What Trump's Department of Education Closure Could Mean for Student Broadband Access
There's a stark disconnect between our era of internet connectivity and a looming sense of detachment, separation and seclusion for some students in K-12 schools.
On March 20, President Donald Trump signed an executive order to close the US Department of Education and return education oversight to state and local communities. A signed executive order will not lead to an immediate shutdown unless Congress approves. However, with this executive order in motion, it's only a matter of time before it sets the stage for a potential homework gap worse than we experienced during the pandemic.
For decades, the US Department of Education was seen as a cornerstone for promoting educational resources and opportunities for students nationwide. However, the executive order to dismantle the department could change that. Eliminating the department will likely have a negative impact on student broadband access.
The department is responsible for distributing federal funds that schools can use for broadband programs. Without it, there would be no large oversight on how these funds can be used to bridge the broadband gap for students. Broadband access is critical for students to succeed in school and beyond.
Lack of internet access can pose challenges when completing schoolwork, staying connected with friends and overall interest in school activities. According to Pew Research Center Data from 2018, around 17% of children nationwide could not complete their homework due to limited internet access. Another study in 2020 showed that 50% of low-income families and 42% of families of color complained about lacking the technology required for online learning.
On March 19, I visited the Renaissance at Rand Middle School in Montclair, New Jersey, a magnet school with over 213 students from grades six through eight.
I spoke with eight students, ages 11 to 13. When asked about their home internet, two of the eight students said they've had issues in the past due to storm-related power outages. Almost all of the students discussed using their home internet for schoolwork and leisure activities such as streaming, online gaming and scrolling on social media.
"There are definitely a lot of resources on the internet that can help me finish my work. If I don't understand a math problem, I can just look it up, or if I need to study, I can just create a quizlet," Jacob, a 13-year-old eighth grader, said.
Most students discussed relying on their home internet to complete weekly assignments through online learning platforms such as ALEKS and IXL.
Established in 1979, the Department of Education wears many hats, from overseeing the federal student loan process to monitoring educational progress through the nation's report card. But one thing that's often overlooked about this department is its importance in keeping students connected to the internet.
In addition to advocating for education and collecting data on the nation's schools, the Department of Education administers federal student loans to more than 46.2 million borrowers nationwide.
When it comes to public school funding, the department is partially responsible for sending money to public schools through funding from state and federal governments, according to NPR. Federal funding only accounts for 6% to 13% of the total, with state and other funds making up the difference, according to a 2018 report from the US Government Accountability Office. Public schools can allocate some of this funding toward installing Wi-Fi internet hotspots in schools or working with libraries to make hotspots available for patrons.
The Department of Education's role isn't to raise funds but to funnel them to where they're needed. It's worth noting that while the department administers several programs established by federal agencies, these programs are not explicitly established to support broadband access in schools. Still, they can help school districts and higher education institutions. Title I, Part A funds, for example, can support broadband access in K-12 schools.
Several other department-led program funds that may be used for broadband access in schools are:
The English Language Acquisition State Grants: The Office of English Language Acquisition established this to help children learn English and meet the state's academic achievement standards.
The Governor's Emergency Education Relief Fund (GEER Fund): The Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act allotted almost $3 billion to the Education Stabilization Fund.
Grants to States for Education of Children With Disabilities: This program provides grants to all 50 states to help with special education costs for children with disabilities.
The Rural, Low-Income School Program: According to a 2022 study published by the Quello Center at Michigan State University, over 93% of rural students in Michigan had no access to home internet or could go online on a smartphone. Rural Americans face many obstacles regarding broadband access, including limited broadband provider options and higher service costs. This program offers financial assistance to small rural local educational agencies or LEAs.
The Native American-Serving Nontribal Institutions Program: This program provides grants to eligible higher education institutions to expand their capacity to serve Native American and low-income students.
Strengthening Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs): Over 82% of HBCUs are in a broadband desert or an area severely lacking broadband. This program provides financial assistance to HBCUs to improve their financial management and academic resources.
Check out the National Telecommunications and Information Administration's funding guide to learn more about what other federal funds the Department of Education oversees.
Without the Department of Education, there would be no way to route funding to schools and educational institutions, which would stall bureaucratic processes. As of today, no person or agency is slated to replace the work the department was doing for students.
