Scottish FA referees chief Willie Collum hits back at John Brown over corruption claim
The Ibrox club were fined £3,000 by the Scottish FA after Brown, while commentating on Rangers TV, described a decision not to allow the club a goal against Hibernian as 'corrupt', and doubled down on his allegation when given the opportunity to row back on his comment.
Rangers protested the fine and said Brown had spoken 'spontaneously and emotionally' and that his comments 'come with the territory' of live broadcasting.
Asked for his view on the comments, Collum was quick to defend his referees and dismiss the allegation.
'What I would say is that I don't think there is any corruption in Scottish football', he told STV. 'I don't think our officials are corrupt.
'Absolutely not. I'm guaranteeing that. I wouldn't be sitting here if that were the case.
'Our referees are like any referees, and they will make mistakes.
What I would say is that when mistakes are made we always try to improve on them. Always.
'But there's no corruption in Scottish refereeing.'
The former top-flight referee says those kinds of allegations aren't welcome, and he prefers to put his energy into raising standards and supporting referees ahead of another busy and challenging season.
'We don't want any comments about corruption or referees,' Collum said. 'I'm focusing on the job at hand.
'For me, that's to prepare the referees and make sure they are well prepared for the new season, focused and ready.
'We leave these kinds of matters to be dealt with by other people.'
'I would say it is corrupt'
The controversy over Brown's comments comes from Rangers TV's coverage of the team's match away against Hibs in May.
Rangers thought they had opened up a two-goal lead in the game, when Nico Raskin believed he had scored before a clearance from Rocky Bushiri.
Referee Nick Walsh and his assistants didn't give the goal and Hibs went on to equalise moments later through Kieron Bowie. A lengthy VAR check by Andrew Dallas reached the conclusion there was no camera angle that proved the ball had fully crossed the line.
Rangers later slammed the decision and called for the introduction of goal-line technology but Brown's disciplinary charge comes from his words in commentary at the time of the incident.
'I would say it is corrupt,' the former defender said, before commentator Tom Miller replied: 'Well, I'm not sure we can actually say that.'
Brown then doubled down, replying: 'Well, I am saying it'.
Rangers insist that those were 'spontaneous, corrected remarks' that should not meet the threshold for action and said that they presented the disciplinary panel with numerous other examples that showed inconsistency in what was being punished.
'These incidents raise legitimate questions about Scottish FA rules and how consistently they are enforced,' a club spokesperson said in a lengthy statement. 'To our knowledge, none of these cases appear to have resulted in charges against the respective clubs.
'The lack of consistency with the Scottish FA's policing of similar incidents leaves more questions than answers. That is why we will be contacting the Scottish FA chief executive and president to seek clarity on what policies and processes the compliance officer has in place, if any, to ensure a consistent and proportionate approach to enforcement and the equal treatment of member clubs.
'We shall also be asking the Scottish FA whether they accept that a rule that cannot be applied consistently across all clubs and all platforms risks losing credibility as a fair and enforceable regulation.
'Our aim here is to understand the rationale behind the differing outcomes. A lack of consistency, or the perception of it, undermines confidence in the disciplinary process and exposes all member clubs to uncertainty about what is and is not allowed.'
The club says they did not reference other examples because they believe they should have resulted in sanctions, but to highlight inconsistency.
Action being taken over comments made by club employees is relatively rare, but BBC pundit Richard Foster was charged by compliance officer Martin Black for a similar rule breach last year.
Foster was disciplined because he was a Motherwell coach when he appeared on radio in his role as a pundit and described an SFA description of a refereeing decision as 'lies'.
He later apologised but was given a six-game suspension over the outburst.
