Roland Butcher: ‘West Indies are struggling – we've not hit rock bottom yet'
Roland Butcher, child of Barbados, once of England and more recently a West Indies selector, has a less optimistic outlook: 'We're struggling, and the struggle is not over. We haven't hit rock bottom yet.' The concentration of power across all three formats in the hands of one coach and selector – Daren Sammy – is what Butcher fears 'is going to finally push us to the bottom'.
Butcher's knowledge of Caribbean cricket is broad and deep, with 15 years as head coach of the University of the West Indies sports academy, one serving on the national team's selection panel alongside another familiar name in Desmond Haynes, and many commentating on matches around the region. He was appointed as a selector in December 2022 but dismissed a year later, with full control of the team eventually handed to Sammy, who picks and also coaches the senior side across all formats as of April this year.
'In Desmond and myself you've got over 100 years of experience at the highest level, still capable, still wanting to contribute,' Butcher says. 'I've moved on and Desmond has moved on as well, but we've got this knowledge, we want to help and they're struggling.
'It was a very left-field change, and not a change that I agree with. Not because I'm no longer a selector, it's just not suitable for somewhere like the West Indies. In 2023, they had the best run they've had for 25 years in terms of results and for some reason they decided to make Daren the only selector and coach. I mean, madness. And it's going to be tested already because they're over here and then in a couple of weeks Australia is arriving for a Test series. I mean, how can you coach three teams? How can you be the only selector for three teams? It's just absolute madness.
England and Surrey seamer Gus Atkinson has been ruled out of the upcoming Metro Bank One-Day Internationals against the West Indies due to a right hamstring strain.Atkinson sustained the injury during England's Rothesay Test victory over Zimbabwe at Trent Bridge last week. He will now undergo a period of rehabilitation under the supervision of the England medical team. No replacement will be added to the ODI squad.England, led by captain Harry Brook, will contest three ODIs with the series getting underway with the opening match on Thursday 29 May at Edgbaston.
ODI squad:
Harry Brook (Yorkshire) – CaptainTom Banton (Somerset)Jacob Bethell (Warwickshire)Jos Buttler (Lancashire)Brydon Carse (Durham)Ben Duckett (Nottinghamshire)Tom Hartley (Lancashire)Will Jacks (Surrey)Saqib Mahmood (Lancashire)Jamie Overton (Surrey)Matthew Potts (Durham)Adil Rashid (Yorkshire)Joe Root (Yorkshire)Jamie Smith (Surrey)Luke Wood (Lancashire)Metro Bank ODIs1st ODI: England v West Indies, Thursday 29 May 2025, Edgbaston, Birmingham2nd ODI: England v West Indies, Sunday 1 June 2025, Sophia Gardens, Cardiff3rd ODI: England v West Indies, Tuesday 3 June 2025, Kia Oval, London
'What they've done is they've said the chairmen of selectors in the territories – so in Barbados or in Trinidad – now becomes a talent scout as well. But there's no selection process for them. The selector in Barbados, he's a man in a full-time job. When does Sammy watch regional cricket? Desmond Haynes and myself, that's all we did, watch cricket, all over the place. I was a youth selector as well so I'd be at the regional tournaments, under‑15, under-17, under-19, and I got to see all the young talent coming through. The talent scouts can't do that. And they didn't just get rid of the senior men's selectors. The youth selectors as well, they changed that.'
In Butcher's year as a selector, the West Indies men's side won 51% of their games, the only time this century they have won the majority of their matches across all formats in a calendar year. 'When I left, I said to Desmond: 'We were a success.' There's no other West Indian selector that has left and can say they were a success, they were always let go because the team failed,' he says. 'We were a success. So that will always stay with me. The powers that be, they wanted to move to a different situation. But we were a success and we were on the right path. There's no question about that. They can't take that away.'
West Indies have been affected by the proliferation of lucrative franchise leagues and their habit of distracting – or just taking – international players. 'But I think England have started to experience what West Indies have experienced for the last 10 years,' Butcher says.
'I don't think many countries looked at what was happening with West Indies and ever thought: 'You know what, this'll happen to us too.' For the last 10 years, West Indies teams have been weakened by domestic leagues and everybody was sitting back saying: 'Oh, West Indies, they're mercenaries.' They didn't think it would come home to roost.'
Sign up to The Spin
Subscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week's action
after newsletter promotion
After a winter in Barbados, Butcher is settling back in to life in England before a summer of commentary and promoting his new book, Breaking Barriers. It certainly doesn't want for interesting stories: being brought up in poverty by his grandmother on Barbados's east coast, being uprooted to join his parents in Stevenage, hoovering up trophies in a wonderful Middlesex side, becoming England's first black player before having his international ambitions crushed by a serious eye injury, and going into and swiftly giving up on cricket coaching. 'I found the English system too rigid. It was all from a book. I didn't feel confident enough that I would be allowed to do what I thought should happen.' He turned instead to football, met a then-unknown Brendan Rodgers while studying for his Uefa B licence and was recruited by him to join Reading's academy, before being left behind when Rodgers was headhunted by Chelsea and from there launched on a stellar coaching career.
'If he hadn't gone I think I would have stuck it longer,' Butcher says. 'What pushed me out eventually was the fact that I knew John Barnes very well and he was having it really tough. He couldn't get interviews, couldn't get shortlisted, couldn't get nothing. So after Brendan left, it dawned on me if guys of that level are struggling to make it professionally, it's gonna be tough for me.'
