
Why we should give The Salt Path a wide berth
Read More:
So, yes, writers are allowed/encouraged to embellish, to take dramatic or comedic license because true life is often listless and boring. The task of the writer is to compress, condense, and distil, and sometimes add a little piquancy to entice the audience along in the journey.
But how far is the writer allowed to wander across the line of truth? Audiences are now asked to answer that question given the accusations surrounding The Salt Path, a 'true' story which emerged firstly as a 2m-selling bestselling book and now a movie starring Gillian Anderson and Jason Isaacs. It's a wonderful tale of self-discovery, of life affirmation and endeavour, which tracks the hiking journey made by Raynor Winn and her husband Moth's 630-mile traipse along the sea-swept South West Coast Path.
This heart breaking story of perseverance, of a couple in their early 50s forced out of their rural home in Wales and seeking solace in nature, was a powerful enough tale of devastated lives with disaster compounded by the diagnosis of Moth's terminal illness with a neurological condition.
Yet, it's been claimed that the protagonist's background story is as stinky as some of the dog dirt the couple picked up on the soles of their hiking boots.
Read More:
For starters, Raynor Winn and Moth are actually Sally and Tim Walker. Sally Walker's Salt Path story claimed the couple lost the family home after a business investment - in which she was helping out a friend, an act of altruism - turned to lead and the couple's savings were blitzed.
But an investigation by The Observer alleges that Sally Walker had worked as an estate agency bookkeeper from whom she embezzled £64,000. After police were involved, she disappeared, turned up in London and they borrowed money - £100,000 - from a distant relative, to pay back it. Their house was put up as collateral. And all calmed down, police didn't pursue charges - but the the relative's business went bust, and he called in the loan. To add to the dark underbelly of the tale, Moth's 'incurable' illness has also been called into question. And it transpires the 'homeless' couple actually owned land in France.
Yet, why let the truth get in the way of a good story? Walker/Winn turned to writing and made millions. And when asked about the embezzlement claims she recently released a carefully worded press statement; 'We are taking legal advice and won't be making any further comment at this time. The Salt Path lays bare the physical and spiritual journey Moth and I shared, an experience that transformed us completely and altered the course of our lives. This is the true story of our journey.' They also said the claims were 'highly misleading.'
the Salt Path poster (Image: PA)
Sure, part of the story is true. But can we truly wallow in their stories of human support and love and kindness while managing to push aside the backstory which has more holes than their cheap pup tent? In writing biographical tales the truth is a spectrum, but can we commit to a writer to whom facts are a stranger? Can a writer truly suggest insight into the human condition when they're so deeply flawed? Yes, Hitchcock did it continually, successfully. But he wasn't writing his own story.
Okay, we've got to allow for imagined or reimagined accounts. Next week at the Theatre Royal in Glasgow, The Last Laugh suggests a meeting between Eric Morecambe, Tommy Cooper and Bob Monkhouse, covering enough of the reality of their relationships to allow for a comedy springboard. Terry Johnson's play Cleo, Camping, Emmanuelle and Dick once allowed the writer to relive parts of the lives Sid James and Barbara Windsor. And West End hit The Motive and the Cue platformed a partly fictionalised expansion of the working experience between Burton and Gielgud. So we have to remember that while truth is often stranger than fiction it's not often quite as funny. (Roby Roy producer Peter Broughan was of the opinion a good biopic of an historical figure 'told lies to tell the truth'.)
And presenting a reformed reality can be a clever device which allows writers to hint at truths without having to sell the house and the BMW by way of libel reparation. And they allow for audiences to bring their own knowledge of the protagonists to the party.
But that doesn't mean we should accept a redacted, post-truth world 'reality' relayed to us by the sort of people we wouldn't leave alone in our house with our PIN numbers. The story may not be not life in actuality but didn't the Walkers present it as such?
