Can't declare physio degree on par with MBBS, says HC
"This court will not direct the authority to consider degree in question as a qualification at par with graduate bachelor's degree in medicine as required under the relevant service rules," Justice Ajit Kumar observed.
Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission issued an advertisement on July 14, 2014, inviting applications for the post of food safety officer with a minimum qualification of a degree in medicine.
The petitioner, Sandhya Yadav, appeared in the written examination and after clearing it, she was issued a call letter for the interview.
However, she was not permitted to participate in the interview as she had a degree in physiotherapy, not medicine. Result was declared on Jan 29, 2015. She then filed a petition before the high court.
The counsel for UP Public Service Commission submitted that the central govt had not notified any other equivalent qualification to the qualification prescribed under the rules. The commission concluded the bachelor's degree in physiotherapy is not equivalent to a degree in medicine/medical science.
The HC further noted in its July 4 order: "This selection pertains to the year 2014 advertisement, which has been completed. This court cannot permit re-opening of selection at this stage."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
15 hours ago
- Time of India
Disability guidelines for NEET 2025 admission fall short, defy Supreme Court directives
NEET 2025 disability guidelines fall short of Supreme Court directives, say activists. (AI Image) Candidates will be assessed based on the benchmark disability criteria outlined in their respective UDID cards The National Medical Commission (NMC) recently released the disability guidelines for MBBS admissions for the academic year 2025-26. Disappointed that the guidelines do not adhere to the Supreme Court (SC) directives, disability rights activists wrote a letter to the Directorate General of Health Services (DGHS), calling for the need to rectify the guidelines. However, the NMC says that the interim disability guidelines will be updated regularly in a phased manner based on the feedback collected from the students falling under the Persons with Benchmark Disability (PwBD) category. Dr Vikrant Sirohi, activist, Doctors with Disabilities, Agents of Change organisation, stated in the letter to the DGHS, "In the case of Omkar Ramchandra Gond vs Union of India, the SC directed an increase in the number of medical boards across the country, mandating at least one medical board in each state and Union Territory for proper medical examinations. However, the list of medical boards notified for the 2025 counselling includes only 16 centres located in 11 states. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Could This NEW Collagen Blend Finally Reduce Your Cellulite? Vitauthority Learn More Undo " Furthermore, the SC directives also required that enabling units and equal opportunity cells, as mandated by the University Grants Commission (UGC), be included in MBBS admission booklets and college websites. Additionally, a database on accessibility and reasonable accommodations at medical colleges should be created. Dr Sirohi added, "These directives remain unimplemented. Moreover, the UGC's accessibility guidelines and standards for Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) 2024 also mandate the establishment of enabling units." A NEET-qualified candidate from Malda, West Bengal, who cleared NEET 2025 with 338 marks and a PwBD rank of 496, says, "I have to travel to Varanasi to get the screening done as there are no medical boards available in my state and the nearest one is in Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh." He has low vision disability of approximately 60%. Speaking to Education Times, Dr BN Gangadhar, chairman, NMC, says, "To improve accessibility of medical boards for PwBD candidates, the NMC is working to increase the number of medical boards. These reforms are part of our commitment to service and welfare. The commission will seek feedback from PwBD students admitted to MBBS colleges to gather information and build a database on accessibility and reasonable accommodations. For now, the NMC has refrained from fully implementing this, as each disability is unique and requires special attention." Dr Satendra Singh, disability rights activist and faculty member at University College of Medical Sciences (UCMS), Delhi, says, "NEET 2025-qualified PwBD students have contacted us, reporting the difficulties they face. For example, a PwBD candidate who uses a motorised wheelchair went to a medical board in Tamil Nadu for the required screening and assessment for medical college admission. She was taken aback when questioned about her ability to save a patient bleeding on the roadside. Her guardians were told to take her home and get her treated by a physiotherapist instead." Dr Gangadhar says, "We have conducted awareness programmes for these medical boards, sensitising them to the needs of PwBD candidates and their screening process. Furthermore, medical assessment officials are now required to submit a report specifying the candidate's disability and the reasons for denial of admission." Self-declaration Form Under Appendix D of the new disability guidelines, PwBD students must declare their locomotor disabilities. This appendix contains a list of activities related to their functional abilities, such as whether they can bear weight and stand on both legs, bear weight and stand on the affected leg, walk on plain surfaces, climb stairs independently, go downstairs independently, and other similar tasks. Dr Sharad Philip, clinical assistant professor, Department of Psychiatry, AIIMS Guwahati, who has 70% permanent disability due to retinitis pigmentosa in both eyes, was disheartened with the type of functional abilities students are required to declare for admission. He says, "Self-declaration is acceptable if it ends there, but it does not. The self-declaration form requires learners with disabilities to comment on abilities such as 'I can stand on my affected leg,' 'I can hold and drink a glass of water,' and more. None of these is relevant to medical training or education. These guidelines fail to adhere to the universal design for PwBD education, assistive technology, or reasonable accommodations. Instead, the onus is on the learner with disabilities to essentially screen themselves." Dr Gangadhar says, "The assessment form is used to declare the type of disability. However, candidates with disabilities will be evaluated by designated medical boards, where the assessment will focus on functional ability rather than a technical evaluation. Furthermore, candidates will be assessed based on the benchmark disability criteria outlined in the Unique Disability Identification (UDID) card." The UDID card is a mandatory document for individuals with disabilities and serves as an essential and authoritative proof for determining the eligibility of NEET-qualified candidates under the disability category. TOI Education is on WhatsApp now. Follow us here . Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
