Politicians see field marshal rank as affirmation of Pakistan army chief's influence, not a power shift
ISLAMABAD: Pakistani politicians and analysts have said that the country's top military commander Asim Munir's promotion to the field marshal rank, which followed Pakistan's recent standoff with India, would not further affect the political landscape as he already held 'great influence.'
The Pakistani government elevated Army Chief Munir to the rank of field marshal on Tuesday, making him only the second military officer after Ayub Khan to attain the title in the history of the South Asian country.
The promotion came more than a week after Pakistan declared victory in a four-day military conflict with India, which saw the archfoes trade missile, drone and artillery strikes, killing around 70 people on both sides.
The office of the army chief is widely seen as the most powerful position in Pakistan, a country where the military has directly ruled for nearly half its history and wields considerable influence in matters of national significance even during civilian rule.
'It will, God willing, have no [further] impact on political space or Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI),' Sayed Zulfikar Bukhari, a spokesperson of jailed ex-prime minister Imran Khan-led PTI party, told Arab News this week.
'He already held all the influence.'
Khan's PTI has been at loggerheads with the military since the downfall of its administration in 2022 and on May 9, 2023, hundreds of people carrying its flags had attacked government and military installations over the ex-premier's arrest in a graft case. The attacks followed hundreds of arrests and dozens of Khan supporters were even tried in military courts.
The PTI denies it instigated its followers to violence and accuses the military and its political rivals of a nationwide crackdown on its supporters. The Pakistani government and the military deny the accusation.
Bukhari called Munir's promotion an 'internal matter' of the army.
'It's generally an internal matter for the army as a result of a victory against India,' he said, adding that the entire nation celebrated that victory and ceasefire.
'We hope that with this promotion, an internal ceasefire is also reached.'
For National Assembly Speaker Sardar Ayaz Sadiq, who is also the vice president of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) party, the promotion was not only a recognition of an individual's capability, but also an acknowledgment of the sacrifices and professional competence of the Pakistani armed forces.
'Field Marshal Munir thwarted the enemy's nefarious designs with great courage and strategy,' he said, adding the decision of his elevation would further boost the morale of the military and promote national unity.
On Thursday, Pakistan's top political leadership conferred the baton of field marshal on Army Chief Munir at a ceremony in Islamabad. PM Shehbaz Sharif praised him for his 'unflinching courage' and the army for responding with speed and precision to Indian military strikes.
The strikes were triggered by an attack in Indian-administered Kashmir that New Delhi blamed on Pakistan, an allegation denied by Islamabad.
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Provincial Governor Faisal Karim Kundi, a senior leader of the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), maintained the promotion of the army chief was a 'merit-based decision' by the government as he fully deserved it.
'This move has no political angle, neither has been done to harm anyone. So, all should appreciate it,' he told Arab News.
Liaqat Baloch, a senior member of the Jamaat-e-Islami party, said it was the government's prerogative to make such promotions.
'I think now Field Marshal Munir should work for the supremacy of the constitution,' he said, adding it would further elevate his status among people.
Baloch said the move would not have much impact on political parties, including the PTI or any other opposition group.
Political analysts believed the promotion will further strengthen army chief's commanding position in the power structure of the country.
'Field Marshal Munir now holds a central and commanding position within the power structure, especially in light of the current weakness and disunity among civilian political leaders,' Mushahid Hussain Syed, a seasoned politician and political commentator, told Arab News.
Even before the standoff with India, he said, all major political forces were already convinced of the establishment's central role in Pakistan's power dynamics.
'All the mainstream political forces are convinced that the path to Islamabad passes through Rawalpindi [home to army headquarters],' he added.
But Ahmed Bilal Mehboob, president of the Pakistan Institute of Legislative Development and Transparency (PILDAT), said the top military commander's promotion would not 'further shrink political space for the opposition,' including Khan's party.
'I do not think this promotion would lead to greater influence in the government affairs than he [Asim Munir] already has,' he added.
Defense analyst and author, Ayesha Siddiqa, called the promotion a 'political decision' by the ruling PML-N party to 'appease' the most powerful individuals within the country.
'It is a political decision because the basis on which this title is given [the standoff with India] was not even an all-out war,' she told Arab News.