Long after the pandemic forced kids to attend class via Zoom or Microsoft Teams, some schools have integrated a hybrid and/or online learning curriculum for students. Providing broadband access for these students is just part of their need for high-speed internet connectivity.
Nahum Prasarn teaches technology at the Renaissance at Rand Middle School and highlights the importance of broadband accessibility for his students.
"When I started teaching technology, it was getting the kids used to keyboarding and understanding how word processing works. Then it became making sure they understood that we have Google Suite, Google Classroom and emailing," he said.
Prasarn has taught at the school for 20 years and is the only technology teacher. He describes how today's children can continue learning outside school by accessing online platforms at home.
"They'll reach out to me through Google Classroom and I will try to answer their questions as soon as they send it to me."
"Everyone's time for learning is different. It could be the only time they can sit down and do their work," Prasarn said.
To succeed academically and beyond, kids in today's classrooms need to develop digital skills, from research to social interaction. Slow internet can hinder growth, so having broadband access is a prerequisite to developing these skills, which roughly fall into two categories: basic internet literacy and social media comprehension. The more developed these skills are, the greater the likelihood of a student excelling in school and pursuing a higher education and even STEM-related careers.
Johannes Bauer, the FCC's former chief economist, and his colleagues at Michigan State University surveyed students in rural communities in Michigan to explore student digital skills. One study, Broadband and Student Performance Gaps (PDF), highlighted the critical nature of developing digital skills. Bauer's colleague Keith Hampton, a professor at Michigan State shared that broadband access in schools is not enough; there also needs to be an adequate broadband connection in the home. A lack of digital skills can hamper student outcomes.
Hampton emphasizes that most kids don't develop these skills at school because they find digital activities rudimentary.
"You know, fooling around online at home, leisure play, games and social media. That's where digital skills primarily come from," Hampton said.
Online learning at home can also support a child's exploration of STEM-related topics.
When asked about the interest in STEM among these children, Hampton says, "The more interested you become in STEM, the more opportunities you have to mess with STEM-related topics."
Kelly Weatherby, a school psychologist at a K-8 school in Syracuse with a decade of experience in education program management, recommends that children stay away from social media until at least the eighth grade, with many studies pointing to the detrimental impact long-term social media use can have on children. However, when it comes to online learning platforms at home, she believes that improving broadband access can promote student online learning, mainly to cater to children's individual needs that aren't being met in the classroom.
"If parents, for example, aren't sure how to teach common core math, you can set your kid on an online learning platform that is adjusting to the programming of your child," Weatherby said. "It will be responsive to a child's performance, so it will be adaptive, making them start at any given level… depending on how the child performs."
A 2021 study from Bauer, Hampton and their other colleagues at Michigan State, found that rural students with broadband access were more likely to complete homework and show greater interest in school, resulting in better academic performance. Conversely, students who have no access to the internet, have slow internet or only have access to a mobile phone can experience homework incompletion and overall disinterest in school, ultimately affecting GPA and SAT performance, a phenomenon known as the homework gap.
The Montclair school district provides free Wi-Fi to students and families that need it.
"When you have students that have spotty internet at home or a student with internet at one home and not the other, there's definitely a difference in productivity," Prasarn said.
With the new administration, there has been a lot of noise surrounding the future of broadband access for the country. With the Affordable Connectivity Program" target="_self gone, there is a looming concern about booting another FCC program that assists schools in connecting to high-speed internet" target="_self.
A Supreme Court hearing took place in late March, centered around a challenge to the lawfulness of the FCC's Universal Service Fund, an $8 billion per year broadband subsidy program that funds initiatives like the E-Rate program. The Supreme Court is hesitant to eliminate the program. However, further deliberation is expected, and a final decision will be reached by late June. This program provides eligible schools and libraries with affordable telecommunication services and free Wi-Fi hotspots. The future of the E-Rate program remains uncertain.
In December 2024, Bauer ended his tenure as the FCC's chief economist. He stressed the importance of establishing a bipartisan, pragmatic and workable approach independent of political orientation, which he described as one of the FCC's key strengths as an agency.
