Pleading final words of death row's oldest inmate, 75, as he was executed by injection for killing wife & her two sons
DEATH row's oldest inmate left behind an eerie plea with his final words before being executed by lethal injection.
Tennessee inmate Oscar Smith, 75, was put to death on Thursday morning for the 1989 murders of his ex-wife and her teenage sons in the state's first execution since 2020.
7
7
With his final words, Smith insisted that he was innocent and begged for the justice system to be reformed.
He said: "Somebody needs to tell the governor the justice system doesn't work."
Refuting his conviction one final time, Smith said: "I didn't kill her."
He was pronounced dead at 10:47am on Thursday after receiving a lethal dose of the drug pentobarbital at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution.
The Sun recently spoke to a former death row executioner who saw a killer's head burst into flames and a pastor who has accompanied with more inmates in their final minutes than anyone else.
Smith was convicted of fatally stabbing and shooting his estranged wife Judith Smith, 13-year-old Jason Burnett and 16-year-old Chad Burnett.
He murdered them at the home in Nashville, Tennessee, on October 1, 1989.
Sentenced to death in July 1990, Smith spent almost 35 years on death row, and was its oldest inmate in the US.
A county court judge denied a request to reopen the case in 2022 , despite some new evidence that another person's DNA had been on one of the murder weapons.
The judge ruled that the evidence of Smith's guilt was overwhelming and that the new information did not change that.
I'm a death row executioner - a killer's head burst into flames when I put him in electric chair
Two of Smith's colleagues told the original trial that he asked them to kill Judith.
He also had a history of violence and threats against the family.
Further clinching the conviction was the fact that Smith took out insurance policies on all three of his victims.
The court also heard that one of the teen victims could be heard screaming "Frank, no!" in the background of a 911 call at the time of the murders.
Frank is Smith's middle name, and the one he used regularly.
After Smith had been confirmed dead, Judith's two siblings said they still miss the three victims, all these years later.
7
7
Her sister, Terri Osborne, said the deaths are a reminder of the dangers of domestic violence.
She said: 'We know it is an incredibly hard thing to do to leave a spouse who is abusing, but pray that this case becomes a call to action, encouraging those in danger to seek help before it's too late."
Smith's execution was the first in Tennessee since 2020, and he chose the lethal injection - a cocktail of three drugs.
He could alternatively have chosen to be killed in the electric chair.
There has been significant controversy around the method in recent years - with Justice Sonia Sotomayor of the Supreme Court describing it as "the chemical equivalent of being burned at the stake".
7
7
In March, a double murderer called Brad Sigmon became the first person in the US to be executed by firing squad in 15 years.
He reportedly kept breathing after being shot three times in the chest.
Three special bullets were shot at his heart by three volunteer riflemen at the South Carolina Department of Corrections in Columbia.
Sigmon, 67, was convicted of beating to death with a baseball bat his ex-girlfriend's parents, David and Gladys Larke, at their Taylors home in 2001.
List of executions so far in 2025
January 31: Marion Bowman (South Carolina)
February 5: Steven Nelson (Texas)
February 6: Demetrius Frazier (Alabama)
February 13: James Ford (Florida)
February 13: Richard Tabler (Texas)
March 7: Brad Sigmon (South Carolina)
March 18: Jessie Hoffman (Louisiana)
March 19: Aaron Gunches (Arizona)
March 20: Wendell Grissom (Oklahoma)
March 20: Edward James (Florida)
April 8: Michael Tanzi (Florida)
April 11: Mikal Mahdi (South Carolina)
April 23: Moises Sandoval Mendoza (Texas)
April 24: James Osgood (Alabama)
May 1: Jeffrey Hutchinson (Florida)
May 15: Glen Rogers (Florida)
May 20: Benjamin Ritchie (Indiana)
May 20: Matthew Johnson (Texas)
May 22: Oscar Smith (Florida)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
42 minutes ago
- BBC News
How a polo-loving businessman was a secret global drug lord
On the surface, Muhammed Asif Hafeez was an upstanding individual.A global businessman and ambassador of a prestigious London polo club, he rubbed shoulders with the British elite, including members of the Royal also regularly passed on detailed information to the authorities in the UK and Middle East that, in some cases, led to the interception of huge shipments of drugs. He was motivated, he said, simply by what he saw as his "moral obligation to curb and highlight criminal activities".At least, that is what he would have had people reality, Hafeez was himself what US officials described as "one of the world's most prolific drug traffickers".From his residence in the UK, he was the puppet-master of a vast drugs empire, supplying many tonnes of heroin, methamphetamine and hashish from bases in Pakistan and India that were distributed across the world. The gangs he informed on were his rivals - and his motivation was to rid the market of his status in the underworld earned him the moniker "the Sultan".But this criminal power and prestige would not last forever. After a complex joint operation between the British and American authorities, Hafeez, 66, was extradited from the UK in 2023. He pleaded