SAAQclic ‘bumpy' as early as 2018, witness tells Gallant commission
The digital transition at Quebec's automobile insurance board (SAAQ) was already 'bumpy' in 2018, the commission investigating the SAAQclic fiasco heard Monday.
Sylvain Cloutier, director of the project office, testified before the Gallant commission, which travelled to Quebec City to begin its sixth week of hearings.
He spoke about the coloured indicators used by his team to track progress — markers that, without clear explanation, often shifted from red to green.
'When things become increasingly chaotic, doesn't accountability matter?' asked Justice Denis Gallant, pressing Cloutier on his apparent lack of control over how the colours were assigned.
Cloutier said the indicators 'on their own weren't enough' to give a full picture of the project's status.
The board's vice-president of information technology, Karl Malenfant, would regularly step in to offer 'explanations.'
Malenfant's name has surfaced repeatedly over the past six weeks at the Gallant commission.
'There were problems, but Mr. Malenfant didn't try to hide them,' said Cloutier.
'He's an experienced man. He's led major projects at Hydro-Québec, at Rio Tinto. He knows what he's talking about. He came in to explain things and reassure the team — not reassure as in spinning stories,' Cloutier added.
'Was everyone aware?' commission lawyer Vincent Ranger asked. 'Was Mr. Malenfant transparent about how difficult the rollout was?'
'Yes,' Cloutier replied.
'Would it be fair to say Mr. Malenfant is naturally optimistic?' Ranger followed up.
'Yes, that's true,' Cloutier said. 'But not in a head-in-the-clouds way. He likes a challenge.'
'I didn't take bribes'
Cloutier also admitted Monday to manipulating a public tender worth over $1 million so it would be awarded to external consultant Stéphane Mercier.
'That was my mistake,' Cloutier acknowledged under questioning from Justice Gallant.
'I'm not saying what I did was right. But I take responsibility — it was me.'
In 2017, Cloutier urgently requested the bidding threshold be lowered to $990,000 after Mercier informed him he couldn't qualify for the contract because he didn't have authorization from Quebec's financial markets authority.
That authorization is required for contracts valued at more than $1 million.
'I was in a panic,' Cloutier said, recalling thinking, 'If I don't have this guy to keep going, we're in deep trouble (…) I'm losing expertise.'
'I did it with the intention of not delaying the project,' he said. 'I didn't take any bribes. I'm not going on fishing trips. I'm not sailing around on a yacht. That's not what this is.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published in French June 9, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
8 minutes ago
- National Post
'Dangerous decision': Telecom CEO blasts Joly's decision to uphold CRTC's wholesale internet rules
Article content 'By immediately increasing competition and consumer choice, the CRTC's decision aims to reduce the cost of high-speed Internet for Canadians and will contribute toward our broader mandate to bring down costs across the board,' she wrote. Article content The decision was made the day before Bell Canada's quarterly results were announced. Bell's stock was down that morning, and observers noted a correlation with the minister's decision. Article content Article content In an analyst call that morning, Bell's CEO Mirko Bibic said he was 'disappointed' and urged the government and the CRTC 'to ensure that network builders are fully compensated for significant build costs and investment risks they take in building.' Article content It also came a few weeks after Cogeco announced a new mobile service with an introductory one-year free offer. Article content 'With this decision, the minister is essentially saying it's okay if the Big Three get even bigger. It's okay if the regional, local players suffer, and it's okay if there's a re-monopolization of telecoms in Canada,' Perron said. Article content 'We don't think it's okay. Consumers won't think it's okay, and we'll fight to make sure it doesn't happen.' Article content Cogeco and Eastlink, which announced last week it was 'suspending further planned upgrades to many smaller communities across Canada,' filed an appeal in July asking the Federal Court of Appeal to quash the decision. Article content But in Ottawa, overriding a decision from the CRTC was seen as a 'bold move' and that could 'rattle the cage' not even six months after an election and a new prime minister in charge. Sources said the minister had a duty to ensure the sustainability of institutions and protect the national interest. Article content Champagne, who has since become minister of finance, did not comment for this story. His office confirmed that he attended the cabinet meeting in which the decision was confirmed and that 'Canada's new government has a