When addressing the broadband gap, the FCC "doesn't require a Republican or Democratic solution; they just require a solution that serves the public interest," Bauer said.
Comparatively, the Biden administration focused on policy intervention to close the gap. However, the new Trump administration could lean toward market forces to close the broadband gap, though beyond pushing for more BEAD funding to go to satellite internet networks like SpaceX's Starlink, we've yet to see much from the White House or the new FCC agenda to suggest how it will handle this issue.
Bauer says we can learn a lot from what led to the demise of the Affordable Connectivity Program. His main criticism was that too many agencies were involved, making the bureaucratic process more complicated.
"There were too many turf wars between those agencies. And we can only speculate that the joint effect of all these fragmented programs is less effective than if we were to see some more orchestrated effort," Bauer said.
But even without a sizable federal agency's oversight and no alternative federal department assigned to assume responsibility in the Department of Education's place, there is a light at the end of the tunnel: State legislatures are stepping up to try to secure federal funding themselves in efforts to close the broadband gap.
For example, in New York, where I'm based, ConnectAll's New York State Digital Equity Plan received over $2.2 million in funding in 2023 from the Digital Equity Act, a subset of the $90 billion in connectivity funding portioned from the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act to expand its digital equity strategy throughout the state.
A spokesperson from ConnectAll tells CNET that federal and state funding supports ConnectAll's initiatives, including the New York State Digital Equity Plan.
"Due to federal restrictions, public schools are not eligible for Digital Equity funding. However, nonprofits -- including nonprofit schools -- can apply for funding to support broadband access and digital inclusion efforts," the spokesperson said.
Until another department replaces the Department of Education, state legislatures can come together to provision and determine funding opportunities for broadband for students.
"Some states may be able to use state-level funds to close those gaps. The awareness is certainly there," Bauer said.
This was especially the case during the COVID-19 pandemic, which forced many schools to adopt a remote learning setting. State legislatures and other stakeholders mobilized funding to expand broadband access programs for students.
New York State Senator and chair of the Internet and Technology Committee Kristen Gonzalez tells CNET she has plans to expand broadband and digital equity initiatives, including ConnectAll, throughout the state.
"It's more than just providing the basics. We want to ensure that schools have the resources they need to create lasting sustainable tech programs -- because access to technology isn't a luxury, it's a right," Gonzalez said.
A 2020 survey published by the New York State Education Department revealed that 11% to 13% of New York City students in each borough lack sufficient internet access at home. The New York City Council supports this by claiming that inadequate broadband access is seen across the boroughs, with over 74% of all students in New York City" target="_self attending schools in Brooklyn" target="_self, Queens" target="_self and the Bronx" target="_self facing issues around broadband access.
Regarding expanding broadband initiatives, Gonzalez is working to implement the Affordable Broadband Act (ABA) to bring high-speed internet to underserved areas, including low-income households.
She is also cosponsoring the S3443 Bill, which would require broadband providers to offer high-speed service to low-income consumers for a maximum of $5 a month.
Without home internet access, more students feeling isolated and separated from their peers could become the new norm.
"A lot of our after-school clubs involve the internet and going on our Chromebooks to research stuff. So, without that, you won't really be a part of it," Mary, a 13-year-old seventh grader, said.
Stella, a 13-year-old eighth grader, is the president of the student council. She discussed the importance of having Wi-Fi at home.
"We have a group chat, and a lot of information goes out there. Whether we're gonna have a meeting and who we need to do what. If people don't have Wi-Fi, it's a lot harder for them to be involved," she said.
Students could enter a new era with the Department of Education in the rearview mirror. With a signed executive order in motion, it's only a matter of time until the department is officially no more. As the Trump administration figures out a different solution to apportioning federal funding to help get students online, any time without the federal funding programs overseen by the Department of Education could lead to more students facing poor or no internet access.
Students will suffer the consequences until the Trump administration offers effective and simple solutions for closing the broadband gap. It could be up to state legislatures and local communities to shoulder the burden of advocating for broadband access for every student in America.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump aides want Texas to redraw its congressional maps to boost the GOP. What would that mean?
