AI tools not for decision making: Kerala HC guidelines to district judiciary on AI usage
The High Court has come out with the 'Policy Regarding Use of Artificial Intelligence Tools in District Judiciary' for a responsible and restricted use of AI in judicial functions of the district judiciary of the state in view of the increasing availability of and access to such software tools.
According to court sources, it is a first-of-its-kind policy.
It has advised the district judiciary to "exercise extreme caution" as "indiscriminate use of AI tools might result in negative consequences, including violation of privacy rights, data security risks and erosion of trust in the judicial decision making".
"The objectives are to ensure that AI tools are used only in a responsible manner, solely as an assistive tool, and strictly for specifically allowed purposes. The policy aims to ensure that under no circumstances AI tools are used as a substitute for decision making or legal reasoning," the policy document said.
The policy also aims to help members of the judiciary and staff to comply with their ethical and legal obligations, particularly in terms of ensuring human supervision, transparency, fairness, confidentiality and accountability at all stages of judicial decision making.
"Any violation of this policy may result in disciplinary action, and rules pertaining to disciplinary proceedings shall prevail," the policy document issued on July 19 said.
The new guidelines are applicable to members of the district judiciary in the state, the staff assisting them and also any interns or law clerks working with them in Kerala.
"The policy covers all kinds of AI tools, including, but not limited to, generative AI tools, and databases that use AI to provide access to diverse resources, including case laws and statutes," the document said.
Generative AI examples include ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Deepseek, it said.
It also said that the new guidelines apply to all circumstances wherein AI tools are used to perform or assist in the performance of judicial work, irrespective of location and time of use and whether they are used on personal, court-owned or third party devices.
The policy directs that usage of AI tools for official purposes adhere to the principles of transparency, fairness, accountability and protection of confidentiality, avoid use of cloud-based services -- except for the approved AI tools, meticulous verification of the results, including translations, generated by such software and all time human supervision of their usage.
"AI tools shall not be used to arrive at any findings, reliefs, order or judgement under any circumstances, as the responsibility for the content and integrity of the judicial order, judgement or any part thereof lies fully with the judges," it said.
It further directs that courts shall maintain a detailed audit of all instances wherein AI tools are used.
"The records in this regard shall include the tools used and the human verification process adopted," it said.
Participating in training programmes on the ethical, legal, technical and practical aspects of AI and reporting any errors or issues noticed in the output generated by any of the approved AI tools, are the other guidelines mentioned in the policy document.
The High Court has requested all District Judges and Chief Judicial Magistrates to communicate the policy document to all judicial officers and the staff members under their jurisdiction and take necessary steps to ensure its strict compliance.>
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘With technology insurance moving from `repair and replace' to prevention'
Mark Klein, Chief Digital Officer at Ergo, leads the insurer's digitalization, marketing and global partnerships. A former telecom and consulting executive, Klein has been with Ergo for nine years. The company, which operates across Europe and Asia in health, life and P&C insurance, recently entered the US market through a $2.6 billion acquisition of digital SME insurer Next. In an interview with Times of India, Klein speaks of how with a goal of becoming the leading digital insurer in its core markets by 2025, Ergo is deploying technologies such as process mining, AI, robotics and phone bots—more than 500 robots and 15,000 daily bot-handled calls—to boost efficiency and customer experience. How does a legacy company become a digital insurer? You've said it's more cultural than technological? That is correct. While most technologies can be deployed on top of legacy systems, the real challenge is cultural. Employees must understand what the technology does and doesn't do. We demystify the tools, give staff a stage to share success stories, and celebrate adoption—even naming robots and marking their 'birthdays.' These technologies take care of repetitive tasks, letting employees focus on complex customer needs. It was an evolutionary transformation. We reengineered core processes gradually, focusing on speed and customer centricity. How did the deployment of AI play out? We began with simple machine learning models, like email classification in 2017. That helped us prepare for broader adoption. Now, with large language models, we focus on three areas: adoption management, scaling use cases, and realizing impact. AI must move beyond pilots and deliver real business value. We have over 110 algorithms in production and a five-year plan to scale across