So, give the book - and the film – as wide a berth as the Salt Path is long. And if you've already bought into both, write to the publishers and producers and ask for a full refund. At the very least truth should be a close approximation.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Metro
2 hours ago
- Metro
Trump 'told his name appears multiple times' in Epstein files'
President Donald Trump was reportedly told by his administration that his name appears in the Jeffrey Epstein files multiple times. US Attorney General Pam Bondi informed Trump in a White House meeting in May that his name is in the Justice Department documents on the late sex offender, senior administration officials told The Wall Street Journal on Wednesday. Trump learned that the 'files contained what officials felt was unverified hearsay about many people, including Trump, who had socialized with Epstein in the past', according to the report. 'Many other high-profile figures were also named.' The meeting, which included Bondi's deputy Todd Blanche, happened weeks before the Justice Department and FBI announced that 'no incriminating 'client list'' existed and that they would not be releasing the files they previously promised to disclose. An administration official quickly shot down the report. 'This is nothing more than a continuation of the fake news stories concocted by the Democrats and the liberal media,' said White House spokesman Steven Cheung in an email. Bondi and Blanche on Wednesday stated that 'nothing in the files warranted further investigation or prosecution, and we have filed a motion in court to unseal the underlying grand jury transcripts'. 'As part of our routine briefing, we made the President aware of the findings,' they said. When asked last week if Bondi told him his name appears in the Epstein files, Trump told an ABC News reporter: 'No, no.' He claimed that the files were 'made up by' former FBI Director James Comey and the Obama and Biden administrations. The Journal report comes a week after the newspaper published a story alleging that Trump sent Epstein a letter for his 50th birthday in 2003 with text framed by the outline of a naked woman, at the request of the disgraced financier's accomplice, Ghislaine Maxwell. Trump has vehemently denied penning the letter and on Friday filed a defamation lawsuit against The Journal, the two reporters who wrote the story, and the publisher. More Trending On Wednesday, the House Oversight Committee also ordered Maxwell, a convicted sex offender, to testify before them on August 11. Maxwell is expected to provide her deposition at the Federal Correctional Institution in Tallahassee, where she is serving a 20-year sentence her role in conspiring with Epstein to sexually abuse and exploit underage girls. 'While the department undertakes efforts to uncover and publicly disclose additional information related to your and Mr. Epstein's cases, it is imperative that Congress conduct oversight of the federal government's enforcement of sex trafficking laws generally and specifically its handling of the investigation and prosecution of you and Mr. Epstein,' states the cover letter of the subpoena to Maxwell. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Two women killed after rubber rings plunged down waterfall named MORE: Should we all be more boomer? Reader says boomers hold the most political sway MORE: Idaho killer locks gaze on victims' families as they face 'evil' in dock


Time Out
6 hours ago
- Time Out
Lollapalooza streets closures have kicked off for next week's fest—what Chicago drivers should know
The Windy City's biggest and arguably most fun summer music festival is nearly here, which means that street closures are already underway. Whether you're partaking in the fun at Lollapalooza's four-day festival, or you're just trying to get to work in the most efficient and quick way possible, here's what you need to know for the coming weeks. From Thursday, July 31 to Sunday, August 3, Grant Park will be the hub for all-things music…and crowds. Headliners, drawing loads of concertgoers, include Tyler, the Creator, Rüfüs Du Sol, Luke Combs, and Olivia Rodrigo. (And, yes, we're excited!) Of course, what this also means is that many downtown streets will close well ahead of the festival, making it difficult to get around if you don't plan ahead. The first thing you should know is that some streets have already began their closures to vehicular and pedestrian traffic—Balbo Drive from Columbus to DuSable Lake Shore Drive closed on July 16. More street closures are planned for the following dates and locales: July 22—August 9: Jackson, from Columbus to Dusable Lake Shore Drive July 28—August 4: Balbo, from Michigan to Columbus July 28—August 4: Jackson, from Michigan to Columbus July 28—August 4: Columbus, from Monroe to Roosevelt July 28—August 4: Columbus (Northbound), from 13 th Street to Roosevelt July 28—August 4: Congress Plaza Dr, from Michigan to Columbus July 30—August 4: Monroe, from Michigan to Dusable Lake Shore Drive Street closures are expected as well, including the following: July 29—August 3: Michigan, from Jackson to 11 th St. Bridge July 16—August 10: Balbo (both sides), from Columbus to DuSable Lake Shore Drive July 16—August 8: Columbus (Northbound side), from Roosevelt to Ida B Wells July 21—August 9: Columbus (Southbound side), from 9 th St. Yard to S. Ida B. Wells July 21—August 9: Jackson (both sides), from Coumbus to DuSable Lake Shore Drive July 23: DuSable Lake Shore Drive (Northbound side), from Monroe to Roosevelt July 19 and July 21—August 9: Monroe (Eastbound side), from Columbus to DuSable Lake Shore Drive July 26—August 9: DuSable Lake Shore Drive (Southbound side), from Monroe to Roosevelt July 28—August 4: Balbo (both sides), from Michigan to Columbus July 28—August 4: Jackson (both sides), from Michigan to Columbus July 28—August: Congress Plaza Dr, from Michigan to Columbus July 26—July 27: Congress Plaza Dr. (Westbound & Eastbound side), from Michigan to Columbus July 28—August 5: Columbus (both sides), from Monroe to Roosevelt Additional closures to know about: The Grant Park Dog Park will be closed from now through August 9. However, a temporary dog park will be available for your furry friends southeast of the skate park. The park's tennis and pickle ball courts will also close from July 27—August 5.


