ICTSI defends partnership with Transnet as Maersk dispute resumes in court
Banele Ginidza
Phillipines-based shipping container lines conglomerate, International Container Terminal Services, Inc. (ICTSI), has reaffirmed the legitimacy of its partnership with Transnet for the development of Durban's Pier 2 terminal.
The dispute with Danish shipping giant Maersk, which returned to the KwaZulu-Natal High Court for two days of deliberation, could significantly impact one of South Africa's crucial trade gateways.
The High Court issued an interdict last year, temporarily halting the collaboration following Maersk's legal challenge.
Despite ICTSI's bid being announced as the preferred option on 11 April 2023, the court's previous decision led to significant frustration regarding delays in critical upgrades to the terminal.
ICTSI has since expressed concern that the ongoing legal disputes could further postpone necessary enhancements.
In a statement on Tuesday, ICTSI emphasised their readiness to commence implementation of the project immediately, asserting that their partnership with Transnet would introduce greater operational efficiency and transparency at Durban Container Terminal Pier 2.
"ICTSI stands ready to begin implementation immediately and remains committed to partnering with Transnet to deliver improved operational efficiency, transparency, and reliability at Durban Container Terminal Pier 2," it said.
"Unlike Maersk, ICTSI is not vertically integrated into shipping and port operations, allowing it to serve all shipping lines impartially," it said on frustrations with the delays stemming from Maersk's legal challenge. ICTSI reiterates its full confidence in the integrity, fairness and transparency of the process, run by Transnet."
ICTSI decried that the challenge by Maersk was lodged nearly a year after the preferred bidder was publicly announced and is based on their interpretation of the financial solvency ratio — a metric that was not a disqualifying factor at any stage of the tender process.
"It is important to clarify that ICTSI and all other bidders disclosed their financials during the Request for Qualification (RFQ) phase in early 2022," it said.
"ICTSI's not only met the required criteria but exceeded them. When final bids were assessed, ICTSI offered R12 billion for the concession and received a 100% evaluation score compared to Maersk's R9.2bn and evaluation score of 83%."
Transnet on Tuesday noted that it was the first day in the legal matter at the KwaZulu-Natal Division of the High Court in Durban.
"Transnet and APM Terminals made their initial submissions to the court and will make further submissions tomorrow (Wednesday), which will be followed by ICTSI's presentation of its case.Transnet will await the court's decision at the conclusion of the case," Transnet said.
In an interview earlier this year, Transnet Ports Terminals CEO Jabu Mdaki said the entity would continue with investments to the Pier 2 infrastructure while the court ruling held the partnership in abeyance.
He said TPT would re-evaluate the inputs, to go into developments, have committed resources that would - That does form part of the contractual issues, what it is that we are doing will be taken into account once the dust settles and depending on which direction this will be settled. The viability of the terminal needs to continue to be a working terminal.
"Our position with Pier 2 is quite important for the economy. We are not going to compromise the viability of Pier 2, which is the reason we are continued investing equipment like the 20 straddle carriers," Mdaki said.
"We have also placed an order for 4 STS cranes for Pier 2 to be delivered second half of this year. This a huge investment, one cannot allow equipment deterioration to continue while waiting for the legal outcome and the counterchallenges that might come. It is important to continue with the business and strengthening the business as well."
BUSINESS REPORT
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Apple and pear exports lost R1 billion in 2024 due to Cape Town port inefficiencies
It is not only US tariffs that keep farmers and export agents up at night. The state of the Cape Town port also has them counting apples. South Africa's apple and pear export industry is calling for Transnet to act due to the mounting losses caused by inefficiencies at the port of Cape Town, estimating that delays and logistical bottlenecks have cost the sector around R1 billion in 2024 alone. The Western Cape department of mobility met with Two-a-Day, an apple and pear packing and marketing cooperative, and its logistics partner, Link Supply Chain Management, on Monday for a strategic discussion and site visit to tackle the logistic challenges affecting the fruit export industry. At the meeting, industry role players warned that without urgent intervention, including the fast-tracking of the port's privatisation, the country risks losing hard-won market share in key global markets. 'We work in a complex, time-sensitive value chain. If a vessel to Europe, the United Kingdom, or the Far East is missed, the sale is gone. You do not get a second chance to deliver on time in a programme-driven market. Logistics is the single biggest risk for us right now. 'If we cannot get our product out, everything else, from on-farm innovation to market development, is compromised,' Roelf Pienaar, managing director of Tru-Cape Fruit Marketing, says. ALSO READ: Cape Town port ranked the worst in the world Delays at Cape Town port force diversions to Port Elizabeth, costing money Chris Petzer, operations director at Two-a-Day, explains that port delays often force the business to divert containers to Port Elizabeth at significant cost, simply to keep the supply chain moving and avoid halting harvest and packing operations. 