guilty last November. On Friday, he was sentenced to 16 years in a New York prison for conspiring to import drugs - including enough heroin for "millions of doses" - into the US. Having been in custody since 2017, Hafeez's sentence will end in BBC has closely followed Hafeez's case. We have pieced together information from court documents, corporate listings and interviews with people who knew wanted to find out how he managed to stay under the radar for so long - and how he eventually got caught. Hafeez was born in September 1958 to a middle-class family in Lahore, Pakistan. One of six children, his upbringing was comfortable. People in Lahore who knew the family told the BBC that his father had owned a factory near the city. Hafeez also later told a US court that he had trained as a commercial the early 1990s to about the mid-2010s, he ran an outwardly legitimate umbrella company called Sarwani International Corporation, with subsidiary businesses in Pakistan, the UAE and the to its website - which has since been shut down - it sold technical equipment to militaries, governments and police forces throughout the world, including equipment for drug the other businesses under the Sarwani umbrella were a textiles company registered in various countries, an Italian restaurant in Lahore that was a franchise of a well-known Knightsbridge brand, and a company named Tipmoor, based near Windsor to the west of London, which specialised in "polo and equestrian services".These businesses not only afforded him a luxury lifestyle, but secured him access to the UK's most exclusive circles. He was listed as an international ambassador for the prestigious Ham Polo Club for at least three years, from 2009 to 2011. He and his wife Shahina were also photographed chatting to Prince William, and embracing Prince Harry, at the club in Polo Club told the BBC that Hafeez had never been a member of the club, that the club no longer has "ambassadors", and that the current board "has no ties to him". It added that the event at which Hafeez and his wife were photographed meeting the princes "was run by a third party".Sarwani's different global arms were dissolved at various stages in the 2010s, according to their listings on Companies House and equivalent global registries. 'Something fishy going on' A former Sarwani employee based in the UAE told the BBC he suspected there had been "something fishy going on" when he worked for the business, because even big projects were "only paid for in cash". The employee - who has asked not to be identified, for fear of reprisals - said he eventually left the business because he felt uncomfortable with this."There were no [bank] transactions, no records, no existence," he told the would also periodically write letters to the authorities in the UAE and UK informing on rival cartels, under the guise of being a concerned member of the public. The BBC has seen these, as well as letters he received in response from the British Embassy in Dubai and the UK Home Office, thanking him and expressing their appreciation for him getting in Home Office told the BBC it does not comment on individual Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office and the Government of Dubai were contacted by the BBC for comment but did not respond. Members of Hafeez's family shared these letters with the BBC in 2018, while he was embroiled in a lengthy legal fight against extradition to the US. They also submitted them to courts in the UK and, later, to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), as evidence that he had been an informant and needed protection. All the courts disagreed and ruled that this was a ploy by Hafeez to rid the market of the ECHR said, was "someone who had brought to the attention of the authorities the criminal conduct of others who he knew to be actual or potential rivals to his substantial criminal enterprise". While Hafeez was writing these letters, a meeting took place in 2014 that - despite him not being there - would lead to his of Hafeez's close associates met a potential buyer from Colombia in a flat in Mombasa, Kenya. They burned a small amount of heroin in order to demonstrate how pure it was, and said they could supply him with any quantity of "100%... white crystal".The supplier of this high-quality heroin, they had told the buyer, was a man from Pakistan known as "the Sultan" - that is, they would soon learn was that the "buyer" from Colombia was actually working undercover for the US's Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA). The entire meeting was part of an elaborate sting operation, and had been covertly filmed - footage that has been obtained by the BBC. US court documents reveal the deal was co-ordinated by Baktash and Ibrahim Akasha, two brothers who led a violent cartel in Kenya. Their father was himself a feared kingpin who had been killed in Amsterdam's Red Light District in deal also involved Vijaygiri "Vicky" Goswami, an Indian national who managed the Akashas' October 2014, with the Akashas, Goswami and Hafeez still unaware of who the buyers really were, 99kg of heroin and 2kg of crystal meth were delivered to the fake Colombian traffickers. The Akashas promised to provide hundreds of kilograms more of each drug.A month later, the Akasha brothers and Goswami were arrested in Mombasa. They were released on bail shortly afterwards, and spent over two years fighting extradition to the the background, American law enforcers were working with counterparts in the UK to piece together their case against