Brains on Autopilot: ChatGPT May Erode Critical Thinking
Participants using only their cognitive abilities showed the greatest neural activation, stronger memory recall, and more nuanced, creative expression. By contrast, ChatGPT users displayed the lowest brain engagement across neural, linguistic and behavioural measures. Experts described their outputs as 'soulless,' and follow‑up testing revealed that those who started by leaning on AI struggled to regain earlier performance levels when later writing independently.
The U. K. survey of more than 600 users echoed these concerns: frequent AI use was significantly linked to reduced critical thinking—especially among younger individuals who offloaded mental effort rather than utilising AI as an aid. Researchers warn this pattern may foster 'cognitive off‑loading,' a dependence that could diminish mental agility.
ADVERTISEMENT
Yet the data also reveal nuance. In a separate high school‑based trial, students who engaged with AI tutors offering iterative guidance rather than complete solutions performed just as well as those without AI assistance. This suggests that when AI is used to supplement learning and not supplant it, cognitive gains remain achievable.
MIT lead researcher Nataliya Kosmyna cautions: 'This study was not measuring intelligence loss, but rather the neural, linguistic and behavioural effects of reliance on generative systems.' She emphasises that the findings remain unreviewed and limited in scope, underscoring the need for long‑term, peer‑validated work before drawing sweeping conclusions.
Cambridge University's Sam Gilbert frames the phenomenon differently: reduced brain activity might reflect a release of mental bandwidth, enabling users to channel attention into higher‑order tasks. But he reminds policymakers and educators that caution is essential when integrating AI in formative environments.
Business and public discourse have responded swiftly. Coverage in the Washington Post highlighted the delicate balance between cognitive off‑loading and the potential to free mental capacity for creative endeavour. Coverage from The New York Post and The Times cited concerns of 'skill atrophy' and warned against passive AI dependence.
Academic literature supports this emerging narrative. An arXiv study dated December 2024 flagged 'metacognitive laziness' among AI‑assisted learners—those who rely on ChatGPT improved essay scores but showed weak knowledge transfer. University of Pennsylvania and Carnegie Mellon faculties likewise document a tension between AI assistance and sustained critical reasoning in student assignments.
Tech industry responses emphasise that AI's strength lies in augmentation, not substitution. Start‑ups such as BioSpark and other 'cognitive‑sparking' interfaces aim to rekindle curiosity and ownership—positioning AI as a creative counterpart rather than a convenience.
Major AI developers, including OpenAI, maintain that generative AI can enhance productivity—citing workforce efficiency gains of up to 15 per cent. Yet they acknowledge that without user agency and deliberate design, those gains may come at the expense of independent thought. With institutional adoption surging—over one billion ChatGPT users worldwide—experts press for frameworks that prioritise mental resilience as much as performance.
The debate reflects a longstanding tension in the adoption of technology. From Socrates' lament over writing to early anxieties about calculators and internet search, each leap in efficiency has triggered reflection on intellectual costs. AI, its proponents argue, is no different: transformation demands vigilance. As Michael Gerlich of the Swiss Business School notes, 'It's become a part of how I think.' But he stresses that training the mind to think with AI, rather than through it, will be critical.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Khaleej Times
an hour ago
- Khaleej Times
Visa's 24/7 war room takes on global cybercriminals
In the heart of Data Center Alley — a patch of suburban Washington where much of the world's internet traffic flows -- Visa operates its global fraud command center. The numbers that the payments giant grapples with are enormous. Every year, $15 trillion flows through Visa's networks, representing roughly 15 percent of the world's economy. And bad actors constantly try to syphon off some of that money. Modern fraudsters vary dramatically in sophistication. To stay ahead, Visa has invested $12 billion over the past five years building AI-powered cyber fraud detection capabilities, knowing that criminals are also spending big. "You have everybody from a single individual threat actor looking to make a quick buck all the way to really corporatized criminal organizations that generate tens or hundreds of millions of dollars annually from fraud and scam activities," Michael Jabbara, Visa's global head of fraud solutions, told AFP during a tour of the company's security campus. "These organizations are very structured in how they operate." The best-resourced criminal syndicates now focus on scams that directly target consumers, enticing them into purchases or transactions by manipulating their emotions. "Consumers are continuously vulnerable. They can be exploited, and that's where we've seen a much higher incidence of attacks recently," Jabbara said. - Scam centers - The warning signs are clear: anything that seems too good to be true online is suspicious, and romance opportunities with strangers from distant countries are especially dangerous. "What you don't realize is that the person you're chatting with is more likely than not in a place like Myanmar," Jabbara warned. He said human-trafficking victims are forced to work in multi-billion-dollar cyber scam centers built by Asian crime networks in Myanmar's lawless border regions. The most up-to-date fraud techniques are systematic and quietly devastating. Once criminals obtain your card information, they automatically distribute it across numerous merchant websites that generate small recurring charges -- amounts low enough that victims may not notice for months. Some of these operations increasingly resemble legitimate tech companies, offering services and digital products to fraudsters much like Google or Microsoft cater to businesses. On the dark web, criminals can purchase comprehensive fraud toolkits. "You can buy the software. You can buy a tutorial on how to use the software. You can get access to a mule network on the ground or you can get access to a bot network" to carry out denial-of-service attacks that overwhelm servers with traffic, effectively shutting them down. Just as cloud computing lowered barriers for startups by eliminating the need to build servers, "the same type of trend has happened in the cyber crime and fraud space," Jabbara explained. These off-the-shelf services can also enable bad actors to launch brute force attacks on an industrial scale -- using repeated payment attempts to crack a card's number, expiry date, and security code. The sophistication extends to corporate-style management, Jabbara said. Some criminal organizations now employ chief risk officers who determine operational risk appetite. They might decide that targeting government infrastructure and hospitals generates an excessive amount of attention from law enforcement and is too risky to pursue. 