Metro
9 hours ago
- Metro
Classic film considered 'coolest of all time' is now streaming for free
Fans who are lovers of the best classic movies are in for a treat as a film considered one of the coolest ever made is now streaming for free. Starring iconic Hollywood actors Paul Newman and Robert Redford, 1969 flick Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid is currently available to watch at no cost on BBC iPlayer. The top-grossing film of its year, the Western buddy movie went on to be nominated for seven Oscars, including best picture and director, winning four. There is literally a Reddit thread titled 'Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid – coolest film ever?' where fans discussed its appeal, so don't take it just from me. Helmed by George Roy Hill (who also directed Newman and Redford in 1973's The Sting) and written by Academy Award winner William Goldman, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid follows the titular members of the outlaw Hole-in-the-Wall gang in 1899 Wyoming. They flee to Bolivia after a train robbery gone wrong with Sundance (Redford)'s lover Etta Place (Katharine Ross), attempting to go straight for the first time after struggling to rob banks in Spanish – but a posse is in hot pursuit. 'It's a classic, and I don't use that term lightly,' shared John W in an audience review on Rotten Tomatoes, while Jamie X posted: 'A beautiful film in every way. The cinematography, characters, story and soundtrack, are all on another level. I simply can't recommend enough.' 'This western movie had it all. Fast action, comedy, whimsical, intense [sic.] intrigue and fast gun play with two of the most dynamic male actors of their time,' added Edward B. Redford, 88, largely retired from acting in 2018, having also appeared in the likes of The Great Gatsby, All the President's Men and Out of Africa, as well as a stint in Marvel Cinematic Universe as Alexander Pierce. He was nominated for best actor and best director twice each at the Academy Awards, winning for his filmmaking in 1980 for Ordinary People, his directorial debut. Newman died in September 2008 aged 83 after a career that saw him nominated for 10 acting Oscars, winning best actor for The Colour of Money in 1987. He also starred in movies including Cool Hand Luke, The Hustler, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof and Road to Perdition. 'Everything I wanted in a movie is here,' enthused another fan, while Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid was also praised as 'the ultimate buddy movie' and a 'classic Western that I just never get tired of watching'. 'Redford and Newman at it again. If you don't love Butch and Sundance, then you don't love cinema,' insisted another lover of the movie. Many cinema fans have intense nostalgia around the film as well, remembering first watching it upon its release decades ago. 'One of the best, a film from my childhood I've had the pleasure of discovering again as an adult,' shared Robin Sattahip on Google, while Ray Moore shared: 'I watched this wonderful movie the week it was released and fell in Love with K. Ross as well with R.R. and Paul whom [sic.] I was already a fan. I have seen it so many times.' Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid appears in multiple AFI lists, including ranking 73rd in the institute's 10th anniversary edition of their 100 Years… 100 Movies list of greatest American films. More Trending Based on real-life figures in the Old West, the film is famous too for its anachronistic use of the very 1960s Burt Bacharach and Hal David song Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head. It's also preserved by the Library of Congress in the United States National Film Registry by for its 'culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant' status. Other stone-cold classic films currently available to watch on iPlayer include The Shining, Don't Look Now and John Wayne classic Western The Searchers. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid is streaming for free in the UK on BBC iPlayer now. Got a story? If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@ calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you. MORE: BBC denies editing Irish verse out of CMAT song after backlash MORE: Danny Dyer wants to play Doctor Who – here's why we should let him MORE: The Celebrity Traitors 'confirmed' cast salaries make me feel incredibly uneasy