Hafeez, partly using evidence gathered from devices they had seized when they arrested Goswami and the Akasha brothers. On those, they had found multiple references to Hafeez as a major supplier, and were able to find enough evidence to identify him as "the Sultan".Facing charges in the US didn't stop one of the men, Goswami, from continuing his illegal enterprise. In 2015, while on bail in Kenya, he hatched a plan with Hafeez to transport several tonnes of a drug called ephedrine from a chemical factory in Solapur, India, to a powerful medication that is legal in limited quantities, is used to make methamphetamine. The two men - Goswami and Hafeez - planned to set up a meth factory in Mozambique's capital, Maputo, US court documents show. But their scheme was abandoned in 2016, when police raided the Solapur plant and seized 18 tonnes of Akasha brothers and Goswami finally boarded a flight to the US to face trial in January 2017. Hafeez was arrested eight months later in London, at his flat in the affluent St John's Wood neighbourhood. He was detained at high security Belmarsh Prison in south-east London, and it was from there that he spent six years fighting extradition to the US.A big development happened in 2019 in the US. Goswami pleaded guilty, and told a New York court he had agreed to co-operate with prosecutors. The Akasha brothers also pleaded Akasha was sentenced to 25 years in prison. His brother Ibrahim was sentenced to 23 who is yet to be sentenced, would have testified against Hafeez in the US had the case gone to Belmarsh, Hafeez was running out of tried to stop extradition to the US - but failed to convince magistrates, the High Court in London and the ECHR that he had, in fact, been an informant to the authorities who was "at risk of ill-treatment from his fellow prisoners" as a result. He also claimed the conditions in a US prison would be "inhuman and degrading" for him because of his health conditions, including type 2 diabetes and lost all of these arguments at every stage and was extradited in May case did not go to trial. In November last year, Hafeez pleaded guilty to two counts of conspiring to manufacture and distribute heroin, methamphetamine and hashish and to import them into the US. Pre-sentencing, prosecutors described the "extremely fortunate circumstances" of Hafeez's life, which "throw into harsh relief his decision to scheme... and to profit from the distribution of dangerous substances that destroy lives and whole communities"."Unlike many traffickers whose drug activities are borne, at least in part, from desperation, poverty, and a lack of educational opportunities," they said, "the defendant has lived a life replete with privilege and choice."
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Daughter of Benidorm attack victim in plea for answers
The daughter of a British man who died after being attacked by a stranger in a Spanish resort city in 2018 has renewed her call for information to help find his killer. Mike Rydings, 48, from Wythenshawe in Manchester, was celebrating a friend's 50th birthday and watching the World Cup at a bar in Benidorm when he was set upon in the early hours of 23 June. His daughter Hayley Barker said witnesses saw him backing away "with his hands up" before he was punched in the face, leaving him with a broken nose and serious head injures after falling on to the concrete. Mr Rydings was treated in a Spanish hospital before being moved to Salford Royal, but died 14 months later. Ms Barker said an investigation by both Spanish and Greater Manchester Police (GMP) had failed to find identify the attacker, despite GMP interviewing a range of British holidaymakers who were at the Hippodrome Bar at the time. "It makes me feel angry," she told BBC Radio Manchester. "My dad was stolen from me in such cruel circumstances, whoever has done this still gets to live their life."We can't move forward as such because we don't have justice." She called for anyone who may have new information that could help to contact GMP. "It would mean the world - we'd actually get some answers, it's what we deserve as a family," Ms Barker said. GMP said while the investigation was the responsibility of Spanish authorities, they were ready to assist if required. She said her father was 5ft 10ins (1.55m), had a stocky build and was wearing a red Hugo Boss t-shirt and glasses at the time of the attack. While Ms Barker said she had great memories of her dad being "the life and soul of the party" before his attack, her children had no memory of him. She said she was pregnant with her first child, a daughter, when Mr Rydings was attacked. "He never even got to hold her because of the condition he was left in before he passed away," she said. "In 2022 I had a son who would have been his only grandson, so that was very sad." Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
'Women are dying while domestic murder reviews plod along'