This coverage is made possible through Votebeat, a nonpartisan news organization covering local election administration and voting access. Sign up for Votebeat Texas' free newsletters here. Republicans representing Texas in Congress are considering this week whether to push their state Legislature to take the unusual step of redrawing district lines to shore up the GOP's advantage in the U.S. House. But the contours of the plan, including whether Gov. Greg Abbott would call a special session of the Legislature to redraw the maps, remain largely uncertain. The idea is being driven by President Donald Trump's political advisers, who want to draw up new maps that would give Republicans a better chance to flip seats currently held by Democrats, according to two GOP congressional aides familiar with the matter. That proposal, which would involve shifting GOP voters from safely red districts into neighboring blue ones, is aimed at safeguarding Republicans' thin majority in Congress, where they control the lower chamber, 220-212. The redistricting proposal, and the Trump team's role in pushing it, was first reported by The New York Times Monday. Without a Republican majority in Congress, Trump's legislative agenda would likely stall, and the president could face investigations from newly empowered Democratic committee chairs intent on scrutinizing the White House. Here's what we know about the plan so far: On Capitol Hill, members of the Texas GOP delegation huddled Monday night to discuss the prospect of reshaping their districts. Most of the 25-member group expressed reluctance about the idea, citing concerns about jeopardizing their districts in next year's midterms if the new maps overextended the GOP's advantage, according to the two GOP aides, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss the private deliberations. Rep. Jodey Arrington, R-Lubbock, was skeptical of the idea. 'We just recently worked on the new maps,' Arrington told The Texas Tribune. To reopen the process, he said, 'there'd have to be a significant benefit to our state.' The delegation has yet to be presented with mockups of new maps, two aides said. Each state's political maps must be redrawn once a decade, after each round of the U.S. census, to account for population growth and ensure every congressional and legislative district has roughly the same number of people. Texas lawmakers last overhauled their district lines in 2021. There's no federal law that prohibits states from redrawing district maps midcycle, said Justin Levitt, an election law professor at Loyola Marymount University and a former deputy assistant attorney general in the Department of Justice's civil rights division. Laws around the timing to redraw congressional and state district maps vary by state. In Texas, the state constitution doesn't specify timing, so the redrawing of maps is left to the discretion of the governor and the Legislature. Lawmakers gaveled out of their 140-day regular session last week, meaning they would need to be called back for a special session to change the state's political maps. Abbott has the sole authority to order overtime sessions and decide what lawmakers are allowed to consider. A trial is underway in El Paso in a long-running challenge to the state legislative and congressional district maps Texas drew after the 2020 U.S. Census. If Texas redraws its congressional maps, state officials would then ask the court to toss the claims challenging those districts 'that no longer exist,' Levitt said. The portion of the case over the state legislative district maps would continue. If the judge agrees, then both parties would have to file new legal claims for the updated maps. It isn't clear how much maps could change, but voters could find themselves in new districts, and Levitt said redrawing the lines in the middle of the redistricting cycle is a bad idea. 'If the people of Texas think that their representatives have done a bad job, then when the [district] lines change, they're not voting on those representatives anymore,' Levitt said. 'New people are voting on those representatives.' The National Democratic Redistricting Committee, Democrats' national arm for contesting state GOP mapmaking, said the proposal to expand Republicans' stronghold in Texas was 'yet another example of Trump trying to suppress votes in order to hold onto power.' 'Texas's congressional map is already being sued for violating the Voting Rights Act because it diminishes the voting power of the state's fast-growing Latino population,' John Bisognano, president of the NDRC said. 