'This is possibly a move by the PML-N to ensure that the army chief stays happy and does not consider too seriously any major [rapprochement] vis-a-vis [the jailed former premier] Khan.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
6 hours ago
- Arab News
Volleyball returns to Azad Kashmir border village as fragile India-Pakistan ceasefire holds
Battal Sector, Azad Kashmir: On a dusty, uneven patch of ground beside the Poonch River, the rhythmic thud of a volleyball hitting palms and sand rose above the late afternoon quiet. It's a familiar sound in the border village of Jhawara, located in the Poonch district of Azad Kashmir, the part of the disputed Himalayan region of Kashmir that is governed by Pakistan. But until recently, it had fallen silent under the roar of artillery and gunfire. Just weeks ago, the area bore the brunt of intense cross-border shelling between India and Pakistan. The Line of Control (LoC), a jagged and heavily militarized de facto boundary slicing through the disputed region, once again became a flashpoint for conflict, forcing families into hiding and pausing everyday joys like this daily volleyball match. Now, with a tenuous ceasefire in place since May 10 — brokered with help from Washington — the boys are back on the field. For them, the return to play is more than a pastime. It's an act of defiance, remembrance, and quiet hope. 'There has been firing here before but now it doesn't feel scary,' said Hamid Fareed, 18, as he waited to serve. 'There is a ceasefire in place now, which is why we play with peace of mind. Before, when there used to be firing, we didn't play here.' The Battal sector, situated at one of the most sensitive stretches of the LoC, was at the heart of last month's escalation, with the shelling so heavy residents were forced to evacuate, and even the simple joy of a volleyball match became too dangerous to risk. Among those displaced were the families of the boys who now fill the field each evening from 4pm until the sunset maghrib prayer. Many had sought shelter with relatives in safer villages farther from the border during the latest fighting. Others, like Fareed, stayed behind but refrained from venturing out unnecessarily. The violence still didn't spare the players. Anwar Taskeen, a 17-year-old student and regular at the matches, was killed in shelling on his home just hours before the ceasefire was announced. 'Our brother who got martyred [on May 10, 2025] used to play volleyball with us,' said Muhammad Nawaz, one of Anwar's closest friends. 'He used to come every day.' 'When they [Indian forces] fire, they target civilians and army posts as well,' he added. SYMBOL OF NORMALCY Now that calm has returned, at least for the moment, the boys are determined to reclaim the ground and the normalcy it represents. Most days, they split into two teams of six, playing until darkness falls. Laughter, shouts, and the squeak of rubber slippers on hard soil fill the air. But the volleyball field isn't just a space for play. It's also a space of memory. Taskeen's absence lingers. So too does the knowledge that peace here is often fleeting. 'There are beautiful places on that side, people should get to enjoy them. And people from there should be able to come here,' said Abdul Hannan, another student who recently completed his intermediate studies. 'Many people there [Indian-administered], in Jammu and Kashmir, play as well,' Hannan added. 'We watch their videos to gain skills. They are playing better than us. We also get motivated by watching them.' The boys recalled that some former players who used to compete on this very field had now moved abroad in search of better opportunities. From afar, many continued to support the volleyball tradition, pooling together funds to help maintain the ground. Their latest contribution helped install a protective net, now in place for six to seven years, which keeps the ball from rolling into the river and drifting downstream toward the Indian side. 'WE JUST WANT PEACE' The Poonch River marks both a border and a lifeline for the region. On hot days, the boys often dive into its cool waters to beat the heat, even as Indian army posts watch from across the bank. That same river has seen far more than games but carried the sounds of shelling, the cries of displaced families, and now, the echoes of a volleyball match played in the name of peace. During Ramadan and other special occasions, the field hosts semi-annual tournaments. Teams travel from neighboring towns and villages to compete, a reminder that even in a conflict zone, community and competition endure. 'When there is peace, we can play. That's all we want,' Fareed saiid. India and Pakistan have long shared a contentious relationship over Kashmir, with flare-ups along the LoC occurring frequently despite periodic agreements. The current ceasefire too is fragile, its future uncertain. But on this side of the Poonch River, young players are daring to imagine something more permanent — not through diplomacy, but through volleyball, through shared videos, playful rivalries, and quiet tributes to friends lost. And through simple, hopeful wishes — that one day, the people of Kashmir might cross the border not as enemies, but as guests. 'We just want peace,' Hannan repeated softly. 'That's all we've ever wanted.'
