Pleading final words of death row's oldest inmate, 75, as he was executed by injection for killing wife & her two sons
Tennessee inmate Oscar Smith, 75, was put to death on Thursday morning for the 1989 murders of his ex-wife and her teenage sons in the state's first execution since 2020.
7
7
With his final words, Smith insisted that he was innocent and begged for the justice system to be reformed.
He said: "Somebody needs to tell the governor the justice system doesn't work."
Refuting his conviction one final time, Smith said: "I didn't kill her."
He was pronounced dead at 10:47am on Thursday after receiving a lethal dose of the drug pentobarbital at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution.
The Sun recently spoke to a former death row executioner who saw a killer's head burst into flames and a pastor who has accompanied with more inmates in their final minutes than anyone else.
Smith was convicted of fatally stabbing and shooting his estranged wife Judith Smith, 13-year-old Jason Burnett and 16-year-old Chad Burnett.
He murdered them at the home in Nashville, Tennessee, on October 1, 1989.
Sentenced to death in July 1990, Smith spent almost 35 years on death row, and was its oldest inmate in the US.
A county court judge denied a request to reopen the case in 2022 , despite some new evidence that another person's DNA had been on one of the murder weapons.
The judge ruled that the evidence of Smith's guilt was overwhelming and that the new information did not change that.
I'm a death row executioner - a killer's head burst into flames when I put him in electric chair
Two of Smith's colleagues told the original trial that he asked them to kill Judith.
He also had a history of violence and threats against the family.
Further clinching the conviction was the fact that Smith took out insurance policies on all three of his victims.
The court also heard that one of the teen victims could be heard screaming "Frank, no!" in the background of a 911 call at the time of the murders.
Frank is Smith's middle name, and the one he used regularly.
After Smith had been confirmed dead, Judith's two siblings said they still miss the three victims, all these years later.
7
7
Her sister, Terri Osborne, said the deaths are a reminder of the dangers of domestic violence.
She said: 'We know it is an incredibly hard thing to do to leave a spouse who is abusing, but pray that this case becomes a call to action, encouraging those in danger to seek help before it's too late."
Smith's execution was the first in Tennessee since 2020, and he chose the lethal injection - a cocktail of three drugs.
He could alternatively have chosen to be killed in the electric chair.
There has been significant controversy around the method in recent years - with Justice Sonia Sotomayor of the Supreme Court describing it as "the chemical equivalent of being burned at the stake".
7
7
In March, a double murderer called Brad Sigmon became the first person in the US to be executed by firing squad in 15 years.
He reportedly kept breathing after being shot three times in the chest.
Three special bullets were shot at his heart by three volunteer riflemen at the South Carolina Department of Corrections in Columbia.
Sigmon, 67, was convicted of beating to death with a baseball bat his ex-girlfriend's parents, David and Gladys Larke, at their Taylors home in 2001.
List of executions so far in 2025
January 31: Marion Bowman (South Carolina)
February 5: Steven Nelson (Texas)
February 6: Demetrius Frazier (Alabama)
February 13: James Ford (Florida)
February 13: Richard Tabler (Texas)
March 7: Brad Sigmon (South Carolina)
March 18: Jessie Hoffman (Louisiana)
March 19: Aaron Gunches (Arizona)
March 20: Wendell Grissom (Oklahoma)
March 20: Edward James (Florida)
April 8: Michael Tanzi (Florida)
April 11: Mikal Mahdi (South Carolina)
April 23: Moises Sandoval Mendoza (Texas)
April 24: James Osgood (Alabama)
May 1: Jeffrey Hutchinson (Florida)
May 15: Glen Rogers (Florida)
May 20: Benjamin Ritchie (Indiana)
May 20: Matthew Johnson (Texas)
May 22: Oscar Smith (Florida)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
DC police will share information on anyone officers encounter with ICE agents
U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi has moved to rescind new guidelines issued by D.C. Police Chief Pamela Smith to enable greater collaboration between local police and ICE agents as part of President Donald Trump 's urban crime crackdown. On Thursday, an executive order from Smith said Metropolitan Police Department officers could assist ICE's crackdown on undocumented migrants by 'sharing information about persons not in MPD custody' and 'providing transportation for federal immigration agency employees and detained subjects.' However, it also stated that members 'shall not make any inquiry through any database solely for the purpose of inquiring about an individual's immigration status' and 'shall not arrest individuals based solely on federal immigration warrants or detainers as long as there is no additional crime warrant or underlying offense for which the individual is subject to arrest.' Bondi – who was handed ultimate responsibility for the MPD after Trump invoked Section 740 of the Home Rule Act on Monday to federalize D.C. law enforcement – has now moved to remove those instructions, clearing the way for officers to help ICE by searching databases and carrying out arrests after all. However, a letter sent to Smith from District of Columbia Attorney General Brian Schwalb, posted to social media by D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser on Thursday evening, argued that Bondi's directives were not consistent with federal law. 