logo
Planet Green, Inc. Petitions U.S. Supreme Court to Review Amazon's Section 230 Defense in Cartridge Mislabeling Case

Planet Green, Inc. Petitions U.S. Supreme Court to Review Amazon's Section 230 Defense in Cartridge Mislabeling Case

Planet Green asks Supreme Court to review Amazon's Section 230 immunity over alleged role in distribution of falsely advertised printer cartridges
WASHINGTON DC, CA, UNITED STATES, June 30, 2025 / EINPresswire.com / -- Planet Green Cartridges, Inc., a U.S.-based remanufacturer of printer ink cartridges, has filed a petition for writ of certiorari ( Docket #23-4434 ), asking the Supreme Court of the United States to review lower court rulings that dismissed its claims against Amazon under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
According to the petition, filed on June 18, 2025, Planet Green alleges that Amazon continued to list and distribute printer cartridges labeled as 'remanufactured' even after receiving formal complaints that the products were inaccurately described. The petition contends that these products were newly manufactured replicas of original equipment manufacturer (OEM) cartridges, not professionally remanufactured used OEM products.
The case, which originated in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California ( Case No. 2:23-cv-06647-JFW-KS ), centers on whether Amazon's actions, as alleged, fall outside the protections of Section 230 when the platform is made aware of and continues to list disputed third-party products.
Planet Green asserts that it provided Amazon with detailed documentation over a period of more than a year, identifying 45 brands and sellers allegedly marketing newly made cartridges as remanufactured. The petition states that despite these efforts, the listings remained active and Amazon cited Section 230 immunity in its defense.
'This case tests whether e-commerce platforms like Amazon can invoke Section 230 immunity when they are sued for allegedly facilitating the sale of misrepresented products,' said John Ulin, legal counsel for Planet Green at TroyGould. 'We believe the statute does not support broad immunity when platforms are knowingly involved in these kinds of sales. We're asking the Supreme Court to clarify the limits of that protection.'
The petition presents two main legal questions:
1. Whether Section 230 provides immunity to online platforms that allegedly permit and profit from the sale of third-party products misrepresented in violation of consumer protection laws.
2. Whether platforms are immune from civil claims based on their own conduct, such as recommendation algorithms and advertising practices.
Planet Green argues that the continued availability of the disputed listings and products, after notice, raises questions about the extent to which Section 230 protects platforms that play an active role in the promotion or sale of such products.
'By continuing to host and distribute the misrepresented products after being notified, Amazon has used the statute as a shield while continuing to benefit commercially,' Ulin added.
Planet Green's filings estimate that annual sales of products labeled as 'remanufactured' ink cartridges on Amazon exceed $3 billion. The petition also references broader national concerns regarding product mislabeling and safety on online marketplaces.
'We went to great lengths to avoid litigation,' said Sean Levi, Founder and CEO of Planet Green. 'We had hoped Amazon would take corrective action once we made them aware of the 45 brands and their sellers we named in our lawsuit. It is nearly impossible for any U.S. company to hold all unlawful Amazon sellers accountable who operate outside U.S. jurisdiction.'
Founded in 1999, Planet Green is one of the few remaining U.S.-based printer cartridge remanufacturers. The company attributes the decline of the industry—once valued at $7 billion—to increased competition from imported products, some of which it claims are marketed in misleading ways.
'Regardless of how the Court rules, we will continue working to raise awareness around anti-competitive challenges facing American manufacturers,' Levi said.
Planet Green's filings also highlight environmental concerns associated with non-recycled cartridges that are marketed as remanufactured. The company notes that most overseas producers of aftermarket cartridges do not offer recycling or take-back programs, resulting in increased landfill waste in the U.S.
The petition asks the Court to grant a jury trial to evaluate the facts and determine whether Section 230 applies in cases where a platform is alleged to have both knowledge of and commercial interest in disputed product listings.
'In our view, Congress never intended Section 230 to shield large platforms from accountability when they knowingly allow the sale of questionable or misrepresented products,' stated Levi. 'If the courts do not address this issue, we believe lawmakers must. Otherwise, U.S. businesses face increasing challenges competing against overseas sellers who may not be subject to the same legal and regulatory standards.'
About Planet Green
Founded in 1999 and based in Chatsworth, California, Planet Green is a U.S. printer cartridge recycler and remanufacturer. The company remanufactures used OEM cartridges and sells surplus OEM stock as an environmentally sustainable alternative to newly manufactured products. For more information, visit planetgreenrecycle.com.
John Ulin
Attorney
Troy Gould
310-553-4441
Eric Sherman - Media Contact
Planet Green
+ +1 800-377-1093
email us here
Legal Disclaimer:
EIN Presswire provides this news content 'as is' without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article, kindly contact the author above.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Jackery Portable Power Station Explorer 300 is 35% off
Jackery Portable Power Station Explorer 300 is 35% off

