Failures in POS integration system: Chainstore Association concerned at deteriorating environment for tax-compliant retailers
Comprising a large portion of Pakistan's retail and wholesale trade, the organized retail sector directly employs over one million people and supports a wide ecosystem including shopping malls, manufacturers, service providers, and the cottage industry. Retail brands are also a growing contributor to export earnings through physical stores abroad and cross-border e-commerce.
Despite being early adopters of the FBR-POS system and generating 25–30% of their turnover in taxes, compliant Tier-1 retailers are now facing a perfect storm of high tax rates, increasingly complex procedures, punitive enforcement, and unresolved system issues.
This year alone, several regulatory instruments including SRO 69(I)/2025, SRO 55(I)/2025 and the Tax Laws (Amendment) Ordinance 2025—have exacerbated compliance burdens without addressing critical FBR-POS system deficiencies. These include issues such as (1) POS profile expiry disconnections, rendering invoices unverifiable; (2) Incorrect POS status flags showing 'disconnected' despite active syncing; and (3) Weak support capacity of Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL) to address technical challenges.
Compounding these technical issues is an increasingly punitive enforcement approach. Several compliant outlets experiencing system errors have been sealed without prior notice, and many retailers report being pressured to pay penalties exceeding Rs500,000 per outlet to reopen, apparently to increase short-term tax collections. Such measures erode business confidence, damage reputations, and undermine long-term documentation efforts.
'We fully support strict action against wilful tax evasion, but the current approach is causing heavy collateral damage,' said Asfandyar Farrukh, Chairperson of CAP. 'Law-abiding retailers are being penalised for compliance, while vast sections of the informal market remain untouched. This is not reform it is a rollback in the making.'
The reversal of key incentives has further compounded the crisis. The discontinuation of the 10–15% concessional GST rate for customers of integrated retailers has rendered many businesses uncompetitive vs the untaxed and undertaxed majority, leading to network consolidation and closures. In recent years, this reform vacuum has stalled employment growth, investment, and even export potential.
CAP also calls for formal inclusion in policymaking processes to ensure that ongoing and future reforms are informed by on-ground realities.
'Compliant retailers who invested in technology and compliance should be recognized as partners in reform. CAP and its members wholeheartedly support broadening of the retail tax base - but it must be fair, functional, and future-focused,' said Tariq Mehboob Rana, CAP Patron-in-Chief. 'Unless the current issues are urgently addressed, years of progress towards the growth of the documented sector risk being reversed.'
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
4 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Gold price per tola gains Rs500 in Pakistan
Gold prices in Pakistan increased on Monday in line with their gain in the international market. In the local market, gold price per tola reached Rs359,500 after an increase of Rs500 during the day. As per the rates shared by the All-Pakistan Gems and Jewellers Sarafa Association (APGJSA), 10-gram gold was sold at Rs308,213 after it gained Rs429. On Saturday, gold price per tola reached Rs359,000 after an increase of Rs6,100 during the day. The international rate of gold increased today. As per APGJSA, the rate was at $3,368 per ounce (with a premium of $20), a gain of $5. Meanwhile, the silver price per tola remained stable at Rs3,953.
Express Tribune
16 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Tobacco sector: potential & illicit trade challenges
Listen to article Pakistan's tobacco industry plays a pivotal role in the nation's economy, providing employment opportunities, generating substantial tax revenue and supporting the agricultural sector. However, it faces growing challenges, including stringent regulations and the pervasive issue of cigarette smuggling, which undermines legitimate businesses and erodes government revenue. According to data from the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) and industry reports, Pakistan's tobacco industry is valued at approximately $2.3 billion as of 2024, with a projected compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6.28% from 2025 to 2029. The cigarette segment dominates the market, with an estimated worth of $1.9 billion in 2025. Despite its economic significance, the industry has witnessed a decline in legal cigarette sales, which fell 8.3% in 2024, from 36 billion to 33 billion sticks, according to statistics from the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). The tobacco sector remains a vital source of revenue, contributing Rs150 billion ($540 million) in taxes during fiscal year 2023-24, as reported by the FBR. This contribution includes federal excise duty (FED), sales tax and other levies, which help fund various government initiatives. Tobacco farming continues to be a critical activity, particularly in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab, where smallholder farmers benefit from higher per-acre returns compared to traditional crops like wheat or maize. Pakistan has implemented stringent anti-smoking policies in line with World Health Organisation (WHO) guidelines. These measures include higher taxes, graphical health warnings on packaging and bans on public smoking. In 2022-23, the FED on cigarettes saw a significant increase, raising the FED share in retail prices to 48% for low-tier brands and 68% for high-tier brands, according to the FBR. While these measures aim to