'Millions of attacks' To combat these unprecedented threats, Jabbara leads a payment scam disruption team focused on understanding criminal methodologies. From a small room called the Risk Operations Center in Virginia, employees analyze data streams on multiple screens, searching for patterns that distinguish fraudulent activity from legitimate credit card use. In the larger Cyber Fusion Center, staff monitor potential cyberattacks targeting Visa's own infrastructure around the clock. "We deal with millions of attacks across different parts of our network," Jabbara noted, emphasizing that most are handled automatically without human intervention. Visa maintains identical facilities in London and Singapore, ensuring 24-hour global vigilance.
Zawya
an hour ago
- Zawya
GCC wealth management landscape is shifting to address investor concerns around agility and technology
Trust in AI is on the rise with 71% of investors expecting wealth managers to incorporate AI into their product offerings Investors in the region are actively engaging with advisors and have higher expectations around investment performance and product access Dubai, UAE – According to the 2025 EY Global Wealth Research Report, the GCC wealth management landscape is undergoing a profound transformation, shaped by shifting client expectations and technological disruption. Investor behavior in the region reflects greater engagement with advisors, increased openness to switching providers, and heightened expectations around investment performance and product access. Nearly 55% of GCC clients reported arranging more advisor meetings in response to market volatility, well above the global average. The importance of understanding how financial activities impact the client's financial health is nearly as important as portfolio allocation, indicating that investors now expect advisors to deliver holistic wealth management. At the same time, multihoming is rising rapidly, with 36% of investors in the region expecting to increase their number of wealth management relationships, and nearly 50% expressing interest in working with more providers, pointing to a growing fragmentation of trust and loyalty. In parallel, clients are showing a strong preference for alternative investments, with 69% already allocating assets to these vehicles. Mayur Pau, EY MENA Financial Services Leader, says: 'The EY Global Wealth Research Report shows that longstanding assumptions in wealth management are being disrupted by accelerating economic shifts and rapid technological change. This is heightening the urgency for wealth managers to offer more clarity, agility, and proactive guidance in an environment defined by uncertainty. Clients also expect greater depth and breadth of the product shelf than ever. Wealth management firms must be prepared to understand the drivers of satisfaction and ensure they are optimized independently of prevailing market conditions.' GCC investors feel satisfied with the services provided by their primary wealth manager across all key dimensions, but they still see the task of managing their wealth becoming more intricate. Only 57% of the region's respondents have reached the 'high bar' of being well-prepared to meet their financial goals, which must be the target for all advised clients. Rising expectations for AI integration In the GCC, 13% of clients express a high level of trust in artificial intelligence (AI), showcasing their openness to AI-powered solutions. This figure is notably higher than in more mature markets, like North America (6%) and Europe (9%), and it is also competitive with Latin America (16%) and Asia Pacific (15%). Wealth managers in the region must leverage this trust to meet the evolving expectations of their tech-savvy client base. The GCC is among the most enthusiastic regions globally when it comes to AI, with 71% of investors expecting wealth managers to incorporate AI into their product offerings. This number is even higher among mass affluents. On the other hand, clients are increasingly aware of the potential risks associated with AI, including data misuse and the accuracy of AI-driven insights. To build trust, wealth managers must actively educate clients about AI's capabilities and the safeguards in place to protect their information. This includes communicating the ethical principles guiding AI use, ensuring compliance with regulations and demonstrating how AI can enhance – rather than replace – the human element of wealth management. Clients seek less common fee arrangements GCC investors are more cautious and proactive, emphasizing transparency, cost clarity and tailored offerings. While percentage-based fees on assets under management (AUM) are unpopular globally (15%), they remain relatively more accepted in the GCC (27%), with performance-based fees, fixed fees, subscription fees and combinations of fee structures losing popularity. These findings show that industry pricing mechanisms are out of step with client preferences, revealing an underlying opportunity for pricing optimization. Concerns around hidden costs have decreased in the last few years, with firms making progress in improving fee transparency. Over 90% of clients in the region strongly believe they are being charged fairly for services rendered. GCC clients cite better investment performance and returns (55%) and access to a wider array of investment products and services (53%) as their top two drivers to switch wealth management