New York Post

time5 minutes ago

  • New York Post

Jackery Portable Power Station Explorer 300 is 35% off

New York Post may be compensated and/or receive an affiliate commission if you click or buy through our links. Featured pricing is subject to change. Before you head into the wilderness this weekend, readers, we advise that you double-check your gear list. Tent? Check. Sleeping bag? Check. But have you made sure to pack your portable power station? If you haven't, you'd do well to head over to Amazon. This week, the e-tail giant is offering 35% off the Jackery Portable Power Station Explorer 300, an ideal power solution for the good times (like camping) and the bad (like power outages). Advertisement This power station from Jackery features multiple ports, including USB-C, USB-A, and DC car ports. The system supports rapid charging via solar input or AC, with an optional 1-hour supercharging mode accessible through the free Jackery app. Pick yours up today, and charge up for cheap! Amazon Stay powered anywhere with the Jackery Portable Power Station Explorer 300. Compact, reliable, and perfect for camping, road trips, or emergencies, it charges phones, laptops, and small appliances with ease. Featuring multiple ports and fast recharging, it's your go-to backup power solution. Quiet, eco-friendly, and lightweight, you take the Explorer 300 wherever adventure or necessity leads. Best of all? It's available for 35% off right now on Amazon. This article was written by P.J. McCormick, New York Post Commerce Deals Writer/Reporter. P.J. is an expert deal-finder, sifting through endless brands and retailers to deliver only the best savings opportunities on truly worthwhile products. P.J. finds Prime Day-worthy deals all year long on some of our favorite products we've tested and our readers' beloved best-sellers, from Wayfair furniture sales to the lowest prices on Apple AirPods. P.J. has been scouring sales for Post Wanted shoppers since 2022 and previously held positions at Rolling Stone, Pitchfork and Hyperallergic. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change. Hunting for a headline-worthy haul? Keep shopping with Post Wanted.

Amazon Web Services CEO: I told my own teenager to develop this No. 1 'most important skill' to succeed in the AI age
Amazon Web Services CEO: I told my own teenager to develop this No. 1 'most important skill' to succeed in the AI age

CNBC

time6 minutes ago

  • CNBC

Amazon Web Services CEO: I told my own teenager to develop this No. 1 'most important skill' to succeed in the AI age

Contrary to popular belief, you won't need a machine learning degree or other highly technical skills to succeed in the near future, according to Amazon Web Services CEO Matt Garman. As more artificial intelligence-powered tools get integrated into the workplace, employers will prioritize hiring workers with "soft skills" like creativity and adaptability, Garman told CNBC's "Closing Bell" on Friday. His advice to his own child, a rising high school senior, he said: Develop your critical thinking skills in college, no matter what subject you study. "I think part of going to college is building [your] critical thinking," Garman said. "It's less about the development of skills and it really is [about] how do you become a critical thinker? In some ways, I think that's actually going to be the most important skill going forward." Critical thinking skills will be most people's No. 1 biggest key to success in the age of AI, he added. "You're going to want to be creative. You're going to want to be [good at] critical thinking. And you're going to want to be flexible," said Garman. "I think the ability to learn new things and adapt is going to be just as important as any particular skill that you learn."The list of skills and administrative tasks that AI tools can replicate continues to grow, seemingly each day. Amazon, Garman's employer, is among the multiple companies that have announced plans to reduce their corporate workforces while adopting more AI tools and agents in the coming years. But AI is no match for human intellect when it comes to using critical thinking and creativity to generate new ideas and make nuanced judgments, research shows. It could be "the most valuable skill of the future" for human workers, particularly those tasked with curating and refining the output of AI tools, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman said during an event hosted by Howard University in January 2024. "AI can generate lots of great ideas, but you still need a human there to say, 'This is the thing other people want,'" said Altman. Students can hone and apply their critical thinking skills across pretty much any area of study. Current workers can improve them through daily habits ranging from playing strategic board games to asking more questions, research shows. Multiple online courses say they'll help you improve your critical thinking and communication skills, including one offered for free through Harvard University and edX. Once you've developed those skills, you can showcase them to your current or prospective employers by highlighting examples of difficult problems you've solved at work — or asking thoughtful, purposeful questions that reflect your curiosity and communication skills, LinkedIn career expert Andrew McCaskill told Make It in January 2022. Garman highlighted two other important soft skills for both today and the future: the ability to smoothly adapt to new technologies, including AI-based tools and agents, and communicate effectively with colleagues and customers. Communication is another skill where humans have a leg up over AI — particularly in terms of our ability to pick up on social cues, exhibiting empathy and emotional intelligence, actively listen, and provide insightful feedback, research shows. "[Those skills] are important today. I think they'll be just as important, if not more important [in the future]," Garman said. As employers make plans to integrate more and more AI tools in the workplace, recruiters are specifically targeting prospective employees with the "adaptability" to keep up with technological changes, according to a LinkedIn blog post published in February 2024. AI tools can handle various administrative tasks, but most customers "still want to talk to a person" and get personal insights and attention from a human being, added Garman. "Those people skills are going to continue to be super important for a long time," he said.

