SFA gives detailed response to 'misleading' Rangers disciplinary complaint
The Scottish FA has responded to Rangers' complaint about their disciplinary process, saying the Ibrox club made misleading comments about their judicial system.
Rangers went public with their anger over a £3,000 fine levied by an independent panel over comments made on club TV by former player John Brown.
While commentating on a match against Hibs at Easter Road, Brown claimed a controversial decision not to award Rangers a goal was 'corrupt' and doubled down on his statement after his colleague corrected his language.
Following the decision, which punished the club under a rule that prevents allegations of 'bias or incompetence' being directed at match officials, Rangers issued a lengthy statement claiming that similar incidents at other clubs have gone unpunished, and that the decision has 'implications for clarity and confidence in the regulatory system'.
The club said that Brown has spoken 'spontaneously and emotionally' and that his comments 'come with the territory' of live broadcasting.
The Scottish FA has now responded, saying that the written reasons from the independent disciplinary panel will be published in due course, but taking issue with the points made by Rangers.
The governing body said that they had to address 'misleading comment' in the interest of accuracy and said that the decision and punishment were in accordance by the rules that all member clubs are expected to adhere to.
A recent case involving Motherwell's Richard Foster was highlighted, with Foster having been banned from the touchline for six games after making similar comments last season.
The SFA also answered a query about the 'rationale behind different outcomes', saying that the organisation's compliance officer can take action short of a full disciplinary charge. Recent incidents involving three Rangers players were given as an example.
The statement read: 'Furthermore, to address the comments regarding 'rationale behind differing outcomes', we wish to point to the fact that investigations were undertaken in previous cases outlined and that the Compliance Officers of the time saw fit to issue a censure by way of warning letter for potential breaches deemed insufficiently serious to be progressed to a Notice of Complaint.
'This system of proportionality has been adopted since the inception of the Judicial Panel Protocol in 2011. Indeed, such discretion was exercised last season when the Compliance Officer wrote to the club to warn of the future conduct of players following matters involving Vaclav Cerny, Dujon Sterling and Mohamed Diomande.
'We also note that Rangers intend to contact the association to seek clarity on the Judicial Panel Protocol and its application. The club is, in fact, already represented on the JPP Working Group.'
The statement concluded by reminding all clubs of their responsibilities in regard to referees, pointing out that the rule that Brown broke with his comments was brought in by clubs to protect referees following their strike in 2010.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
38 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Rangers ‘agree deal for key target' as Russell Martin closes in on first signing
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) RANGERS are one step closer to signing Max Aarons from Bournemouth, according to a report. SunSport were first to reveal that Russell Martin was set to land his former Norwich City team-mate on loan for the season, along with Peterborough winger Kwame Poku on a permanent deal. Sign up for the Rangers newsletter Sign up 2 Max Aarons is set to join Rangers Credit: Getty 2 Russell Martin is set to land his first Rangers signing Credit: PA Fixtures will come thick and fast for the new Ibrox gaffer with his baptism of fire against Panathinaikos now less than five weeks away. He will welcome his players back for pre-season on Monday and is hoping to have some new signings in the door before the big Champions League qualifier next month. And it looks like Bournemouth full-back Aarons could very well be his first arrival at Ibrox. Sky Sports have issued an update on the potential transfer, claiming it's now pretty much a done deal. It's stated that both clubs have now reached an official agreement that will see Aarons head to Scotland for the season, but there WON'T be a buy-out clause to make the move permanent next year. The 25-year-old has fallen out of favour down south and was sent out on loan to Valencia for the second half of last season. He's now looking to revive his career in Glasgow with his old mentor Martin, who he recently described as being a "father figure" for him when he was a youth player at Norwich. Speaking to Talk Norwich City podcast last month, Aarons said: "When he came and trained with us, he had an aura. "You have to be training well every single day and I could feel that when he was training with us. "I always knew he would go on to be a manager. I think players that played with him always knew that as well. Rangers captain James Tavernier spotted training with ex-team-mate and old Premiership rival Ryan Porteous who branded him 'bad loser' "I knew we had to be on it when he was training with us, giving 110 per cent because if not, Russ will tell you and I loved that. "He pushed every single training session. "When he was training with us it almost gave me a feel that I was ready to go and make the jump with the senior players. "And as soon as Russ came in and trained with us, the advice he would give and the relationship we built from there, he was almost like a father figure." Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Max Aarons to Rangers transfer 'agreed' at last as exact terms revealed over Bournemouth star's move
