure. But all you needed to do was look at his scorecard to realise why. Marape signed for a – how do we put this nicely? – 97. Twenty-five-over the card! He had a couple of pars, but there were also eight bogeys, seven doubles and a nasty triple. At least, and any average hacker will attest to this feat, he managed to scrape in under 100. Before you jump up and down about how a PM has shoehorned his way into a professional tournament, a couple of things to consider: Marape actually played in the tournament before in 2023 (missing the cut); he's using his profile to preach the opportunity his country is trying to give local players, including the weekend's PNG Women's Open; the field wasn't filled so every professional who entered the tournament was given a start; and there's already 20 local amateurs featuring in the event, so ample opportunity for some of the country's emerging talent. Then came the tournament invitation for Marape, who one-upped The Don by at least playing in an event for world rankings points. Prime Minister Marape now has one up on President Donald Trump. Picture: AP Photo/Jacquelyn Martin 'I just want to inform the country, this is our 50th (anniversary as a nation), and for the first time we've gone past a hundred professional golfers in our country,' Marape beamed after his round on Thursday, presumably not heading straight to the range to work on his swing. '(There's) 120, including seven female professionals who are coming in, participating on Saturday and Sunday. It's a step in the right direction. 'Sport does sell our country's image. Sport does inform the world who we are. And here you have professional golfers coming from right across the world to come in to play in Port Moresby. 'This morning, I was privileged that they gave me a run with last year's winner, William (Bruyeres), and they're all in the running for whoever comes out top on Sunday.' Said tournament director Graeme Scott: 'I believe there are discussions currently underway as to how the PGA of Australia can assist in the development of young players because it's very much our goal to have your aspiring professionals and young players coming to play on our Tour. 'I know in speaking to my own colleagues this morning, that was a crucial thing that we were trying to develop with Papua New Guinea, is that we can see a pathway for these players to come.' For the record, Victorian Joel Mitchell was the solo first round leader with a five-under 67 … just a lazy 30 shots ahead of a Prime Minister, who at least let's everyone watch him counting his score. Read related topics: Donald Trump