'To draw an even more extreme gerrymander would only assure that the barrage of legal challenges against Texas will continue.' When Republicans in charge of the Legislature redrew the district lines after the 2020 census, they focused on reinforcing their political support in districts already controlled by the GOP. This redistricting proposal would likely take a different approach. As things stand, Republicans hold 25 of the state's 38 congressional seats. Democrats hold 12 seats and are expected to regain control of Texas' one vacant seat in a special election this fall. Most of Texas' GOP-controlled districts lean heavily Republican: In last year's election, 24 of those 25 seats were carried by a Republican victor who received at least 60% of the vote or ran unopposed. The exception was U.S. Rep. Monica De La Cruz, R-Edinburg, who captured 57% of the vote and won by a comfortable 14-point margin. With little competition to speak of, The Times reported, Trump's political advisers believe at least some of those districts could bear the loss of GOP voters who would be reshuffled into neighboring, Democratic-held districts — giving Republican hopefuls a better chance to flip those seats from blue to red. The party in control of the White House frequently loses seats during midterm cycles, and Trump's team is likely looking to offset potential GOP losses in other states and improve the odds of holding on to a narrow House majority. Incumbent Republicans, though, don't love the idea of sacrificing a comfortable race in a safe district for the possibility of picking up a few seats, according to GOP aides. In 2003, after Texas Republicans initially left it up to the courts to draw new lines following the 2000 census, then-U.S. House Majority Leader Tom DeLay, a Sugar Land Republican, embarked instead on a bold course of action to consolidate GOP power in the state. He, along with his Republican allies, redrew the lines as the opening salvo to a multistate redistricting plan aimed at accumulating power for his party in states across the country. Enraged by the power play, Democrats fled the state, depriving the Texas House of the quorum it needed to function. The rebels eventually relented under threat of arrest, a rare power in the Texas Constitution used to compel absent members back to return to Austin when the Legislature is in session. The lines were then redrawn, cementing the GOP majority the delegation has enjoyed in Washington for the past two decades. However, what's at play this time is different than in the early 2000s, when Republicans had a newfound majority in the Legislature and had a number of vulnerable Democratic incumbents they could pick off. Now, Republicans have been entrenched in the majority for decades and will have to answer the question of whether there's really more to gain, said Kareem Crayton, the vice president of the Brennan Center for Justice's Washington office. 'That's the tradeoff. You can do that too much so that you actually make them so competitive that the other side wins,' Crayton said. 'That's always a danger.' Texas Republicans are planning to reconvene Thursday to continue discussing the plan, according to Rep. Beth Van Duyne, R-Irving, and Rep. Wesley Hunt, R-Houston, who said they will attend the meeting. Members of Trump's political team are also expected to attend, according to Hunt and two GOP congressional aides familiar with the matter. Natalia Contreras is a reporter for Votebeat in partnership with the Texas Tribune. She's based in Corpus Christi. Contact Natalia at ncontreras@ Disclosure: New York Times has been a financial supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization that is funded in part by donations from members, foundations and corporate sponsors. Financial supporters play no role in the Tribune's journalism. Find a complete list of them here. Big news: 20 more speakers join the TribFest lineup! New additions include Margaret Spellings, former U.S. secretary of education and CEO of the Bipartisan Policy Center; Michael Curry, former presiding bishop and primate of The Episcopal Church; Beto O'Rourke, former U.S. Representative, D-El Paso; Joe Lonsdale, entrepreneur, founder and managing partner at 8VC; and Katie Phang, journalist and trial lawyer. Get tickets. TribFest 2025 is presented by JPMorganChase.
Yahoo
25 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Musk regrets some of his Trump criticisms, says they 'went too far'
Musk regrets some of his Trump criticisms, says they 'went too far' Elon Musk, the world's richest person and Donald Trump's former advisor, says he regretted some of his recent criticisms of the US president (Kevin Dietsch) (Kevin Dietsch/GETTY IMAGESvia AFP) Elon Musk, the world's richest person and Donald Trump's former advisor, said Wednesday he regretted some of his recent criticisms of the US president, after the pair's public falling-out last week. "I regret some of my posts about President @realDonaldTrump last week. They went too far," Musk wrote on his social media platform X, in a message that was received favorably by the White House. Musk's expression of regret came just days after Trump threatened the tech billionaire with "serious consequences" if he sought to punish Republicans who vote for a controversial spending bill. Their blistering break-up -- largely carried out on social media before a riveted public since Thursday last week -- was ignited by Musk's harsh criticism of Trump's so-called "big, beautiful" spending bill, which is currently before Congress. ADVERTISEMENT Some lawmakers who were against the bill had called on Musk -- one of the Republican Party's biggest financial backers in last year's presidential election -- to fund primary challenges against Republicans who voted for the legislation. "He'll have to pay very serious consequences if he does that," Trump, who also branded Musk "disrespectful," told NBC News on Saturday, without specifying what those consequences would be. Trump also said he had "no" desire to repair his relationship with the South African-born