STV News is now on WhatsApp
Get all the latest news from around the country
Follow STV News
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Belfast Telegraph
16 minutes ago
- Belfast Telegraph
Son of Manchester United legend hits the target for Red Devils as SuperCup NI gets under way
Kai Rooney, son of the club's all-time record goalscorer and former SuperCup NI player himself Wayne, scored in a 3-0 win over West Cork Academy. They meet Rangers in a glamour game at the Coleraine Showgrounds tonight after a 1,000 crowd in sun-splashed Bushmills were treated to an impressive performance from a player with the perfect name to play for Scottish giants. Kyle Glasgow struck twice, his second a penalty, in a 5-0 win over County Tyrone, who conceded the final three goals late on. Substitute Ruairidh Hall also scored twice. County Down's Mason Ayre is hoping to fire his team all the way to the SuperCup NI Premier Final after he scored two spectacular goals in a 4-2 win over Intercontinental FA. Ayre came off the bench to hit a stunning half-volley before firing home a superb free-kick in injury-time after the American side had twice come from a goal down. Zak Magowan hit a wonderful free-kick strike himself midway through the first-half before the impressive Ben Quirino equalised from the penalty spot. Shea Trainor added to the array of special goals to restore Down's lead only for Sam Winik to reply from a low driven corner after an impressive save by Max Sykes. 'I don't usually score those too often, it was good to score both,' said Ayre. 'It's much more of a buzz when you score goals like that. 'Hopefully, we can make it all the way to the Final.' County Down now meet 2024 winners Brighton, who were 2-1 winners over County Armagh who the Seagulls defeated in the Final. AFC Bournemouth head Group B after they won 3-0 against County Fermanagh, and Hamilton Academical came from behind to draw 1-1 with Mexican side Tigres after missing a first-half penalty. County Londonderry won 2-1 in their derby with County Antrim and now face Southampton, 2-0 winners against Ichifuna of Japan. Mixed emotions for manager Darragh Peden following County Armagh Juniors' victory Darragh Peden confessed to being torn between the joy of victory and frustration over County Armagh Juniors' performance despite a winning start to the SuperCup NI. A goal from Alfie Davidson five minutes from time, when he let the ball run across his body before unleashing a shot into the bottom corner of the net, gave Armagh a 1-0 victory in their derby against County Tyrone. Up to then, it had been the quality of rival goalkeepers Aidan Cunningham of Armagh and Tyrone's Jake Morgan that kept the scoreline blank. 'I think we're a better quality team than what we showed,' said Peden. 'The coach in me is frustrated but I suppose the manager in me is feeling 'job done' and now we move on to the next game. 'It's always a balance between winning games and trying to do it with a wee bit more flair. For me, as Juniors manager, it is more than just results; it's an experience at the SuperCup.' That win was key for Armagh as their final Group A opponents Blackburn Rovers defeated Crewe Alexandra 4-1. It was a tough start for County Down, who gradually grew into their game against St Patrick's Athletic before going down to two second-half goals from Conor Hudson and Gethin Davies. West Ham and Plymouth Argyle finished 2-2 in the other Group D encounter. County Fermanagh also lost to southern opposition, 4-1 to Bohemians in Group C, while Celtic won 4-2 over Chicago City. Michael Mulholland scored twice for County Antrim while Fionnbharr Stiobhard got the third in a 3-0 win over County Londonderry, setting them up perfectly for today's clash with Tottenham Hotspur, who were 5-2 winners over Charlton Athletic with Ashiah Haughton-Sinclair scoring four of the Spurs goals. Crusaders' quest to retain Minor crown suffers blow after defeat to Shamrock Rovers Defending champions Crusaders' hopes of retaining their Minor title were dealt an early blow as they were defeated on the opening day at the SuperCup NI. While the Crues got off to the kind of start they didn't want, there were goals galore for two other Irish League clubs, who each hit four goals in their victories. The Crues were beaten 2-0 by Dublin giants Shamrock Rovers and that result sets up a hugely interesting Group A clash on day two as they now face Ballymena United in Castlerock today after the Sky Blues finished 4-2 winners over Ross County. Cliftonville also made an impressive start to the tournament by hitting four goals in their 4-1 success against Loughgall. That game was, however, overshadowed entertainment-wise by the other game in Group C as Leeds United and Surf Select from the USA shared six goals in a thrilling 3-3 draw. The Reds now face Surf Select today. It is all to play for in Group B after both games finished level. Glenavon and Linfield battled to a scoreless draw, while Kilmarnock drew 1-1 with Al Jazira Club of the UAE. Coleraine and Blackburn Rovers will do battle for control of Group D when they meet in Bushmills after both were victorious in their opening games of the tournament. Blackburn were 3-0 winners over IDA Bermuda, while Coleraine managed to squeeze out a 1-0 victory over Shankill Juniors.
