Jack Vettriano's ‘cheeseburger' art and the matter of taste
Eddy Frankel's article on Jack Vettriano ('His paintings are like a double cheeseburger in a greasy wrapper', 3 March) is full of the sort of backhanded compliments, grudging recognition and snobbish disdain that followed the Scottish painter throughout his career. For many art critics, Vettriano committed the ultimate sin of being popular with the sort of people who don't usually 'get' art. Or, as Frankel puts it, the sort of people who enjoy the occasional McDonald's cheeseburger.
I've always been wary of the notion that art is better if you have to perform mental acrobatics in order to 'get' it. I have been shown 'good' modern art many times, and have been told why it is good – but I would not necessarily want it hanging in my home.
Vettriano's best paintings, on the other hand, elicit feelings in people that many apparently 'good' modern artworks are simply unable to provoke. Regardless of the 'conceptual edge' that Frankel finds lacking in The Singing Butler, few people would deny that it is a beautiful painting. And would you rather hang a beautiful painting on your wall, or a painting whose 'conceptual edge' means absolutely nothing to anybody except the artist and a handful of critics?
I imagine people will still appreciate Vettriano's paintings in 50 years' time – long after all memory of the 'conceptually edgy' modern art that the critics would prefer we liked has faded. With the poised beauty of his paintings, Vettriano democratised art, taking it out away from the critics and placing it into the hands of everyday people. It is a sin for which many in the art world still cannot forgive him. But then maybe I just don't 'get it' like the critics do.Ross McQueenBrussels, Belgium
It is 2025, yet the Guardian's main comment on the death of Jack Vettriano appears to be that his work is 'sexy'. Are we really still only appraising art through the male heterosexual gaze? Eddy Frankel concedes that Vettriano's work is 'pretty sexist', a dismissive understatement if ever there was one. Vettriano's work is retrograde and objectified women (women of a very narrow age bracket) in a way that is no longer acceptable.
It is no defence to claim that something is 'popular'; Donald Trump can be said to be 'popular'. The distasteful aesthetic of Vettriano's work, its ability to give you a sense of unease, which Frankel does manage to allude to by describing it as 'a double cheeseburger wrapped in greasy paper', is embedded in the obvious untruths his images peddle; the scenarios in the paintings masquerade as sexy and romantic while serving up a polished turd of thinly veiled misogyny. Tamar Payne MA painting student, Royal College of Art
I am perhaps one of the great unwashed. I always liked Jack Vettriano's paintings and I have a room of his prints. I also have prints of Van Gogh's and of Munch's pictures, and a few originals I could afford by 'undiscovered' artists. What the art world seems to forget is that it is possible to like all these at the same time. In the same way, I like Schubert and I like Boney M, albeit one is better for dancing to.Neil Heydon-DumbletonPathhead, Midlothian
Have an opinion on anything you've read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Summer in Scotland just got tastier with Six by Nico
Relive their greatest menus with The Six Club Summer Series Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... This summer, Six by Nico is turning up the flavour in Scotland with the launch of the Six Club Summer Series – a midweek dining festival celebrating the menus that made them famous. Running for 12 weeks from Monday, June 9, Six by Nico Edinburgh West End, Six by Nico Byres Road Glasgow and Six by Nico Aberdeen and will serve up fan-favourite menus as well as rolling back the price to a special Summer 2025 rate of £28 per person for a six-course tasting menu. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Whether you're a long-time regular or new to the concept, Six Club invites guests to rediscover six-course menus that have captured imaginations across the UK, from The Chippie to Tokyo, Guilty Pleasures, and beyond Chef Nico Simeone has 6 locations across Scotland Kicking off the Summer Series across Glasgow, Edinburgh and Aberdeen, we're serving up fan favourites mid-week Tuesday- Thursday offering even more opportunities to explore these bold and nostalgic menus. Founder and CEO Nico Simeone shares: "Our Scottish community has embraced Six by Nico since day one and the Summer Series is our way of giving something exciting back. These menus helped define who we are, and we're thrilled to bring them back in a way that's accessible, affordable, and packed with flavour." First Up: The Chippie – From Monday, June 9 - June 23 The Summer Series begins with the one that started it all: The Chippie. Inspired by the classic British chip shop, this menu features reinvented favourites like smoked sausage, scampi, and of course, the legendary deep-fried Mars bar. Nico's famous Chippie menu is back for a limited time The full case of Iconic menus will feature: The Chippie New York Tokyo The Iconic Irn Bru dessert returns as part of the Summer Series Guilty Pleasures Down The Rabbit Hole Amalfi Coast Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Each six-course experience is available with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free alternatives available. Address:Scotland Locations taking part Six by Nico Byres Road Glasgow, 358 Byres Rd, Glasgow G12 8AW Six by Nico Edinburgh West End, 40 Queensferry St, Edinburgh EH2 4RA Six by Nico Aberdeen, 367 Union St, Aberdeen AB11 6BT Guests can elevate their Six Club evenings with optional drink pairings.
