PHC moved against JCP judges' removal
A writ petition, filed by Advocate Zarak Arif Shah through Advocate Ali Gohar Durrani, contends that the removal of senior puisne judges from the JCP membership violates the Constitution. The petition names the Judicial Commission of Pakistan and the Ministry of Law and Justice as respondents.
According to the petition, the federal government, following the 26th Amendment, altered Article 175(2), replacing the position of the senior puisne judge on the JCP with the head of a newly proposed "constitutional bench." Consequently, on January 27, 2025, the JCP issued a notification terminating the membership of senior puisne judges in the commission.
The petitioner argues that this change effectively excludes all senior puisne judges from High Courts across the country from participating in the JCP and claims this action is unconstitutional. The petition points out that under Article 175A, the change is only enforceable once constitutional benches are formally established under Article 202A, a process that has yet to occur.
The petition further contends that until these constitutional benches are constituted, the existing role of senior puisne judges in the JCP must remain intact. It argues that the move contradicts not only the letter and spirit of the 26th Amendment but also fundamental provisions of the Constitution, including several clauses from the 1973 Constitution and subsequent amendments.
The petitioner emphasized that a truly independent judiciary requires judges of superior courts to be involved in judicial appointments, rather than allowing the executive to dominate the process.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
2 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PTI's parliamentary core falls to ECP's guillotine
Listen to article The Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) on Tuesday delivered a major blow to PTI's parliamentary muscle, disqualifying several of the party's top opposition leaders on the day it marked the second anniversary of Imran Khan's arrest with countrywide protests. The axe fell hard, sweeping away the party's parliamentary leadership in both houses, following a recent ruling by an anti-terrorism court (ATC) in Faisalabad. The court handed down prison sentences of up to 10 years to over 100 PTI leaders and workers, including key opposition figures, for their alleged involvement in the May 9 riots, triggered by Khan's dramatic arrest in 2023. Those de-notified include Senate Opposition Leader Shibli Faraz, National Assembly Opposition Leader Omar Ayub Khan, Sunni Ittehad Council chief Sahibzada Hamid Raza, and PTI Parliamentary Leader Zartaj Gul. Three members of the Punjab Assembly – Muhammad Ansar Iqbal, Junaid Afzal Sahi, and Rai Muhammad Murtaza Iqbal – have also been disqualified. Acting on the convictions, the ECP issued a formal notification disqualifying nine lawmakers under Article 63(1)(h) of the Constitution, which bars any person convicted of an offence involving moral turpitude and sentenced to two or more years in prison from holding elected office. "A person shall be disqualified from being elected or chosen as, and from being, a member of the Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament) if he has been, on conviction for any offence involving moral turpitude, sentenced to imprisonment for a term of not less than two years, unless a period of five years has elapsed since his release," reads Article 63(1)(h). The ECP stated the lawmakers, having been convicted and sentenced, now "stand disqualified under Article 63(1)(h) of the Constitution," adding that, "Consequently, their seats have become vacant". All nine had been found guilty by the ATC for their alleged roles in the May 9 unrest, when PTI supporters, incensed by Khan's arrest outside the Islamabad High Court, stormed and vandalised military installations, including martyrs' memorials. The PTI had earlier declared that any attempt to arrest Khan would cross its "red line". In the aftermath, the military declared May 9 as a "Black Day", calling it a "dark chapter" in national history. However, the PTI has consistently claimed the events were a "false-flag operation" orchestrated by the establishment to frame the party and crush dissent. The ECP's move landed just as PTI was reigniting street agitation to mark the anniversary of Khan's arrest. With the latest disqualifications, the PML-N-led ruling alliance now sits virtually unchallenged in parliament, deepening the political vacuum and tightening the noose around what remains of the opposition. Reacting to ECP's decision, Ayub stated on X that he was grateful for the opportunity to serve as the leader of the opposition in NA. Expressing that his leader, Imran Khan and his colleagues had nominated him, he said that he has been de-seated as MNA NA18 Haripur and opposition leader "due to a bogus verdict by the ATC Faisalabad Judge Sheikh Javed Iqbal, who has wrongly convicted me for 10 years". Ayub further stated that the court "relied on the evidence of prosecution witnesses who were rejected by the ATC Sargodha Judge last year, and we were acquitted". He said the verdict proves "there is no rule of law in Pakistan". "This hybrid regime and its backers were perturbed by my stand as Leader of the Opposition for stating the truth and holding them accountable," he asserted. He vowed to challenge both the ATC verdict and the ECP disqualification in court, expressing hope that Chief Justice Yahya Afridi would take note of what he called the "deplorable state of affairs in Pakistan's judiciary." Ayub ended on a defiant note, saying, "I was, I am, and I will be a worker of PM Imran Khan and PTI".