'It is my opinion that the Bondi Order is unlawful, and that you are not legally obligated to follow it,' Schwalb told Smith, adding that police officers in the capital 'must' continue to follow her orders 'and not the order of any official not appointed by the mayor.' Bondi also moved on Thursday to clear out the city's homeless encampments and appoint Drug Enforcement Administration chief Terry Cole as D.C.'s new 'emergency police commissioner.' The upheaval comes after Trump took over D.C. law enforcement while insisting the nation's capital city is overrun by violent street crime – despite the official statistics suggesting offenses are actually at a 30-year low. His opponents calling the move a 'distraction' tactic. The National Guard, alongside agents from the FBI, DEA, and Homeland Security, were dispatched to the streets of Washington to patrol its historic landmarks, including the Washington Monument and Lincoln Memorial. Their presence has not been entirely welcomed, however, with traffic stops in the northwest of the city greeted by protests from around 100 members of the public on Wednesday evening. Some of the protesters chanted, 'Go home, fascists!' while others held aloft signs that read, 'Police checkpoint ahead' and 'ICE,' to warn approaching drivers about the active checkpoint. Mayor Bowser has also criticized the Trump administration's actions, saying they illustrate precisely why she believes the district should be granted statehood and called them 'an authoritarian push.'
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
‘An intimidation tactic': Trump's show of force dismays Washington residents
Washington DC's only Home Depot was busy with contractors and customers on Thursday morning – but the Hispanic day laborers who usually gather and wait for work under the parking lot's sparse trees were nowhere to be found. Two days earlier, masked federal agents swarmed the area and made several arrests, which were photographed by bystanders and posted on social media. Juwan Brooks, a store employee who witnessed the raid, said the agents grabbed anyone who appeared Hispanic. 'They don't ask no questions,' Brooks said. People walking across the parking lot, getting out of their cars, or even sleeping in their vehicle – all were grabbed by the agents, leaving behind empty work trucks that were eventually towed away. 'It was cool when Trump was saying it, but to actually see it first hand? I didn't like it,' Brooks said. The day laborers 'are not bad people', and he wondered what happened to the children of the men that were taken away. Four days after Trump ordered federal agents and national guard on to the streets of Washington DC to fight a crime wave that city leaders say is not happening, residents of the capital are becoming used to the presence of groups of armed men in their neighborhoods, and the aggressive tactics they use. Beyond the apparent immigration arrests at Home Depot – which Brooks said was the second raid there he is aware of since Trump took office – federal agents have been spotted setting up roadblocks at busy intersections, and patrolling neighborhoods across the city. Trump, who exercised a never-before-used clause in the law governing the district to take over the Metropolitan police department (MPD) for 30 days, this week said he would seek Congress's approval to keep it under federal control for the 'long term'. It's unclear how much of a difference the deployment has yet made on public safety. Rates of violent crime dropped to 30-year lows last year, but it remains more prevalent in Washington DC than many cities with similar populations. Since Trump made the deployment official on Monday, the city recorded two homicides, bringing its count for the year up to 101. 'I just feel like it's too much federal overreach. I think it's unnecessary, and I think our MPD does a great job,' said Kevin Cataldo, a neighborhood commissioner whose district includes the block just north of downtown where the 100th homicide of the year took place on Monday, hours after Trump announced the federal takeover. The White House says 800 national guard troops will be on the ground in the city, along with hundreds of federal officers from the Drug Enforcement Administration, border patrol, FBI and other agencies. On Thursday afternoon, a half-dozen unarmed troops, who said they had been told not to talk to the press, could be found milling among the tourists visiting the Lincoln Memorial on the National Mall, an area not known for crime. 'What they are doing right now? It's just a show of force. I did that in Iraq,' said Kevin Davis, a 21-year army veteran visiting the capital from El Paso, Texas. 'When people see the uniform, they act differently.' More prevalent have been the federal agents who have appeared in neighborhoods across the overwhelmingly Democratic city. They began arriving over the weekend, and on Sunday night, a justice department employee was arrested for hurling a sandwich at a Customs and Border Protection official, and later charged with felony assault on a federal officer. Recent evenings have seen federal agents and police set up roadblocks and pull drivers over on major roads, as protesters gathered to condemn them. On Tuesday evening on 14th Street in Columbia Heights, a north-west Washington neighborhood that is home to the city's largest Hispanic population, police and federal agents, some with their faces covered, began stopping cars, said a local shop manager who declined to be named. Before long, dozens of people emerged to berate them. '[Residents] were trying to tell them to leave, you know, the people in the street and the neighbors,' he told the Guardian. 