providers. Only 26% would opt for a different provider due to seeking lower fees for services. Hamdan Khan, Partner, EY MENA Wealth and Asset Management, says: 'With investors increasingly expecting AI-powered solutions and holistic wealth management approaches, firms must act swiftly to align their strategies with these evolving demands. By investing in AI technologies, enhancing client engagement and prioritizing ethical data practices, wealth managers can position themselves for success in a rapidly changing landscape. The future of wealth management is not just about managing assets; it's about building relationships, fostering trust and leveraging technology to create exceptional client experiences.' The biennial EY Global Wealth Research Report aims to help wealth managers align strategic priorities with deep, data-driven insights into client behavior, preferences and expectations. It also identifies clear trends in managing provider relationships, reallocating capital, and planning for intergenerational wealth transfer. For more information on the report and its findings, please visit: management-research -Ends- About EY | Building a better working world EY is building a better working world by creating new value for clients, people, society and the planet, while building trust in capital markets. Enabled by data, AI and advanced technology, EY teams help clients shape the future with confidence and develop answers for the most pressing issues of today and tomorrow. EY teams work across a full spectrum of services in assurance, consulting, tax, strategy and transactions. Fuelled by sector insights, a globally connected, multidisciplinary network and diverse ecosystem partners, EY teams can provide services in more than 150 countries and territories. All in to shape the future with confidence. EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients. Information about how EY collects and uses personal data and a description of the rights individuals have under data protection legislation are available via EY member firms do not practice law where prohibited by local laws. For more information about our organization, please visit The MENA practice of EY has been operating in the region since 1923. Over the past 100 years, we have grown to over 8,500 people united across 27 offices and 14 countries, sharing the same values and an unwavering commitment to quality. As an organization, we continue to develop outstanding leaders who deliver exceptional services to our clients and who contribute to our communities. We are proud of our accomplishments over the years, reaffirming our position as the largest and most established professional services organization in the region. © 2025 EYGM Limited. All Rights Reserved. ED None This material has been prepared for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be relied upon as accounting, tax, legal or other professional advice. Please refer to your advisors for specific advice.
Zawya
an hour ago
- Zawya
HCLSoftware launches sovereign AI aimed at Governments and Regulated Organizations concerned with their data privacy
NOIDA, India, HCLSoftware, a global leader in enterprise software solutions, announced today the launch of HCL Domino 14.5. Specifically targeting governments and regulated organizations concerned with their data privacy, HCL Domino 14.5 ushers in significant enhancements to the Domino+ sovereign collaboration portfolio, including the introduction of Domino IQ, a sovereign AI extension to the Domino platform that protects an organization's data privacy and ensures information security. Users of the HCL Domino platform leverage powerful AI to automate tasks, analyze data, and more, by choosing the models that their organization or trusted sources have built. With compliance measures such as the European AI Act aimed at shaping the development and use of artificial intelligence within the EU, Domino IQ enables organizations to have more fine-grained control over AI investments and, additionally, remove their reliance on foreign cloud-based services. 'In an uncertain geopolitical landscape, governments and regulated organizations, such as private banks, are increasingly concerned about their data sovereignty and digital independence', said Richard Jefts, Executive Vice President and General Manager, HCLSoftware. 'The importance of data sovereignty and avoiding unnecessary foreign government influence extends beyond SaaS solutions and AI. Specifically for collaboration - the sensitive data within email, chat, video recordings and documents. With the launch of Domino+ 14.5, HCLSoftware is helping over 200+ government agencies safeguard their sensitive data.' "Today more than ever, true digital sovereignty is the key to Europe's digital future. That's why at IONOS we are proud to provide the sovereign cloud infrastructure for HCL's sovereign collaboration solutions. Our platform is powerful, secure, and – above all – free from foreign access. Together, we are setting an example for responsible innovation and digital self-determination, a key factor for companies and institutions in regulated industries with particularly sensitive requirements," said Achim Weiss, CEO of IONOS, the leading European hosting provider and trusted cloud enabler. Other key capabilities of this Domino+ launch include: BSI certification of Information Security and use of Security Event and Incident Management (SEIM) tools. Compliance with the European Accessibility Act for web-based, business user experiences. Ready to deploy, and enhanced sovereign chat and meetings solutions. About HCLSoftware HCLSoftware is a global leader in software innovation and the software division of HCLTech. We develop, market, sell, and support transformative solutions across various industries, including business and industry, intelligent operations, total experience, data and analytics, and cybersecurity. Our commitment to customer success and our core values of integrity, inclusion, value creation, people-centricity, and social responsibility drive us to deliver best-in-class software products that empower organizations to achieve their goals. With a rich heritage of pioneering spirit, HCLSoftware serves more than 20,000 organizations, including a majority of the Fortune 100 and almost half of the Fortune 500. Learn more about how we can help you achieve your goals. Media Contacts: Jeremy McNeive Animesh Biswas