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Theatre reviews: Nan Shepherd: Naked and Unashamed
Sign up to our Arts and Culture newsletter, get the latest news and reviews from our specialist arts writers Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Nan Shepherd – Naked and Unashamed, Pitlochry Festival Theatre ★★★★ Meme Girls, Oran Mor, Glasgow ★★★★ Since she first appeared on a Scottish £5 banknote in 2016, interest in the 20th-century Scottish writer Nan Shepherd has soared. Her restoration to national fame, almost 90 years after the success of her first novel The Quarry Wood, turned out to be timely, as readers began to rediscover both her passionate connection with a natural world now increasingly under threat, and the story of her life as a young woman in a male-dominated literary world. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Susan Coyle and Adam Buksh in Nan Shepherd Naked and Unashamed – Photo by Tommy Ga-Ken Wan It was therefore a fine moment, last year, for Firebrand Theatre and Pitlochry Festival Theatre to launch their studio show Nan Shepherd – Naked And Unashamed. Co-written by Firebrand founders Ellie Zeegen and Richard Baron, the play features just two actors, and offers an 80-minute journey through Nan Shepherd's life in flashback form. When it appeared at Pitlochry in 2024, it attracted such a strong positive response that it has now been revived, with a new cast, for another short studio run. Sign up to our FREE Arts & Culture newsletter at So this year, actors Susan Coyle and Adam Buksh lead us through Nan's story, settling briefly in 1981, the year of her death, before leading us through some key turning points in her life, including her early success as part of a radical literary generation that also included Neil Gunn, Hugh MacDiarmid and Lewis Grassic Gibbon. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In a sense, the sheer popularity and emotional power of Baron and Zeegen's play is difficult to analyse; the play sometimes seems almost more like a lecture than a piece of drama, as – in fairly traditional style – it packs in a tremendous amount of information about this remarkable woman, and the age of war and cultural radicalism through which she lived. Yet there's something about the play's insistent loving care for a neglected part of Scotland's cultural history, and about the open, shining character of Nan herself, that makes this tale of her struggles and successes both deeply absorbing and profoundly touching, not least in its tender use of a now old-fashioned form of middle-class Scots. And in this new staging, both Coyle as Nan, and Buksh as all the men who cross her path, deliver the story with impressive skill and passion; with Coyle's Nan truly touching the heart, as a woman of sparkling wit and joy whose sense of humour endured to the last, and who now – in a final irony – finds herself immortalised on our banknotes in a 'Nordic princess' pose she adopted for a laugh, using a discarded strip of film, during what she intended as a much more serious photo-shoot. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Meme Girls Andy McGregor's latest Play, Pie And Pint mini-musical also involves a generation of young Scottish women struggling for creative expression; but in Meme Girls, the time is now, and the play features two teenage heroines growing up in the Clyde coast town of Largs. Jade is a doctor's daughter with a real gift for songwriting, while bestie Clare has had a much tougher life; and together, they begin to navigate the world of online media, performing Jade's songs, and trying to build up a following on YouTube. Their work fails to go viral, though; and after a wild night at a party leads to Clare achieving an instant online fame that has nothing to do with music, their creative and personal relationship begins to fall apart.
