Failures in POS integration system: Chainstore Association concerned at deteriorating environment for tax-compliant retailers
LAHORE: The Chainstore Association of Pakistan, representing the country's organized retail sector, on Saturday, expressed grave concern over the deteriorating environment for tax-compliant retailers due to aggressive revenue enforcement and persistent failures in the FBR-POS integration system.
Comprising a large portion of Pakistan's retail and wholesale trade, the organized retail sector directly employs over one million people and supports a wide ecosystem including shopping malls, manufacturers, service providers, and the cottage industry. Retail brands are also a growing contributor to export earnings through physical stores abroad and cross-border e-commerce.
Despite being early adopters of the FBR-POS system and generating 25–30% of their turnover in taxes, compliant Tier-1 retailers are now facing a perfect storm of high tax rates, increasingly complex procedures, punitive enforcement, and unresolved system issues.
This year alone, several regulatory instruments including SRO 69(I)/2025, SRO 55(I)/2025 and the Tax Laws (Amendment) Ordinance 2025—have exacerbated compliance burdens without addressing critical FBR-POS system deficiencies. These include issues such as (1) POS profile expiry disconnections, rendering invoices unverifiable; (2) Incorrect POS status flags showing 'disconnected' despite active syncing; and (3) Weak support capacity of Pakistan Revenue Automation Limited (PRAL) to address technical challenges.
Compounding these technical issues is an increasingly punitive enforcement approach. Several compliant outlets experiencing system errors have been sealed without prior notice, and many retailers report being pressured to pay penalties exceeding Rs500,000 per outlet to reopen, apparently to increase short-term tax collections. Such measures erode business confidence, damage reputations, and undermine long-term documentation efforts.
'We fully support strict action against wilful tax evasion, but the current approach is causing heavy collateral damage,' said Asfandyar Farrukh, Chairperson of CAP. 'Law-abiding retailers are being penalised for compliance, while vast sections of the informal market remain untouched. This is not reform it is a rollback in the making.'
The reversal of key incentives has further compounded the crisis. The discontinuation of the 10–15% concessional GST rate for customers of integrated retailers has rendered many businesses uncompetitive vs the untaxed and undertaxed majority, leading to network consolidation and closures. In recent years, this reform vacuum has stalled employment growth, investment, and even export potential.
CAP also calls for formal inclusion in policymaking processes to ensure that ongoing and future reforms are informed by on-ground realities.
'Compliant retailers who invested in technology and compliance should be recognized as partners in reform. CAP and its members wholeheartedly support broadening of the retail tax base - but it must be fair, functional, and future-focused,' said Tariq Mehboob Rana, CAP Patron-in-Chief. 'Unless the current issues are urgently addressed, years of progress towards the growth of the documented sector risk being reversed.'
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
7 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan debt stock reaches all-time high of Rs75trn
KARACHI: The federal government's total debt stock surged by over Rs 6 trillion during the first ten months of this fiscal year (FY25) due to massive borrowing to finance the budget deficit. According to a statistic released by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) on Wednesday, the central government's total debt, comprising domestic and external liabilities, rose by 9 percent during July-April of FY25. Overall, the stock reached an all-time high level of Rs 74.936 trillion by the end of April 2025 compared to Rs 68.914 trillion as of June 2024, depicting an increase of Rs 6.022 trillion. The major growth in debt stocks was attributed to domestic borrowings, which rose by 11.37 percent or Rs 5.363 trillion to reach Rs 52.523 trillion in April 2025 up from Rs 47.16 trillion in June 2024. The domestic debt comprised long-term loans worth Rs 44.132 trillion and short-term borrowings amounting to Rs 8.328 trillion. Pakistan govt's debt stock soars to Rs73.6trn by March-end External debt, in rupee terms, saw an increase of Rs 659 billion during the first ten months of FY25, reaching Rs 22.413 trillion by the end of April 2025 compared to Rs 21.754 trillion in June 2024. The SBP reported that the Weighted Average Customer Exchange Rate of the US dollar was Rs 278.3668 in June 2024 and Rs 280.9739 in April 2025. The federal government's debt showed a notable increase of Rs 1.248 trillion in April 2025 due to massive borrowing to finance the budget deficit. On a month-on-month (MoM) basis, the federal government's debt stock rose by 2 percent from Rs 73.688 trillion in March 2025 to Rs 74.936 trillion in April 2025. Analysts noted that the tax collection by the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) is 26 percent higher during the first eleven (July-May) months of this fiscal year compared to previous year; however, cumulatively FBR has failed to achieve the target. The shortfall in revenue collection has compelled the federal government to borrow from domestic and external resources. FBR had missed its revenue collection target by some one trillion rupees in the first eleven months of this fiscal year due to lower imports and slowing economic growth. The FBR has collected some Rs10.233 trillion between July-May of FY25 as against the budgetary target of Rs11.241 trillion for the same period. The SBP has already emphasised the need for a sharp acceleration in tax revenue growth to meet the annual targets. Achieving the primary balance target remains a significant challenge for the government. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