Major companies reframing, not abandoning, DEI: report
Major companies reframing, not abandoning, DEI: report

Yahoo

time13 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Major companies reframing, not abandoning, DEI: report

This story was originally published on ESG Dive. To receive daily news and insights, subscribe to our free daily ESG Dive newsletter. Dive Brief: More than half of S&P 100 companies adjusted how they communicated diversity, equity and inclusion efforts in their annual securities filings this year compared to 2024, according to a new report by The Conference Board. Among S&P 500 companies, the use of the acronym 'DEI' dropped by 68% compared to 2024, according to the report. Twenty-one percent of companies reduced or removed DEI-related metrics and targets. While firms scaled back DEI language and commitments, 79% percent of S&P 500 firms disclosed board committee oversight of DEI, up from 72%, according to the report. For Russell 3000 companies, this figure jumped from 48.4% to 86.8%. Rather than simply abandoning DEI, this suggests that companies are being more cautious about external messaging while integrating DEI into governance to make it more legally defensible, according to the report. Dive Insight: Companies have been rolling back their DEI programs since the Supreme Court's 2023 decision outlawing affirmative action in higher education. After President Donald Trump's reelection, McDonald's, Meta, a few banks and others preemptively adjusted policies in anticipation of backlash. When a January 2025 executive order directed heads of agencies to target private sector DEI, another wave of major companies — including Target, BlackRock and even law firms — dropped their DEI goals, a trend that continues. A July 23 report by reported that 20% of companies have scrapped their DEI programs since Trump's reelection. The Conference Board report, based on 2025 Form-10K filings, largely aligns with the individual headlines. More companies in 2025 have limited disclosures of workforce or leadership diversity. The share of S&P 500 companies that disclosed data on women in management dropped from 71.2% in 2024 to 55.1% in 2025, and the share that disclosed the total number of female board members dropped from 90.5% to 60.4%. Just 2.5% of companies did not disclose any information about board racial diversity in 2024, but that number jumped to 33.9% this year. Among Russell 3000 companies, that figure leaped from 14.1% to 54.7%. In recent years, some U.S. public companies have linked executive compensation to DEI-related goals. In 2024, 68% of S&P 500 companies and 41.6% of Russell 3000 companies disclosed in their annual reports that they linked these metrics. In 2025, this figure dropped to 35.3% for S&P 500 companies and 18.7% for Russell 3000 companies. Instead, in 2025 more companies disclosed how executive compensation was linked to broader human capital goals, such as talent development and employee engagement. 'This shift in public disclosure doesn't signal companies are abandoning DEI,' said Andrew Jones, principal researcher at The Conference Board and coauthor of the report, in an Aug. 4 press release. 'Rather, they're selectively reframing commitments, reducing public exposure and embedding oversight more quietly yet firmly into governance and human capital management.' But as companies shift their DEI strategies to protect themselves in a hostile U.S. legal landscape, they also become increasingly misaligned with international disclosure standards, such as the European Union's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, the International Sustainability Standards Board and the Global Reporting Initiative, the report noted. Such standards still emphasize workforce DEI and generally require more consistent demographic disclosure, the report said. Recommended Reading 1 in 5 companies say they've slashed DEI since Trump's election Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store