'They yelled back 'don't make the people scared, this is a free country', 'why make the community unsafe?',' the manager said. The scene repeated a little over a mile south on 14th Street on Wednesday evening, with police and federal agents pulling over cars, and locals heckling them and trying to warn approaching drivers away, according to videos posted on social media. Owen Simon, an undergraduate government student at Georgetown University, had heard that agents were spotted in the tony neighborhood around campus, and wondered what they were doing there. Muggings happened occasionally in the neighborhood, but Simon said he was less concerned about those than what the agents might do to foreign students – or students who appeared to be foreign. 'No one wants to walk around knowing that anyone could be scooped up out of the street at any moment,' he said. 'I don't think that this move by the Trump administration is a way to crack down on crime. I think it's about optics.' As he smoked a cigarette in the Home Deport parking lot, Brooks had a similar concern about Congress Heights, the south-east Washington neighborhood where he lives. Crime there is undoubtedly a concern, but it was teenagers who were behind it, not his working-class neighbors. 'You got other people catching strays off that, too,' he said. 'You got working people living in the neighborhood, going to the store, getting picked up because of 16-, 17-year-olds. 'I understand targeting the area, but you can't really blame the people in the area who are trying to do better,' he added. Over the weekend, he had seen eight cars full of federal agents driving through his neighborhood like they wanted to be seen, something he had never witnessed the city police do. 'What is this for?' he wondered. 'It's more of an intimidation tactic.' Joseph Gedeon contributed reporting
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Ex-guard at California women's prison sentenced to 224 years for sexual abuse
A former California correctional officer convicted of dozens of sexual abuse charges at a women's prison was sentenced to 224 years in prison on Thursday. Gregory Rodriguez, 57, worked as a guard at the Central California women's facility (CCWF), the state's largest women's prison, and was found guilty in January of over 60 charges of abusing nine women in his custody, including rape and battery. Rodriguez's case became a huge scandal for the state, exposing a longstanding crisis of sexual misconduct and abuse behind bars. The officer was found to have targeted incarcerated women over the span of nearly a decade before he retired in 2022 while under investigation. A Guardian investigation published in 2023 revealed the prison received a report of Rodriguez's abuse in 2014, but did not terminate him and instead punished the victim. That survivor spoke of being sent to solitary confinement while authorities investigated claims of her abuse. It is rare for prison officers to be criminally charged and convicted for on-duty sexual misconduct, despite data suggesting abuse by guards is a systemic problem in California and across the US. Misconduct records disclosed by the California department of corrections and rehabilitation (CDCR) showed that from 2014 to 2023, hundreds of incarcerated women filed complaints of staff sexual abuse, but only four officers were terminated for sexual misconduct in that timeframe. Rodriguez, who worked for the CDCR for 27 years, isolated victims in areas without cameras and coerced them into sex by offering items such as gum or tobacco and threatening to 'make prison very difficult' if they did not comply, according to prison investigators' and victims' lawsuits. The majority of rapes charged by prosecutors occurred in 2021 and 2022 in the board of parole hearings area, where incarcerated residents have confidential attorney meetings and appear before commissioners to plead for their freedom. One woman struggling with substance use disorder said Rodriguez coerced her into sex by offering to get her addiction medication, but instead of getting her a prescription, he gave her heroin, which led her to overdose. In announcing the sentence, Judge Katherine Rigby recounted how Rodriguez lured his victims and tried to hide his assaults, saying the survivors would suffer 'lifelong impacts'. She said: 'These victims were put in unfathomable and untenable positions, and they could not leave as they were incarcerated.' Rodriguez had pleaded not guilty and his attorney sought to cast doubt on victims' accounts at trial. He was convicted on a majority of the more than 90 charges prosecutors brought on behalf of 13 women, though for some counts, the jury was hung or found him not guilty. His lawyers had asked for a 56-year sentence, and Rodriguez told the judge his daughter was sick and needed support. His family also testified on his behalf. After his conviction, his attorney, Roger Wilson, said 'the jury clearly believed some inmates and disbelieved others'. Wilson did not immediately respond to an inquiry. Some survivors testified in court last month in front of Rodriguez, including Nikki, who spoke out to the Guardian in 2023 from behind bars and has since been released. She has been referred to by her first name in court proceedings. 