Scottish Sun
3 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Full list of road closures in Glasgow with 70 streets to shut as major Hollywood blockbuster starts filming
Read on for the full list of roads that will be closed, plus the exact time they are expected to reopen PLAN AHEAD Full list of road closures in Glasgow with 70 streets to shut as major Hollywood blockbuster starts filming Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DRIVERS have been warned that almost 70 roads in a Scottish city centre will be closed this weekend as filming for a major Hollywood movie gets underway. Motorists in Glasgow have been urged to plan ahead as film crews prepare to descend on the city in the coming days. 3 Drivers have been warned to plan ahead as almost 70 roads are set to close next weekend Credit: Getty 3 The closure comes as filming gets underway for a Hollywood film Credit: Mark Ferguson The unknown flick, directed by JJ Abrams, is set to star Top Gun: Maverick actor Glen Powell and Wednesday lead Jenna Ortega. It's also understood that acting legend Samuel L. Jackson is tipped for a key part in the movie, according to The Hollywood Reporter. Filming for the flick is expected to start over the weekend and will run into next week. However, it means that a number of roads will be closed throughout the city for days as a result. Some closures will kick in as early as tomorrow to stop vehicles from waiting, loading, and unloading in certain streets in preparation for the filming. The closures are being implemented by Glasgow City Council, which has warned that bus and taxi lanes will also be impacted, with a suspension in place. Motorists will not be able to wait, load, and unload on the following streets: From 3pm on June 8, to 6pm on June 18 George Street - between North Hanover Street and Montrose Street From 3pm on June 13, to 6pm on June 16 John Street - for its full length Montrose Street - between George Street and Cochrane Street Glasgow transformed for filming of The Running Man remake as Hollywood star spotted From 3pm on June 15, to 8am on June 23 Blythswood Street - between St Vincent Street and Argyle Street Bothwell Lane - for its full length Bothwell Street - between Pitt Street and Wellington Street Cadogan Street - between Douglas Street and Wellington Street Douglas Street - between St Vincent Street and Cadogan Street Holm Street - between Blythswood Street and Wellington Street Pitt Street - between Waterloo Street and Bothwell Street St Peter's Lane - for its full length St Vincent Lane - between Pitt Street and Wellington Street Washington Lane - for its full length Washington Street - between Broomielaw and Balaclava Street Waterloo Street - between Douglas Street and Wellington Street West Campbell Street - between St Vincent Street and Argyle Street From 3pm on June 18, to 6pm on June 21 Milton Street - between Port Dundas Road and Maitland Street From 3pm on June 19, to 8am on June 21 Dunblane Street - between Milton Street and McPhater Street Maitland Street - between Stewart Street and McPhater Street Stewart Street - between Maitland Street and Dunblane Street McPhater Street - between Port Dundas Road and Dunblane Road The following roads will be closed to drivers as filming gets underway: From 3am to 11.59pm on June 17 Newton Street - between Argyle Street and Broomielaw North Street - between Anderston Quay and Argyle Street From 8am on June 15, until 11.59pm on June 16 Cadogan Street - between West Campbell Street and Douglas Street Blythswood Street - between Waterloo Street and Holm Street Douglas Street - between Cadogan Street and Waterloo Street From 1pm to 11.59pm on June 17 Blythswood Street - between St Vincent Street and Argyle Street Bothwell Lane - for its full length Bothwell Street - between Pitt Street and Wellington Street Cadogan Street - between Douglas Street and Wellington Street Douglas Street - between St Vincent Street and Cadogan Street Holm Street - between Blythswood Street and Wellington Street Pitt Street - between Waterloo Street and Bothwell Street St Peter's Lane - for its full length St Vincent Lane - between Pitt Street and Wellington Street Washington Lane - for its full length Washington Street - between Broomielaw and Balaclava Street Waterloo Street - between Douglas Street and Wellington Street West Campbell Street - between St Vincent Street and Argyle Street From 8am June 18, until 11.59pm on June 23 Cadogan Street - between West Campbell Street and Douglas Street Blythswood Street - between