Majority on Brazil court in favor of tougher social media rules
The South American country's highest court is seeking to determine to what extent companies such as X, TikTok, Instagram and Facebook are responsible for removing illegal content, and how they can be sanctioned if they do not.
The judges' final ruling will create a precedent that will affect tens of millions of social media users in Brazil.
At issue is a clause in the country's so-called Civil Framework for the Internet, a law in effect since 2014, that says platforms are only responsible for harm caused by a post if they ignore a judge's order to remove it.
By Wednesday, six of the court's 11 judges had ruled in favor of higher accountability, meaning sites should monitor content and remove problematic posts on their own initiative, without court intervention.
One judge has voted against tougher regulation, and three have yet to express an opinion.
Alexandre de Moraes, one of 11 judges of the court, has repeatedly clashed with X owner Elon Musk and various right-wing personalities over social media posts.
The review is taking place in parallel with the Supreme Court trial of far-right former president Jair Bolsonaro, who is alleged to have collaborated on a coup plot to remain in power after his 2022 election defeat.
Prosecutors say Bolsonaro's followers used social media to lie about the reliability of the electoral system and plot the downfall of successor Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.
Last year, Moraes blocked X for 40 days for failing to comply with a series of court orders against online disinformation.
He had previously ordered X to suspend the accounts of several Bolsonaro supporters.
Musk and other critics say Moraes is stifling free speech, and US President Donald Trump's administration is weighing sanctions against the judge, whom Bolsonaro accuses of judicial "persecution."
Lula, who emerged the victor in a tightly-fought election against Bolsonaro in 2022, is advocating for "accelerating regulation" of online platforms.
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
5 hours ago
- France 24
AI-powered disinformation spreads online amid Los Angeles protests
Since June 6, Los Angeles has been rocked by protests and clashes with law enforcement, after more than 40 migrants were arrested downtown by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). The events have escalated into a confrontation between Donald Trump and the California leaders after the US President deployed National Guard troops against protestors on June 7, overriding the objections of California Governor Gavin Newsom. In this context, several internet users have circulated misleading or erroneous content using artificial intelligence tools. AI-generated selfie video of National Guard soldier On June 9, an alleged National Guard soldier, who identified himself as Bob, posted a selfie video on TikTok that garnered more than 770,000 views. The 'soldier' is seen smiling and offering a 'behind-the-scenes' look at troops preparing for deployment to 'gas' protesters. The second scene of the video features 'Bob' during the clashes, decrying the throwing of 'oil-filled balloons' at law enforcement. It turns out that the video is fake. There are several indications that it was generated using artificial intelligence. For instance, in the video's first scene, one of the badges that should display the soldier's rank shows nonsensical characters. AI still struggles with creating coherent text. Another inconsistency is a strangely placed traffic light on the left side of the image, which is partially obscuring another traffic light. We found another anomaly in the video's second scene. A police car displays an incorrect acronym, LAPC. The Los Angeles Police Department's actual acronym is LAPD. The TikTok account that posted the video, 'maybenotquitereal', is a parody. Its bio states that the user produces "satirical" content. However, this disclaimer isn't visible in the video featuring the supposed National Guard soldier. As seen in the comments, many users believe the video is genuine. Some urge "Bob" to "stay safe" and thank him for 'protecting the country', while another pro-protester online user criticises him for "hurting the citizens" he was supposed to "protect". Did California's Governor share fake National Guard photos? An AI fact-check error On June 9, California Governor Gavin Newsom posted photos on social media showing National Guard soldiers seemingly asleep on the ground. "You sent your troops here without fuel, food, water or a place to sleep. Here they are — being forced to sleep on the floor, piled on top of one another. If anyone is treating our troops disrespectfully, it is you, Donald Trump,' Newsom wrote. However, a user quickly challenged Newsom's claim in the comments, asking, "Why are you posting fake news?" The user backed up this assertion with a screenshot of an image verification performed by ChatGPT. According to the AI, the photograph was taken on August 19, 2021, at Hamid Karzai Airport in Kabul, Afghanistan, during the fall of the Afghan capital to the Taliban. The image was reportedly part of a series titled "Afghanistan Evacuation [Image 1 of 3]," published on Dvids, a US military image bank. As explained by BBC Verify journalist Shayan Sardarizadeh, ChatGPT's analysis is inaccurate. A reverse image search (here's how to do one) traces the origin of the images to an exclusive publication by a local media, the San Francisco Chronicle, on June 9, 2025. No instances of these photos appear on Google before this date. Furthermore, our team conducted a search on the Dvids website, where ChatGPT claimed the photos come from, using the AI's suggested title, "Afghanistan Evacuation [Image 1 of 3]." The search yields photographs unrelated to those published by Gavin Newsom. The reliability of image origin verification by chatbots like ChatGPT and Grok varies significantly. Search results from these AI can change depending on when the query is made, as demonstrated by a recent X thread where several users asked Elon Musk's Grok AI to identify the source of the photos. In an analysis initiated on June 9 at 22:55, Grok determined that photographs shared by Gavin Newsom were taken in Kabul on August 19, 2021, just like ChatGPT. In this analysis, the chatbot even deemed the use of these photos in 2025 to criticise the troop situation in Los Angeles as "misleading". However, the same analysis performed at midnight on June 10 yielded a different outcome. While Grok still suggested the photo was taken in Afghanistan in 2021, it no longer entirely ruled out the possibility that it could date from 2025. Finally, an analysis run on June 10 at 5:23 provided the correct result, attributing the photograph's origin to the San Francisco Chronicle. A search conducted by our team in English on ChatGPT on June 10 at 17:46 also yielded an accurate result, crediting the San Francisco Chronicle as the source of the photographs.