'It is not sustainable, but sometimes it is the only option to prevent greater losses.' Although the Cape Town port's efficiency is slightly improving, according to Chris Knoetze, managing director of Link Supply Chain Management, a fourth-party logistics provider owned by several of the Western Cape's leading fruit exporting companies, including Two-a-Day and Tru-Cape Fruit Marketing, it is still throttling exports. A more effective port with higher productivity will attract more vessels and services, expand capacity and give more reliable shipping options to various export markets. 'Given several interventions, like Transnet's appointment and changes at senior management level, the repair and maintenance of equipment, solving personnel matters, focusing on operational improvement and capital investment in new rubber tyre gantry cranes (RTGs) in Cape Town Container Terminal, we should expect to see a step change in productivity to at least twenty gross crane movements per hour (GCH) or more in the coming months. 'However, the process is still too slow and far removed from the 33 GCH reported by Transnet in November 2012. When port operations are disrupted, it affects product quality, increases costs and damages our credibility with overseas buyers.' ALSO READ: Where are the private sector plans for Cape Town port? Inefficiencies cost apple and pear industry R1 billion in 2024 Knoetze emphasises that inefficiencies have cost the apple and pear industry in the Western Cape an estimated R1 billion in 2024 due to additional storage, trucking and plug-in costs, as well as missed market opportunities when vessels bypass Cape Town. 'We urgently need to fast-track the privatisation of the Cape Town terminal to restore competitiveness.' The Department of Mobility confirmed that it is actively pursuing measures to tackle these constraints. Corrine Gallant, deputy director-general of the Western Cape's mobility department, outlined existing initiatives, including the port of Cape Town's Logistics Development Project Management Unit and plans to revitalise rail infrastructure. 'We are working on the landside and waterside inefficiencies. This includes improving road freight safety and capacity, restoring rail services like the Overberg line and ensuring that the Western Cape's needs are heard at a national level. 'We cannot afford more costs down the chain. Our focus is on solutions that remove bottlenecks and protect jobs.' ALSO READ: US tariffs: SA sends new proposal but no changes to laws Global shipping bypasses port due to inefficiencies Industry representatives stressed that time is critical and warned that delays in decision-making could see global shipping lines bypass Cape Town in favour of more efficient ports, delaying fruit by one to two weeks and undermining the Western Cape's competitiveness. 'The farmers, pack-houses and exporters are investing in efficiency every day. Now we need the same urgency and commitment at the port, as without it, the entire value chain is at risk,' Gerhard van Heerden, director at Link Supply Chain Management, warns. Isaac Sileku, Western Cape minister of mobility, echoed this and emphasised the need for urgency and structured collaboration with Transnet. 'We cannot afford to be reactive. We must have formal agreements and mechanisms in place so that when bottlenecks arise, we know exactly which button to press. Speed of execution is critical — our farmers and exporters cannot wait years for solutions.' The session concluded with agreement on the need for: Faster execution of port and rail improvement projects. Formal industry-government forums with direct access to decision-makers. Targeted short-, medium- and long-term actions to resolve 'low-hanging fruit' issues and systemic challenges. The Western Cape apple and pear industry contributes significantly to local employment and the provincial economy and stakeholders agreed that improving Cape Town's port efficiency is essential not only for sustaining the sector but also for enhancing South Africa's competitiveness in global fruit markets.
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Cape Town's vulnerable residents face transport crisis as Dial-a-Ride service is scaled back
Users have expressed concern over changes to Cape Town's Dial-a-Ride service amid budget constraints. Image: Supplied A controversial decision by the City of Cape Town to scale back its Dial-a-Ride service from September 8 2025, has sparked outrage and a public petition. Critics say that the move will strip thousands of the city's most vulnerable residents of their only safe and reliable access to essential services. For many people with disabilities, it's deemed a necessity, not just a convenience, and would directly hit living standards and quality of life for its users. According to the Dial-a-Ride site, the service transports 350 regular users and 2,270 ad-hoc passengers, providing a dedicated kerb-to-kerb transport option for people with disabilities who are unable to use mainstream public transport. The service has been in operation since the late 1990s, serving individuals, including the mentally disabled, visually impaired, and infirm, enabling their access to healthcare, places of worship, work, education, and community activities. Under the impending changes, the service will be severely limited to only wheelchair-bound individuals and those with severe walking impairments, and exclusively for transport to and from work. The reduction is expected to affect more than 1,000 vulnerable individuals. The City attributes its decision to an "unsustainable" R12 million annual shortfall. However, this response was met with strong condemnation. Roscoe Palm, a GOOD City of Cape Town Councillor, dismissed the R12 million figure as a "rounding error" within a municipal budget exceeding R70 billion. Palm has called on Councillor Rob Quintas, Mayoral Committee Member for Urban Mobility, to "immediately find the R12 million needed to keep Dial-a-Ride accessible for all its current users, and also to expand the service" as the city's transport infrastructure grows. The controversy is further exacerbated by the fact that just last year, Quintas had publicly celebrated the programme's expansion under a new six-year, R28.1 million-per-year contract with HG Travelling Services. