'Trump accounts' for newborns passed the House. Here's why financial experts don't like them.

Yahoo

22-05-2025

Pretty soon, every newborn American could be the proud owner of their very own 'Trump account.'
The Republican party's 'one big beautiful bill,' which passed the House early Thursday, contains a pilot program that would automatically create a new, tax-advantaged investment account prefunded with $1,000 for each child born from the beginning of 2025 through the end of 2028.
Originally dubbed "MAGA accounts," the acronym stood for 'money account for growth and advancement' — obviously meant as a tribute to President Trump's most famous catchphrase. In an 11th hour amendment, House Republicans voted to put the president's name on the accounts.
Whether you love or hate the branding, the idea's backers say the accounts are a way to get all kids into saving and investing early in life, while helping them save for goals like college or a home.
But financial advisers who spoke with Yahoo Finance warned that, aside from the free seed money, the benefits the accounts offer are relatively paltry compared to other tax-shielded savings options Americans already have available, including the 529 accounts parents use to put away money for college. The new Trump accounts also come tied up with a fairly complex and potentially confusing set of rules.
As a result, putting any money into them beyond what the government offers might not make sense for most families, they said.
'It's not very attractive,' Ann Reilley, CEO of Alpha Financial Advisors, said of the program. 'It just seems like they're complicating things for no reason.'
By subscribing, you are agreeing to Yahoo's
Terms
and
Privacy Policy
Under the proposal, parents will have the option to open Trump accounts for any child under the age of 8 at a bank of their choice, but only newborns will receive the free $1,000. In cases where parents fail to set up an account for their baby, the government will create one automatically and notify them.
From there, contributions to the accounts will be capped at $5,000 per year, with a limited exception for gifts from local charities. The money can grow tax-free until it's withdrawn but must be invested in a broad stock index.
That's about it for the tax advantages. Once cashed out, investment returns will be taxed as long-term capital gains — but only if the funds are used for one of a few approved purposes. Those include paying for higher education or other job training expenses, starting a small business, or making a down payment on a first home.
Money spent on anything else will be treated as ordinary income.
Overall, it's a less generous deal than putting money into a 529 account for higher education or Roth IRA for retirement, since both of those options allow investors to withdraw their money entirely tax-free. The Trump account also comes with additional strings attached that could make it tricky to manage. Children can begin taking out their savings once they turn 18, but can't use more than half before age 25. Then at 31, all the cash is automatically disbursed.
Read more: How much should I save before going to college?
The Trump account could theoretically be useful for families who are already comfortable with their retirement savings and whose children don't plan to pursue college, since the money can be used for other purposes like homebuying without a penalty. But even then, there might be pitfalls.
For instance: Say a child ends up spending the money on anything other than education, a business, or a house and gets hit with the higher ordinary income rate. In that case, their family would have been better off investing in a normal brokerage account, said Zach Teutsch, a managing partner at Values Added Financial.
'The giving kids money aspect is generally good,' Teutsch said. 'The account structure seems ill-considered.' He added that a family would need to be 'shockingly sure' that their child wasn't going to college before it would make sense to invest in a Trump account instead of a 529.
The concept of providing every child a small, prefunded investment account isn't new in Washington. Progressives have long-pitched a version of the idea known as 'baby bonds,' which they've argued could help close the racial wealth gap. Among Republicans, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz is credited for originating the Trump account proposal — he called them Invest In America Accounts — which he has described as a way to help hook kids on investing and broader capitalist values.
'There are many Americans who don't own stocks or bonds, are not invested in the market, and may not feel particularly invested in the American free enterprise system. This will give everyone a stake,' Cruz told Semafor last week.
The experiment is not especially expensive in the scheme of the GOP's massive tax package: Trump accounts will cost the government about $17 billion over 10 years, according to Congress's Joint Committee on Taxation. But Republicans appear to have kept costs down in large part by loading the proposal with restrictions that limit the value of the program, said Alan Cole, a senior economist at the Tax Foundation.
'It's like, thank you government for the free money, but I care about the usefulness,' Cole said. 'And realistically, this is the sixth or seventh best tax-free savings account option.'
Jordan Weissmann is a Senior Reporter at Yahoo Finance.
Sign up for the Mind Your Money newsletter