A deal has reportedly been agreed to take Martin to Ibrox on loan Rangers have reportedly agreed a deal with Bournemouth to take Max Aarons to Ibrox on loan. Russell Martin has wasted no time putting together a list of targets to improve his Rangers team right away with Aarons, Conor Coady and Kwame Poku among the early names to emerge. Tonight it's been reported in Croatia that defender Luka Jelenic is also a target, with centre-back near the top of the priority list amid John Souttar's ongoing injury fears. But it now appears likely Aarons may be the first signing of the Martin era. That's because Sky Sports report a deal has been agreed with the Premier League side to take the right-back, capped 27 times for England's U21s, to Ibrox. It's reported it will be a 'straight loan deal' with no obligation to buy, and there is no mention of a pre-agreed buy option for the 25-year-old. He spent last season on loan at Valencia and is on record as being a big fan of Ibrox boss Martin with whom he last crossed paths while both were players at Norwich. But now it looks as if he's on his way to Glasgow with James Tavernier's position as the starting right-back now seriously under threat. Rangers have of course already signed Lyall Cameron from Dundee but Aarons will become the first player Martin has directly recruited to the club. Speaking earlier today the boss stressed the need to get signings in before the Champions League playoff with Panathinaikos gets underway on July 22. He told club media: 'I think the squad will look different. We will have some players in by then as well, so the earlier we can do that, the better, so they become ingrained in what we are trying to build culturally and in terms of performance. 'The players are back in on Monday. That's the most exciting bit. We will see what the players can do, how we are going to have to adapt and tweak to make it really built-in and ready for us, and then the rest will take care of itself.' You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Rangers and Celtic pages, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Man accused of gangland 'murders' of Eddie Lyons and Ross Monaghan appears in court
Michael Riley, 44, appeared in court in the latest stage of the extradition proceedings. The man accused of gunning down Eddie Lyons and Ross Monaghan in Spain appeared in court today. Michael Terrence Riley from the Merseyside area, was arrested by local officers last week in connection with the deaths after an international arrest warrant was issued by Spanish cops. He is charged with two counts of murder and one of possession of a firearm over the incident which saw Monaghan, 43, and Lyons, 46, killed at Monaghan's bar in Fuengirola. Riley first appeared at Westminster Magistrates' Court yesterday, Thursday, June 19, but the hearing was delayed due to technical issues. During a brief hearing today, a court date for his next appearance was set, reports the ECHO. Riley, who is represented in court by specialist extradition lawyer Renata Pinter, will appear again before the same court next month, on July 18. He was remanded in custody until then. The full hearing, where Riley will challenge extradition, is scheduled for October 9 this year. The Lyons crime clan has been locked in a deadly feud with the rival Daniel mob for a quarter of a century, following the theft of drugs from a Glasgow safe house in 2001. A top Spanish cop told reporters that the assassinations of Monaghan and Lyons are part of the feud, claiming that Riley is a member of the Daniel gang. Speaking at a press conference in Spain, Pedro Agudo Novo said: "The double murder was carried out by a professional killer and member of one of the victims' rival gangs. "In this case we are not talking about an independent hired killer but an internal member of the rival Daniels gang who ends up assassinating two members of an enemy gang." But Scottish police, who have been investigating the war between the rival crime syndicates for decades, seemed to suggest the killing had nothing to do with their rivalry - or the war on the Daniel mob being waged by Lyons associate Ross McGill. Henchmen of the Dubai-based former Rangers ultra - who headed the Union Bears fan group and is nicknamed 'Miami' - have waged war on the Daniel mob and associates for the last few months. That feud has seen a number of homes, people and businesses targeted in firebombings, knife attacks and shootings, in Glasgow, Edinburgh and surrounding areas, and is being investigated by Police Scotland as part of Operation Portaledge.