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading At the time, Quintas stated that this new contract was intended to allow for the expansion of the service to accommodate more eligible users as additional budget became available. The GOOD Party views the current decision as a "reversal" and "starkly at odds with the City's oft-stated values of Opportunity, Care, Accessibility, and Safety". In response to the impending cuts, a petition titled "Stop the Cancellation of Dial-a-Ride in Cape Town" has been launched on by The Western Cape Network on Disability. The petition highlights that the service is crucial for users to access work for their livelihoods, enables children to attend school, ensures vital hospital visits for medication and check-ups, and allows participation in recreational and community life. It asserts that losing Dial-a-Ride would be "catastrophic," potentially leading to job losses, educational setbacks for children, and compromised health for many in the Western Cape. "The impact of losing Dial-a-Ride is catastrophic. Without this service, many in the Western Cape will lose their jobs due to a lack of transportation, exacerbating financial hardship and increasing unemployment rates. It jeopardises the education of children who will struggle to attend school, impacting future generations. Additionally, it risks our health by making it difficult to access medical care," the petition reads. At the time of publishing, 1,697 people have signed the petition. The petition directly appeals to Quintas, urging the City to reconsider its decision. It proposes exploring alternatives such as increased funding, better route planning, and community involvement in decision-making processes to enhance and expand the service. IOL
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Chinese warehouse workers welcome Trump's extended tariff truce
Employees in China's export hubs are cautiously optimistic as US President Donald Trump prolongs a fragile truce on tariffs with Beijing. Labourer Shuai Hang went a week without work earlier this year when sky-high US tariffs on Chinese goods overwhelmed the warehouse he works at and slowed the company's US-bound parcels to a trickle. But on Tuesday, after US President Donald Trump announced a truce on those duties would be extended, the depot in southern China's manufacturing hub Guangzhou was alive with noise as workers stuffed trucks with packages of clothes and kitchenware. Many are destined for the doorsteps of US customers of Chinese-founded online shopping giant Temu. Tariffs hit workers' wages and job stability 'Tariffs impact our daily lives,' said 31-year-old Shuai, whose monthly pay of more than 10,000 yuan ($1,400) had dropped by a third previously. 'If tariffs are slightly lower, then there are more outgoing shipments, and then we have higher wages,' he said. Trump's tariff policies since taking office have upended global trade and set off a blistering tit-for-tat with Beijing — but in May the two major economies agreed to a fragile truce, with each temporarily lowering levies on the other's goods. That agreement was extended to November by Trump on Monday, hours before it expired. Deliveries plunge during peak tariff periods At the height of the tariffs, said Shuai, who has been loading parcels for Guangzhou-based logistics company Weijiang International for a year, 'there was not a single truck' for him to fill, so he couldn't work. ALSO READ: US tariffs: Here's why talks over trade deal have been 'complex' Overall deliveries dropped by about 20 percent in May, according to Weijiang's founder Xiong Wei, with the US market making up around a quarter of their cross-border business. But business has recovered since July, he said. Xiong said he hadn't lost sleep over the looming expiration of the 90-day tariff truce this week, as he had expected it would be renewed. 'We might have been worried in May, but now we are indifferent,' said Xiong. 'We are used to it'. 'Cards reshuffled' These days the warehouse is sending out 100 tonnes of packages every 24 hours, with up to 70 trucks making trips. On Tuesday industrial fans whirred as sweat-slicked workers methodically scanned yellow, black and sage green bundles into lorries. Xiong's company has recently invested in its own warehouse in Chicago. ALSO READ: Lesufi says US tariffs due to SA's Palestine stance, backs China to prop up Gauteng In many ways the uncertainty provided opportunity for smaller logistics companies like theirs, said manager Chen Weiyan, as they have taken the chance to expand their market. 'The cards have been reshuffled,' he said. Temu link boosts cross-border flows Around 30 percent of the parcels moved by Weijiang International end up in a different warehouse, this one owned by Temu-parent PDD, where they are unloaded, repacked and readied for a flight across the ocean. While the truce is welcome, Shuai, who packs three to four tonnes in a truck daily, said he still pays close attention to tariff news. 'For those of us who have travelled over 1,000 kilometres to work here, we definitely don't want frequent breaks. We all want to earn more money,' said the native of neighbouring Guizhou province. 'Folks in America need our goods' Working at the warehouse was less tiring than labouring at a construction site, and earning money had become more difficult in the past two years, he said. Chen, the manager, was bullish. 'We will not give up this market,' he said. 'Folks in America need our goods'. NOW READ: SA and China can 'do much to cooperate in film making'