Germany, Poland, Austria, Belgium, Spain, the UK, and Greece. In Germany, we launched "Ergo GPT," a secure ChatGPT-style tool for employees. About 60% of staff use it daily. We also use gen AI to convert unstructured broker emails into structured data and to make internal product documentation searchable using a retrieval augmented generation (RAG) model. How is process mining helping the company? Process mining offers transparency. It helps identify inefficiencies and manual bottlenecks. It creates you the full transparency of a process because it takes the log files out of your IT systems and with that really shows you the full transparency of your process. How long did it take? Which were the different steps? And you see immediately where you still have a lot of manual work, where you have working times, where your process is not so straight. Sometimes you think oh, it's a very easy process. And then you. But you have many, many permutations of that. And with that you can see how to adjust the process, how to further automate the process that you get with process mining. Is Ergo outsourcing to India? Yes, we have our service hub here, our nearshoring location for Ergo Technology Services India (ETS) in Mumbai. The team is over 600 and growing. ETS supports digital initiatives across the group. With digitisation happening at the same time as genome sequencing and predictive analysis in health and telematic insurance in motor, is insurance now more about managing risk than just calculating probability? Both matter. We're moving from "repair and replace" to prevention. In health, that means encouraging healthier lifestyles. In motor, telematics helps avoid accidents. But prediction and probability will still play a role. We are also preparing for new risks such as Cyber risks, climate-related events, and rising health issues, especially in Western Europe. These require stronger coverage and better response capabilities. With Europe having stronger privacy and data security norms. How do you ensure compliance across geographies? We follow strict governance and comply fully with GDPR. We only use customer data with explicit consent and do not use data scraping for underwriting. For rejections, there is always the concerpt of human-in-the-loop. If a claim is approved straight through, AI can handle it. But rejections always require human oversight. HDFC Ergo has launched `Here' app which goes beyond insurance and is key interface for customers. Are you looking to replicate it in other markets? We're exploring that. India's public digital infrastructure makes such services easier to implement than in Europe. Are you bringing anything new to the Indian JV? Yes. India led our group in adopting robotics in 2016. Now we exchange best practices regularly and benchmark progress across markets with four key performance indicators (KPIs): share of online sales, portal registrations, digital interactions, and availability of online products. Customer experience is the key driver. Ergo is investing over €130 million in GenAI infrastructure over the next five years—this does not including staff or operations— this is purely for tech. Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays . Discover stories of India's leading eco-innovators at Ecopreneur Honours 2025
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Samsung launches Galaxy Book 4 Edge in India: Price, specifications, availability
Samsung has launched the Galaxy Book 4 Edge in India, expanding its AI-powered personal computing offerings. The device is equipped with on-device AI features and Microsoft's Copilot+ integration. It is part of Samsung's Galaxy AI ecosystem, enabling connectivity between Galaxy smartphones and PCs. With features like Link to Windows, Multi Control, and Second Screen, the Galaxy Book 4 Edge allows users to mirror smartphone screens on the PC.(Samsung) With features like Link to Windows, Multi Control, and Second Screen, the Galaxy Book 4 Edge allows users to mirror smartphone screens on the PC and manage devices across platforms. Galaxy AI functionalities such as Chat Assist and Live Translate are now available on this PC. The Galaxy Book 4 Edge runs on the Qualcomm Snapdragon X processor, delivering up to 45 trillion operations per second (TOPS) of neural processing unit (NPU) performance. It includes Qualcomm's Adreno GPU and supports features like Cocreator, which uses AI to convert sketches and text prompts into images. Windows Studio Effects are also available, offering tools such as voice focus, background blur, and eye contact correction during video calls. The device comes in a 15-inch variant with a full HD (1080p) camera, Wi-Fi 7 support, and a battery that is claimed to last up to 27 hours on a single charge. It is manufactured using recycled materials, including plastic, glass, and aluminium. The device weighs 1.55 kg. Security features include Samsung Knox, providing hardware-level and real-time threat monitoring. As a Microsoft Secured-core PC, it offers firmware protection and supports on-device data management with features like Recall. Users can control or delete stored data directly on the device. The Galaxy Book 4 Edge is priced at ₹64,990 in India. A launch offer provides ₹5,000 cashback on select bank cards, bringing the effective price down to ₹59,990. The device is available starting today via Samsung's official website, Flipkart, the Samsung Shop App, Samsung Experience Stores, and authorised retail outlets.