Waterloo Street and Holm Street Douglas Street - between Cadogan Street and Waterloo Street (access to car park only) From 9am June 16, to 8am June 19 Blythswood Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street Bothwell Street - between Pitt Street and Hope Street Douglas Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street St Vincent Lane - between Pitt Street and Hope Street Wellington Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street West Campbell Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street From 8am June 18, to 6pm June 21 Pitt Street - between St Vincent Street and Bothwell Street St Vincent Lane - between Pitt Street and Douglas Street Top filming location BACK in November, Glasgow was transformed into a dystopian New York as filming got underway for The Running Man, a reboot of the classic Arnold Schwarzenegger film. Glen Powell was spotted filming in and around the city, and he even popped into The Locale in Charing Cross for a wrap party. Rumours are swirling that director Abrams' new film is an 80s throwback loosely inspired by The Last Starfighter, but the title remains unknown. And more filming crews are set to swarm the city for Spider-Man 4. Some scenes being shot will reportedly 'involve vehicles on the road', with crews anticipating that Bothwell Street will be the focal point. It is understood that the Glasgow-based shoot for the upcoming Marvel blockbuster will commence in mid-August. Other films that have been shot in the city over recent years include World War Z, which used George Square to represent Philadelphia, and was also transformed into Gotham City for Batgirl and The Batman. Other notable films shot in Glasgow include Skyfall, Avengers: Infinity War, Fast & Furious 6, Trainspotting, and Perfect Sense. From 8am on June 20, to 8am on June 21 Dunblane Street - between Milton Street and McPhater Street Maitland Street - between Stewart Street and McPhater Street Milton Street - between Port Dundas Road and Maitland Street Stewart Street - between Maitland Street and Dunblane Street Larbert Street - between Milton Street and McPhater Street From 8am on June 19, until 11.59pm on June 20 Blythswood Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street Bothwell Lane - between Blythswood Street and West Campbell Street Bothwell Street - between Douglas Street and West Campbell Street St Peters Lane - between Douglas Street and Blythswood Street St Vincent Street - between Douglas Street and West Campbell Street From 3am on June 20, to 8am on June 21 Blythswood - between St Vincent street and Bothwell Street Bothwell Street - between Pitt Street and West Campbell Street Douglas Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street St Vincent Lane - between Pitt Street and Hope Street West Campbell Street - between St Vincent Street and Bothwell Street From 3pm on June 20, to 8am on June 21 Cadogan Street - between West Campbell Street and Douglas Street Blythswood Street - between Bothwell Street and Holm Street Douglas Street - between Cadogan Street and St Vincent Street Bothwell Street - between Pitt Street and Blythswood Street From 12.01am on June 21, to 7am on June 23 Blythswood Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street Bothwell Lane - between Blythswood Street and Wellington Street Bothwell Street - between Pitt Street and Hope Street Cadogan Street - between Douglas Street and Wellington Street Douglas Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street Holm Street - for its full length St Peters Lane - for its full length St Vincent Lane - between Pitt Street and Hope Street St Vincent Street - between West Campbell Street and Pitt Street Waterloo Street - between Douglas Street and Wellington Street Wellington Lane - for its full length Wellington Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street West Campbell Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street From 8am to 11.59pm on June 22 Blythswood Street - between St Vincent Street and Waterloo Street Bothwell Lane - between Blythswood Street and West Campbell Street Bothwell Street - between Douglas Street and West Campbell Street St Peter's Lane - between Douglas Street and Blythswood Street St Vincent Street - between Douglas Street and West Campbell Street Bus lanes will also be impacted with a suspension in place on several routes. These include: From 1pm on June 17, to 8am on June 19 Hope Street at Waterloo Street From 12.01am on June 21, to 7am on June 23 Hope Street at Waterloo Street
