Appeal against Teesside 'net zero' power station dismissed
In March, Dr Boswell's legal representatives had argued the government did not fully explore the environmental impacts of the scheme before approving it.DESNZ said it had acknowledged the "significant" greenhouse gas emissions the scheme would cause before any decision was made.Barrister Rose Grogan, for DESNZ, had told the court: "Fossil fuel remains part of the government's energy mix. "It's part of the transition to a low-carbon economy... but it needs to be low carbon through the deployment of CCS [carbon capture and storage]."
The plant, which is planned for the Teesworks site, near Redcar, is being developed by a firm called Net Zero Teesside Power – owned by BP and Equinor.The company previously stated the project could generate up to 860MW of low-carbon electricity.It has claimed at least 90% of the gas power station's emissions would be captured and funnelled beneath the North Sea.
'No merit in challenge'
In its judgement, the court said its task was simply to determine whether or not the decision-making process surrounding the power plant was lawful.It said the "evaluation" and "acceptability" of the estimated emissions caused by the plant was a "matter of fact and judgement for the decision-maker".The government had made "lawful and properly reasoned conclusions" regarding the plant's potential greenhouse gas emissions, the court said.Net Zero Teesside Power said: "[We] welcome this second judicial confirmation that there is no merit in Andrew Boswell's challenge."Dr Boswell called for the government to launch a scientific review into the use of carbon capture and storage technology (CCS) for gas power plants.
Follow BBC Tees on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
8 minutes ago
- The Independent
Government ‘admits 49 Afghan data breaches in four years'
The Ministry of Defence has admitted there have been dozens more data breaches relating to Afghan relocation cases than publicly known, according to a report. A Freedom of Information request by the BBC revealed there had been 49 data breaches in the past four years, including four already known to the public. Seven breaches were serious enough to be reported to the UK's data watchdog, the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), three of which had not been made public, the broadcaster reported. Those three included one in 2021 and two in 2022, the same year a major leak prompted the Government to obtain an unprecedented superinjunction barring journalists from reporting it. The Ministry of Defence (MOD) did not provide any details of the nature of each breach. Adnan Malik, of Barings Law, which represents 1,500 affected people, said: 'This represents a deeply alarming data failure and the recent 49 Ministry of Defence breaches make clear that the Afghan case was not an isolated error but part of a wider and troubling pattern of negligence.' Last month, a High Court judge lifted the gagging order relating to the major breach, which saw the details of 18,714 applicants for the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (Arap) scheme released in 2022. When the breach was discovered more than a year later in August 2023, the MoD were granted an unprecedented gagging order amid fears the Taliban could target would-be refugees for reprisals. It also saw the establishment of a secret £850 million scheme, the Afghanistan Response Route (ARR), to bring thousands of those affected to the UK. Arap was responsible for relocating Afghan nationals who had worked for or with the UK Government and were therefore at risk of reprisals once the Taliban returned to power in Kabul in 2021. An MOD spokesperson said: 'We take data security extremely seriously and are committed to ensuring that any incidents are dealt with properly, and that we follow our legal duties. 'All incidents that meet the threshold under UK data protection laws are referred to the Information Commissioner's Office and any lesser incidents are examined internally to ensure lessons are learned.' The ICO said it continues to engage with the MoD and 'can be assured that they have made the required improvements'.
The Independent
8 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘Hypocritical' Badenoch calls for Tory councils to launch legal challenges against asylum hotels
Kemi Badenoch has been branded a 'hypocrite' for calling for Conservative councils to challenge the use of so-called asylum hotels in their local areas. The Tory leader said in a letter on Wednesday that she was 'encouraging' councils to 'take the same steps' as Epping Forest District Council 'if your legal advice supports it'. But the move has been criticised as 'desperate and hypocritical nonsense', given the Conservative's own record with asylum hotels. At the peak of their use in the summer of 2023 under the Conservative government, there were more than 400 asylum hotels in use. Figures on those staying in hotels date back to December 2022 and showed numbers hit a peak at the end of September 2023, when there were 56,042 asylum seekers in hotels. The Essex council secured a temporary injunction from the High Court on Tuesday, blocking the use of Epping's Bell Hotel as accommodation for asylum seekers on planning grounds. Speaking on Thursday morning, shadow home secretary Chris Philp admitted there 'should not have been 56,000 people in hotels' under the conservatives, but echoed Ms Badenoch's call for councils to take legal action. Mr Philp said: 'Kemi's letter yesterday said she would support and encourage conservative councils to follow what conservative-led Epping started in fighting the use of asylum hotels, where there is a legal basis to challenge them. 'What the Epping case has demonstrated is at least some of these asylum hotels the government are using aren't being done so in accordance with the law. We're encouraging and supporting conservative councils to do what Epping has done in standing up for their local communities.' Mr Philp said he had written to the home secretary, Yvette Cooper, to ask that people being moved out of the Bell Hotel are not put in another hotel or housed in multiple occupation (HMOs). School standards minister Cat McKinnell said she would not be able to comment on the specifics on where people being housed in hotels would be moved to. The government is facing the prospect that more councils across the country could also launch legal action to restrict the use of the hotels. These include Labour-run Tamworth and Wirral councils, Tory-run Broxbourne and East Lindsey councils and Reform's Staffordshire and West Northamptonshire councils. When asked whether she would support Labour-run councils in doing so, Ms McKinnell said it 'wasn't her place' to comment on what 'would be a legal process' and said: 'I think it's important the government works really closely with local authorities to manage these circumstances within local communities. 'We recognise the legitimate concerns and the efforts that local authorities are making to make sure the situation under their locality is appropriate.' A Labour spokesperson said Mrs Badenoch's letter was a 'pathetic stunt' and 'desperate and hypocritical nonsense from the architects of the broken asylum system', saying there were now '20,000 fewer asylum seekers in hotels than at their peak under the Tories'. The Bell Hotel in Epping had previously been used as asylum accommodation briefly in 2020 and then between 2022 and 2024, also under the previous Conservative government. According to new Home Office data from Thursday morning, the number of asylum seekers in hotels has dropped slightly from 32,345 in March this year, to 32,059 in June 2025. However, figures from the last 12 months during Labour's first year in power show that the figure has increased from 29,585 compared to 32,059 this year - a rise of 8 per cent.
Daily Mail
9 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
DANIEL HANNAN: Lucy Connolly is just a mother who made a mistake and has been ludicrously and despotically punished for it. If we tolerate such blatant double standards we'll no longer be a free society
Lucy Connolly was a political prisoner. There is no other way to describe the viciousness with which she was charged, prosecuted, sentenced and even reportedly dealt with in prison. Today, after more than a year behind bars, the Northampton childminder will finally be reunited with her husband and 13-year-old daughter.