France 24
9 hours ago
- France 24
Fourth policeman killed in clashes with Morales backers in Bolivia
Supporters of Morales, who led the Andean country from 2006 to 2019, began blocking key roads on June 2 over electoral authorities' refusal to allow him to run for a fourth term in August 17 elections. The protests have since snowballed into a wider revolt over President Luis Arce's handling of a deep economic crisis, marked by severe shortages of hard currency and fuel. On Wednesday, three officers deployed to clear a roadblock in Llallagua, a mining town in the country's southwest, were shot dead in violent clashes with protesters, police said. On Thursday, Justice Minister Cesar Siles said a fourth officer, Cristan Calle Alcon, died. Deputy Interior Minister Jhonny Aguilera said Alcon had been "taken hostage by a horde" and was killed by "the use of dynamite" on his person -- apparently a device taped to his chest. Aguilera announced the military will be sent to Llallagua to "guarantee a state of calm and of peace." Several dozen people have been reported injured in clashes in the town since Tuesday. Other officers were also hurt Wednesday trying to clear roadblocks elsewhere in the country, including on the road connecting La Paz with Cochabamba, Morales' political stronghold. Bolivia's roads authority said there were 19 roadblocks left countrywide on Thursday. Morales, 65, has been barred by the Constitutional Court from seeking re-election but nevertheless attempted, in vain, to register as a candidate last month. The government accuses him of trying to sabotage the election by calling for blockades to sow chaos. The protesters' goal "is to encircle La Paz to force it into submission through hunger," President Arce said Wednesday as he announced a joint police and military operation against the blockades. On Monday, the attorney general said Morales was under investigation for "terrorism" for allegedly inciting the protests. Bolivia's first Indigenous president has been holed up in his central stronghold in the Cochabamba department since October to avoid arrest on charges of trafficking a minor. The charges relate to Morales's alleged sexual relationship with a 15-year-old with whom he is accused of fathering a child while in office. He denies the charges. Morales retains a large following in the South American country, particularly among Indigenous communities.
AFP
12 hours ago
- AFP
Posts falsely claim Namibia has announced ban on US gas and oil exploration
'Namibia cancelled contract with US from Mining their OIL & GAS,' reads an X post published on May 30, 2025. With more than 16,000 likes, the post adds: 'They ended the Oil & Gas contract with the US and told the US Government to immediately stop all Mining Operations in Namibia as Namibia ventures into State-owned mining operations.' Image Screenshot of the false X post, published on May 28, 2025 The post includes side-by-side photos of Namibia's President Netumbo Nandi-Ndaitwah and US President Donald Trump. Similar posts were shared thousands of times more on X and other platforms, including Facebook, TikTok and blogs. Nandi-Ndaitwah, who was elected in March, placed the country's oil and gas industries under direct presidential control the day after her inauguration. They previously fell under the Ministry of Energy and Mines (archived here). However, the government has not announced the cancellation of any energy contracts with the United States. No announcements A keyword search for 'Namibia cancels oil and gas with the US' turned up more posts repeating the false claim, as well as articles debunking it (archived here). The posts began circulating at about the same time as claims debunked by AFP Fact Check alleging that Namibia had announced the deportation of 500 Americans. As reported by AFP in April, Nandi-Ndatiwah explained that the oil and gas sector had the potential to transform Namibia's economy within the next five years by securing energy supplies and creating jobs (archived here). 'Mining contributes 12 percent to our gross domestic product and over 50 percent of our foreign exchange earnings. Regrettably, this figure does not reflect the true potential of mining and our mineral resources,' she was quoted as saying. On May 30, 2025, her presidency responded to the viral posts by labelling them 'fake news' (archived here). Namibia's presidency reiterated this to AFP Fact Check on June 4, 2025. 'The Namibian government has not at any point cancelled any contracts with investors from the United States in the mining, oil and gas sectors,' said press secretary Alfredo Hengari. He added that 'it is not the policy of the government to cancel contracts that are binding'. A US State Department spokesperson told AFP Fact Check on June 11, 2025: 'The online claims that Namibia has cut off the United States from mining and gas are false.' Foreign investment Contrary to the claim, Namibia has become a global exploration hotspot with several international gas and oil companies actively exploring its coasts in recent years (archived here). At the start of 2025, American firm Chevron announced that it had not found commercially viable gas in Namibia's Orange Basin By April, however, the company confirmed it would continue exploration in the Walvis Basin in 2026 or 2027, where firms including TotalEnergies, Shell, and Galp have made discoveries. Similarly, British multinational Shell deemed its Namibia oil discoveries uncommercial due to high gas levels in January. However, France's TotalEnergies believes it can handle these geological challenges, but its investment decision hinges on maintaining production costs below $20 per barrel (archived here). Another American corporation, ExxonMobil, is investigating (here and here) the country's potential in the Namibe Basin (archived here and here). The state itself, through the National Petroleum Corporation of Namibia (NAMCOR), holds a 10 percent stake in its exploration partnership with TotalEnergies (50.5 percent), QatarEnergy (30 percent) and Impact Oil and Gas (9.5 percent) (archived here). As a top uranium producer, Namibia also announced in April 2025 that it will launch talks this year on its first nuclear energy plant, seeking to exploit its rich natural wealth to transform its economy (archived here).