strong mandate to bring costs down and to build one, strong, Canadian economy.' Article content 'We would have liked to see a lot more courage, and I'm happy to be quoted on that. It seems to me like deferring to the CRTC and maintaining the status quo was the easy way, but not the right way. Sometimes the best decision is the hard decision in life, and we are saddened that the hard decision was not made,' said Perron. In a statement last week, Rogers Communications said 'the Carney government has declared its priority is to build a strong Canada and this decision does the exact opposite.' Article content A recent PwC study shows that the telecommunication sector directly contributed $87.3 billion in GDP to Canada's economy and supported over 661,000 jobs in 2024. Article content By 2035, the Canadian telecom industry could contribute another $112 billion to Canada's overall GDP, according to the study. Article content
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Sudbury police probe apparent pellet gun damage in Copper Cliff
Greater Sudbury police are investigating after youths allegedly fired a pellet gun at a Copper Cliff homes Sunday night. A resident reported loud bangs on their window around 10:30 p.m. before seeing a group flee. Ward 2 Coun. Eric Benoit urged residents to report incidents and consider security cameras. Police say pellet guns aren't illegal but misuse can lead to mischief charges.
CTV News
3 hours ago
- CTV News
Air Canada, flight attendants yet to call 72-hour notice of job action
MONTREAL — There's no word yet whether Air Canada and the union representing some 10,000 of its flight attendants have averted a possible strike or lockout that could begin as soon as Saturday. The Air Canada component of the Canadian Union of Public Employees will be in position to strike as of 12:01 a.m. ET on Saturday. That means the required 72 hours' notice for any job action could be given at any point. However, there is so far no indication from either side that notice of strike or a lockout has been served, or that a tentative deal that would avert a work stoppage has been reached. Air Canada said on Tuesday afternoon it has reached an 'impasse' in negotiations with the union, which on Tuesday said it declined a proposal from the airline to enter a binding arbitration process. In a statement, the airline said in the event of a stoppage, it would notify customers whose flights are potentially cancelled and they will be eligible for a full refund, which could be obtained through its website or the Air Canada mobile app. It said it has made arrangements with other Canadian and foreign carriers and Via Rail to provide customers alternative travel options 'to the extent possible.' Earlier Tuesday, CUPE said in an update to members that the company has 'decided they no longer want to negotiate.' The union attached a letter that it received from Air Canada, dated Monday, in which the airline proposed going the arbitration route to secure a new contract. That would have suspended the union's right to strike, as well as Air Canada's right to lock out union members, the letter noted. Last week, the flight attendants voted 99.7 per cent in favour of giving their union a strike mandate, which is effective for 60 days. 'After eight months of negotiation, we have been unable to reach a tentative collective agreement despite our best efforts and those of the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service,' stated the Air Canada letter, signed by executive vice-president and chief human resources officer Arielle Meloul-Wechsler. 'Engaging in interest arbitration will let the flight attendants, CUPE, Air Canada and Air Canada Rouge move forward without further delay and uncertainty, both of which weigh on us all.' The letter pointed out that Air Canada and CUPE have successfully used arbitration in previous negotiations. But CUPE called it a 'proposal to preserve an exploitative system and strip away (members') voice.' 'Everyone knows that the best deals are made at the bargaining table, not handed down by an outside third party,' the union said in its message to members. It said that, unlike with a tentative agreement reached through negotiations, members would not get a chance to vote on an arbitrator's decision, which would be final. The union also said arbitrators 'rely on precedent and the status quo to make their determinations,' which runs counter to its objectives in bargaining talks. 'Air Canada flight attendants are trying to break the status quo by ending the historic abuse of unpaid work in this industry,' it said. 'Air Canada wants an arbitrator to do their dirty work for them to keep the status quo intact.' The union has said its main sticking points revolve around what it calls flight attendants' 'poverty wages' and unpaid labour when planes aren't in the air. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 13, 2025