Business Recorder
6 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Achakzai accuses ‘establishment' of undermining civilian governance
ISLAMABAD: In a scathing critique of the country's power dynamics, Mahmood Khan Achakzai on Tuesday accused the establishment of undermining civilian governance, asserting that the Constitution had been effectively 'shredded,' with unelected officials operating as the nation's real rulers. Achakzai, leader of both the Tehreek-e-Tahaffuz-e-Ayin-e-Pakistan – an alliance of opposition parties – and the Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party (PkMAP), condemned the government's silence on what he described as a systematic dismantling of democratic institutions. Taking a pointed dig at National Assembly Speaker Ayaz Sadiq, Achakzai charged him with inaction as parliamentarians were 'dragged' out of the House. 'Speaker, members were dragged in your presence,' he thundered. 'So far, no one – including you – has taken any action.' He sharply criticised the military and bureaucracy, accusing them of enabling even junior officers – such as colonels and prison superintendents – to control access to political detainees, notably ex-prime minister Imran Khan, whom he termed the country's 'biggest leader.' 'How shameful and disgusting is the treatment meted out to him,' Achakzai lamented, expressing deep concern over the state of democracy in Pakistan. Achakzai also targeted the Pakistan People's Party (PPP), a key coalition partner of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), expressing disbelief at its apparent complicity. 'The Constitution is being destroyed, and the PPP is supporting it,' he lamented. According to him, court orders are routinely flouted, and lower-level prison officials operate with impunity. 'The Constitution of Pakistan has been shredded,' he lamented. Adopting a populist tone, Achakzai asserted: 'This country does not belong to a few – Pakistan is not anyone's personal estate. Those who think so live in a fool's paradise.' Clarifying that he bore no personal animosity towards the military, Shehbaz Sharif, or Nawaz Sharif, he stressed that 'real rulers' must be those chosen by the people, not state employees. Returning to Speaker Sadiq, he criticised him over the alleged disqualification and mistreatment of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) lawmakers in connection with the May 9, 2023 events. 'You should have taken a stand,' Achakzai said. 'Why were your members mistreated.' He also lamented the government's silence on international matters, especially its failure to pass a resolution condemning Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, stating, 'Netanyahu should be taken to the International Court of Justice.' Despite his trenchant criticism, Achakzai concluded with a call for reconciliation. 'Let us all repent and forgive each other. Let us start a new politics where this House makes the decisions,' he urged, advocating a return to civilian supremacy and provincial autonomy. However, he ended with a stark warning: 'The way you marched into Bajaur– this will lead to civil war. And if it does, the Shehbaz Sharif government will be responsible.' Echoing the anti-establishment sentiment from the opposition benches, PTI MP Malik Aamir Dogar condemned the government's crackdown. 'You sentenced our members to ten years each,' he said, referring to punishments handed down to PTI activists. 'Ten members were removed from this House, and you took no action.' On Imran Khan, Dogar added, 'He didn't bow down – that's why he's in jail. Had he submitted, he'd be sitting here today. If this is how things are going to be, then just lock the Assembly.' Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
6 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Total number reaches 14: More PTI lawmakers disqualified
ISLAMABAD: The electoral body has disqualified nine more Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) lawmakers from their legislative memberships - five members of National Assembly, three of Punjab Assembly, and a senator - in connection with their convictions by an anti-terrorism court related to 9 May riots - as the total number of PTI legislators who have been disqualified in the last three weeks in consequence of court verdicts now reaches 14. Leader of the Opposition in NA Omar Ayub Khan and Leader of the Opposition in Senate Shibli Faraz are among the nine PTI lawmakers disqualified by the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) under Article 63(1)(h) of the Constitution on Tuesday. The other lawmakers are Member National Assembly Rai Haider Ali (NA-96 Faisalabad), MNA Sahibzada Hamid Raza NA-104 Faisalabad, MNA Rai Hassan Nawaz NA-143 Sahiwal, MNA Zartaj Gul (NA-185 Dera Ghazi Khan), Member Provincial Assembly (PP-73 Sargodha), MPA Junaid Afzal Sahi (PP-98 Faisalabad) and MPA Rai Murtaza Iqbal (PP-203 Sahiwal). ECP disqualifies several PTI lawmakers including Shibli Faraz, Omar Ayub, Zartaj Gul Despite that the nine disqualified legislators belong to PTI, six of them had to contest the last year's general elections on Sunni Ittehad Council (SIC) tickets against the backdrop of PTI electoral symbol controversy. The NA opposition leader was elected to NA as an independent candidate whereas the remaining four MNAs, and two of the three MPAs were elected on SIC tickets in the last year general elections. Only one MPA Murtaza Iqbal, as well as the Senate opposition leader, were elected to the respective legislatures on the PTI tickets. On 31 July, an ATC in Faisalabad sentenced PTI lawmakers to 10-year imprisonment over their alleged involvement in 9 May 2023 riots. On 29 July, the ECP disqualified PTI MNA Abdul Latif under Article 63(1)(h) over his alleged involvement in 9 May riots. A five-member ECP full bench heard different cases seeking Latif's disqualification before deciding against him under Article 63(1)(h). Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
