Health data cover up? 100+ US government datasets quietly altered without warning
Change Logs Claim 'No Changes,' Despite Edits
Live Events
Why It Matters for Public Health
Researchers Warn of Misinterpretation in Gender-Sensitive Data
Edits Followed White House Directive Targeting 'Gender Ideology'
Public Trust at Risk if Data Integrity Isn't Protected
FAQs
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
Over 100 US government health datasets were quietly altered earlier this year, and most of those changes were made without public notice, leaving major transparency and trust issues about official data, as per a report.A recent study in The Lancet went deep into 232 datasets from major organizations such as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Department of Health and Human Services, and the Department of Veterans Affairs, according to Psypost. The study, "Data manipulation within the US Federal Government ," was authored by Janet Freilich and Aaron S. Kesselheim, as reported by Psypost.What they discovered was that almost half of the datasets had had wording adjustments that were not mentioned anywhere in the formal change logs, as per the report. The most frequent edit was replacing the term "gender" with "sex," as reported by Psypost.ALSO READ: Epstein files stay sealed — Republicans block move to force Trump admin to reveal details To find this out, the researchers compared existing datasets to older versions held online, as per the report. In most instances, despite the dataset appearing to have been recently updated, the change logs indicated nothing had been changed, according to Psypost. For instance, a Veterans Affairs document monitoring veteran medical care changed "Gender" to "Sex" in its headers and titles, but its change log doggedly reported, "No changes have been archived yet," as reported by Psypost.It is important to know because these datasets are the foundation of millions of public health studies on everything from mental illness to chronic disease and health disparities, according to the report. When words like "gender" and "sex" are incorrectly interchanged without definition, it is nearly impossible to tell whether changes in the data indicate true changes in the population or merely a quiet rewrite behind the scenes, as per the Psypost report.ALSO READ: Trump's tariff threat could trigger recession as August 1 deadline looms, and he might not blink this time This is not merely a statistical concern, as gender and sex are not the same thing: gender is social identity, and sex is biological categorisation, according to the report. A large number of transgender and non-binary individuals have identities that differ from the sex at birth, as reported by Psypost. Thus, if suddenly one dataset starts remapping "gender" to "sex" without explaining why it was altered, researchers cannot interpret results properly, according to the report. That confusion might compel public health officials to make decisions based on false information, as per Psypost.The timing of the edits is also significant because the edits primarily occurred between January and March of 2025, shortly following a White House directive that called on federal agencies to drop language linked to what it referred to as "gender ideology," as reported by Psypost. Although there is no official confirmation about the dataset edits being carried out in response to the White House's directive, but the pattern indicates a coordinated effort, according to Psypost.The researchers indicate that this lack of transparency jeopardises both scientific integrity and public trust, as per the report. They call for more robust systems for tracking and justifying all changes to data so that everyone, from policymakers to ordinary citizens, can clearly see what's been changed and why, according to Psypost. They also propose that independent groups and researchers maintain their own versions of datasets and compare them with archives on a regular basis, as per the report.'Sex' usually refers to biology (male or female), while 'gender' includes social identity (like non-binary or transgender). Swapping them without clarification can distort results.No federal agency has publicly confirmed the edits or explained the reason behind them.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
34 minutes ago
- Mint
White House physician's verdict on Trump's health after chronic venous insufficiency diagnosis: ‘Abundance of caution'
US President Donald Trump has been diagnosed with chronic venous insufficiency following complaints of leg swelling, but White House doctors stated Thursday that he remains in 'excellent health.' The White House Medical Unit conducted a 'comprehensive examination' of Trump, 79, after recent photos showed him with swollen ankles and a bruised hand, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said at a press briefing, as reported by Bloomberg. The ankle swelling is related to the disease, which occurs when damaged valves inside the veins struggle to keep blood flowing from the legs back to the heart. Leavitt called it a 'common condition, particularly in individuals over the age of 70.' The disorder affects about one in 20 adults, according to the Cleveland Clinic. According to a report by Bloomberg, a subsequent memo from White House physician Sean Barbabella said doctors found 'no evidence of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) or arterial disease' and that 'no signs of heart failure, renal impairment, or systemic illness were identified.' 'President Trump remains in excellent health,' Barbabella wrote. Leavitt said Trump is experiencing 'no discomfort' related to his ankles and the president underwent the exam 'out of an abundance of caution' after noting the lower leg swelling. The exam included vascular studies, an echocardiogram and ultrasounds. Blood testing produced results 'within normal limits,' she added. The hand bruising is 'consistent with minor soft tissue irritation from frequent hand-shaking' and is also 'a well-known and benign side effect of aspirin therapy,' Leavitt said. Trump is taking the medicine as part of a 'standard cardiovascular prevention regimen,' she said. In January, Trump became the oldest individual ever sworn in as U.S. president, exceeding his predecessor Joe Biden. Throughout the 2024 election, Trump frequently criticised the now 82-year-old Biden for his age and physical endurance. However, Trump ultimately exited the race following a disastrous debate performance that intensified concerns about his own fitness. Meanwhile, images showing swelling in Trump's hands and ankles raised further questions about his personal health. The left foot and swollen ankle of President Donald Trump are pictured as he sits with Bahrain's Crown Prince Salman bin Hamad Al Khalifa in the Oval Office of the White House, Wednesday, July 16, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon) Photos taken last weekend at the FIFA Club World Cup showed Trump's ankles appearing swollen inside his socks. Then on Tuesday, reporters noticed what seemed to be makeup covering marks on the president's hand as he left the White House for a trip to Pennsylvania. (With inputs from Bloomberg)