Now 71, Butcher has no intention of drifting away from cricket. He is very active as the president of Barbados Royals girls cricket club, the region's first all-female club, and a patron of the Ace Programme, the British charity trying to drive engagement in the sport among underrepresented communities. 'While I'm still capable physically and mentally to do something, I think I've got a lot to offer. I'm a cricket man and cricket has been my life.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
8 minutes ago
- Telegraph
‘Leave our kids alone': One parent's anger as school fees rise under Labour
As a small business owner, Emma says the new VAT on private school fees is hitting families like hers hard. 'It's now just under £10,000 pounds for each term in the senior school,' she says. 'By the time we're paying the school fees… My husband and I have paid our taxes. We've absolutely done everything we can.' Instead of spending money on luxuries, she adds, 'my husband and I are putting money into the local economy, paying local teachers… And that's even before you get into all the kind of charity work the school does'. Emma is frustrated by what she sees in school catchment areas. 'There's a moral turpitude to that kind of attitude… renting flats near the school, not even living there to get the residency… How can you live with yourselves?' Meanwhile, private school parents are painted as villains. 'When we get vilified as private school children, parents… I do start to lose the plot a bit.' Her message to the Government is simple: 'Leave our kids alone.' She adds, 'By not sending my two children to state school, I'm saving the Government… about seven and a half thousand pounds per child per year… We're not taking anything away from the state at all.'
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
Orchard tours 'essential' to Guernsey cider farm survival
The owner of a Guernsey cider farm has said money generated from tours around the orchards is "essential" to help his business succeed. James Meller, managing director at Rocquette Cider, started giving tours more than ten years ago and said it had increased in popularity year by year. He said it helped his business stand out in a "challenging market with lots of other ciders around". Deputy Sasha Kazantseva-Miller, Economic Development President, said it was important local producers "innovate" how they delivered their services. Mr Meller, who has been part of Rocquette Cider since it began in 1998, said cider drinking had increased over the past few years."In the UK you have orchardists growing a large amount of apples to supply the cider industry and since the resurgence of cider there's been an over-supply of apples in England so cider producers are spoilt for choice", he said."Over here [in Guernsey] we don't have so much, we grow a lot of our own and we also appeal to the public every year to take in apples."We've had to produce more and more each year because cider is so popular, so trying to get enough apples is a bit of a challenge." Mr Meller said he has had to "make space" to be able to upgrade his tours. He said: "We've had to provide toilets, increase the number of guides and develop the website for online booking."The tours are critical for the success of the business, they're such a large part of the turnover and allows us to market ourselves in what is a challenging market with lots of other ciders around." Meanwhile Jonathan Guille from Reservoir View Wine said he had just started to offer tours to people of his newly established vineyard. He planted the vines for his new Reservoir View wine in April and said he was hoping to have the first bottles up for sale by 2028."It's a difficult one because you can never tell how people will respond, but we're hopeful that we will get some interest", he said."Perhaps if everyone turned up at once that would probably be a bit of a nightmare but we're hoping we'll have some good interest."We've just launched some tours for people just to see the other side." 'Absolutely crucial' Deputy Kazantseva-Miller said the new economic development committee wanted to understand the challenges the rural industry was facing."It's not an easy industry to be in and I think it is very important that local producers innovate in how they deliver the services," she said."Sometimes [that is] making sure you're offering something for the tourism and visitor sector as well and not just selling that product locally or internationally, whether it's organising tours, selling off-island will be quite important."We come from a very horticultural and agricultural background, it's been the bread and butter and being an island it's both the marine resources but also on-island resources that are absolutely crucial and that's what maintained our community over the centuries."
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
Shropshire veteran allowed to keep his car following Motability row
A veteran who was told his Motability vehicle would be taken away following a review has been told he can keep it and will have his circumstances Motability scheme allows people with a personal independence payment, or Pip, to lease a vehicle, but Dean Tolhurst, who lives in Bicton Heath, Shropshire, claimed a recent reassessment had not been done properly. Mr Tolhurst said the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) had now "reopened both of my mandatory reviews."A spokesperson for the DWP said it was "changing the welfare system so it helps people to live with dignity". Mr Tolhurst has had a Motability car for six years, after breaking his back, having three strokes, two hernias, knee reconstructions and a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).He said he was unable to afford his own vehicle and relied on his mobility 56-year-old said knowing he will keep his car, a red Vauxhall Crossland, is "absolutely fantastic, [it allows me] to get up in the morning"."My car is my freedom," he added. Pip is paid to 3.7 million people with a long-term physical or mental health condition in England and includes a daily living component and a mobility component and claimants may be eligible for one or March, the government announced plans to tighten daily living assessments for both current and future after more than 120 Labour MPs threatened to vote against the change, it confirmed that those already receiving Pip would not be affected. To receive Pip, people are asked questions about everyday tasks, with each scored from zero, for no difficulty, to 12, for most Tolhurst said his recent reassessment did not properly take his mobility issues into account, which resulted in him not receiving an extra mobility payment that would allow him to lease a Motability car. Mr Tolhurst, who served in the British Army in the 1980s as a driver in the Royal Corps of Transport, said he has also "got the backing" of Shrewsbury MP Julia Buckley, who has written to the DWP. The 56-year-old said his "anxiety levels are not quite as high as they were", attributing it to the support of the added that he feels "a lot better knowing that people are backing me.""When I said the system was wrong, DWP didn't listen to me - but they've listened to BBC Radio Shropshire, and they will be listening to Julia Buckley," he said. Mr Tolhurst said anyone in his situation should "pick up the phone and ring your local radio station.""[The DWP has] done things wrong, and they need to turn around and go 'sorry we'll rectify it' - that's the only thing I can hope for." A spokesperson for the Department for Work and Pensions said they are "changing the welfare system so it helps people to live with dignity," adding that they have "announced a ministerial review of the PIP assessment process." Follow BBC Shropshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