Arab News
6 hours ago
- Arab News
Pakistani, Muslim leaders share Eid greetings, offer special prayers for Gaza
ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar on Sunday exchanged Eid Al-Adha greetings with the leaders of the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Oman, Bahrain, Jordan and other Muslim nations and offered special prayers for the people of Gaza. Eid Al-Adha is one of the two most important festivals of the Islamic calendar, marked by Muslims in Pakistan and around the world by slaughtering animals such as sheep and goats, and distributing their meat among family, friends and the poor. Pakistan Deputy Prime Minister Dar held a telephonic conversation with his UAE counterpart Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al-Nahyan and exchanged warm Eid greetings, the Radio Pakistan broadcaster reported. They prayed for peace, prosperity and well-being of Muslims across the world. Separately, PM Sharif held a telephonic conversation with Oman's Sultan Haitham bin Tarik and conveyed his warm greetings to him and the brotherly people of Oman on the Eid Al-Adha. 'While exchanging Eid wishes, the two leaders prayed for unity and harmony among the Muslim Ummah. They also offered special prayers for the people of Gaza,' Sharif's office said. The development came as at least four Palestinians were killed and others were wounded by Israeli fire around a kilometer from an aid distribution point in the Gaza Strip, Palestinian health officials and witnesses said on Sunday. Israel's military campaign has killed over 54,000 Palestinians, according to Palestinian Health Ministry. The war has destroyed vast areas of Gaza and displaced around 90 percent of its population. The territory's roughly 2 million Palestinians are almost completely reliant on international aid because nearly all of Gaza's food production capabilities have been destroyed. The Pakistani leaders also held similar calls and exchange of Eid greetings with Bahrain's King Hamad bin Isa Al-Khalifa, Jordan's King Abdullah II Ibn Al Hussein, Tajikistan President Emomali Rahmon, Malaysian Prime Minister Dato' Seri Anwar Ibrahim and Uzbekistan President Shavkat Mirziyoyev.
Arab News
9 hours ago
- Arab News
Pakistan delegation in UK after ‘successful' talks in New York on India conflict
KARACHI: A Pakistani delegation has arrived in the United Kingdom (UK) as part of Islamabad's diplomatic outreach over last month's military conflict with India, following their 'successful' talks in New York. India and Pakistan engaged in the worst fighting between them in decades, raising fears of the prospect of an all-out nuclear war. After both countries traded heavy fire for four days, pounding each other with missiles, fighter jets and drone strikes, US President Donald Trump announced a ceasefire between them on May 10. The nine-member Pakistan delegation, led by former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, held several meetings with representatives of the United Nations (UN), its member states and US officials to present Pakistan's stance on the standoff with India and peace in the region. The Pakistan delegates said the purpose of their meetings was to have peace in the region and to have talks with New Delhi on all India-Pakistan issues, including the restoration of the Indus Waters Treaty and the resolution of Kashmir dispute. 'We have explained to them [US officials] that Pakistan's water, this is a civilization, the lives of 240 million people, their culture [depend on it],' Khurram Dastgir, a Pakistani lawmaker who is part of the delegation, told a Pakistani news channel in the UK. 'We explained this to America that their economic partnership with India, it will not bring about that development if India and Pakistan will perpetually remain [in a state of] war.' India announced in April that it was putting the 1960 World Bank-mediated treaty in abeyance after it accused Pakistan of backing an attack on tourists in Indian-administered Kashmir. Islamabad denied complicity in the attack that killed 26 people. Jalil Abbas Jilani, a former Pakistani foreign secretary, said they held quite constructive talks with members of the UN Security Council during their New York visit. 'Basically, our message was that India committed an aggression and that Pakistan is a peaceful country... Pakistan wants all India-Pakistan issues to be resolved in a peaceful manner,' he said. Pakistani senator Sherry Rehman, who was also part of the talks, said the main objective of their discussions was peace in the region. 'Our goal was peace, promote dialogue, to have the status of water treaty changed, which they [India] have unilaterally suspended, and to start a discussion on Kashmir,' she said. The Pakistani delegates are expected to meet key UK officials during their visit to highlight Pakistan's perspective on last month's conflict and its possible consequences for the region. British foreign minister David Lammy is the highest-profile Western official to have visited both New Delhi and Islamabad since the South Asian neighbors agreed to a ceasefire last month. 'We want the situation to be maintained, but of course we recognize fragility, particularly in the backdrop of terrorism, terrorism designed to destabilize India,' Lammy said, adding that he discussed the next steps with both Modi and Indian Foreign Minister S. Jaishankar, but gave no specifics. 'We are keen to continue to work with our Indian partners on counter-terrorism measures.' India and Pakistan, bitter rivals since they gained independence in 1947 from British rule, have fought three wars, including two over the disputed Himalayan territory of Kashmir. Both countries administer Kashmir in parts but claim the region entirely. Pakistan accuses India of occupying Kashmir and denying its people their right to self-determination. It regularly calls on India to abide by the United Nations Security Council resolutions and hold a transparent plebiscite in the territory. India, on the other hand, accuses Pakistan of arming and funding militant separatists in the part of Kashmir it administers. Islamabad has denied the allegations and says it extends only diplomatic and moral support to the people of Indian-administered Kashmir.