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
2 hours ago
- Business Standard
Trump checked for lower leg swelling, diagnosed with common vein condition
President Donald Trump recently underwent a medical checkup after noticing "mild swelling" in his lower legs and was found to have a condition common in older adults that causes blood to pool in his veins, the White House has said. Press secretary Karoline Leavitt said on Thursday that tests by the White House medical unit showed that Trump has chronic venous insufficiency, which occurs when little valves inside the veins that normally help move blood against gravity gradually lose the ability to work properly. Leavitt also addressed bruising on the back of Trump's hand, seen in recent photos covered by makeup that was not an exact match to his skin tone. She said the bruising was "consistent" with irritation from his "frequent handshaking and the use of aspirin". Trump takes aspirin to reduce the risk of heart attack and stroke. She said during her press briefing that her disclosure of Trump's medical checkup was meant to dispel recent speculation about the 79-year-old president's health. Nonetheless, the announcement was notable given that the Republican president has routinely kept secret basic facts about his health. Trump in April had a comprehensive physical exam with more than a dozen medical specialists. The three-page report released then by the White House did not include a finding of chronic venous insufficiency. At the time, Trump's doctor determined that the president's joints and muscles had a full range of motion, with normal blood flow and no swelling. Leavitt did not say when Trump first noticed the swelling in his lower legs. As part of the president's routine medical care and out of an "abundance of caution", she said he had a "comprehensive exam" that included vascular, lower extremity and ultrasound testing. She noted that chronic venous insufficiency is a benign condition that is common in people over 70. She said the tests revealed no evidence of deep vein thrombosis, a more serious medical condition in which a blood clot forms in one or more of the deep veins in the body, usually in the legs. Nor was there any evidence of arterial disease, she said, reading a letter from Trump's doctor. People often are advised to lose weight, walk for exercise and elevate their legs periodically, and some may be advised to wear compression stockings. Severe cases over time can lead to complications including lower leg sores called ulcers. Blood clots are one cause, but was ruled out, Leavitt said. Leavitt said the condition wasn't causing the president any discomfort. She wouldn't discuss how he was treating the condition and suggested those details would be in the doctor's letter, which was later released to the public. But the letter was the same as what she read, and it did not include any additional details. The exam the White House disclosed on Thursday included other testing that found no signs of heart failure, renal impairment or systemic illness, Leavitt said. "The president remains in excellent health, which I think all of you witness on a daily basis here," she told reporters. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
White House releases Trump's health reports, cites chronic venous insufficiency common at his age, criticizes Biden health cover-up
The White House has released President Donald Trump 's latest physician's letter , confirming that the 79-year-old president remains in 'excellent health' despite rumors about his physical condition. The detailed medical report addresses recent speculation regarding swelling in Trump's legs and visible bruises on his hands, aiming to set the record straight and reassure the American public. This proactive disclosure stands in sharp contrast to Trump's ongoing allegations that former President Joe Biden 's health issues were deliberately concealed during his presidency. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Select a Course Category healthcare MCA Operations Management Data Science Management Cybersecurity Digital Marketing Product Management others Finance Artificial Intelligence Data Science Technology Project Management PGDM Data Analytics Leadership Healthcare Public Policy Design Thinking CXO Others Degree MBA Skills you'll gain: Duration: 11 Months IIM Lucknow CERT-IIML Healthcare Management India Starts on undefined Get Details According to the letter from the White House medical team, President Trump has been diagnosed with chronic venous insufficiency – a condition frequently seen among seniors, in which vein function in the legs is reduced, leading to mild swelling. The physician emphasized that this is quite common at Trump's age and, crucially, there is no sign of more serious vascular issues such as deep vein thrombosis or arterial disease. The team also clarified concerns about the noticeable bruises on Trump's hands, explaining they result from frequent handshaking and the preventative use of aspirin, not from any blood disorder or acute illness. Routine testing confirmed that Trump's heart and kidney function are normal, and his essential health indicators remain stable and within normal limits. The physician's recommendations included sensible advice like regular walking, healthy eating, and using compression stockings if necessary. The timing of Trump's medical report release is significant. In recent weeks, President Trump has ramped up accusations that his predecessor, Joe Biden, and his staff engaged in a systemic cover-up of Biden's own health challenges. Trump argues that the American people were kept in the dark about what he calls 'cognitive decline' in Biden's final years in office. Live Events In a strongly worded statement, Trump described the alleged secrecy as 'one of the most dangerous and concerning scandals in American history,' referencing claims that Biden's executive power was quietly delegated while the autopen was used to sign key documents. Biden has consistently rebutted these charges, insisting, 'Let me be clear: I made the decisions during my presidency… Any suggestion that I didn't is ridiculous and false.' He has pointed out that the use of an autopen for signatures is a routine practice that precedes his administration. The battle over presidential health transparency has now become a central issue in Washington. Supporters of Trump praise the public release of his physician's report as evidence of openness and fitness to lead, while Democrats argue that there's no hard proof of a cover-up during Biden's presidency and maintain that his health and capacity to govern were never truly in question.