"There are women dying while these reviews are plodding along."Poppy Devey Waterhouse was 24-years-old when she was murdered by her ex-boyfriend Joe was described by her family as "a bright button" who loved to travel and who was excited about the next chapter of her instead, this was "cruelly and senselessly cut short", when Atkinson failed to come to terms with the end of their three-year repeatedly stabbed Poppy in a rage at their flat in Leeds in 2018 using a kitchen knife that left her with more than 100 has taken more than five years for a Domestic Homicide Review (DHR) to be completed to find out whether lessons could be learnt from Poppy's has been a process which her mother, Julie Devey, from Frome in Somerset, describes as "excruciating"."You have no idea it's going to be like that," she said."You get the review and you read it and as I turned the pages, I couldn't understand it, it wasn't Poppy's voice, it was his voice, it was all about him." The review into Poppy's death was published by the Home Office in May - more than five years and eight versions said that the final report was "vastly different" to how the first one was written."We are very happy with how its written [now]," she added."He [Atkinson] is represented in it, but it's not 'poor me, poor me'. There are a few recommendations, but they were small things."Atkinson, 25, who admitted Poppy's murder, was jailed in 2019 for a minimum of 15 years and 310 Poppy's death, a DHR was commissioned by Safer Leeds, a safety partnership made up of local organisations including the council, police and health care found Poppy's death was neither predictable or review recommended raising awareness of domestic abuse and delivering a public or education focused campaign on the risks that might be present during the separation of a relationship. This would include recognising what could be considered obsessive, controlling and stalking behaviour. If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this story, support and advice is available via BBC Action Line. Every domestic killing or suicide involving people aged 16 and over in England and Wales is subject to a DHR, recently renamed as a domestic abuse-related death review (DARDR).They examine the role of professionals who had contact with the victim or the perpetrator before an attack, but do not issue Office guidance states the reviews, which make recommendations to help prevent other people being killed by partners or family members, should be finished within six BBC research has revealed just 1% of reviews into domestic abuse-related deaths in England and Wales are being completed in the recommended time, with most taking years. But for Julie, it was not only delays that made the review process difficult."There were endless examples of language used [in the report] that took away the responsibility from his decision making," she said."It was arduous, you'd send it back with recommended changes and then it would come back, and you'd have to do it all over again."Poppy needed to be the centre of this review - as her mum I had to represent her."Despite this, Julie - who has also been campaigning for tougher sentences for those who commit domestic murders - believes DHRs are important as it has provided the family with a thorough picture of the last few months before Poppy died."But the length of time they are taking is excruciating," she added."The idea is to find out if the death was preventable or predictable, and to come up with recommendations to save other lives."There are women dying while these are plodding along."A Leeds City Council spokesperson said Safer Leeds has been improving the review processes and expressed its "apologies for the delays in completing this review"."Unfortunately, the process involved does not lend itself to completion within six months with reviews often having to be paused. There are a number of factors that can cause a delay to a report, including coronial or judicial processes and we recognise that this does add to a family's trauma," they said. Julie is one of a number of bereaved families that the BBC has spoken to who have criticised the length of time the reviews Jane Monckton-Smith, a criminologist specialising in domestic homicide at the University of Gloucestershire, said when done properly DHRs can bring about real change."I do think there are ways that we could make them more efficient and perhaps more effective," she said."I'm not sure we need a big panel of people sitting for multiple meetings for every review."Prof Monckton-Smith, who has chaired several reviews, said six months - the recommended time for completion - is "too short" but four or five years is "far too long" for families to wait. Minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, Jess Phillips, said DHRs offer "a really important opportunity" for agencies to improve their safeguarding practices and ultimately prevent these deaths from happening."But we know that more needs to be done to ensure these reviews are effective and timely, which is why we are cracking on with action to improve the way they are undertaken," she government is now creating a new oversight board with publicly appointed members to make the process for reviewing reports faster, she added. Julie said that during conversations with Safer Leeds it has "taken onboard several ideas that we thought would help other families and those writing it". "One simple thing we asked for was that a photo of the victim is always present when the DHR is being completed, so it takes it away from being an administrative task and so the victim is the centre of all the conversations taking place," she said."We also thought there should always be a person on the panel who is from a women's organisation to ensure there is no victim blaming language."Leeds City Council added that every review is now reviewed at draft stage by a senior manager specifically to ensure that it "focuses on the voice and life of the victim and not the perpetrator"."Safer Leeds will continue to work to improve the timeliness of reports, putting bereaved families at the forefront of the review," it added.