Tesla and SpaceX chief, and that he has "no intention of speaking to him." But after Musk's expression of regret, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters that Trump was "appreciative," adding that "no efforts" had been made on a threat by Trump to end some of Musk's government contracts. "The president acknowledged the statement that Elon put out this morning, and he is appreciative of it," Leavitt said. ADVERTISEMENT According to the New York Times, Musk's message followed a phone call to Trump late on Monday night. Vice President JD Vance and Chief of Staff Susan Wiles had also been working with Musk on how to broker a truce with Trump, the report said. - 'Wish him well' - In his post on Wednesday, Musk did not specify which of his criticisms of Trump had gone "too far." The former allies had seemed to have cut ties amicably about two weeks ago, with Trump giving Musk a glowing send-off as he left his cost-cutting role at the so-called Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). But their relationship cracked within days, with Musk describing the spending bill as an "abomination" that, if passed by Congress, could define Trump's second term in office. Trump hit back at Musk's comments in an Oval Office diatribe and from there the row detonated, leaving Washington stunned. ADVERTISEMENT Trump later said on his Truth Social platform that cutting billions of dollars in subsidies and contracts to Musk's companies would be the "easiest way" to save the US government money. US media have put the value of the contracts at $18 billion. With real political and economic risks to their falling out, both already appeared to inch back from the brink on Friday, with Trump telling reporters "I just wish him well," and Musk responding on X: "Likewise." Trump had spoken to NBC on Saturday after Musk deleted one of the explosive allegations he had made during their fallout, linking the president with disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein, who was accused of sex trafficking. bur-arp/aha


Fox News
26 minutes ago
- Fox News
Kim Kardashian says immigrants in LA suffering 'fear and injustice' thanks to Trump immigration plan
Despite working with President Donald Trump on issues in the past, Kim Kardashian indicated on Friday she does not support his administration's immigration policy. In a recent Instagram post, the reality TV star condemned operations conducted by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), calling them "inhumane." "When we're told that ICE exists to keep our country safe and remove violent criminals — great. But when we witness innocent, hardworking people being ripped from their families in inhumane ways, we have to speak up. We have to do what's right," she stated in an Instagram story Friday. The Los Angeles native shared the post as her hometown continues to be shaken by violent anti-ICE riots that started last week in response to the federal law enforcement agency detaining illegal immigrants. DHS said ICE raids in L.A. over the weekend resulted in "hundreds of illegal aliens [being] arrested by ICE officers and agents," including "many with a criminal history and criminal convictions." Protests and clashes outside multiple locations in downtown L.A. have grown so chaotic that Trump ordered National Guard troops into the city, followed by several hundred U.S. Marines, to restore order. Some California officials, including Gov. Gavin Newsom, have accused the administration of exacerbating the situation. Despite the attacks on cops and other law enforcement officials by rioters, Kardashian argued in her post that immigrants are dealing with "fear and injustice" at the hands of the federal government. She added, "Growing up in LA, I've seen how deeply immigrants are woven into the fabric of this city. They are our neighbors, friends, classmates, coworkers, and family. No matter where you fall politically, it's clear that our communities thrive because of the contributions of immigrants. We can't turn a blind eye when fear and injustice keep people from living their lives freely and safely." "There HAS to be a BETTER way," Kardashian declared, concluding her post. The celebrity followed that post by sharing a video of pop star Doechii bashing Trump and ICE while accepting the of best female hip hop artist award at the BET Awards on Monday night. During her acceptance speech, the musician stated, "There are ruthless attacks that are creating fear and chaos in our communities in the name of law and order," she said. "Trump is using military forces to stop a protest, and I want y'all to consider what kind of government it appears to be when every time we exercise our democratic right to protest, the military is deployed against us." Despite Kardashian's harsh stance on Trump's immigration agenda, she has had a constructive relationship with him in the past. In 2019, she appeared at the White House alongside Trump to promote his criminal justice reform policies, calling them "magic." By that point, Kardashian had been at the White House several times to discuss criminal justice reform issues and successfully lobbied President Trump to pardon Alice Marie Johnson, who was serving life without parole for drug offenses. The White House did not immediately reply to Fox News Digital's request for comment.