Jury reaches verdict in 2022 fatal stabbing of Good Samaritan in Bradford
A jury has found Brandon Aaron guilty of second-degree murder and assault following a violent incident in Bradford three years ago that left a 59-year-old man, who police called a Good Samaritan, dead.
The jury took about two hours to reach its verdict Thursday, convicting Aaron of stabbing David Goddard 20 times and assaulting his then-girlfriend in the early morning hours of Sept. 4, 2022.
According to the Crown, the attack happened on Holland Street West around 3 a.m., after Aaron and the young woman, then a teenager, had been out drinking in downtown Bradford. The court heard she became upset with Aaron for losing her cellphone, and the situation quickly escalated.
Brandon Aaron
Brandon Aaron, 23, denied repeated suggestions by the Crown he was the aggressor when violence broke out between Aaron and David Goddard, 59, whom police described as a hero who stepped in to help Aaron's former girlfriend after she'd been assaulted by Aaron along Holland Street West September 4, 2022.
The Crown said Aaron held a knife to her throat and later broke her arm with a flashlight she had borrowed from a nearby gas station to search for her phone.
It was then that Goddard, a bystander, stepped in to help the woman. The Crown told the court Aaron became enraged, pulled out a steak knife, and fatally stabbed Goddard over and over before leaving him on the side of the road.
David Goddard
Cameron David Goddard, 59, is identified as the victim of a homicide on Sept. 4, 2022, in Bradford, Ont. (Supplied)
The defence argued Aaron acted in self-defence and was frightened by Goddard, who was both older and larger.
'He was fearful for his life,' said defence lawyer Eugene Bhattacharya. He described Goddard's behaviour as provocative and said Aaron's ability to understand what was happening that night was impaired by intoxication.
During the trial, the young woman offered a different account from what she had originally told police just hours after the stabbing. On the witness stand she claimed she broke her own arm that night and said Goddard had simply offered to take her home.
The defence urged the jury to find Aaron not guilty of murder if they were left with any reasonable double about whether he acted out of fear.
Ultimately, the jury wasn't swayed by the defence.
Aaron is scheduled to return to court next week when a date is expected to be set for his sentencing hearing.
Brandon Aaron Court Exhibits
Brandon Aaron photographed by the South Simcoe Police Service on Sept. 4, 2022.
(Source: Court Exhibit)
Related Articles
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
25 minutes ago
- CBC
RCMP ask for help identifying 2 men connected to indecent acts on P.E.I.'s North Shore
Police in Prince Edward Island are asking for the public's help identifying two men involved in separate incidents of indecent acts that were reported in Queens County. RCMP officers responded to the first report on June 4 inside P.E.I. National Park in Cavendish. According to a news release, a cyclist reported seeing a man committing an indecent act inside a white, family-style van parked along the Gulf Shore Parkway at around 3 p.m. The vehicle's side door was open when the incident occurred. The man in this case was described as heavier set, with a reddish-grey beard and wearing a blue shirt. North Rustico incident A week later, on June 11, a man was seen committing an indecent act near a trail behind several homes on Autumn Lane in North Rustico between noon and 12:20 p.m., police said in the release. A witness told police the man was on the back side of a neighbouring property next to the trail. The suspect is described as thin, about 172 cm tall, and wearing a blue shirt, dark hat and light blue beach shorts. Police do not believe he is the same person involved in the Cavendish incident. Queens District RCMP is asking anyone who recognizes the individuals or has information about either incident to contact them at 902-368-9300. Tips can also be submitted anonymously through P.E.I. Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS (8477) or online at . These incidents come amid growing concerns about sexual offences on the Island.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Man shot with pellet gun during North End home invasion: police
A Winnipeg Police Service shoulder patch is seen at the Public Information Office in Winnipeg, Sept. 2, 2021. THE CANADIAN PRESS/David Lipnowski A Winnipeg man was taken to the hospital on Wednesday morning after he was shot with a pellet gun during a home invasion in the city's North End. The incident happened around 8 a.m. on Wednesday when the suspect, accompanied by another person, went to a home in the 300 block of Church Avenue and started banging on the door. According to the Winnipeg Police Service, a 53-year-old man answered the door, and an argument ensued. Police allege the suspect then forced his way into the home and fired his pellet gun at the 53-year-old man. The suspect then fled the scene. The victim was taken to the hospital in stable condition. Officers later arrested the suspect at an apartment complex. The major crimes unit took over the investigation and searched the suspect's residence, where they seized a loaded shotgun and an air pistol. A 29-year-old man has been charged with a dozen firearm, assault, and break-and-enter-related offences. He is in custody and none of the charges have been tested in court. The investigation continues. Anyone with information is asked to contact police at 204-986-6219 or Crime Stoppers at 204-786-8477.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
B.C. man charged in highway crash that killed 2, injured 3 others
Police were called to the crash on Highway 1 in Burnaby, B.C., on Feb. 18, 2024. A Surrey, B.C., man has been charged with multiple counts of driving while impaired by drugs after a highway crash that killed two young people and seriously injured three others. A statement Friday from the Burnaby RCMP says 35-year-old Chi Sun Park is facing 15 charges in relation to the collision between a Tesla and a minivan last year. Two women from Maple Ridge, ages 20 and 23, were killed in the 3 a.m. crash on the Trans-Canada Highway near the Sprott Street exit on Feb. 18, 2024. Two other Maple Ridge women, also in their 20s, were seriously hurt, as was a Surrey man in his 30s. Police initially said impairment was not suspected as a contributor to the crash, however further investigation has led them to believe otherwise. 'This matter is now before the courts and no further information will be released at this time in order to respect the court process,' the RCMP statement said. The B.C. Prosecution Service approved the following charges against Park on June 9, according to police: Two counts of dangerous operation of a conveyance causing death; Three counts of dangerous operation of a conveyance causing bodily harm; Two counts of operation of a conveyance while impaired by drugs causing death; Three counts of operation of a conveyance while impaired by drugs causing bodily harm; Two counts of operation of a conveyance with a blood drug concentration that exceeded the concentration for methamphetamine prescribed by regulation causing death; Three counts of operation of a conveyance with a blood drug concentration that exceeded the concentration for methamphetamine prescribed by regulation causing bodily harm. Park is scheduled to appear in Vancouver provincial court on July 24.