reduce smoking rates, they have, on the contrary, fueled the illicit cigarette trade, which accounted for 46 billion out of 79 billion cigarettes sold in 2024, as per an Oxford Economics study. The illicit trade poses a significant threat to Pakistan's tobacco industry and the broader economy. Over the past decade, the country has lost over Rs567 billion in revenue due to smuggling and illegal manufacturing, as estimated by the FBR. In 2024 alone, legal cigarette sales dropped 8.3%, while the illicit market expanded. The availability of 74 smuggled cigarette brands across the country, as reported by the FBR, reflects inadequate enforcement measures. Many of these smuggled brands evade high taxation, which makes them cheaper and more accessible, thereby exacerbating public health risks. Pakistan's tobacco industry operates within a regional context that includes India, Bangladesh and Iran, each of which faces similar regulatory and economic challenges. India's tobacco industry is one of the largest in the world, valued at $11 billion in 2024, according to the India Brand Equity Foundation, with a projected CAGR of 4.5% from 2025 to 2029. Cigarette sales in India are under pressure due to high taxes and stringent regulations, including an 85% graphical health warning mandate. Despite contributing over $7 billion in annual tax revenue, India's illicit cigarette trade accounts for nearly 25% of the market, reported the Euromonitor International. Bangladesh's tobacco industry is valued at $1.8 billion, with a projected CAGR of 5.2%, said the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. The sector contributes $1.2 billion in taxes and employs thousands of farmers, particularly in Rangpur and Chittagong regions. Regulatory measures, including tax hikes and smoking bans, have led to illicit trade accounting for 20% of sales, showed WHO statistics. Smuggled products primarily enter the country from India and Myanmar, facilitated by weak border enforcement. Iran's tobacco industry, valued at $1.2 billion, is heavily regulated, with a projected CAGR of 3.8%, according to the Iranian Customs Authority. Despite contributing $800 million in taxes, strict regulatory measures have caused legal sales to decline, fueling the growth of illicit trade. Smuggling, primarily from Afghanistan and Iraq, makes up 30% of the market. All four countries — Pakistan, India, Bangladesh and Iran — struggle with the issue of smuggled cigarettes, which harm legitimate businesses and reduce government revenues. Pakistan's illicit trade share, at 58%, is the highest in the region, underscoring the urgent need for stronger enforcement measures. Pakistan's high taxation and graphical health warnings have disproportionately impacted legal sales compared to its regional counterparts. Finding a balance between public health objectives and economic interests remains a critical challenge. Despite these challenges, Pakistan's projected CAGR of 6.28% is the highest in the region, suggesting significant potential for expansion if the issue of illicit trade is addressed effectively. Enhanced regional cooperation, particularly with India and Bangladesh, could help curb cross-border smuggling. Sharing best practices in enforcement, digital tracking systems and policy frameworks could prove mutually beneficial. Pakistan's tobacco industry should also explore opportunities in reduced-risk products, such as e-cigarettes and heated tobacco, to align with global trends. Supporting farmers in transitioning to alternative crops could help mitigate the risks associated with regulatory pressures. In conclusion, while Pakistan's tobacco industry remains a key economic contributor, it faces significant challenges from regulatory pressures and illicit trade. Proactive measures by industry stakeholders and the government, coupled with regional collaboration, will be essential to navigate these challenges and secure a sustainable future for the sector. The writer is a Mechanical Engineer and is pursuing Master's degree
Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Textile exporters alarmed by 19pc US tariff decision
KARACHI: Following the US decision to impose a 19 percent tariff on Pakistani goods, Pakistani textile exporters have expressed concerns, stating that this move will increase prices in the US, initially affecting exports. However, they believe business conditions will gradually improve. Young textile exporter and Director of Lakhany Silk Mills, Farhan Lakhany, said the tariff has significantly affected their sales in the US He added that while exports to the United Arab Emirates have increased, the US was Pakistan's most lucrative market and has now been impacted. He explained that due to the tariffs, product prices have risen. According to Farhan Lakhany, although Pakistan faces lower tariffs compared to Bangladesh and India, higher production costs negate any advantage. Nevertheless, he emphasized the need to remain optimistic about the future. PTC warns FBR's new amendments will cripple Pakistan's textile exports Farhan Lakhany informed Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah, during his visit to the Lakhany Silk Mills stall at the ongoing 'My Karachi' exhibition at Karachi Expo Center that his company produces high-quality textile products which are appreciated globally. Also present at the occasion were Rizwan Lakhany, KCCI President Javed Bilwani, Zubair Motiwala, and Idrees Memon. Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah expressed best wishes for Pakistan's textile industry and exports, stating that the Sindh government has always prioritized resolving industrial issues. He assured that, following the directives of Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari, the provincial government would continue to facilitate export-oriented industries. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