10 hours ago
- Business Recorder
PBF urges govt to exempt local cotton, seed, yarn, fabrics from 18pc GST
LAHORE: The Pakistan Business Forum (PBF) has called on the federal government to exempt local Cotton, yarn, Fabrics, Oil cake, seed cotton and oil from the 18% General Sales Tax (GST) in the upcoming Federal Budget 2025–26, warning that the failure to do so could push the country's Agriculture and textile industry toward total collapse. PBF Chairman South Punjab, Malik Talat Suhail while talking to media emphasized that the Export Finance Scheme (EFS), introduced to phase out subsidies and promote exports, has instead proven detrimental to the textile sector. Under EFS, imported raw materials are exempted from both sales tax and customs duty, while local inputs continue to be taxed at 18%. Though this tax is technically refundable, in practice, only 60–70% of refunds are released. The refund process is plagued by delays, manual processing, and high costs—issues that disproportionately harm small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). This imbalance has led many exporters to favour imported inputs, causing serious damage to local suppliers. As a result, Pakistan's import of cotton, yarn, and fabric surged by $1.5 billion in FY 2025, climbing from $2.19 billion to $3.64 billion. In contrast, textile exports rose by only $1.4 billion and net textile exports are projected to decline from $14.0 billion to $13.6 billion. Over 120 spinning mills and more than 800 ginning factories have shut down, while protests from loom workers in Faisalabad are growing. SMEs are particularly vulnerable, as they face multiple tax payments at every stage of production and have limited access to cheaper imported alternatives, unlike larger firms. The current situation has placed severe pressure on the country's foreign exchange reserves, especially as the number of commercial import licenses has tripled from 800 to 2,400. Meanwhile, local cotton production has fallen to a historic low of just 5 million bales, with further declines anticipated. Due to a lack of government support and declining demand, many farmers are abandoning cotton cultivation in favour of more water-intensive crops, placing further stress on national water resources. PBF also warned that the collapse of the cotton economy is stripping rural areas of $2-3 billion in income, with women cotton-pickers among the hardest hit. 'Pakistan is currently the only country imposing an 18% sales tax on cottonseed and cotton feed, driving farmer income below the cost of production and hitting the poorest segments of society the hardest'. Rising unemployment and declining rural earnings are further exacerbating the economic crisis. PBF South Punjab Chief has urged the government to immediately delist cotton, yarn, and fabric from the current EFS policy. He further stated that maintaining GST on local cotton while exempting imports under EFS is effectively a 'Pakistan-unfriendly policy'. It undermines local production, weakens the economy, and benefits only opportunistic importers. Without urgent reforms, the country risks facing a deepening economic crisis driven by misguided policy decisions. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
11 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PTC urges tax on cigarette paper
Listen to article The Pakistan Tobacco Company (PTC) has urged the government to impose an adjustable tax on cigarette paper in a bid to ensure full documentation of the cigarette industry and combat the rapidly growing illicit trade, which it says has now become the market leader. At a pre-budget media briefing, PTC Director Asad Shah expressed serious concern over the rise in untaxed cigarettes, calling for uniform implementation of the track-and-trace tax stamp policy. Without uniform enforcement, he argued, the policy is ineffective. Shah also proposed reducing the adjustable tax on cigarette filter material acetate tow from Rs44,000 per kilogram to Rs4,000 per kilogram to discourage smuggling. Authorities seized 450 metric tonnes of smuggled acetate tow this year alone, he added. Shah also proposed that adjustable tax should be imposed on cigarette paper to ensure complete documentation. He noted that illicit cigarettes now account for 58% of the total market, with Pakistan's annual cigare tte consumption estimated at 82 billion sticks. Shah claimed that the sector has the potential to generate Rs570 billion in tax revenue annually, but only Rs292 billion was collected in FY2023-24 and Rs223 billion so far in the first 11 months of the current fiscal year. "It is impossible to collect the remaining Rs50 billion in a single month," he said, pointing to widespread tax evasion and the alleged involvement of some non-governmental organisations (NGOs) pursuing specific agendas. Shah recalled that 12 years ago, the government taxed 67 billion sticks annually. That number has now dropped to just 34 billion, despite consistent or growing demand. He criticised the 2023 tax policy, saying it led to the second decline in government revenue from the sector in a decade. Despite holding only a 42% market share, the legal tobacco sector still contributes 98% of the revenue, Shah said. He urged authorities to enforce documentation requirements across the board, stressing that 18 billion sticks are being sold at or below Rs150 per packbelow the official minimum price of Rs162.25 — without any penalties for violators. He pointed out that no one has ever been penalised for violating the minimum price law and instead recommended raising the minimum price per pack to counter the perception of cigarettes being cheap in Pakistan. "No policy can succeed without non-discriminatory implementation," he said, adding that untaxed, locally manufactured cigarettes are still openly sold.