NEET UG counselling 2025: West Bengal releases provisional merit list, 11,178 candidates eligible for first round
The West Bengal Medical Counselling Committee (WBMCC) has published the updated provisional state merit list for NEET UG 2025 counselling under the 85 per cent state quota. According to official figures, 11,178 candidates have been deemed eligible to participate in the first round of choice filling for MBBS and BDS admissions across government and private medical institutions in the state. In addition, the WBMCC has issued the seat matrix for the academic session 2025–26, confirming a total of 5,589 seats on offer in MBBS and BDS programmes. West Bengal Medical Counselling 2025 : Choice filling and locking deadline The choice filling process has already commenced and will remain open until midnight on August 17. Candidates must carefully arrange and lock their preferences before the deadline, as no further modifications will be allowed once the choices are submitted. West Bengal Medical counselling 2025: Admission schedule As per the official counselling calendar: Seat allotment results will be declared on August 20. Students allotted seats must report to their respective colleges for admission between August 21 and 23 from 11 am to 4 pm. Round two registration is scheduled to begin on August 27, open to candidates dissatisfied with their first allotment or those who missed the initial registration. West Bengal NEET UG provisional merit list 2025: Steps to download Candidates can click on the link provided here to download the West Bengal NEET UG provisional merit list 2025 from the official website: Visit the official website : Go to Select the counselling section : On the homepage, click on UG Medical/Dental Counselling 2025. Find the merit list link : Under the Notices/Announcements or Download section, locate the link titled Provisional State Merit List for NEET UG 2025 (85% State Quota). Click on the link : The merit list PDF will open in a new window. Download the file : Click the download icon or press Ctrl + S (Windows) / Command + S (Mac) to save the document to your device. Check your details : Open the PDF and search your NEET UG roll number or name using the Ctrl + F function. Alternatively, candidates can click on the link provided here to download the West Bengal NEET UG provisional merit list 2025. West Bengal NEET UG counselling 2025: Steps to apply Candidates can follow the steps mentioned here to apply for the West Bengal NEET UG Counselling 2025: Visit the official WBMCC portal – Log in with NEET UG roll number and security pin. Check available seat options displayed on the dashboard. Arrange preferences as per choice; edit and reorder if required. Lock the final list of preferences before the deadline. Download and save a copy of the submitted list for future reference. Context and significance The NEET UG counselling process is critical for aspiring medical students in West Bengal, as the state quota accounts for the majority of MBBS and BDS admissions. With over 11,000 candidates vying for just 5,589 seats, competition remains intense. Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
The Hindu
3 days ago
- The Hindu
Maharashtra Health Department integrates TB screening into medical college family adoption programmes
In a bid to tackle the challenge of delays in identifying persons with presumptive Tuberculosis (PwTB), the Maharashtra health department has asked medical colleges to incorporate Active Case Finding (ACF) activities into the Family Adoption Programme (FAP) of medical colleges. Active Case Finding (ACF) is one of the strategies used by the National Tuberculosis Elimination Programme (NTEP) to detect missing PwTB. Dr. Sandeep Sangale, Joint Director of Maharashtra State Health Services (TB and Leprosy) department, issued a notice directing colleges and universities to integrate TB screening activities into the FAP, asking that reports of collected data be sent to respective District TB officers for further integration into the NTEP. The move comes after Bharati Vidyapeeth Medical College in Maharashtra's Pune and the District TB Unit ran a pilot programme in rural Pune villages, integrating ACF activities, including community screening for TB through door-to-door visits. The team, including Swathi Njarekkattuvalappil, Saibal Adhya, and Sanjivani Patil from Bharati Vidyapeeth Medical College and Sanjay Darade from Pune District TB centre, wrote a proposal to the State Health Department for ACF integration. According to the proposal, Maharashtra state has around 80 medical colleges (government and private/deemed) with a yearly intake of an average of 150 students each, with each student allotted 5 households for follow-up over the next 3 years under FAP. With this integration of TB care with FAP, students can screen a cohort of 60,000 households (approximately 2,40,000 individuals) across the state each year and continue their follow-up for at least the next 3 years. 'The pilot programme was about providing hands-on experience to detect presumptive TB in individuals for early-stage treatment. This was more about training MBBS students to ask the right questions and detect symptoms for further diagnosis,' said Ms. Njarekkattuvalappil. The pilot programme was implemented in September last year, with five batches of 30–35 MBBS students each working in four villages, including Bhukum and Ambarwet grampanchayats of Pune's Paud, where active case finding was conducted. At least 959 individuals were screened, with 10 identified as having presumptive TB. The authors selected Paud because it reported 1,057 cases of TB (13% of total notified cases from Pune Rural) in 2022, the second highest among the 14 TUs constituting Pune rural district. Maharashtra is among the leading contributors to the country's TB burden; it reported about 2.34 lakh cases in 2022, about 10% of total notified cases in India. Almost 64% of the symptomatic population in India do not seek healthcare, mainly due to ignoring symptoms and lack of awareness. Speaking to The Hindu, Ms. Njarekkattuvalappil said, 'Now that the government has issued a notice for integration, we will be holding meetings next week with medical deans, directors and district medical officers to explain the process and share all important aspects of the study, including the questionnaire.'