Glasgow Times
16 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Kris Boyd in Rangers signing warning over Mikey Moore
The Ibrox club are favourites to secure the 17-year-old winger for the season, beating competition from English Championship clubs. Moore is eager to move to Glasgow, and the deal is expected to be finalised soon, although some details remain. While the prospect of Moore's arrival has generated excitement, Boyd has cautioned fans to manage their expectations. The former Rangers striker believes that a loan move to either side of the Old Firm carries much higher pressure than a typical loan stint in England's lower leagues. He said: "Moore's a young boy who'll be looking for an opportunity to kick on, but there's a little bit of a risk attached to a first loan move. "He's shown in any opportunities he's had at Tottenham that he has a chance. "But it can be difficult because a lot of Premier League players in England who go out on loan go to a level where they've got time to adapt, whether it's the Championship or other teams who don't have to play under the same pressure as [[Rangers]] and Celtic have." Boyd also highlighted the need for clarity regarding [[Rangers]]' striking options, with Cyriel Dessers and Hamza Igamane potentially leaving the club amid interest from European teams. He said: "The Cyriel Dessers and Hamza Igamane situation needs to be addressed one way or another. "Everybody needs clarity on that pretty quickly. "The league starts on Saturday, and your two most important players on the pitch are your goalkeeper and your number nine. "Rangers are no further forward as to who their number nine is - the top goalscorer from last season is still being linked with moves away, he's not played a lot of football, and he's still got a level of fitness to get to. "For me, there's still no guarantee who's going to be that number nine for Rangers. "If Mikey Moore is to come in, it's a big ask for him to come in and be Rangers' number nine and lead the attack." Boyd's comments come after Russell Martin's first competitive game as [[Rangers]] manager resulted in a 2-0 victory over Panathinaikos in Champions League qualifying. However, Boyd believes there is still much work to be done to get the team where Martin wants them, particularly given the expansive style of play he is trying to instil. He said: "If you go on last week's performance against Panathinaikos, there's still a bit of work to be done for Rangers. "With Russell Martin coming in and implementing a new style, it's not going to be fixed overnight and there's no doubt there were going to be some teething problems and that's going to be the case for a number of weeks. "When you're coming in and you want to implement the style of play that he wants, you're going to make mistakes. "There's going to be scary moments within the games." Martin has previously stated that his squad will look different by the end of the transfer window, suggesting there is still much movement to come, including potential departures.
BBC News
17 minutes ago
- BBC News
Midtjylland hit Sonderjyske for six before Edinburgh trip
Midtjylland thumped Sonderjyske 6-2 in the Danish Superliga as they prepared for the second leg of their Europa League second qualifying round tie against Hibs on from Adam Gabriel, Valdemar Andreasen, Mads Bech Sorensen, as well as a hat-trick from Franculino Dju secured three points for Midtjylland, who are now third in the table after two rounds of the dominant scoreline, Sonderjyske had 20 shots at goal, only one fewer than Midtjylland, suggesting the victory was not plain sailing for Thomas Thomasberg's Danes drew 1-1 with Hibs in Herning last week after Aral Simsir cancelled out Jamie McGrath's winners at Easter Road on Thursday will progress to face Fredrikstad of Norway.