'For over a decade, I have lived in the aftermath of what you did to me,' she said in court, according to a copy of her statement she shared with the Guardian. 'I was an incarcerated woman – vulnerable, alone, stripped of dignity, humanity and power … You used that moment to feed on me. You hunted me … What you did was predatory, manipulative and evil. You violated me under the cloak of authority … You raped me when I had no freedom to run, no rights to call upon, no one I could tell without fear of retaliation. You didn't just hurt me, you shattered something sacred inside me. I'm still trying to crawl out of the hole you put me in.' She said he had 'groomed' her, saying he 'exploited my isolation, my loneliness, my hunger for basic humanity': 'You built a prison inside the prison, and I still live in that.' She added: 'I will no longer whisper the truth that you, your lawyer and CDCR tried to bury. This statement is for me so I can start to reclaim what you tried to take from me.' In an interview this week before sentencing, Nikki said she would not stay quiet: 'I'm doing this for the women who are still inside … who are too terrified to speak out, because that was once me, too.' She said the CDCR was 'run by bullies protecting themselves' and that while incarcerated, she faced harassment and intimidation after Rodriguez's abuse came to light: 'It was their way of silencing and normalizing the trauma they perpetuate … This was never about one bad apple. CDCR enabled Rodriguez, who got away with rape for years, and more abusers hide in plain sight. How many more women must be broken before we call this what it is: an injustice?' The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know. If you have something to share on this subject you can contact us confidentially using the following methods. Secure Messaging in the Guardian app The Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories. Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs. This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said. If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu. Select 'Secure Messaging'. SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and post If you can safely use the tor network without being observed or monitored you can send messages and documents to the Guardian via our SecureDrop platform. Finally, our guide at lists several ways to contact us securely, and discusses the pros and cons of each. On Thursday, before the sentence was announced, one incarcerated victim cried as she testified by Zoom from prison, condemning Rodriguez for failing to take responsibility or express remorse. Addressing his family, she said: 'He didn't think about his daughter when he raped me. He didn't care about me being someone's daughter … I will encourage women to speak up because there are too many men like you who are still out there.' Another survivor's statement, read by a victim's advocate, said that after Rodriguez raped her, she asked the CDCR for STD and pregnancy tests, but officials told her she would have to admit engaging in 'risky behavior' and could face discipline and a lengthened sentence. She criticized the department for not terminating supervisors and other officers who 'allowed this to continue for so long' despite knowing about Rodriguez's abuse. She said: 'The system has failed.' The CDCR previously said it had identified more than 22 potential victims of Rodriguez. A department spokesperson said on Thursday the sentence 'reaffirms CDCR's own internal investigation and referral' to prosecutors: 'The department resolutely condemns any staff member – especially a peace officer who is entrusted to enforce the law – who violates their oath and shatters public trust.' The spokesperson referred to a 2022 statement that said the CDCR enforces a 'zero-tolerance policy for sexual violence', that retaliation against people who report abuse 'is not tolerated', and that it was expanding its system of surveillance cameras to assist in 'preventing or detecting misconduct by both staff and inmate alike'. Last year, the US Department of Justice under the Biden administration opened a civil rights investigation into staff sexual abuse at CCWF and California's other women's prison, citing the Rodriguez case and hundreds of lawsuits. The justice department noted that officers accused of misconduct included 'the very people responsible for handling complaints of sexual abuse'. Under Trump, the justice department has dismissed police civil rights abuse cases brought by the previous administration, but advocates said the inquiry into California prison misconduct is ongoing. A justice department spokesperson declined to comment, and the CDCR spokesperson referred to a statement from last year saying the department 'embraces transparency' and welcomed the investigation. Information and support for anyone affected by rape or sexual abuse issues is available from the following organizations. In the US, Rainn offers support on 800-656-4673. In the UK, Rape Crisis offers support on 0808 500 2222. In Australia, support is available at 1800Respect (1800 737 732). Other international helplines can be found at