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Tech giants are revising AI product claims that faced scrutiny
Apple, Google, Microsoft and Samsung have been revising or retracting certain claims about their newest, hottest artificial intelligence products. The tech giants made the changes over the past year in response to a probe by an ad-industry self-regulatory group into whether marketers are overstating the capabilities or availability of AI features. The Federal Trade Commission has also been studying the sector's advertising, in September announcing several legal complaints as part of a crackdown it called Operation AI Comply. The scrutiny comes as the biggest names in tech seek returns on their massive investments in the AI race, holding splashy events, publishing demonstration videos and running advertising to bring in customers. AI developers including OpenAI and Anthropic ran commercials during the Super Bowl, the biggest television event of the year. But it can be challenging to describe AI features quickly and compellingly if also giving all the caveats. 'That is the struggle in a lot of these cases around AI tools and products," said Laura Protzmann, an attorney at the National Advertising Division of BBB National Programs, the industry group that has probed the issue. NAD typically referees complaints that companies lodge against competitors in categories like light beer and cellphone service. But it began proactively examining AI marketing when more companies started promoting claims about their new tools to the public, according to Protzmann. 'We thought that it was an important area to focus on, in part because these are hard claims for consumers to evaluate themselves," she said. While NAD found that some of the marketers' claims had support, it identified notable exceptions. NAD found in April that Apple's website had prominently advertised unreleased AI features for the newest iPhone as 'available now," for example, and that its small-print disclosures weren't clear or conspicuous enough. Most of those features have since arrived, but Apple's site now more visibly warns that new capabilities for its Siri digital assistant remain in development. Apple also pulled an ad, released last year, that depicted Siri checking the iPhone calendar of 'The Last of Us" star Bella Ramsey to summon the name of an acquaintance from a meeting months earlier. That ability has yet to see the light of day. Although Apple disagreed with the conclusions, according to NAD, it pledged to follow the group's recommendations. The company didn't respond to requests for comment. An Apple executive in June told The Wall Street Journal, however, that the features it promoted had worked enough to demonstrate but didn't 'converge in the way quality-wise that we needed." Siri is now getting a new underlying architecture, the executive said. Google last year unlisted a YouTube video showcasing the Gemini assistant—including a brief disclaimer that the depicted actions of Gemini had been 'shortened throughout"— after NAD began examining its depiction of performance and speed. The 2023 video, which shows Gemini doing everything from identifying a picture being drawn to composing music, now lives mainly on a company blog post discussing the kinds of prompts used to assemble it. The video shouldn't be seen as an accurate depiction of how the product works, according to a Google spokeswoman. Microsoft removed a page promoting the Business Chat function of its Copilot assistant that claimed the product works 'seamlessly across all your data." An NAD decision released last month concluded that the phrase might lead consumers to think Copilot could perform tasks like switching from one Microsoft application to another and generating a new document there. Users still have to take manual steps to do that, NAD said. Microsoft also added a disclaimer to survey results, including a finding that 75% of respondents reported greater productivity after using Copilot for 10 weeks, clarifying that the numbers reflect people's perception rather than objective measurements. Microsoft disagrees with some conclusions about misleading language but agreed to follow the NAD's recommendations, said Jared Spataro, chief marketing officer of Microsoft's AI at Work division. The removal of the Business Chat page preceded the release of the NAD decision, according to a Microsoft spokeswoman. Microsoft created a new page for the renamed Copilot Chat in its place. And Samsung last month agreed to drop assertions that its AI-powered refrigerator 'automatically recognizes what's in your fridge, so you always know what's inside" after NAD began an inquiry. Protzmann said the NAD found that the camera behind Samsung's 'AI Vision Inside" product can recognize just 33 specific food items and only if they are clearly visible, but the group didn't issue an official judgment because the language in question had been abandoned already. The FTC has used its own power to pursue penalties over allegedly false AI claims. A proposed court order against a company called Ascend Ecom, whose ads promised that customers could make $10,000 a month by purchasing an AI-powered e-commerce operation, would permanently ban its founders from marketing similar services and require them to forfeit related assets as part of a $25 million monetary judgment. Ascend Ecom's attorney declined to comment. As AI worms its way into almost every industry, customers should expect a surge in questionable marketing, according to George Heudorfer, adjunct professor of marketing at the University of New Haven's Pompea College of Business. 'When you market AI like magic, you're going to invite scrutiny," said Heudorfer. 'Sometimes that exaggeration isn't just puffery. It's a performance claim, and you need to back that up with something more than a keynote and a catchphrase."
